New 2019-20 Maple Leafs thread

In the salary cap era, sometimes all you get is one (if that) Cup. Sundin has no Cup. Ovechkin might end his career with just one Cup.

Also, it really helps to win the Cup(s) before your star players become RFAs or UFAs.
 
The Blues highest paid player makes $7.5 million.
If they lose Pietrangelo they have an additional $6.5 million to replace him.
Their position looks very favourable.
St. Louis just dumped Jake Allen to Montreal and that will save them $4.35 million for next season. They took no salary back from Montreal just draft picks so it looks like they are starting to clear salary to resign Pietrangelo.
 
St. Louis just dumped Jake Allen to Montreal and that will save them $4.35 million for next season. They took no salary back from Montreal just draft picks so it looks like they are starting to clear salary to resign Pietrangelo.

Blues now with 3 players to sign (to get to 23) and $6,397,501 to do it, as of now.
 
One is enough?

It's a shame Armstrong overpaid lesser players and the team is now possibly going to lose it's captain and best defenceman.

Don't look back, someone might be gaining on you.
~Leroy Robert Satchel Page.
Is zero too many?
Yea, after 53 years, I'ld be happy with one.
 
Blues now with 3 players to sign (to get to 23) and $6,397,501 to do it, as of now.
They don't absolutely have to get to 23, they just have to be able to dress 20 for a game. And those 3 extra players could all be guys who spent this past season in San Antonio and make fuck all.
 
St. Louis just dumped Jake Allen to Montreal and that will save them $4.35 million for next season. They took no salary back from Montreal just draft picks so it looks like they are starting to clear salary to resign Pietrangelo.
I assume Jake Allen will back up Carey Price? Montreal have both cap room and draft picks.
 
gcostanza just to answer your question about Stanley Cups yes one would be enough my Habs have not won since 93. With so many teams in the league it is so tough now.
 
Mitch Marner Patrick Kane comparison first 3 years of their NHL careers.
Kane... 244 games 76 goals 230 pts, hits 52, blocks 33, takeaways 123, plus 9 in +/-
Marner 241 games 67 goals 224 pts, hits 101, blocks 107, takeaways 230, plus 21 in +/-

If you want to add their 4th year comparison
Kane 73 pts in 73 games for 1 point per game
Marner 67 pts in 59 games that is over a point per game.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Darts: "Wouldn't bother me one bit if they cancel the NBA. Too few players look like me. "
Did Dart really say this?
Didn't think he could sink any lower but he did.
 
Last edited:
Mitch Marner Patrick Kane comparison first 3 years of their NHL careers.
Kane... 244 games 76 goals 230 pts, hits 52, blocks 33, takeaways 123, plus 9 in +/-
Marner 241 games 67 goals 224 pts, hits 101, blocks 107, takeaways 230, plus 21 in +/-

If you want to add their 4th year comparison
Kane 73 pts in 73 games for 1 point per game
Marner 67 pts in 59 games that is over a point per game.

This confirms my belief that Marner is a special player, especially the number of hits and blocked shots show that he plays with a lot of heart and grit. A lot of people also ignore his ability to raise the play of his line mates. Both Kadri and Tavares had career year with him on the wing.

He might have been paid a couple of millions more per year than we’d like to see but he’s worth a lot more to the team than a guy like Nylander who has never shown that kind of efforts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: superstar_88
There's a premium signing for term.
Salary cap was projected to go up prior to covid.
Look at Rielly and Kadri's contracts now.
They are bargains now because when they signed they signed with term and the salary caps have gone up since.
If Marner had signed for 1 year it would have been for a couple of millions lower that you mention.
Then each one year contract he would sign afterwards would be higher as the salary cap goes up and he becomes a better player.
So by signing for term you're overpaid the early years and underpaid the later years.
People who failed math don't understand this. (i.e. Dart)
Like buying a house in the 1950's for 50 thousand dollars. Expensive at the time but now it'll only get you a garage or a parking space in some downtown condos.
 
Last edited:
This confirms my belief that Marner is a special player, especially the number of hits and blocked shots show that he plays with a lot of heart and grit. A lot of people also ignore his ability to raise the play of his line mates. Both Kadri and Tavares had career year with him on the wing.

He might have been paid a couple of millions more per year than we’d like to see but he’s worth a lot more to the team than a guy like Nylander who has never shown that kind of efforts.
The Marner vs Kane comparison will go on for as long as Marner is active and maybe even afterwards.

Here are the updated numbers after 4 years.
Goals: Kane 103, Marner 83
Points: Kane 303, Marner 291

Where Kane clearly excels is in the playoffs with 20 goals and 28 assists in 45 games and one Cup, Marner is 5 goals and 16 assists in 25 games.

Is Marner worth $11mm? One problem with a long term contract is what if the player doesn't perform up to expectations as has happened to some players? Also, why pay an RFA like an UFA?

So, who would you pick?
 
The Marner vs Kane comparison will go on for as long as Marner is active and maybe even afterwards.

Here are the updated numbers after 4 years.
Goals: Kane 103, Marner 83
Points: Kane 303, Marner 291

Where Kane clearly excels is in the playoffs with 20 goals and 28 assists in 45 games and one Cup, Marner is 5 goals and 16 assists in 25 games.

Is Marner worth $11mm? One problem with a long term contract is what if the player doesn't perform up to expectations as has happened to some players? Also, why pay an RFA like an UFA?

So, who would you pick?

I would answer your questions as follows :

- at this point of their careers I’d pick Marner. He may still have another level whereas Kane at 31 will very soon be going on a downward spiral;

- in the case of a special player, and I understand you may not think that Marner is one, Dubas had to take into consideration the possibility of an offer sheet. What if another GM signed him to 12.5 per ? Obviously you’d say you’d take the 4 firsts but without Marner, that would set the Leafs back at least a couple of years from being a contender and you would waste a couple of the best years of Matthews and Tavares. Dubas has made a few bad decisions but in my biased opinion signing Marner wasn't one of them.

You’ll likely argue that the team has been more like a pretender than a contender since signing Marner, but that imo had to do the fundamental flaws that exist in the team structure than Marner. With Matthews, Marner and Tavares, Leafs‘ offence is at least on par with the real contenders. All they need to do is to make the proper adjustments in the supporting cast to add the missing ingredient. Defence including goaltending is another story and a major overhaul is needed before this team becomes a real contender.
 
Last edited:
Did Dart really say this?
Didn't think he could sink any lower but he did.
I "copy and pasted" his racist quote word for word. I think it was in the thread that said something like Obama was responsible for the boycott.

If he goes quack, quack and ducks without attempting to back it up, he is admitting that he is a racist. On the other hand, I don't see how he can because there isn't any other way to interpret it. He dislikes blacks and ignores their accomplishments for no other reason than their skin colour.

He has made other racist posts as well, just not as blatant as this one.
 
I would answer your questions as follows :

- at this point of their careers I’d pick Marner. He may still have another level whereas Kane at 31 will very soon be going on a downward spiral;

- in the case of a special player, and I understand you may not think that Marner is one, Dubas had to take into consideration the possibility of an offer sheet. What if another GM signed him to 12.5 per ? Obviously you’d say you’d take the 4 firsts but without Marner, that would set the Leafs back at least a couple of years from being a contender and you would waste a couple of the best years of Matthews and Tavares. Dubas has made a few bad decisions but in my biased opinion signing Marner wasn't one of them.

You’ll likely argue that the team has been more like a pretender than a contender since signing Marner, but that imo had to do the fundamental flaws that exist in the team structure than Marner. With Matthews, Marner and Tavares, Leafs‘ offence is at least on par with the real contenders. All they need to do is to make the proper adjustments in the supporting cast to add the missing ingredient. Defence including goaltending is another story and a major overhaul is needed before this team becomes a real contender.
I agree completely. There is a tonne of talent offensively and Rielly and Muzzin are anchors of a defence. Getting some muckers and grinders is easier to acquire than the offensively talented.

Keep in mind also, that Keefe has had less than a full season to learn about the players he has. Learn just not about what they can do physically, but maybe more importantly, psychologically. How to motivate them, what buttons to push, what makes them click.

Some changes are obviously needed along with some patience but an overhaul is just plain dumb.
 
- at this point of their careers I’d pick Marner. He may still have another level whereas Kane at 31 will very soon be going on a downward spiral;
I know there is a time warp but to be fair we need to compare Kane and Marner at the same stage of their career. So, the question is after 4 years in the NHL, would you or anyone else pick Marner or Kane?

To continue the debate/discussion, here are more facts to consider,
1) Kane never had a centre anywhere near the caliber of a Kadri or Taveras. I think he and Toews rarely played together 5 on 5.
2) Not sure about his first 4 years but Kane is/was a regular PK.
3) Marner has 5 more years on his contract. We already know how Kane did in his next 5 years. What will Marner do in his next 5?

Conclusion: No respect to Marner, but I would pick Kane based on their first 4 years. Their regular season stats are pretty close but where Kane excelled is in the playoffs, including one Cup. Also, Kane did it without a centre like Kadri or Taveras. Lastly, the fact that Marner is overpaid means less money available for the rest of the team.