Asia Studios Massage

Most Overrated Bands/Musicians

jeff2

Well-known member
Sep 11, 2004
1,509
813
113
Pink Floyd ?? It pains me to see this, honestly...
Did the OP take the time to read the history, listen to the music, and read the lyrics?

Who is overrated? U2: Bono, himself, admitted, in a recent podcast, that he hates U2 music, hates his own voice ...
[/QUOT
Yeah. I would take Pink Floyd over U2 anyday. Dark Side and Wish You Were Here are masterpieces. Outside of that it is hit or miss and they admitted their songs did not make a lot of sense until Dark Side.
I admit I have not given Animals a full fair listen to comment on it even though I have the CD.
 

tml

Well-known member
Aug 10, 2011
5,065
2,826
113
I really hate when people shit on musicians. If you don’t like the Biebs…. Then don’t listen to him. Easy fix. No need to shit on him.
I've liked him more the older he's gotten. His music seems a bit more serious now.
 

tml

Well-known member
Aug 10, 2011
5,065
2,826
113
Tom Waits
Louis Armstrong
Billie Holliday
I find their voices are more of a novelty.

Boys to Men.
No doubt they are talented, but they overdo every note. Relax guys just let your talent flow.

Placido Domingo
Jose Carreras
Screaming in Italian is not necessarily singing.
 

JeanGary Diablo

Well-known member
Aug 5, 2017
1,419
1,818
113
Most bands that put out good songs in the 1970s put out crappy songs in the 1980s.
LOL, I was talking to a buddy on the phone not 30 minutes ago, and we were saying the exact same thing! Hilarious!

Except we included bands that were also good in the '60s. The Stones, The Kinks, The Who, Pink Floyd, Bowie, Neil Young. Some actually revived themselves in the '90s with some good stuff, but in the 1980s they were crap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeff2

onomatopoeia

Bzzzzz.......Doink
Jul 3, 2020
20,756
17,059
113
Cabbagetown
Randy Bachman and Neil Young had a conversation a few years back. Neil said something to the effect of, that he hated when artists put the same material out over and over and over again, and called it a new album.

Bruce Springsteen had a massive hit with Born to Run… and the market (and record label) were ripe for a more pop sounding album from him…. He follows it up with the bare bones acoustic album Nebraska he recorded in his living room. Epic!
Born to Run wasn't a massive hit when it was released. It's six times Platinum in sales NOW, but it was no more than a Gold record in 1975. On the supporting tour, he didn't play any venues with more than 2,000 seats.

Bruce was involved in a lawsuit with his former manager Mike Appel following BTR, and was not allowed to record any new music while the matter was still in court. His major source of income in 1976 and early 1977 was from live gigs, and without a new record to promote, he was still playing in theaters, rather than arenas.

His acoustic album Nebraska was released more than seven years after Born to Run, with the single disk Darkness on the Edge of Town and the double album The River in between. The Darkness tour was the first time Bruce and The E Street Band played in sports arenas, but only in the some of the larger cities on the tour. Opening night of the Darkness tour was at Shea's in Buffalo, capacity 3,000. Prove it All Night was the highlight of the Darkness Tour:


In Montreal, he played at The Forum in November, 1978, but in the 'concert bowl' configuration, where the stage is at about center ice for hockey, instead of at the north end of the rink, and seating behind the stage wasn't sold. Capacity for that show was probably about 8,000, and about 75% of the seats were sold. Many consider the Darkness tour to have been his peak artistically as a live performer. I agree with that opinion, having seen that November, 1978 show as well as The River and Born in the USA tours.

I don't listen to any of his studio albums after Nebraska, and the last album of his that I bought was Born in the USA, on cassette tape. I still do enjoy listening to recordings of his live performances from 1974-78. Bruce hadn't declined as a performer on The River tour, it was more a case that his better live songs had been on the previous two albums, and he couldn't play all of his best while necessarily including much of The River in his set, even in a three hour show. He also played very little guitar on stage on the The River and Born in the USA tours. He had played most of the lead parts and solos on previous tours.

"People say we have ten albums that sound exactly the same. That isn't true. We have eleven albums that sound exactly the same" - Angus Young of AC/DC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: poker

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
49,899
9,217
113
Toronto
Bruce Springsteen had a massive hit with Born to Run… and the market (and record label) were ripe for a more pop sounding album from him…. He follows it up with the bare bones acoustic album Nebraska he recorded in his living room. Epic!
Actually he did Born to Run, then Darkness on the Edge of Town, then The River and then Nebraska.
 
  • Like
Reactions: poker

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
49,899
9,217
113
Toronto
Born to Run wasn't a massive hit when it was released. It's six times Platinum in sales NOW, but it was no more than a Gold record in 1975. On the supporting tour, he didn't play any venues with more than 2,000 seats.
It did launch his career, though. His first two albums did poorly and Born was pretty much his last chance as far as his label was concerned and Bruce new it. He slaved over it and drove the band crazy doing take after take after take. I'm not sure, but that may have been when he got the nickname, "The Boss".

I saw him on the Born to Run tour and, as you say about small venues, he played the Seneca Field House on Finch and it was basically a gymnasium with no seats.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: poker

K Douglas

Half Man Half Amazing
Jan 5, 2005
27,011
7,535
113
Room 112
For me it has to be Bob Dylan. I just don't get it.

Mentions:
Radiohead
The Clash
Bruce Springsteen
Bon Jovi
Blondie
TLC
Kendrick Lamar
Adele
OutKast
 

barnacler

Well-known member
May 13, 2013
1,465
847
113
Foreigner. Why or how Ian McDonald could leave a band like King Crimson and become a member of that impersonation of a rock group is beyond my comprehension. If I'm in the car and a station starts playing 'I Want to Know What Love Is', I just give up on the day and go find a place to drink and then bed down for the night.
Many, many bands go soft and commercial later on, and it sucks.

Led Zeppelin is a case in point.

All of My Love is so bad, it is painful.

Phil Collins, Heart, Aerosmith (don't want to miss a thing (except this song!))

I respect the ones like Peter Gabriel that stay musical.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ogibowt

barnacler

Well-known member
May 13, 2013
1,465
847
113
But NOONE can compare with The Tragically Hip for being so bad on so many fronts:

voice, music, quality of musicianship, meaningless lyrics - while pathetically trying to sound meaningful.
 

Varoufakis

Well-known member
Jul 11, 2015
961
1,402
93
But NOONE can compare with The Tragically Hip for being so bad on so many fronts:

voice, music, quality of musicianship, meaningless lyrics - while pathetically trying to sound meaningful.
wow ... you said that in a tragic... and hip way ...
LoL
 

Bbw hunter

Well-known member
Dec 17, 2018
1,271
802
113
But NOONE can compare with The Tragically Hip for being so bad on so many fronts:

voice, music, quality of musicianship, meaningless lyrics - while pathetically trying to sound meaningful.
I had this co worker in the 90's who was a Hip fanatic but I just couldn't get what all the fuss was about. To me they sounded quite mediocre.
He kept saying that they "kick ass" but I just couldn't hear it. Van Halen kicked ass....The Hip sounded sluggish to me.
He was a Grunge kid so maybe it was a generational thing.
 

barnacler

Well-known member
May 13, 2013
1,465
847
113
I had this co worker in the 90's who was a Hip fanatic but I just couldn't get what all the fuss was about. To me they sounded quite mediocre.
He kept saying that they "kick ass" but I just couldn't hear it. Van Halen kicked ass....The Hip sounded sluggish to me.
He was a Grunge kid so maybe it was a generational thing.
Alice in Chains is Grunge and they are fantastic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: seagerbuzz
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts