Mini ice age about to start...

he Ice caps have indeed shrunk over the last 50 years , the problem is what is the correct amount of ice at the polar caps? ...

I do agree with your point, what is the correct amount of ice at the polar ice caps?

As you state we don't know the optimum level. But what we do know is there should be some ice. Why? There are a few animals that are at risk of extinction due to the lack of ice. An example would be the polar bear, they require the ice to find and catch food. The king penguins also require the ice to travel in safety between their hunting and spawning grounds.

People will also be more at risk due to lack of food for the polar bears will travel more south and more interaction with humans will occur. BTW the polar bear is the only know animal to kill without cause.

There are other changes that will occur such as migratory patterns in birds and whales. The results are unknown.
 
100 years ago? How accurate was measuring the ice cap 100 years ago? It's too close in time to use ice core drilling, flight was in its infancy and crossing the atlantic took up to 1.5 weeks. Now I'm not saying that pollution doesn't exist. It does and it's not healthy but I'm not convinced of global warming trends as a result of human activity.

I remember reading in the 70's that pollution was causing global cooling because of all the pollution we were throwing into the air, which reflected solar radiation in the upper atmosphere, preventing the sun from warming the Earth. Now, I'm obviously not a scientist or an expert at these things, but I have a health scepticism for any theory that has billions of $$$ tied to it.

Yes, there has been detailed research on polar ice cap recession in the last 50 years. Prior to that it is not as accurate for sure, however there is some very rudimentary data available from explorers. When charting the data it is logarithmic in nature and does fit the historical trends.
 
I do agree with your point, what is the correct amount of ice at the polar ice caps?

As you state we don't know the optimum level. But what we do know is there should be some ice. Why? There are a few animals that are at risk of extinction due to the lack of ice. An example would be the polar bear, they require the ice to find and catch food. The king penguins also require the ice to travel in safety between their hunting and spawning grounds.

People will also be more at risk due to lack of food for the polar bears will travel more south and more interaction with humans will occur. BTW the polar bear is the only know animal to kill without cause.

There are other changes that will occur such as migratory patterns in birds and whales. The results are unknown.

There is no single answer because it not an single optimal number. It slides with the situation and the situation is getting dire. Even if we turn things around the ice needed to begin recovery will depend on the starting point and that in turn will effect the theoretical correct amount. That question cannot be answered. It's like asking how long is a string. ANSWER: It depends.

They know that what we have now is not it and that the concern.
 
OMG! Just saw on CNN, we have THREE big volcanoes..

What I do not understand is that the CO2 we put ionto the stratosphere is a tiny fraction compared to a good volcanic eruption

Yet hard to argue with scientists

..warming up! But because of the DUST they toss up high, they are major chillers.

It only takes ONE big one (Krakatoa, Tambora, Yellowstone caldera) to shield the sun and make an Ice Age.
 
Not going to get too involved in this discussion, because if scientists are debating this with opposing views, then it is more than I can get into in a post but.....

Ice ages and Global warming are part of the normal cycle of the planet, such as the extreme warming that took place after the initial asteroid hit that wiped out the dinosaurs and the ice age that followed.

The real question isn't if these processes occur or don't or if they are detrimental, but if our presence and behavior as humans drives the process in any way, and if we can reduce our impact. Why? Because whether or not global warming is occurring, if our behavior causes warming to occur, through CO2 emissions and being an oil based society, I wouldn't want that to happen because I don't like the idea of mass migrations occurring as a result of natural disasters such as eroding shorelines, increased hurricanes and tornados (such as New Orleans), Tsunamis etc. The short term impact of millions of people relocating inland to from tropical areas to more temperate climates such as here in Toronto would be highly invasive. Most of us don't see the hundreds of thousands of species dying on this planet, as we live removed from it, so the problem seems invisible. And if it doesn't affect us directly, for most people it isn't an issue.

Global cooling also sucks as I hate Canadian winters as they are. 8 months of the year it is cold here, and then we get a 4 month summer. I don't want to be shoveling the snow in July or October. These changes are affecting our food supply and the rate at which produce grows. Shorter, cooler seasons means less productivity, from a food production perspective. Less fish spawning, less development, reduced population etc. Too high of a climate, and reproduction may not occur, because the temperature requirements for proper embryo development occurs at a specific and short temperature buffer range for many lower order organisms, such as insects, which we depend on for pollination and feeding higher order (by order I'm referring to their Linnaeanic designation on the phylogenetic tree, not to their rank of importance to life) organisms which we consume, such as fish.

More importantly though, in places where industrial farming methods are not modernized for mass consumption, or where the cost is too high to support the population, such as China or India, once food webs start breaking down as a result of global temperature ranges going above or below these critical temperature buffer ranges, then this potentially has the ability to affect global food supply and mass starvation, a state which we are in at the moment with underdeveloped nations and communities. This is a global concern, because the most obvious solution is if there isn't food where you are, you go looking for it elsewhere, elsewhere being here. If one or two people do that, no problem. But if environmental conditions change to affect processes at a larger level, as they do with Global warming and cooling, then these impacts will affect many, and migration would follow on a massive scale. Either that, or governments would have to find a way to accommodate a large financial cost to address those issues. The cheaper more effective way is to reduce our impact.
 
Well if no animals ever went extinct, the dinosaurs might still be ruling the earth and humans might never been born.

Everybody talks about extinction yet few talk about new forms of life that replace them. True in the short term it doesn't happen that way, takes tens of thousands of years.

The earth tilts on its axle and chages its angle over time, its been proven. Goes back and forth over like a million years. Nobody knows why it moves or how it stops--YET. Likely nobody is going to want to try to change it either cause it could wipe out life all together.

Oil is going to run out someday, there is not a ended less supply. Coal is dirtier and more around but can now be burn much cleaner to make electricity. The world will be getting cleaner sooner or later.

Yeah we hear all the talk how bad hurricanes can be but what happen the past few years--like none really happen this last season, hmmm. Europe is having its coldest winter in many years.

No matter what happens short of nuclear war life will go on, it always has for million of years now. Animals go extinct and new life forms come around...someday maybe even humans will go extinct, it be natural to happen (expect we are smarter and can adapt better then most forms of life)
 
It’s a perfectly acceptable for the scientific community to say, “We don’t know,” when asked about the climate change debate.

Yet, many of them claim to know the answer. Worse, political activists with an agenda jump on the global warming bandwagon and tell us that the sky is falling, the ice caps are melting stuff.

The politicians are using this hysteria and feeding on our fear to push through “carbon” taxes and redistribute wealth based on fear.

I think this global warming “cult” of fear and paranoia seems to have run its course and perhaps common sense and real scientific method can return.
 
The politicians are using this hysteria and feeding on our fear to push through “carbon” taxes and redistribute wealth based on fear.

Here we go again with the same old...
smilie67.gif
 
..warming up! But because of the DUST they toss up high, they are major chillers.

It only takes ONE big one (Krakatoa, Tambora, Yellowstone caldera) to shield the sun and make an Ice Age.

Thanks for you contribution. I don't know where to begin, so I'll say this, if your tongue was not in your cheek, don't let the door hit you on the way out.
 
Here we go again with the same old...
smilie67.gif

Just consider the source and it makes sense Woodie. CF has been a master of hyperbole for a while and that about says it in a nut shell.

Sorry CF, I was harsh you not a master, but do practice a lot. Blame my outburst on long days and short nights.
 
Last edited:
Not going to get too involved in this discussion, because if scientists are debating this with opposing views, then it is more than I can get into in a post but.....

Ice ages and Global warming are part of the normal cycle of the planet, such as the extreme warming that took place after the initial asteroid hit that wiped out the dinosaurs and the ice age that followed.

The real question isn't if these processes occur or don't or if they are detrimental, but if our presence and behavior as humans drives the process in any way, and if we can reduce our impact. Why? Because whether or not global warming is occurring, if our behavior causes warming to occur, through CO2 emissions and being an oil based society, I wouldn't want that to happen because I don't like the idea of mass migrations occurring as a result of natural disasters such as eroding shorelines, increased hurricanes and tornados (such as New Orleans), Tsunamis etc. The short term impact of millions of people relocating inland to from tropical areas to more temperate climates such as here in Toronto would be highly invasive. Most of us don't see the hundreds of thousands of species dying on this planet, as we live removed from it, so the problem seems invisible. And if it doesn't affect us directly, for most people it isn't an issue.

Global cooling also sucks as I hate Canadian winters as they are. 8 months of the year it is cold here, and then we get a 4 month summer. I don't want to be shoveling the snow in July or October. These changes are affecting our food supply and the rate at which produce grows. Shorter, cooler seasons means less productivity, from a food production perspective. Less fish spawning, less development, reduced population etc. Too high of a climate, and reproduction may not occur, because the temperature requirements for proper embryo development occurs at a specific and short temperature buffer range for many lower order organisms, such as insects, which we depend on for pollination and feeding higher order (by order I'm referring to their Linnaeanic designation on the phylogenetic tree, not to their rank of importance to life) organisms which we consume, such as fish.

More importantly though, in places where industrial farming methods are not modernized for mass consumption, or where the cost is too high to support the population, such as China or India, once food webs start breaking down as a result of global temperature ranges going above or below these critical temperature buffer ranges, then this potentially has the ability to affect global food supply and mass starvation, a state which we are in at the moment with underdeveloped nations and communities. This is a global concern, because the most obvious solution is if there isn't food where you are, you go looking for it elsewhere, elsewhere being here. If one or two people do that, no problem. But if environmental conditions change to affect processes at a larger level, as they do with Global warming and cooling, then these impacts will affect many, and migration would follow on a massive scale. Either that, or governments would have to find a way to accommodate a large financial cost to address those issues. The cheaper more effective way is to reduce our impact.

WS, you pretty well sum it up and I can't add to it.
 
Check this thread out..what IF this is the real reason?

http://nearing.newsvine.com/_news/2...ilted-in-our-lifetime-and-is-it-still-tilting

Has the Earth tilted in our lifetime (and is it still tilting)?:

t's been very interesting to see elders and hunters across Nunavut make the same observation about the world having shifted on its axis.

Elders across Nunavut have noticed that the sun and stars have changed their position in the sky. The sun is now rising higher and staying longer than it used to. Importantly, in the far north, you must remember that the sun goes below the horizon for a large part of the year, and therefore Inuit are very familiar with its celestial pattern. Indeed, Inuit we're talking with are telling us stories about how in the old days, during the dark months, they would travel the land by dog team using stars as their navigational tools. So, when Inuit talk about the sun and stars, they do so with an intimate knowledge of these systems.

When we began this project, I scanned the academic literature to see if there was any scientific evidence to support Inuit claims that the "earth has tilted" and thus causing climate change, but nothing existed. Now that we're in Igloolik, editing the film, and hearing this observation repeatedly, I hit the literature again. And, to my surprise and delight, two research studies have recently been published that relate to the Inuit knowledge we are collecting with video.

Drysdale et al (2009) published a study in the prestigious journal Science this past August that argues the Late Pleistocene (approximately 141,000 years ago) glacial period came to an end because of changes to the obliquity, or tilt, of the earth. Like Inuit, the study states that this is a possible climate change hypothesis "because of the relatively large and persistent increases in summer energy reaching the high latitudes of both hemispheres during times of maximum Earth tilt". Although Drysdale et al (2009) are discussing past climate change, their findings seem to support present claims by Inuit that a tilting earth may warm climate. In another study, published this past September in Geophysical Research Letters, Landerer et al (2009) indicate that the warming of oceans, exacerbated by melting glaciers that flow into them, is causing "horizontal mass redistribution" of the world's seas. Essentially, the weight and position of the world's oceans have shifted, and this has literally caused the earth to shift its position on its axis! In both the Drysdale (2009) and Landerer (2009) studies, the authors argue that these phenomena have not been previously reported, and that their findings offer new insights into how scientists and society should think about climate
change and its causes and associated impacts.
 
There is no single answer because it not an single optimal number. It slides with the situation and the situation is getting dire. Even if we turn things around the ice needed to begin recovery will depend on the starting point and that in turn will effect the theoretical correct amount. That question cannot be answered. It's like asking how long is a string. ANSWER: It depends.

They know that what we have now is not it and that the concern.


How do we know what we have now is not the optimum? The point is we don't.
 
Check this thread out..what IF this is the real reason?

http://nearing.newsvine.com/_news/2...ilted-in-our-lifetime-and-is-it-still-tilting

Has the Earth tilted in our lifetime (and is it still tilting)?:

t's been very interesting to see elders and hunters across Nunavut make the same observation about the world having shifted on its axis.

Elders across Nunavut have noticed that the sun and stars have changed their position in the sky. The sun is now rising higher and staying longer than it used to. Importantly, in the far north, you must remember that the sun goes below the horizon for a large part of the year, and therefore Inuit are very familiar with its celestial pattern. Indeed, Inuit we're talking with are telling us stories about how in the old days, during the dark months, they would travel the land by dog team using stars as their navigational tools. So, when Inuit talk about the sun and stars, they do so with an intimate knowledge of these systems.

When we began this project, I scanned the academic literature to see if there was any scientific evidence to support Inuit claims that the "earth has tilted" and thus causing climate change, but nothing existed. Now that we're in Igloolik, editing the film, and hearing this observation repeatedly, I hit the literature again. And, to my surprise and delight, two research studies have recently been published that relate to the Inuit knowledge we are collecting with video.

Drysdale et al (2009) published a study in the prestigious journal Science this past August that argues the Late Pleistocene (approximately 141,000 years ago) glacial period came to an end because of changes to the obliquity, or tilt, of the earth. Like Inuit, the study states that this is a possible climate change hypothesis "because of the relatively large and persistent increases in summer energy reaching the high latitudes of both hemispheres during times of maximum Earth tilt". Although Drysdale et al (2009) are discussing past climate change, their findings seem to support present claims by Inuit that a tilting earth may warm climate. In another study, published this past September in Geophysical Research Letters, Landerer et al (2009) indicate that the warming of oceans, exacerbated by melting glaciers that flow into them, is causing "horizontal mass redistribution" of the world's seas. Essentially, the weight and position of the world's oceans have shifted, and this has literally caused the earth to shift its position on its axis! In both the Drysdale (2009) and Landerer (2009) studies, the authors argue that these phenomena have not been previously reported, and that their findings offer new insights into how scientists and society should think about climate
change and its causes and associated impacts.

There is a wobble to the earth as it orbits, IE the north star was not always Polaris, it changes about every 5000 years based on the wobble in the orbit, the LAnderer study is probnlematical, the Argos sea temperature studies have not found any heating of the oceans in fact they have found a slight decrease in the average ocean temperature.
 
I do agree with your point, what is the correct amount of ice at the polar ice caps?

As you state we don't know the optimum level. But what we do know is there should be some ice. Why? There are a few animals that are at risk of extinction due to the lack of ice. An example would be the polar bear, they require the ice to find and catch food. The king penguins also require the ice to travel in safety between their hunting and spawning grounds.

People will also be more at risk due to lack of food for the polar bears will travel more south and more interaction with humans will occur. BTW the polar bear is the only know animal to kill without cause.

There are other changes that will occur such as migratory patterns in birds and whales. The results are unknown.

Humans are animals as well.
 
The wait and see position has one major flaw, we're cutting so close now that if we missed the tipping point it's over and that pisses me off as we have the chance now to start something to turn this ocean liner around.

Again the problem is that the science does not support this . The concept of human caused global warming is based on science that is largly in question at the moment due to the actions of some scientist and political activists who have screwed up the science to such an extent that the IPPC reports have to be viewed with scepticism. The inability to replicate large amounts of the research independantly and the refusal of the authors to release raw data and computer modeling codes for scrutiny followed by the release of the data and e-mails from the CRU at East Anglia have cast an unpleasant light on the people behind the science, and unfortunatly on the science itself. Who can we believe?

The whole situation needs to be audited from the beginning to examine methodologies and assumptions , and it needs to be done in the wide open spaces, by that I mean it needs to be done in the public and by people not associated with any of the centers that published the work. By all means have them watch and after the audit results are published for all to see they get first crack at answering any questions regarding the work, followed by anybody else who wishes to jump in.

At the moment that is the only way any resemblance of sanity can be restored to teh debate.
 
This is all to true and I have never had a problem with and in fact am in favour of reducing our impact on the planet.

The omediate issue is if we should be jumping head long into a carbon reduction process that

A) is going to cost trillions of dollars and based on the Copenhagen accord will not have any effect what so ever

B) is being driven by radical elements of the ecological fringe who happened to find a message that they could force.

In either case sending all of our money to China to build more coal fired plants seems like a waste of time and money.
 
There is a wobble to the earth as it orbits, IE the north star was not always Polaris, it changes about every 5000 years based on the wobble in the orbit, the LAnderer study is probnlematical, the Argos sea temperature studies have not found any heating of the oceans in fact they have found a slight decrease in the average ocean temperature.

Yuor first point escape me with respect to the thread, but the temperatures observed in the Argos experiment were taken in what areas and at what depth of the oceans and sea? You biggest weakness in your statement is in the claim of no change in the AVERAGE temperature of the oceans as a whole. So if the equatorial current showed a decrease of 4°C and the polar currents showed a increase of 4°C the net change would be 0, but the end result would border on catastrophic. Only one such example but a very clear and presently observed one. Be very careful with averages.
 
This is all to true and I have never had a problem with and in fact am in favour of reducing our impact on the planet.

The omediate issue is if we should be jumping head long into a carbon reduction process that

A) is going to cost trillions of dollars and based on the Copenhagen accord will not have any effect what so ever

B) is being driven by radical elements of the ecological fringe who happened to find a message that they could force.

In either case sending all of our money to China to build more coal fired plants seems like a waste of time and money.



The cost of not doing anything is higher. The estimated cost was said to be than 1% of the total GDP of the G30 countries, as I
stated in an earlier post of mine place on Terb at the end of Copenhagen; absolute peanuts.

The Copenhagen accord was worth next to nothing. Not a total waste, but it will lead to nothing short term. This is the first time I've been referred to as a radical.

As far as China and their coal projects these deals were in place sometime back and the cost of backing out would be more than just money.
 
Why are places like Canada so worry if sea levels rise and temps increase / seems like places such as the Florida Keys would be gone but most of Canada is just too darn cold most the time to live there. (talking about for humans)

There very well might be vast oil reserves under all the ice of Antarctic. That ice is not forecast to melt as fast.

Sad the polar bears might be gone but does that effect 99% of us??

Just cause major changes may happen doesn't mean for sure it be for the worst. Yeah if I owned some homes in the Florida Keys I be worried but I don't.