MLB Playoffs - Matchups

blueline said:
Also, good managing by Pinella to put the hook on Zambrano early in game 1. Now he will be very well rested for Spring Training.

I rhink people are making way too much of that situation.

First off the Cubs still had to score a run too win.... they did not.

Second, there is a prob a 30-50% chance that Zambrano would have given up a run himself if he had pitched another two innings.

People tend to overrate starting pitchers over relievers... can a reliever be as effective as Zambrano as a starter. Not a chance But a good reliever who is asked to pitch the seventh or eighth is more effective then an elite starter who is potentially tiring.

Piniella brought in a good reliever. He gave up a run. You know what... runs are scored in baseball. But it gives fans something to talk about.

Really this is Bud Selig's fault... see I can always blame something on Bud. :D

If Bud did not have his head up his ass:
a) The first round would be seven games
and
B) THERE WOULD BE NO DAYS OFF DURING A SERIES, so the way use a pitching staff comes close to resemblng the real season. It is absolutely assinine that the Yankees play three games in five days. It's not a "coincidence" that the Yanjs series has the most days off... they have the least depth in there starters and there bullpen.
 
maurice93 said:
I Really this is Bud Selig's fault... see I can always blame something on Bud. :D

If Bud did not have his head up his ass:
a) The first round would be seven games
and
B) THERE WOULD BE NO DAYS OFF DURING A SERIES, so the way use a pitching staff comes close to resemblng the real season. It is absolutely assinine that the Yankees play three games in five days. It's not a "coincidence" that the Yanjs series has the most days off... they have the least depth in there starters and there bullpen.

Actually it was the Red Sox series that was to have the most days off in total, that number being 3. Yankees series only has 2 days off total. That was no "coincidence" either. Sox had the best record in the AL and had the choice of what schedule to play to.
 
one day off makes total sense for travel, which is what they do in the regular season if you're going from the east coast to west coast ie Boston to Anaheim.

Sure the distance between Cleveland and New York isn't far, but you have to have a level playing field.
 
blueline said:
Actually it was the Red Sox series that was to have the most days off in total, that number being 3. Yankees series only has 2 days off total. That was no "coincidence" either. Sox had the best record in the AL and had the choice of what schedule to play to.

I stand corrected. That being said I still hate the excessive days off whether its the Yanks or anybody else.

They should not have the choice - that is the problem. The seroes have to all be the same with one day off (Max)
Anyway was trying to take a shot at Selig and the yanks... guess I'll just take a shot at Selig,
 
the_big_E said:
one day off makes total sense for travel, which is what they do in the regular season if you're going from the east coast to west coast ie Boston to Anaheim.

Not quite. More often then not (as compared to days off) teams play a day game then a night game when travelling coast to coast, which is mandated by the CBA.

I can live with one day off in a series but not two, especially a five game series.
 
Anderson said:
I have been holding your hand all year with your beloved Red Sox and I stood firm as you were waiting for another collapse.

This though is the end- say bye bye because they lose to LA I think.

LAA
NYY
Philly
Cubbies

How did that turn out for you?

As for me expecting a collapse by the Sox, I already told you that's what Red Sox fans do. They can lose a Tuesday night game in July to Tampa Bay and people are ready to jump out their windows. They break our hearts so many times that we come to expect the worst. It is great the Sox won the ALDS, of course I couldn't be happier. But we know it takes 11 games to win so I, for one, won't be blowing my horn til it's over. We know what can happen so we just sit back and away from any sharp objects til the series is over.
 
maurice93 said:
I stand corrected. That being said I still hate the excessive days off whether its the Yanks or anybody else.

They should not have the choice - that is the problem. The seroes have to all be the same with one day off (Max)
Anyway was trying to take a shot at Selig and the yanks... guess I'll just take a shot at Selig,

I am not sure I like the choice of three days off either. While it is done to reward the best team and allow them to start their top two pitchers twice, it does the same for the team they are playing. So I really do not see the advantage. Next year the NL has the choice so looks like Bud-Lite wants this to be a regular thing.
 
On to the ALDS & NLDS...and I am glad the Yankees will not be partaking. Excellent job by the Indians shutting down that lineup....so

Arizona vs Colorado
Boston vs Cleveland

I am picking Arizona on the basis that good pitching beats good hitting in the playoffs, and can the Rockies keep playing this well?

And I'll go with Boston in 7...this should be a very good series, the teams are really close, but I give the slight edge to Boston but it wouldnt surprise me if the Indians win.
 
blueline said:
How did that turn out for you?

As for me expecting a collapse by the Sox, I already told you that's what Red Sox fans do. They can lose a Tuesday night game in July to Tampa Bay and people are ready to jump out their windows. They break our hearts so many times that we come to expect the worst. It is great the Sox won the ALDS, of course I couldn't be happier. But we know it takes 11 games to win so I, for one, won't be blowing my horn til it's over. We know what can happen so we just sit back and away from any sharp objects til the series is over.

Did not turn out that well ! LOL !

Probably could not do that again if I tried !

Arizona and Cleveland , although I would love to see Dice win a few games in the WS !

Good Luck though,
 
Anderson said:
Did not turn out that well ! LOL !

Probably could not do that again if I tried !

Arizona and Cleveland , although I would love to see Dice win a few games in the WS !

Good Luck though,

Guess that's why I seldom make a lot of predictions. Especially with the Sox, more often than not, things blow up in my face.

Well I would also love to see him pitch well and give the Sox a chance to win. As I been saying all year long, many times in a game he is one pitch away from disaster. Sometimes he gets out of jams and others he blows up. You never know what you are going to get with him. Hey, the guy could turn out to be a great pitcher, who knows. I am sure this has been a tough year for him, new team, new league, better players, new culture, not able to communicate with teammates. If you think I am tough on him you should have read some of the posts on the Boston Globe message boards during the game.

Looks like it will be Beckett, Schilling, Dice-K and Wakefield. For Indians I would expect the same rotation as against the Yankees. CC, Carmona, Westbrook and Byrd. I know Byrd has given Sox fits in the past and Carmona had a great outing earlier in the year, I think it was against Dice-K.

My heart obviously says Sox in 7 but Indians are a very good team, managed by a former Red Sox catcher. I can't see either NL team beating the AL rep. Should be good.
 
blueline said:
Guess that's why I seldom make a lot of predictions. Especially with the Sox, more often than not, things blow up in my face.

Well I would also love to see him pitch well and give the Sox a chance to win. As I been saying all year long, many times in a game he is one pitch away from disaster. Sometimes he gets out of jams and others he blows up. You never know what you are going to get with him. Hey, the guy could turn out to be a great pitcher, who knows. I am sure this has been a tough year for him, new team, new league, better players, new culture, not able to communicate with teammates. If you think I am tough on him you should have read some of the posts on the Boston Globe message boards during the game.

Looks like it will be Beckett, Schilling, Dice-K and Wakefield. For Indians I would expect the same rotation as against the Yankees. CC, Carmona, Westbrook and Byrd. I know Byrd has given Sox fits in the past and Carmona had a great outing earlier in the year, I think it was against Dice-K.

My heart obviously says Sox in 7 but Indians are a very good team, managed by a former Red Sox catcher. I can't see either NL team beating the AL rep. Should be good.

You and I have been doing this all year with Dice but he did win 15 and for a rookie , that was a great year. Forget about my bravado for a second ( ROY, CY Etc) but I think he did better than the other free agents such as Zito, Meche, Lilly but I have not looked at the numbers too closely. I think many are upset at Dice because of the money and I think thats ok but the extra 50 million to Japan is neither here nor there in my opinion.

You would know better than me but I think that he did not have the run support that some of the other Red Sox pitchers had as well.


Dare I say MVP for Dice for the playoffs ???? LOL.
 
Sox-Tribe

I think the key for the Sox is what happens in Games 3 and 4. I am quite confident that Beckett and Schill will come up big. These are two proven big game pitchers in the post season. However, it is Dice-K and possibly Wakefield (or Lester) that worry me. Sox have not officially named a game 4 starter but Wake could be the choice, unless they want to pitch Beckett on 3 days rest. Lester is erratic and his pitch count rises just as fast as Dice-K's.

So while you can argue that Fausto and CC have been a better 1-2 than Sox in 2007, this is the post season and Sox 1-2 are proven gamers.

While DQ pointed out that Indians bullpen has the edge over Boston, I respect that, but Delcarmen, Okajima and Papelbon have also been lights out. If I had the choice to hand the ball over to a guy with a 5.07 era (Borowski) or a guy with a 1.85 era (Papelbon), I'd pick Papelbon. No disrespect to Borowski but Sox fans know how it feels when Gagne and his high era takes the hill in late innings.

Offensively, Indians hit more HRs than Sox, but Boston had a better Avg and scored more runs. What makes the Tribe so dangerous is how they hit and scored with 2 outs in the ALDS, freaking scary. Papi, Manny and Lowell need to keep hitting because Sizemore and Hafner are going to hit.

Have to take my Sox in 7, again with home field advantage being the decisive factor. Either way, the two best teams in baseball are playing, both with 96 wins, so it is rather fitting they should meet.

Oh, another advantge Boston has over Cleveland is how much better prepared they seem to be. Case in point - did you notice the Sox players all wearing protective goggles during the post game celebrations to avoid champagne spray from getting into their eyes. :p
 
Anderson said:
You and I have been doing this all year with Dice but he did win 15 and for a rookie , that was a great year. Forget about my bravado for a second ( ROY, CY Etc) but I think he did better than the other free agents such as Zito, Meche, Lilly but I have not looked at the numbers too closely. I think many are upset at Dice because of the money and I think thats ok but the extra 50 million to Japan is neither here nor there in my opinion.

You would know better than me but I think that he did not have the run support that some of the other Red Sox pitchers had as well.


Dare I say MVP for Dice for the playoffs ???? LOL.

No - please don't jinx it now. :p
 
the_big_E said:
Well CC got LIT up tonight....uncharacteristically wild in both of his post-season starts...

Sox are hitting on all cylinders. Gonna be a tough one tonite against Carmona.
 
DonQuixote said:
Bos 10 Cle 3
Cle 13 Bos 6

So much for lights out pitching.
I love the draw being from Cle.
I just don't like the games. I
prefer 1-0 scores.
Credit to the Indians' bullpen. I was just waiting for Boston to score in the 9th or 10th but it didn't happen. Woo hoo.
 
If that dam arsonist GAG-ne sees another game from the hill this season it will be too soon for me. What a freaking piece of work. He got the fire started then Lopez brought in his gas can. At least the trio of Delcarmen, Okajima and Papelbon held serve (except for 1 run off Delcarmen). Fausto and Schill didn't have good nights. Fausto started off very good and looked unhittable, then Sox waited him out.

Sox are in a bit of trouble now with two very erratic pitchers going in Dice-K and Wakefield. They really needed that game last night. I would not be suprised to see Beckett back for Game 4 on 3 days rest.
 
Gagne stinks...dont know what happened to him.

Not sure they'll rush Beckett back, it depends on what happens in Game 3. I'd still take Matsuzaka and Wakefield over Westbrook and Byrd.
 
the_big_E said:
Gagne stinks...dont know what happened to him.

Not sure they'll rush Beckett back, it depends on what happens in Game 3. I'd still take Matsuzaka and Wakefield over Westbrook and Byrd.

Deal. I'll throw in Gagne and Drew then give us back Nixon. :p