Motorcycle Death Arrest

Her greatest error was getting on the bike withis wingnut.

Getting on any bike with somebody else driving is an error. Period. We have to wear seatbelts by law in this country when inside a car. A car comes complete with four wheels and protection from the elements. On a bike, there is no seatbelt and no protection. I don't care how cool or how safe some leather clad monkey on a bike thinks he is. If you ride with somebody on a bike, you have to accept the risks.
 
Which makes one wonder why she was not holding on for dear life.

She was obviously afraid.
Fear makes people panic.
Panic makes people do the wrong thing at the wrong time.
Vicious circle.
 
She was obviously afraid.
Fear makes people panic.
Panic makes people do the wrong thing at the wrong time.
Vicious circle.

You have NO WAY OF knowing any of that....all the perp needs is reasonable doubt. Here you already said she did something wrong... which mitigates the blame of the perp....now what if she was also drunk?
 
Getting on any bike with somebody else driving is an error. Period. We have to wear seatbelts by law in this country when inside a car. A car comes complete with four wheels and protection from the elements. On a bike, there is no seatbelt and no protection. I don't care how cool or how safe some leather clad monkey on a bike thinks he is. If you ride with somebody on a bike, you have to accept the risks.

I don't agree, but that said there are people I would be very confident riding pillion, and some I would never ride with. I have almost fallen off a bike.. yes I was not holding on properly. If I fell it would have been my own stupid fault.
 
You have NO WAY OF knowing any of that.

You are absolutely correct.
99% of what is out there in the universe is unknown which forces people to speculate based on a balance of probabilities.
My personal speculation is there is a 99.8% chance she was absolutely terrified.
 
[The] judge will go based on the evidence. All the defence really has to do is attack the evidence. If the guy knows what is good for him he will not testify. Just attack the evidence and show that nothing can be proven.
Yes but.


If he was already riding like an idiot (which presumably attracted the attention of the cops) then how can you conclude he was attempting to evade rather then just continuing to ride like an idiot.
I like that. Do you think an actual judge or jury will buy that. "Yes it is true that the Defendant was criminally speeding and was traveling at over twice the posted speed limit, and that Sargent Krumpke had activated the lights and siren on his cruiser, but even though according to witness testimony the Defendant sped up, he wasn't attempting to allude, because after all he was already going over double the posted speed limit so he was just attempting to continue on his merry way, rather than stop as the law provides."

Do you really think the law works like that?
Well I can't speak for Ontario. But yes closer to Fuji's version than yours.
 
You are absolutely correct.
99% of what is out there in the universe is unknown which forces people to speculate based on a balance of probabilities.
My personal speculation is there is a 99.8% chance she was absolutely terrified.

If you are someone who gets scared easily by speed, sure. But considering she want for a ride on a motorcycle, one would think she was at least a bit of a thrill seeker.
 
Yes but.


I like that. Do you think an actual judge or jury will buy that. "Yes it is true that the Defendant was criminally speeding and was traveling at over twice the posted speed limit, and that Sargent Krumpke had activated the lights and siren on his cruiser, but even though according to witness testimony the Defendant sped up, he wasn't attempting to allude, because after all he was already going over double the posted speed limit so he was just attempting to continue on his merry way, rather than stop as the law provides."

Well I can't speak for Ontario. But yes closer to Fuji's version than yours.

Wow, you would make a great lawyer...telling the judge your client is guilty... lol.. why don't you just stop there. Firstly, how do you know the defendant was speeding, did you measure his speed with any speed measuring device or pace him? How do you know the defendant accelerated in response to your lights as opposed to just accelerating into a gap in traffic?

Sargent Krumpke: uhhhh uhhhh.. dooh!!!
 
Perhaps you already answered this Nottyboi, but how are you going to get around Rashid Soujah's failure to stop when the passenger fell off?
 
Perhaps you already answered this Nottyboi, but how are you going to get around Rashid Soujah's failure to stop when the passenger fell off?

You can charge him with fail to remain. But the puzzling thing is, they have not chosen to do so. So I suspect there is significant risk that charge will not stick due to other issues. And if one of the charges goes down, it can take the whole case down like a house of cards. This may change so I am just speculating. But it seems they have chosen to throw the highest charge they can at him in hopes of a plea bargin...
 
Getting on any bike with somebody else driving is an error. Period. We have to wear seatbelts by law in this country when inside a car. A car comes complete with four wheels and protection from the elements. On a bike, there is no seatbelt and no protection. I don't care how cool or how safe some leather clad monkey on a bike thinks he is. If you ride with somebody on a bike, you have to accept the risks.


With that responsibilty of riding a bike you also have to be a responsible bike rider, much like a driver in a car.
A driver can be speed as insanely fast as he wants but he has a responsibility for the safety of his passengers as well.
 
We shall see...if the cops have no video evidence it will be hard to prove. How can you say for certain the bike was responding to the cops flashers....if he in fact put them on... maybe he was just giving it the beans for fun. (as if that never happens on a sport bike) If she was not holding on to him (very possible) it is likely he would not even know if she fell of for a bit.

Think about what you just said, if he sped up for fun, he did it at a REAL bad AND conicidental time - cop asking him to pull over.
He's in deep crap and rightly so, failure to stop.
There's a bike forum that I caught a thread about this issue and every single person in the thread was railing him for what he did, not stopping and just taking off, ESPECIALLY since he had a passenger with him.

edit - Here's one link to a thread, it's not the one I was thinking about, but it's a start.
http://www.gtamotorcycle.com/vbforum/showthread.php?126549-Whitby-Accident-Victim-Identified
Post #9 sums it up.
http://www.gtamotorcycle.com/vbforu...m-Identified&p=1393256&viewfull=1#post1393256
 
Firstly, how do you know the defendant was speeding
Because, I would certainly presume that the Constable involved can after foundational questions, give the appropriate version of "I was in a marked Cruiser traveling at X km/h on the 401. . . (and that after I activated the lights and siren on the cruiser) I had the distinct and articulable sensation that the Motorcycle was rapidly pulling away"
 
Indeed it is....after which I would ask the Judge to strike the officers testimony as it was all speculation. In fact I would object as speculation to ANY of these so called facts.
I didn't know that you really wanted a class in courtroom procedure, I thought this was posting about current events on TERB. Hence just are you are doing license is allowed.
 
If you are someone who gets scared easily by speed, sure. But considering she want for a ride on a motorcycle, one would think she was at least a bit of a thrill seeker.

I understand that you are playing devil's advocate and cool wannabe motorcycle toughguy, but any experienced motorcyclist with a clue knows that s/he should never take risks - beyond those already associated with riding - with a passenger on the back. Period.

In fact, before even allowing someone on a bike, the rider should have sussed out what she was wearing and given her the dos and don'ts of being a passenger. Even with that, it is the rider's responsibility to ensure the passenger is both safe and comfortable - 99% of the time, the rider can't even hear the passenger, so he has to be intuitive and smart. Going 180km/h with someone on the back is not only stupid, but it's reckless and dangerous. I'm a little surprised that a 37-year old rider is that inexperienced and stupid, but hey, some folks are just that damn dumb.

As to the assertion that the passenger is a thrill seeker who should be able to hold on, and that it is somewhat or completely her fault, you show a complete lack of understanding of riding, human nature, science, the law and common sense.

The fact that this guy a) fled the scene after dropping his passenger and, b) tried to evade the police in the days and weeks after, shows that he knows what he did was wrong. You seem to lack that capacity and as such, should never have a passenger on whatever bike you claim to ride.

Did this woman show bad judgment in getting on a bike with this guy? Yup. Should she have tried to do everything in her power - safely - to get him to pull over and let her off? Sure. Did she have that opportunity? We'll never know. Is it her fault? Only if she had the power of 20/20 hindsight. Did she deserve to die because of the actions of the rider? Not in a rational universe.

nottyboi said:
If she was not holding on to him (very possible) it is likely he would not even know if she fell of for a bit.
This statement alone makes me wonder 1) if you've ever ridden a bike, 2) and if so, ever had a passenger on it, or, 3) whether you have a clue.
 
Think about what you just said, if he sped up for fun, he did it at a REAL bad AND conicidental time - cop asking him to pull over.
He's in deep crap and rightly so, failure to stop.
There's a bike forum that I caught a thread about this issue and every single person in the thread was railing him for what he did, not stopping and just taking off, ESPECIALLY since he had a passenger with him.

edit - Here's one link to a thread, it's not the one I was thinking about, but it's a start.
http://www.gtamotorcycle.com/vbforum/showthread.php?126549-Whitby-Accident-Victim-Identified
Post #9 sums it up.
http://www.gtamotorcycle.com/vbforu...m-Identified&p=1393256&viewfull=1#post1393256

What are you trying to say?.. the guy is a moron dickhead? SURE... I AGREE... but that does not mean the victim was blameless? If you associate with pond scum.. you are gonna get dirty.. WTF is wrong with you people.