Motorcycle Death Arrest

The douchebag is fully responsible. Any modern bike can lift the front wheel at any speed up to about 180 km/h or more - the driver has a hard enough time holding on, let alone a passenger.

I have seen many, many videos of bikes doing wheelies with a passenger.... who did not fall off.
 
However, seemingly in this case, that (incorrect defendant) would be a matter for pretrial motions.

To use an analogy, if "D" is driving down the highway in a pick-up truck and suddenly accelerates and swerves rolling the truck over and a passenger is thrown out onto the highway and run over by a Austin Mini (who does not have time to avoid them) - it is not the driver of the Austin who will be charged rather "D".

Probably, but this accident was so dynamic it will be hard to map... and there was no real collision that caused the passenger to be thrown off. The guy was riding the motorcycle within the technical limits of the machine.(even if those limits are sky high) He did not lose control of the machine. If he had crashed the bike and killed the passenger, your example would apply. But this is more akin to the passenger falling out of the bed of a pickup truck or not closing the door properly and falling out during a hard cornering event.
 
Your entire premise is based on the pre-mature assumption this was an accident. Police will have to investigate all possibilities, including that he may have deliberately pushed her off the bike...are there witnesses who claim she fell???? I mean..look at the red-neck fuckers foto i could see him pushing his own kid off a bike if it served his purposes..or worse, strangling his partner then drowning his kids and torching the motel room they all shared for a weekend, wouldnt be the first time we have seen that on the news in the Oshawa area. Nottyboi..are you some sort of soft on crime, blame the victim, stand up for the rights of the perpetrator card carrying Liberal??? why would you go so far at this point to categorically believe this was an ACCIDENT??, before the police have even had a chance to fully conduct an investigation?

your reference go Canada Safety Council is laughable, How do you know these folks even spoke English. How do you know if this guy owned the bike, or had ever ridden a bike of this sort before...really,,,how do you know anything except the fact that you clearly enjoy making a dumb ass of yourself on this website???
 
If the accident was not his fault... I doubt there would be a charge. In this case, the bike did not get into an accident so it will be interesting to see how the court apportions blame.

The bike did get into an accident. Plainly.

He accelerated in an unsafe way and his recklessness resulted in someone else's death. Manslaughter is the right charge here--he did not intend to kill her, but he did not show due regard for her safety and as a direct consequence of his reckless action in attempting to illegally flee from the police she's now dead.
 
A North York man has been charged with manslaughter after a woman fell off a motorcycle and was struck by several vehicles and killed three weeks ago.

Rashid Soujah, 37, fled the scene on Hwy. 401 in Whitby and is charged with manslaughter, Durham police said Saturday.

Ioana Bocunescu, 40, was the passenger on the bike when Durham cops attempted to pull it over.

She fell off in the westbound lanes just past Brock St.

Soujah is being held in custody.

The province's Special Investigations Unit is probing the accident.

kevin.connor@sunmedia.ca

The chump in the facebook is Rich Soujah; the asshat from the accident is Rashid Soujah. I'm not certain if they are one in the same.

What I am certain of is this:
a. Soujah evaded a marked police cruiser.
b. Soujah had no regard for his passenger's life.
c. Soujah did not stop when his passenger fell off his bike.
d. Soujah left the scene of an accident.
b. Because of Soujah's actions, a woman is dead and several drivers will be forever traumatized as they could not avoid hitting her. Her family and friends have been traumatized because of Soujah's actions.

Nottyboi in post #9 stated his is not a lawyer. Yet, Nottyboi infers that he knows the law and his opinion is the passenger is responsible for her actions; therefore, she has to accept some responsibility for her death. I wonder what Ioana Bocunescu would tell us if she said STOP or FLEE! Oh, we'll never know because Soujah killed her! Nottyboi just thrives on the drama that he can create at the expense of someone's death.
 
You've mixed me up with nottyboi I agree that the guy is properly charged with manslaughter.

No, that was directed at Nottyboi, I know where you stand on this Fuji.
 
One should always hold on tight and be in a position to strengthen ones grip in an emergency... what if the bike hit a bump?

If going at a reasonable speed and they were riding for however long already, she seemed to be fine and he was riding fine as well.
BUT, once the blinkers went off, he "fled" and in order to do that he really had to "give it the beans" (as they sometimes say on Top Gear).
 
Your entire premise is based on the pre-mature assumption this was an accident. Police will have to investigate all possibilities, including that he may have deliberately pushed her off the bike...are there witnesses who claim she fell???? I mean..look at the red-neck fuckers foto i could see him pushing his own kid off a bike if it served his purposes..or worse, strangling his partner then drowning his kids and torching the motel room they all shared for a weekend, wouldnt be the first time we have seen that on the news in the Oshawa area. Nottyboi..are you some sort of soft on crime, blame the victim, stand up for the rights of the perpetrator card carrying Liberal??? why would you go so far at this point to categorically believe this was an ACCIDENT??, before the police have even had a chance to fully conduct an investigation?

your reference go Canada Safety Council is laughable, How do you know these folks even spoke English. How do you know if this guy owned the bike, or had ever ridden a bike of this sort before...really,,,how do you know anything except the fact that you clearly enjoy making a dumb ass of yourself on this website???

If I am jumping to conclusions then the people saying hang the guy are equally guilty. Based on your little rant, you don't even KNOW if she was a victim. maybe she decided to jump off when he took off from the cops...she may have been drunk.. who knows. So there you have it. If you are accusing me of making a dumb ass of myself, then you are equally guilty of the same thing.
 
The bike did get into an accident. Plainly.

He accelerated in an unsafe way and his recklessness resulted in someone else's death. Manslaughter is the right charge here--he did not intend to kill her, but he did not show due regard for her safety and as a direct consequence of his reckless action in attempting to illegally flee from the police she's now dead.

It will easily be shown in court that even at maximum acceleration, a passanger will have no problem staying on the bike. So again, how do prove his acceleration was "unsafe". Secondly, how do you prove he was actually seeking to evade the police? How far behind was the cruiser...how do you PROVE he saw the flashing lights, how do you PROVE he was not trying to merge to the right lane as is ones obligation when one sees and emergency vehicle... so many outs here. Sure there was an accident, but how do you prove the driver caused it? Clearly this bike is a DOT approved vehicle, and he was riding it within it's limits how do you pin the accident on him?
 
He'll get his day in court and if there are extenuating circumstances his lawyer will surely raise them.

Based on what little we know from the news article though a manslaughter charge is correct: He drove recklessly to escape from the police and as a result a woman died. That IS manslaughter, if it's what happened.
 
So again, how do prove his acceleration was "unsafe".

Sudden, unexpected, and greatly exceeding the speed limit.

Secondly, how do you prove he was actually seeking to evade the police?

The nice thing about our legal system is that such questions are decided by people with brains. That is a question of fact that a jury will determine. There are lots of people in jail who made arguments like this: "how do you PROVE he saw the flashing lights, how do you PROVE he was not trying to merge to the right lane as is ones obligation when one sees and emergency vehicle... so many outs here."
Juries see right through that crap on a regular basis.
 
If going at a reasonable speed and they were riding for however long already, she seemed to be fine and he was riding fine as well.
BUT, once the blinkers went off, he "fled" and in order to do that he really had to "give it the beans" (as they sometimes say on Top Gear).


We shall see...if the cops have no video evidence it will be hard to prove. How can you say for certain the bike was responding to the cops flashers....if he in fact put them on... maybe he was just giving it the beans for fun. (as if that never happens on a sport bike) If she was not holding on to him (very possible) it is likely he would not even know if she fell of for a bit.
 
The nice thing about our legal system is that such questions are decided by people with brains. That is a question of fact that a jury will determine. There are lots of people in jail who made arguments like this: "how do you PROVE he saw the flashing lights, how do you PROVE he was not trying to merge to the right lane as is ones obligation when one sees and emergency vehicle... so many outs here."
Juries see right through that crap on a regular basis.
There are days when Fuji is just plain entirely correct.
 
Sudden, unexpected, and greatly exceeding the speed limit.



The nice thing about our legal system is that such questions are decided by people with brains. That is a question of fact that a jury will determine. There are lots of people in jail who made arguments like this: "how do you PROVE he saw the flashing lights, how do you PROVE he was not trying to merge to the right lane as is ones obligation when one sees and emergency vehicle... so many outs here."
Juries see right through that crap on a regular basis.

How do you prove any of that? Is it definitely a jury trial? There are also a lot of people who made arguments like this who are walking the streets. It is possible that the cops decided not to press all the other charges as they felt they could not convict, ergo it would weaken the manslaughter charge...so you are possibly already seeing some cracks in the case.
 
How do you prove any of that? Is it definitely a jury trial?

The guy could opt for trial by judge, in which case the judge will see right through crap like that. What it is NOT is trial by scientist or trial by computer. It's trial by thinking humans.

If you walk into court hoping to get yourself off by telling people they can't PROVE what is obviously true you will lose. The judge or the jury (your choice) will decide whether a reasonable person would conclude that you are full of shit, and when they decide to disbelieve your "it was random co-incidence that I hit the accelerator and sped off when the cop turned his lights on" you will find out the hard way that "proof" in a court is "beyond a reasonable doubt" in thinking, intelligent, insightful human minds, and not "mathematically, scientifically proven".
 
Her greatest error was getting on the bike withis wingnut. Nottyboi's point is not all that relevant and one suspects he is just pushing it to be difficult. Without being an eyewitness its hard to believe anyone being dumb enough to venture an opinion on this - again not that it means anything in the grand scheme of the case. I have a hard time seeing a judge rule" I'm giving you 2 years and reducing it to 22 months because I have determined that the victime was 10% responsible".
 
The guy could opt for trial by judge, in which case the judge will see right through crap like that. What it is NOT is trial by scientist or trial by computer. It's trial by thinking humans.

If you walk into court hoping to get yourself off by telling people they can't PROVE what is obviously true you will lose. The judge or the jury (your choice) will decide whether a reasonable person would conclude that you are full of shit, and when they decide to disbelieve your "it was random co-incidence that I hit the accelerator and sped off when the cop turned his lights on" you will find out the hard way that "proof" in a court is "beyond a reasonable doubt" in thinking, intelligent, insightful human minds, and not "mathematically, scientifically proven".

Do you really think the law works like that? A good judge will go based on the evidence. All the defence really has to do is attack the evidence. If the guy knows what is good for him he will not testify. Just attack the evidence and show that nothing can be proven. If he was already riding like an idiot (which presumably attracted the attention of the cops) then how can you conclude he was attempting to evade rather then just continuing to ride like an idiot...for example. Intent is a LARGE part of any trial.