new prostitution bill by spring

I wonder if you will still feel way when you are facing criminal charges.

Like I said I'm going to wait a spell if it goes Nordic and see what LE is up to. If I have to give it up I'm not that invested.

More than likely though the agencies will continue to run. Believe it or not Fuji but the cops don't go after these things for the most part. Hey, I can also go back to regular MP as well. Lots of options.

The boards will be more important than ever. But until a law is actually passed and enforced there really isn't any point after I gave my imput to the petitions and govt forums to stress over it.

Besides. Do you really think that Junior or Munclair will overturn it? Won't happen. And if they had been in power they would be doing the exact same thing.
 
I think he meant forced into prostitution out of economic necessity (which the Cons believe all prostitutes do it as last resort) rather than forced by a pimp...


I tend to agree. Perhaps not as an absolute last resort, but certainly as a matter of expedience.


I am amused by all the positive chatter about enlightened morality and friendly LE attitudes regarding prostitution. For as long as I can remember, and even after the initial lower court ruling in support of SP rights, you could count on a bawdy house/MP crackdown in an election year. It was generally seen to be good politics. What has changed?
 
It's going to be the Nordic Model.
The Harper Conservatives needs the religious right to win the next election.

Unfortunately for them, they'll need a hell of a lot more than that to win the next election. They'll get the religious right no matter what. It's the moderates they have to curry favour with if they want any hope in hell. And given polls on the prostitution figures, the moderates are for legalizing it.
 
I tend to agree. Perhaps not as an absolute last resort, but certainly as a matter of expedience.


I am amused by all the positive chatter about enlightened morality and friendly LE attitudes regarding prostitution. For as long as I can remember, and even after the initial lower court ruling in support of SP rights, you could count on a bawdy house/MP crackdown in an election year. It was generally seen to be good politics. What has changed?

Funny. I don't remember really hearing about crackdown raids unless trafficking or under-agers were involved. And never noted a timing to elections. Are you refering to Fed, Prov, or Municipal for the timing?

Like to hear from the advertisers if they think this is an issue as well......
 
Funny. I don't remember really hearing about crackdown raids unless trafficking or under-agers were involved. And never noted a timing to elections. Are you refering to Fed, Prov, or Municipal for the timing?

Like to hear from the advertisers if they think this is an issue as well......

Municipal. Like clockwork. Do a search on terb. We used to talk about it during election years.
 
They may well be struck down, but they can also be enacted and it will be another 5-7 year cycle. I don't want to wait.

The "forcing women underground" argument is fallacious. The ostensibly endangered party (SPs) would not be the ones who are subject to criminal prosecution under an anti-john law. The commercial transaction would itself become; there is not charter right to practice a particular profession.

Women would be forced underground to stay in business. To me it seems cut and dry (although that's not worth a lick of anything). How can you tell the people that it's perfectly legal to SELL something, but entirely illegal to BUY something?

You need to go check out some local rub n tugs, brother.....

To be honest, the idea of a rub & tug that offers anything other than an HJ makes me nervous. If I were a cop, that'd be first place I'd bust...

I only went to MPs twice before I made the leap to SPs. But neither of them hinted that anything else was available. I also got the distinct impression that asking would be considered faux pas.
 
I wonder if MPA's will be bribed heavily to suck dick or fuck once SP's get driven under the radar. This new law may put those girls at risk.
 
wouldn't the stuff you all talking about would out SPs in danger?
 
I really hope you're wrong about that, for all our sakes! Unbelievably, there are still posters on various boards who believe that having the old laws struck down was a good thing... :Eek:
 
Guys you heard it here first.... The legislation will be the Canadian Version of the Nordic model.

Be ready and prepared to deal with it.
 
There are already a significant percentage of those involved in the sex trade being on social assistance. The Conservatives ( Reformist) would not likely make further programs to rescue sex workers for the same reasons that they are not interested in financing or encouraging safe injection sites or supplying addicts with controlled substances. The new laws will result in innovative and new forms of evasion by the sex trade and enforcement headaches for LE.
 
What MacKay actually said was that a bill would be introduced by summer. That would mean sometime during this Spring session. It will probably be no earlier than May. It generally takes a bill about 100 sitting days from the time it is introduced into the House until it passes Royal Ascent. They will have trouble getting anything passed by the Dec. 20th deadline. If the bill is particularly controversial it could take considerably longer than this, and could even be withdrawn.
I'm heartened by the fact that afterwards MacKay was asked point blank about the Nordic model and if you can decipher his politician's weasel talk he pretty much said it's not on.
He also said that passing a new law was like passing a legislative thread through the eye of a needle. So, we can expect a bill that will directly address the Supreme Court decision. It will be narrowly focused and no broad sweeping legislation. The government is also aware that it will have to be able to pass a Charter challenge or it ends up in the Supreme Court. No government wants to waste time and resources passing a law that will be struck down in the courts.
He has also said that a number of other Criminal Code provisions remain in place to protect those engaged in prostitution and other vulnerable persons, including procuring offences, child prostitution offences, and human trafficking offences. He said the same thing to me in response to a letter I sent.
So, I think once the dust settles, it will be a narrowly focused law that will allow most of us hobbyists to continue on with our favourite passtime, without fear or worry.

I agree. Funny little thread here, sensible responses are ignored and everyone else is running around like the sky is falling. It seems consensus on this thread is Canada will have the most draconian prostitution law in the world. Consensus among police isn't consensus, they can't agree, and the population at large seems pretty much against going Nordic or worse.

This thread isn't worth the time to read any more.
 
Lol. How does the Nordic model shut massage parlors down? A licensed Body Rub parlor is a licensed business. With that logic, are they gonna shut down Strip Clubs too? Lol.

MP licensing is a municipal issue. If the criminal code were to make the purchase of sex illegal, that would most certainly affect MPs....if it sells sex. The City can't license a criminal business.

Having said that, it doesn't mean that body rubs could/would be shut down even if they made prostitution illegal. The legality of a hand job rests on a very narrow interpretation of the law. Case law clearly establishes that a hand job is a sexual act. BUT rub n tugs are "OK" is because the court (in 2007, sorry, can't remember the name of the case offhand) found that a manual release performed as part of a full body rub is NOT an act of prostitution (per se). It's just part of rubbing the client's "full body". If the officer in that case had separately negotiated/paid for a release, we'd be having a different conversation. Remember, your license says body rub parlour. Not hand job parlour.... So as long as you remain a body rub parlour and you don't offer sexual services for separate/specific compensation, you're cool ;)

I agree. Funny little thread here, sensible responses are ignored and everyone else is running around like the sky is falling.
Many viewpoints here are amusing. Those who think the world is falling, those who think that we have a god-given constitutional right to poon/prostitute ourselves and those who think that any anti-hobbying law will be struck because they will necessarily endanger SP safety and therefore fail a constitutional challenge. Funny shit.
 
Yes I hope that I am wrong too but realistically did you ever believe that this government would ever bring the decriminalization model?

No, it was just wishful thinking, and by the sounds of things on other boards, a lot of people still have their rose colored glasses on. That said, I still contend that Bedford et.al. are idiots for launching a constitutional challenge against the (still) existing laws. While admittedly flawed, for all intents and purposes they worked for the industry as a whole overall. Now with the law of unintended consequences, where will we be??? :mad:
 
They may indeed abuse their majority and impose a pure Nordic Model, even though it is unconstitutional. They might bank on the fact that it will appease their base, as well as to be seen doing something - that is, adhering to their "tough on crime" motto. It will inevitably be challenged, but it could take years to go through the entire process. In effect, they get what they want in the short term, and leave the fallout for another government to deal with in the far off future.
 
I sent an email to Peter McKay a while back and got the following generic response. I guess some response is better than nothing at all...

"Thank you for your correspondence, concerning prostitution.

As you may know, on December 20, 2013, the Supreme Court of Canada rendered its decision in Bedford v. Attorney General of Canada. The Court found that three prostitution‑related provisions in the Criminal Code were unconstitutional: the bawdy house offence with respect to the practice of prostitution; the living on the avails offence; and, the communicating for the purposes of prostitution offence.

The Court suspended the effects of this decision for one year. The Government is considering a legislative response to this judgment. You may be interested to know that the Department of Justice Canada launched an online consultation, from February 17 to March 17, 2014, to seek the views of Canadians on this issue.

We are committed to ensuring that the criminal law continues to address the significant harms that flow from prostitution to communities and to those engaged in prostitution, as well as other vulnerable persons. It is important to note that a number of other Criminal Code provisions remain in place to protect those engaged in prostitution and other vulnerable persons, including procuring offences, child prostitution offences, and human trafficking offences.

Thank you again for writing.

Yours truly,

The Honourable Peter MacKay"
 
So, does that mean Mackay intends on drafting additional legislation on top of the other criminal code provisions mentioned in the form letter? Wouldn't that mean shifting their focus to consenting adults?

I sent an email to Peter McKay a while back and got the following generic response. I guess some response is better than nothing at all...

"Thank you for your correspondence, concerning prostitution.

As you may know, on December 20, 2013, the Supreme Court of Canada rendered its decision in Bedford v. Attorney General of Canada. The Court found that three prostitution‑related provisions in the Criminal Code were unconstitutional: the bawdy house offence with respect to the practice of prostitution; the living on the avails offence; and, the communicating for the purposes of prostitution offence.

The Court suspended the effects of this decision for one year. The Government is considering a legislative response to this judgment. You may be interested to know that the Department of Justice Canada launched an online consultation, from February 17 to March 17, 2014, to seek the views of Canadians on this issue.

We are committed to ensuring that the criminal law continues to address the significant harms that flow from prostitution to communities and to those engaged in prostitution, as well as other vulnerable persons. It is important to note that a number of other Criminal Code provisions remain in place to protect those engaged in prostitution and other vulnerable persons, including procuring offences, child prostitution offences, and human trafficking offences.

Thank you again for writing.

Yours truly,

The Honourable Peter MacKay"
 
It depends on how you view prostitution. If you see it as being inherently exploitative and consequently that no one can willingly consent to being exploited.......
 
Lol. How does the Nordic model shut massage parlors down? A licensed Body Rub parlor is a licensed business. With that logic, are they gonna shut down Strip Clubs too? Lol.

I concur but take this tongue-in-cheek note:


It's Not the Crime Lyrics

Tower of Power

I broke the law last night,
commited a criminal and sexual act.
She was on top* in this state,
I said I went to get bopped.

And though I didn't get caught,
I know in my mind I commited no crime,
Still by some fluke I'm here serving time,
Oh No!!

It's not the crime,
and it's not the thought,
It's not the deed,
It's if you get caught.

I got some friends who like to stay HIGH,
Think of, the tax potential,
if it was legal to buy.
But instead the kid is forced,
to bust on victimless crimes,
It's the look last bust,
Nickel and dime,
Oh, Oh...

It's not the crime,
and it's not the thought,
It's not the deed,
It's if you get caught.

Think of all them Profiteers,
and how they got that way,
Cause they sure the hell would not be there,
without the payoff game that's played.
Think of what we could do,
if it was you that was in their shoes,
You either play the game
or else you lose,
Bad News,

It's not who's sold,
It's not who's bought,
and it's not the kickbacks,
It's if you get caught

It's not the crime,
it's not the thought,
and it's not the deed,
It's if you get caught.

*(In some States, it was illegal for a gal to ride a guy cowgirl).