Montreal Rules

Raducanu didn't drop a set in the entire tournament. No shame in losing to that juggernaut.
Agree with you. Leylah never gave up and had Emma on the run. I think that Emma was near to being gassed by the end.

Responding rationally to shittydrawers is wasted energy. I have not seen one intelligent post from him yet. Only one insult after another.
 
Fernandez didn't put up much of a fight today, seemed to be a step behind the whole match. Hard to tell if she'll will just be a cinderella story too.
The talking heads on TV said that Fernandez spent 5 hours more time on court than Emma, had the tougher opponents and had to win 5 tie breakers and that is both physically and mentally taxing.

BTW: If you didn't already know, you're finding out that it is impossible to reason with that other poster. So many of his posts are nothing more than just noise. “It’s all sound and fury, signifying nothing” Quoting Willie Shakespeare.
 
Exactly , no one else in MLB can hit and pitch successfully as he does, hence he is the most talented and best player in the majors.
Shohei Ohtani is a sometime pitcher, sometime DH and sometime OF.

It's rare for a pitcher to win MVP without also winning Cy Young and it is even rarer for a DH to win MVP. Only 3 DH's who played a few games as DH have won MVP.

"Since 1973, which was the first year DHs were used by the American League, three players have won the MVP award in years they played a significant amount of games as a designated hitter.

The first was Boston's Jim Rice who in 1978 played 49 of his 163 games (remember the one-game playoff against New York) as a DH. The next season California Angels league MVP Don Baylor played 65 of 162 games at DH, and finally in 1996 Texas' Juan Gonzalez played 32 of 134 games at DH."
 
Shovel Ohtani is almost guaranteed to be winning the MVP.

Current odds per Bet 365:
Ohtani -5000 (bet $100 and get back $102)
Guerrero +1400 (bet $100 and get back $1500).

The playoff team argument is not that relevant in this case. Look at Mike Trout who was won MVPs in the same scenario in An

Guerrero can win the Triple Crown and have a historic season. It’s just that Ohtani has happened to have one of the more historic and unique seasons since Babe Ruth.

In most seasons Guerrero would be the clear MVP. He is just running into something unseen in over 100 years.
 
Last edited:
Shovel Ohtani is almost guaranteed to be winning the MVP.

Current odds per Bet 365:
Ohtani -5000 (bet $100 and get back $102)
Guerrero +1400 (bet $100 and get back $1500).

The playoff team argument is not that relevant in this case. Look at Mike Trout who was won MVPs in the same scenario in An

Guerrero can win the Triple Crown and have a historic season. It’s just that Ohtani has happened to have one of the more historic and unique seasons since Babe Ruth.

In most seasons Guerrero would be the clear MVP. He is just running into something unseen in over 100 years.
If vlad wins triple crown and leads in 6 offensive categories he will win imo. I believe the pitching will become less significant in voters eyes. If he's significantly ahead of ohtani in many offensive categories it will offset the other numbers imo.
 
The talking heads on TV said that Fernandez spent 5 hours more time on court than Emma, had the tougher opponents and had to win 5 tie breakers and that is both physically and mentally taxing.

BTW: If you didn't already know, you're finding out that it is impossible to reason with that other poster. So many of his posts are nothing more than just noise. “It’s all sound and fury, signifying nothing” Quoting Willie Shakespeare.
I don't think at her age it should have mattered. She looked overmatched from the start imo.
 
BTW: If you didn't already know, you're finding out that it is impossible to reason with that other poster.
What did I say that was unreasonable about the Ohtani-Guerrero comparison? Eh, Turtle Boy?

1631416102165.png

If you ever want to have an honest debate, I can stop showing your picture. Until then, you are full value for the moniker.
 
Seek help immediately, I'll pay.
What did I say that was unreasonable? All you do is lob insults without saying anything relevant to the topic at hand. Would you like to discuss things as an adult?

Keeping dart's link of a reasonable opinion in mind, who is the best player and who is the most valuable player?
 
If vlad wins triple crown and leads in 6 offensive categories he will win imo. I believe the pitching will become less significant in voters eyes. If he's significantly ahead of ohtani in many offensive categories it will offset the other numbers imo.

most MVP voters have moved more toward advanced composite stats such as WAR for their MVP assessments and don’t obsess as much about counting stats rankings as much as they used to … although they are not irrelevant either and a triple crown means something.

Ohtani due to his effectiveness in both roles had a lead of about 8 to 6 in WAR. That is a big difference.

I think there is some value at Guerrero at +1400 in the odds but he is going to really need to step up above his current level his last 20 games to get there and he will need Ohtani to have a big slump on one side of the field. It helps that the Jays could make the playoffs for a few voters.

MVP voters are public and many have already said they will be almost certainly be voting for Ohtani. Vegas doesn’t throw odds of -5000 and +1400 without doing some careful research. That all being said I do see value in the +1400 but Vlad will have to exceed his current level down the stretch and Ohtani may need to get rocked in most of his starts.
 
Last edited:
What about Toronto's own Joey Votto. Doesn't get a lot of love playing in the National League with the Reds, but he's an almost sure hall of famer.

As for the best hockey team...Well, as someone mentioned, sure, for two months. Don't know how they'll look this year after all the losses and injuries...
are you kidding been better over the last 100 years of any team in nhl 24 almost 25 cups. and thank god montreal didnt have a parade for making it to finals when toronto had a parade for making it to semi finals what a joke of a franchise
 
most MVP voters have moved more toward advanced composite stats such as WAR for their MVP assessments and don’t obsess as much about counting stats rankings as much as they used to … although they are not irrelevant either and a triple crown means something.

Ohtani due to his effectiveness in both roles had a lead of about 8 to 6 in WAR. That is a big difference.

I think there is some value at Guerrero at +1400 in the odds but he is going to really need to step up above his current level his last 20 games to get there and he will need Ohtani to have a big slump on one side of the field. It helps that the Jays could make the playoffs for a few voters.

MVP voters are public and many have already said they will be almost certainly be voting for Ohtani. Vegas doesn’t throw odds of -5000 and +1400 without doing some careful research. That all being said I do see value in the +1400 but Vlad will have to exceed his current level down the stretch and Ohtani may need to get rocked in most of his starts.
Maurice, as usual you are elegant in articulating the pros and cons on particular issues. I guess I keep thinking of Ohtani as a part-time pitcher, part-time DH and part-time OF. I hope he will just pick one or the other like every other MLB player, including Babe Ruth, and maybe he will at some point.
 
"shack said:
What did I say that was unreasonable about the Ohtani-Guerrero comparison? Eh, Turtle Boy?"

Apparently, TERB rule #2 doesn't apply to Shack as he is a serial violator of that rule.
You will post anything other than having a rational, logical debate.
1631504938062.png

What did I say that was unreasonable about the Ohtani-Guerrero comparison? It was factual based on the article that you referenced.

Do you want some cheese with that whine?
 
Last edited:
are you kidding been better over the last 100 years of any team in nhl 24 almost 25 cups. and thank god montreal didnt have a parade for making it to finals when toronto had a parade for making it to semi finals what a joke of a franchise
Toronto has had a bad half century. There is no argument there. Harold Ballard was a cancer to this team that set them seriously back. But, up until expansion, both teams had near equal amounts of cups. Since expansion, Montreal was able to draft incredible well (something Toronto obviously didn't do), and take advantage of weak expansion teams to go on a legendary run in the 70s. Interestingly, once the expansion teams got good, Montreal has only won two cups.

So, that might not be the flex you think it is. I mean, it's been nearly 30 years since the Candien's won the cup. We don't know (yet) when they or the Leafs will win it next. Despite the embarrassment of the playoffs this year, I still think Toronto is a vastly superior team, and might surprise everyone this year. Montreal...well, since the Finals and draft it's been sort of a disaster....
 
I mean, it's been nearly 30 years since the Candien's won the cup.
Last Canadian team to win the Cup.

We don't know (yet) when they or the Leafs will win it next. Despite the embarrassment of the playoffs this year, I still think Toronto is a vastly superior team, and might surprise everyone this year.
The Leafs haven't won even round one in recent memory.
 
Sure. But it'll be 29 years of futility for the Habs after this season. They've had a couple of deep runs in that time, but nothing to show for it. You're right, the Leafs haven't won fuck all in a hell of a lot longer time, but I'd still go with the Buds in the near term. I seriously wonder if Montreal will even make the playoffs this season in a pretty competitive Atlantic division. Tampa is a little weaker, but still strong. Boston is diminished, but can still maul a team, Florida has made some significant improvements over the past few seasons, and Toronto can still light it up (in the regular season)....Where does that leave Montreal? Best defensemen is on the shelf for a good chunk of this year. Can Price be healthy and consistent? Who's going to score?