Nelson Mandela RIP

Really? Over the likes of Martin Luther King, Jr, Winston Churchill, Albert Einstein................not even close.

Really Winston Churchill the man who orchestrated the CIA and MI6 overthrow of the peoples elected Iranian Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh in 1953 because Mossadegh nationalized the Iranian oil industry in 1951 due to the fact that Britian did not want to make concessions of 50-50% on Iranian oil.
Albert Einstein was the greatest scientist and his creations are in our daily lives but he never helped people change their way of thinking on interacting with one another.
Martin Luther King's fight against the same rights for blacks was a great fight but it was a fight that was mostly in the U.S where Mandellas fight for the same rights were viewed more worldwide and had a greater affect.
Do not trying to hijack this thread with your bullshit.

Nelson Mandella was a great man and probably the most humane person in the 20th century for people who are willing to learn and be more humane.

What I have learned from Mandella is to be kind as a human being to others regardless of the colour of their skin, their religion, the country they come from. Whether you learned this from Mandella or not speaks more about your own character then it does his.
 
The two greatest humans on earth to live in the 20th century are hands down Gandhi and Mandella.
Their ideology of equality should be thought in all schools around the world and maybe one day this world could be a better place for all.
 
Gandhi lived non violence more than Mandela. Mandela went to prison for creating an armed wing, and the armed wing he created went on to carry out many attacks while he was in prison.

Actually, he seems to have developed the open, inclusive, peacemaker spirit in prison. He came out of prison much more moderate and dedicated to a peaceful outcome than when he went in.

I part he appears to be a moral paragon mostly because he was against an obviously vile regime next to which anyone looks like an angel.

That said he was smart, tough as nails, persistent, principled, and ultimately effective in defeating a truly evil oppression.

Gandhi, however, managed to do something similar while remaining fully committed right his spiritual beliefs in non violence.
 
Hmm. You don't think de Klerk was just yielding to international pressure?
Of course he was.

If there had been no outside political pressure or Sun City songs Mandela wouldve died in prison
 
Hmm. You don't think de Klerk was just yielding to international pressure which was by then becoming fairly invasive in the lives of white South Africans?
Perhaps he was, then again other states have done a fine job of riding out world pressure.
 
Gandhi lived non violence more than Mandela. Mandela went to prison for creating an armed wing, and the armed wing he created went on to carry out many attacks while he was in prison.

Actually, he seems to have developed the open, inclusive, peacemaker spirit in prison. He came out of prison much more moderate and dedicated to a peaceful outcome than when he went in.

I part he appears to be a moral paragon mostly because he was against an obviously vile regime next to which anyone looks like an angel.

That said he was smart, tough as nails, persistent, principled, and ultimately effective in defeating a truly evil oppression.

Gandhi, however, managed to do something similar while remaining fully committed right his spiritual beliefs in non violence.

But Gandhi had the advantage of dealing with a Britain which wished to decolonize and - right at the end - a Labour government which hero-worshipped him. Mandela had to deal with a gritty, go-down-fighting Afrikaner regime.

It's a lot easier to be non violent when your opponent wishes to give in.
 
The British did not decolonize of their own accord, President Roosevelt had a hand in that as part of the deal he negotiated with Churchill.

Some have blamed Gandhi for the horrendous poverty India found itself in when the British left, again a myth. The British were despoiling India long before Gandhi showed up. It began in earnest when the UK converted prime land to cotton production after the American Civil War. Cotton is very taxing on the soil it is grown in, the British reaped the profits while the Indians were left to clean up the mess in their wake. That is why the spinning wheel is the state emblem.

Yes Mandela may have made a mistake in creating the armed wing of the ANC but it took a man made of sterner stuff to democratize the nation. Gandhi began his campaign for human rights in South Africa and failed.
 
The two greatest humans on earth to live in the 20th century are hands down Gandhi and Mandella.
Their ideology of equality should be thought in all schools around the world and maybe one day this world could be a better place for all.

Mao Zedong? He took a failed, defeated China and made it into a superpower. Both India and South Africa are failed nations. China is the future, his legacy endures.

Leaders with teeth actually get stuff done.
 
The two greatest humans on earth to live in the 20th century are hands down Gandhi and Mandella.
Their ideology of equality should be thought in all schools around the world and maybe one day this world could be a better place for all.
Curt Flood and Jackie Robinson.
Banting and Best.
Lennon and McCartney.
Penn and Teller.
Itchy and Scratchy.

The debate could go on forever.
 
Mao Zedong? He took a failed, defeated China and made it into a superpower. Both India and South Africa are failed nations. China is the future, his legacy endures.

Leaders with teeth actually get stuff done.

Mao didn't make China a superpower. Deng did that. Mao did take the country back from foreigners and keep it unified. But he fucked up the thirty years after that.

Perhaps the most important moment in modern Chinese history was when everyone collectively agreed with Deng that it doesn't matter what colour a cat is.
 
Really? Over the likes of Martin Luther King, Jr, Winston Churchill, Albert Einstein................not even close.

It is hard to compare between a scientist and a politician.

But yeah, I would put him over MLK or Churchill, by a long shot.

The oppression Mandela faced was far worse than anything MLK faced, more institutionalized, and far more dangerous.

Churchill did a good job on WWII, but he was on the wrong side of a lot of other issues.
 
Bullshit. A terrorist is a terrorist plain and simple. I'm not callling Mandela a terrorist but he did have ties to terrorist groups. His govt was also corrupt with his wife being the Queen Bee.

What is it that Winnie did while Nelson was out of jail that concerns you?

I don't think you will find many that will agree this government was "corrupt."

In fact his very moderate approach to banking, and property rights is credited with preventing an economic and social meltdown in South Africa.
 
It is hard to compare between a scientist and a politician.

But yeah, I would put him over MLK or Churchill, by a long shot.

The oppression Mandela faced was far worse than anything MLK faced, more institutionalized, and far more dangerous.

Churchill did a good job on WWII, but he was on the wrong side of a lot of other issues.

Influence is different from what people think is "right or wrong". In history Churchill is far far more influential, he changed the course of it, so are Lenin, Stalin.

Personally What did Mandela do that Che Guevara or Castro didnt? All were revolutionaries. Lets not talk about political leadership after taking over, South Africa is a cesspool of crime, poverty, aids, etc.

And why did you leave out Mustafa Kemal? Turkey is actually a developed nation now with a high literacy rate.
 
Influence is different from what people think is "right or wrong". In history Churchill is far far more influential, he changed the course of it, so are Lenin, Stalin.

Personally What did Mandela do that Che Guevara or Castro didnt? All were revolutionaries. Lets not talk about political leadership after taking over, South Africa is a cesspool of crime, poverty, aids, etc.

And why did you leave out Mustafa Kemal? Turkey is actually a developed nation now with a high literacy rate.

What Mandela did that Castro and Che did not, was lead a peaceful transition to power, and then willingly give up power in a free and democratic process. He sought to reconcile the oppressors and the oppressed rather than loot his former enemies.

Greatness includes being right and successful. Churchill fought against things like women's sufferage, or Indian independence. He was wrong on those issues, and history judges him so.

While South Africa has significant problems, many of them are holdovers of the apartheid and colonial era. People seem to think black African nations should be able to achieve in 50 years of independence what it took european nations centuries to achieve. South Africa is far better off than its neighbours and has managed the transition away from Apartheid better than any of its neighbours have done in their transition away from colonialism. A lot of that success is due to Mandela's unique approach.

I didn't try to create a comprehensive list of leaders for comparison, but Kemal would certainly be worthy of consideration, although his great work came before modern communications and thus I think had less international impact than Mandela's did.
 
Gandhi lived non violence more than Mandela. Mandela went to prison for creating an armed wing, and the armed wing he created went on to carry out many attacks while he was in prison.

Gandhi, however, managed to do something similar while remaining fully committed right his spiritual beliefs in non violence.

I remember the days of "Necklacing", his wife and other ANC officials supported it , later the ANC condemned it.

"Necklacing is the practice of summary execution and torture carried out by forcing a rubber tire, filled with petrol, around a victim's chest and arms, and setting it on fire. The victim may take up to 20 minutes to die, suffering severe burns in the process."

Necklacing "sentences" were sometimes handed down against alleged criminals by "people's courts" established in black townships as a means of enforcing their own judicial system. Necklacing was also used by the black community to punish members of the black community who were perceived as collaborators with the apartheid government. These included black policemen, town councilors and others, as well as their relatives and associates. The practice was often carried out in the name of the ANC. Winnie Mandela, then-wife of the imprisoned Nelson Mandela and a senior member of the ANC, even made statements that endorsed its use.[2] The ANC officially condemned the practice.[3] The number of deaths per month in South Africa related to political unrest as a whole from 1992 through 1995 ranged from 54 to 605 and averaged 244.[4] These figures are inclusive of massacres as well as deaths not attributed to necklacing.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necklacing