Money Doesn't Make People Happy

xUxJr311fr3P

Guest
Dec 31, 2005
123
0
0
Money Doesn't Make People Happy

By Tim Harford
Forbes.com

"The hippies," claimed economist Andrew Oswald recently, "are having their quiet revenge." Oswald, a professor at Warwick University in England, is one of a growing number of economists fascinated by the question of what makes us happy. In a recent public lecture he announced, "Once a country has filled its larders, there is no point in that nation becoming richer."

That, at least, should bring a smile to a few faces. Economists have suddenly realized that money can't buy you happiness? This is like the squarest kid at school suddenly discovering beer, girls and music in his 30s. The rest of the world had worked it out already.

One of the things that excites economists like Oswald is the ability to compare data on wealth, education and marital status with the results of happiness surveys. In these surveys, people are asked such questions as "Taking all things together, would you say you are very happy, quite happy, not very happy, not at all happy?" Economists have been trying to make sense of the results across individuals, across countries and across the years. The headline: Once a country gets fairly rich (though much poorer than the United States), further economic growth does not seem to make its citizens any happier.

So, money does not buy happiness. Or does it? "In every society, at any point in time, richer people are happier," points out Will Wilkinson, a policy analyst at the Cato Institute in Washington D.C., who runs a blog on happiness research and public policy. "But that in itself doesn't tell you much about the relationship between money and happiness."

Richer people, after all, tend to have high-status jobs. They tend to have more control over their lives at work--why pay someone six figures if you're not going to ask her to use her own judgment? They also have higher expectations and will be comparing themselves to wealthier people. It's hard to say what is really driving the results: money, status or expectations.

Perhaps each society's richer people are also happier because happiness comes not from absolute wealth but from relative wealth--recall H.L. Mencken's quip that "a wealthy man is one who earns $100 a year more than his wife's sister's husband." A more skeptical view is that while it means something to compare my happiness with that of the guy asking me for change on the street, it means nothing to compare my feelings today to those of my grandfather in 1950--or those of a Portuguese shopkeeper or a Japanese salaryman.

Wilkinson and economists like Oswald and his compatriot Lord Layard are thinking about the policy implications of happiness research. My own interest is a little different: Can the new breed of happiness economists offer us any tips for happier living?

Much of the advice is pretty slippery. For instance, married people are much happier than single people. So perhaps you should get married? (Even better if your fiancée's sister's husband is unemployed.) Not so fast. More sophisticated surveys show that the causation runs both ways: Happy people tend to find spouses, while those suffering from depression don't find it so easy. And--not surprisingly--some people do brilliantly out of marriage, and others are utterly miserable. As an economist, I'm afraid I have no idea whether you should propose to that cute girl you've been seeing. (You may or may not take comfort in Oswald's finding that you can always get out of marriage: People are happier immediately after a divorce than immediately before.)

Oswald also suggests self-employment, if you can pull it off without losing out financially. "Everything associated with self-employment--independence, autonomy--is also associated with being happy."

Both Oswald and Richard Layard argue that relationships are more important than money--and that includes professional relationships. "I've come to believe in the old-fashioned view that one should be tender in one's dealings with colleagues," Lord Layard told me in an interview. And what else? "Think about what you have rather than what you don't have, both materially and in your relationships and your personal strengths. To use the language of economics, don't try to rectify things that aren't your comparative advantage."

This is spiritual thinking from an economist, but Oswald goes one better. If you're depressed, why not just wait? "There's a kind of J-curve describing happiness over time. Your late 30s are the most unhappy period of your life, but then the older you get the happier you are. Life really does begin again at 40."

I think the most useful research, though, is by an honorary economist: Danny Kahneman, the only psychologist ever to win the Nobel Prize in economics. He asked nearly 1,000 working women in Texas to reflect on their previous day, list the different episodes in it, what they were doing and how they were feeling.

Some results are predictable enough: Work is miserable, and commuting is worse. Others are not so obvious. For instance, praying is fun, but looking after the kids is not. Spending time with your friends is one of the most enjoyable things you can do, but spending time with your spouse is merely OK. In fact, parents or other relatives turn out to make more enjoyable company than the supposed love of your life.

What is perfectly clear, though, is that socializing with anyone except your boss makes you feel good. Sex is best of all. This is handy advice at last. But what if you are having sex with your boss? Whereof economists cannot speak, we must remain silent.

Tim Harford, a Financial Times columnist, is the author of The Undercover Economist.

Go to Forbes.com to see the slideshow

Back to Your Money: Money, Happiness, the Opposite Sex
 
Happiness is free

Ok, nobody replied so I will let you know what I think. Most people do equate money with happiness, especially in Toronto. This does not surprise me but what if you were diagnosed with a serious life threatening illness? Would you still think as much about money? Probably not. You would be a lot more concerned with your health and ask yourself what really matters in life.

Everybody needs money but I can tell you that I personally know many disgustingly rich people in my line of work that are miserable. Why? because being happy comes from within, not from external goods and services. One of my favorite philosophers, Bertrand Russell, wrote a great book on happiness. He concludes that we can only achieve true happiness when we stop worrying about ourselves and start helping other people.

I know, this is counterintuitive, but if you think hard about it, it makes perfect sense. Finally, absolute wealth is meaningless, it is relative wealth that ultimately matters in society. If you have enough to feed yourself, clothe yourself and have a roof over your head, you're very lucky.

Of course, we always want more money, bigger breasts, longer penises, face lifts, etc., but this is a sure way down misery lane.

GG
 
Esco,

Judging by the way you replied, you're an obvious retard who is in terrible need of oxygen to restore the precious few neurons that might still be functioning in your shit-for-brains.

Now why don't you make like the wind an blow me!
 
General Gonad said:
Esco,

Judging by the way you replied, you're an obvious retard who is in terrible need of oxygen to restore the precious few neurons that might still be functioning in your shit-for-brains.

Now why don't you make like the wind an blow me!
Now thats a good comeback!! :D
 
A sack of cash sure as hell would make me one happy fuckin bunny right now. A hell of a lot of stress would simply disappear so I think your analysis may be a bit skewed there General. This coming from someone who isn't that high up on the food chain BTW.
 
When I ask my friends what's new? They usually reply, "nothing much just working." To be frank, I don't really care about the money they're earning. I just want to know what they're doing in there spare time. It is what you do in your spare time is what shapes you as an individual that is different from the rest of the group.

You brought up an interesting question about money. A majority of men have their self worth tie up to how much income they earn in a year. Suppose you were laying on your death bed. Are you going to say, "Oh, I wish I had work more overtime or more hours for that extra money." Chances are you would probably wish you would have spent more time with (insert name). Better yet, fulfilling a personal goal which only has significant meaning to you. All in all, if you don't see the need to keep up with the Jones, then you wouldn't put much thought into negative remarks by your peers regarding your home furnishings.

The problem in Toronto is that cost of living is high and income isn't keeping pace. For single parents, they would have to work more than one job to support a family. For those who are business owners, they can relate to the challenge of trying to sell more to existing customers or finding new customers to raise their income. There's a trade off for working long hours, you don't get to spend much time with the people you care about in your lives because you get tired from work.
 
I suppose money doesn't buy happiness but it doesn't hurt.

Lack of money is often the root of marital/problems in the relationship.

The stress of paying bills can really weigh people down.

Hard to focus on the relationship with that hanging over your head.

Plus how do you pursue happiness or maintain a relationship when you're busy working.
 
I wouldn't generalize, happy people can be wealthy or poor.

Money can solve problems, but so can things that cost nothing like knowledge, encouragement, luck or just hard work.
 
Money is not directly responsible for people's happiness. However, it does give you a whole lot more options. Money definitely puts you in the driver's seat and not a mere passenger in life...and that is surely a step closer to happiness - although many other factors are in play that can pull you many steps away from it. With all things being the same, I'd rather have more money as opposed to less of it :)
 
Svend said:
Money can solve problems, but so can things that cost nothing like knowledge, encouragement, luck or just hard work.
Good quote!

I don't have much money but looking back fond memories of truly being happy when we had less.
 
Money doesn't necessairly make people happy, but it sure as hell helps. Perhaps the true meaning of happiness is far more then just one thing alone. With lots of money, yet you are lonely does not equate happiness. Yet with no money but a SO that loves you very much is not happiness either. I think the true pursuit is for that middle ground. The compromise of both mediums to justify your existance and therefore your happiness. To find the balance of two things that are so important that they can only prevail by needing each other to sustain this emotion you call happiness rather then standing alone and seperate from each other. Ok this is becoming to philosophical for me, but all I can say is I'd rather be rich and have a content marriage, then broke and really happy with nothing. :cool:
 
Money may not buy happiness, but poverty sure as HELL doesn't.
 
More money = More Happy

ALL you ALL who said money doesn't buy happiness are lying. MONEY CAN BUY YOU EVERYTHING BUT LOVE!!!

I am going to the dentist today, if I didn't have money to pay him, I'd be shit out luck and in pain - that would NOT make me happy!!! But because I have the money to pay him I AM VERY VERY HAPPY!!!!

I am sitting on an old desk chair, it's been hard on my back lately, my kid needs a new chair as well. We went looking yesterday for chairs, the ones we liked were around $300.00 a piece. After the dentist, I am going out to buy 2 new executive leather chairs. We are going to feel more comfortable when at the computer. I AM SUPER HAPPY!!!

There are lots of other things I can tell you about, that make me happy and most of them require money. Since health, love and relationships are already here I don't worry about that and besides that's not the subject at hand. But I do stress when I don't have money, not because I can't buy anything new, but because I worry about keeping the roof over our heads. That's the only real concern I have.

Other than that we can live with the basics but clearly money can buy you health / healthier living. When I have more money I buy better food and that makes us happier and healthier. It also makes me happy when my kid has everything they need or want. As far as I am concerned we are only here once - so why not live it up. Besides when I have money I spread it around ;-), I don't just hog it and keep it in the bank; I use it, share it, and keep the economy going, keeping the rich happy too, :eek: