Montreal Rules

I seriously wonder if Montreal will even make the playoffs this season in a pretty competitive Atlantic division. Tampa is a little weaker, but still strong. Boston is diminished, but can still maul a team, Florida has made some significant improvements over the past few seasons, and Toronto can still light it up (in the regular season)....Where does that leave Montreal? Best defensemen is on the shelf for a good chunk of this year. Can Price be healthy and consistent? Who's going to score?
I think the Leafs are weaker this year with the loss of Hyman and Andersen.

The Canadiens will have Cole Caufield for the full season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: silentkisser
I think the Leafs are weaker this year with the loss of Hyman and Andersen.

The Canadiens will have Cole Caufield for the full season.
I'm not concerned about Freddy, Hyman might be a difficult thing to replace. But his contract is going to look very expensive in the final years (likely). He was a great player and will be missed.
 
Maurice, as usual you are elegant in articulating the pros and cons on particular issues. I guess I keep thinking of Ohtani as a part-time pitcher, part-time DH and part-time OF. I hope he will just pick one or the other like every other MLB player, including Babe Ruth, and maybe he will at some point.

Why would you hope he picks one or the other? How does this possibly add any value to fans.

There have been many great pitchers … many great hitters. Why do we want him to be something that we have already seen countless times?

Do we not want to enjoy and see greatness in a unique way? Doesn’t mean he is better than other greats just different.

When Bobby Orr started dominating the NHL as an offensive defenceman did you hope that he would become a forward instead or become a more standard Defender for that time?
 
Why would you hope he picks one or the other? How does this possibly add any value to fans.
I guess I'm a traditionalist in some respect. Even Babe Ruth (of course, there was no DH in his era) picked being a full time position player. If he wants to do both and his team and MLB allows him to do both, then so be it. Maybe he'll start a trend.

I heard there were some NFL players who played both offense and defense and/or also kick. Not sure if there are any now who do both in a meaningful way. Deion Sanders did played some offense in addition to his full time DB position.
NFL's Best Two-Way Players of All Time | Bleacher Report | Latest News, Videos and Highlights
 
When Bobby Orr started dominating the NHL as an offensive defenceman did you hope that he would become a forward instead or become a more standard Defender for that time?
As far as I know, Orr only played as a defenseman, he did not play one game as a defenseman and then another as a forward, one position (defense) only (with maybe some rare occasions when he did not). Unlike Ohtani who is pitcher, DH and/or OF depending on the game.

BTW: Red Kelly started as a defenseman and then switched to centre full-time.
Red Kelly - Wikipedia
 
As far as I know, Orr only played as a defenseman, he did not play one game as a defenseman and then another as a forward, one position (defense) only (with maybe some rare occasions when he did not). Unlike Ohtani who is pitcher, DH and/or OF depending on the game.

BTW: Red Kelly started as a defenseman and then switched to centre full-time.
Red Kelly - Wikipedia
Whoever knew that Kelly changed positions?

So Orr was one-dimensional and Ohtani can contribute multiple ways. That sounds more valuable. Not that you will want to debate that.

Regardless, trying to currently compare Montreal to Toronto, the title of this thread should not have been Montreal rules, it should have been "Montreal Drools". And you won't debate that either.
 
You can’t turn right on a red light in Montreal, this nullifies any chance of being a great city.
 
You can’t turn right on a red light in Montreal, this nullifies any chance of being a great city.

Carey Price has had to shoulder the fate of the Canadiens, he's burned out. Will this be the return of Red Light Racicot?

In terms of restaurants Toronto is catching up, Montreal still has better seafood. Philadelphia makes baby food compared to Toronto.

 
Last edited:
Apparently, mental/emotional stress (just guessing). It's stressful being the best goalie of your generation. It's stressful being a goalie, period.

It’s most likely some sort of substance abuse issue — be it alcohol, painkillers, recreational drugs. Of course the cause of that could well be mental stress.

He is in a program that be must stay in for at least 30 days per league and player association agreement. That is just not for mental stress.
 
Last edited:
Apparently, mental/emotional stress (just guessing). It's stressful being the best goalie of your generation. It's stressful being a goalie, period.
I feel bad for Price.

Between the rabid fans and relentless press in Montreal it's no wonder that there's lots of stress.

They've/you've been drinking a lot of Kool-Aid, pas de champagne, for the last 30 years but he's the one that pays the price (apologies, but the pun was unavoidable).
 
Last edited:
Ok, Angela Price on Instagram mentioned "mental health".
Instagram photo by Angela Price • Oct 7, 2021 at 11:01 AM

She is not incorrect. Substance abuse of whatever kind ia typically a mental health issue as well.

When Drouin left last year for mental health issues, Bergevin confirmed that it was not related to drug abuse at the time. He also did not have a set timeline on his time away and he was not part of the voluntary assistance program because it was not that type of issue. Bergevin while not being specific on Price’s issue said the situation was not the same as Drouin.

The fact that he is part of the voluntary assistance program and he must stay in it for at least 30 days is sort of a give away of some issue. Glad he is getting help.
 
Last edited:
On Jesus Price.
When he is on, he is on. However we spends so much time either injured, slumping or pulling a temper tampum forcing Montreal to go with their backup as number 1. I wonder if he is worth it. Yeah sure he should get help, but when you combine rest of the history... Maybe he will get his head on straight and the extra time off will embiggin his physical condition. One can hope. I can't see it being the drugs but as we learned when everyone, in particular the leftists were piling on mayor Ford, addiction is also a mental health issue.

On Montreal.

Traffic. I hear people complain about Montreal highways but they don't bother me much. You quickly get used to the French signage although some of it sucks [in any language]. I do find that Toronto embiggins my urge to kill ever time to go there/through there in a way Montreal does not, even when the Turcott exchange was all fucked up under construction.
Never been on the Toronto Metro but I get the impression the Montreal one is more cromulent
Go Trains are better than Montreal. I just don't understand them. Even my father who spent his first 20 years as French only can't figure it out, and last time I was at the station, the other people at the stop couldn't either. One time I went from DT to the burbs I had to get help from someone. Double plus an issue because well if you don't know French.

Swiss Chalet > St Hubert Jay Baruchel can suck my dick and lick my asshole clean... and probably would enjoy it considering he is a Hubert fan. Chalet fries are 10 times better, the bread is 10 times better, it's a bit cheaper, you get get ribs as a 1/3 in case you don't want to die of a heart attack right away and the desserts although more plain, I enjoy more.

More black eye candy in Montreal I think, more Indian and Oriental eye candy in Toronto.

Best part, if you are wealthy and have spots set up in the downtown of both, it is only a shortish train ride between the two.