Most Overrated NHL Player

Manji

The Balance of Opposites
Jan 17, 2004
11,804
129
63
BTW...how about Tim Thomas? Vezina winner to back-up with Rask playing well now....Leaf fans should be more than a little annoyed with that trade for Raycroft.

What are you gonna do?

The Leafs kept Pogge instead hoping he was gonna be the next big thing....
Pogge didn't do much and neither did Raycroft....

It wasn't a stupid move (which is rare by Leafs management at the time)....the Leafs gambled and they lost...
 

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
51,394
9,968
113
Toronto
Well, there is some consolation in that Kessel gave them a 30 goal scorer. Otherwise, the Leafs would be the only NHL team without even a 20 goal scorer.
I'm sure they had a handfull of others who would have stepped up. (Just don't ask me who.)
 

Scenicdrive

New member
Jan 26, 2005
2,747
0
0
Thomas 'Vanish" Vanek of the Sabres deserves honorable mention. The $7+ Million dollar man has been mostly invisible when the team needs him.
 

maurice93

Well-known member
Mar 29, 2006
5,927
903
113
Maybe, but it won't be in a Hab's uniform...they'll trade him after the playoffs. It seems to me that Montreal consistantly brings more great young goaltenders up through the ranks than any other team, only to put them directly in the fire and expect far too much far too soon, looking for their next "Patrick", and if they don't get instant results, they trade them....Thibault, Theodore, Huet and now Price. Being a Montreal fan, it pisses me off and I hope Price does find himself on a team next year that will allow him to develop and become a star for them.
Your examples are factually incorrect.

Thedore - how could they have rushed him, and never got any results, when he won the damn Hart Trophy!!

Huet - the guy was like 28 years old when he came to the Habs, a career retread.
 

dagwood69

Member
Aug 9, 2009
914
7
18
not a player but i,d say Brian Burke is overrated as a GM, yes the Kessel deal was brutal,,,Based on statistics, u,d get Taylor Hall and anther quality player next year instead of a 1 dimensional player in Kessel, but maybe others would say Taylor Hall is overrated so who knows,,,,Anahaim had the makings of a good team even before Burke took over but he did get the Sedins in Vancouver,,,
 

PornAddict

Active member
Aug 30, 2009
3,620
2
36
60
PHil KESSAL IS WAY OVERATED PLAYER FOR LOUSY 30 GOAL SCORER!!
DEFINITELY NOT A SNIPER... A MEDIOCRE GOAL SCORER WHO IS OVERATED!!
A awesome real sniper is when you score 50 goal in a NHL season. A good sniper is when you score 40 goals in a season.
We trade away our number 1 draft pick for this piece of overated hockey player name Phil Kessal. This trade will resulted in the Toronto Maples Leaf waiting for another 40 years in order to win the Stanley Cup. They haven't won a stanley cup in 40 year...and did not qualify for the playoff in the past 6 year. Prepare to wait for another decade for them to qualify for the playoff. Leaf sucks ... bunch of overrated loser!!!
 
Last edited:

PornAddict

Active member
Aug 30, 2009
3,620
2
36
60
Phil Kessel will always be compared to those two #1's and one #2 draft picks. Imagine if they turn out to be the second coming of Crosby and Ovechkin?
LOL Phil Kessal the second coming of Crosby or Ovechkin! In your dreams ... I don't know what you are smoking lately!!! You are comparing a Porche ( Crosby or Ovechkin) vs Ford Buick ( Kessal) .

Leaf fans are delusional!!
 

The Bandit

Lap Dance Survivor
Feb 16, 2002
5,754
0
0
Anywhere there's a Strip Joint
LOL Phil Kessal the second coming of Crosby or Ovechkin! In your dreams ... I don't know what you are smoking lately!!! You are comparing a Porche ( Crosby or Ovechkin) vs Ford Buick ( Kessal) .

Leaf fans are delusional!!
Obviously you misunderstood, he was saying if the draft picks are the second coming, not Kessel! Go back to watching your porn!
 

PornAddict

Active member
Aug 30, 2009
3,620
2
36
60
Obviously you misunderstood, he was saying if the draft picks are the second coming, not Kessel! Go back to watching your porn!
Yes I misunderstood... I will go back to watching my porn. LOL
 

Questor

New member
Sep 15, 2001
4,549
1
0
PHil KESSAL IS WAY OVERATED PLAYER FOR LOUSY 30 GOAL SCORER!!
DEFINITELY NOT A SNIPER... A MEDIOCRE GOAL SCORER WHO IS OVERATED!!
A awesome real sniper is when you score 50 goal in a NHL season. A good sniper is when you score 40 goals in a season.
We trade away our number 1 draft pick for this piece of overated hockey player name Phil Kessal. This trade will resulted in the Toronto Maples Leaf waiting for another 40 years in order to win the Stanley Cup. They haven't won a stanley cup in 40 year...and did not qualify for the playoff in the past 6 year. Prepare to wait for another decade for them to qualify for the playoff. Leaf sucks ... bunch of overrated loser!!!
Losers
Even
After
Forty
Seasons

Thankfully, it will still work when they are losers even after 50 seasons.

Burke wants to build a version of the Broad Street bullies in Toronto. He really blew it with the Kessel trade. Boston chose not to keep him for a reason. They knew they could fleece someone in a trade and they couldn't resign all their RFA/UFAs last year. Kessel is not a team guy, so he had to go. Considering what they got for him, it was a wise decision. Most teams have to tank in order to get those kind of draft picks. Boston will be laughing for years.
 
May 22, 2008
694
2
18
Losers
Even
After
Forty
Seasons

Thankfully, it will still work when they are losers even after 50 seasons.

Burke wants to build a version of the Broad Street bullies in Toronto. He really blew it with the Kessel trade. Boston chose not to keep him for a reason. They knew they could fleece someone in a trade and they couldn't resign all their RFA/UFAs last year. Kessel is not a team guy, so he had to go. Considering what they got for him, it was a wise decision. Most teams have to tank in order to get those kind of draft picks. Boston will be laughing for years.
i just cant believe we gave up such a high draft pick for kessel. its simply crazy. at least with a draft pick, we can get an elite defensmen or possibly a 40-50 goal prospect. correct me if im wrong...we could have given up kaberle for kessel, right? nothing against kaberle but i doubt he'll be part of the leafs' future.
 

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,776
0
0
i just cant believe we gave up such a high draft pick for kessel. its simply crazy.
Kessel is only 22 and he was a first round pick himself so he is worth one first round draft choice BUT we gave up TWO first round picks and one of those could be a first OVERALL pick.
 
Price is only 22y/o. In 2 years, he will be a star. Maybe.
definitely a slim maybe... Fleury and Ward won stanley cups before age 24. Roy - 20, Brodeur - 23 ... I'm just saying- that's what it takes to be a star in 2 years...

I'd have to say Roberto Luongo is overrated... not the most, but quite suitably in the top 10. I agree Phaneuf is probably the most overrated... just look at his +/- and giveaways.
 
Last edited:

Lapper

.
Aug 20, 2001
3,014
139
63
I'd have to say Roberto Luongo is overrated... not the most, but quite suitably in the top 10.
i'd have to agree with this especially the way he's been playing this season. i can count on one hand the number of games luongo has "stolen" for the canucks this season. not good for someone who had a $7.5 million cap hit this year ($10 million next year). he's a good goalie but he doesn't deserve all the praise he gets.
 
Toronto Escorts