Mini ice age about to start...

lurkerjoe

Active member
Apr 13, 2004
496
49
28
Interesting compliments a paper i read a couple of months ago from a Australian researched that basically said the same thing, all the temperature fluctuations over the last 50 years ( the limit of their actual data) could be directly related to Pacific ocean currents. It is a conundrum, the actual measured data says one thing and the infered data says another which to believe?

Add the ocilations into the equation with the unusually quiet sun this solar cycle and we could be sking down Yonge St next April.......

Short term weather changes are generally not indicative of the actual climate it could be a blip and if it is we should have a better idea come spring, if it is a cold and wet as last summer I am betting on a cold cycle.
 
Hmmmpf.

t2978.gif


When weather forecasters learn how to predict TOMORROW'S weather, then next week's and next month's weather accurately, maybe then I will start to believe they can predict it years from now.
 
But as the global warming priests tell us, its not about weather, its about the climate. What's interesting is that people tend to believe that the world is warming up yet ocean temperature data hasn't backed up with theory. Some nutball even said, the oceans aren't warming because the polar ice caps are melting. As if the ice caps are somehow not already floating on the oceans.
 
LS;

If you could come up with that researchers name it would help but if as I suspect, his work has been discussed earlier on this BB and found to be greatly lacking an opinion mirrored by many of his peers. I'm not able to dig up my past posts on this because alas, my posting history is still adrift in the ether of a fatal flaw since Jan 6 and I cannot retrieve it. Oh sigh!!! There was a mini downturn in global temperatures in the 70's but it was no trend and short lived.

The names Grandia or Evans ring a bell but I'm not sure.

I tried to read the article both the pictures of Ashley Greene and Dannii Minogue caught my eye first. Damn Daily Mail.
 
I am confused.....what and who are we non-science types supposed to believe???? For the longest time I was, and still am, believing the argument that current global warming trends is largely a result of man-made activity. When I read this article, and again I have no science background at all, it casuses me to question whether the current trend of global warming is entirely man made......who are we supposed to believe??
 
I am confused.....what and who are we non-science types supposed to believe???? For the longest time I was, and still am, believing the argument that current global warming trends is largely a result of man-made activity. When I read this article, and again I have no science background at all, it casuses me to question whether the current trend of global warming is entirely man made......who are we supposed to believe??

Your confusion might simply be as highlighted above. No one is sure to what extent but there is a connection and it 'is' something we can correct to some degree.
 
The theory of global cooling doesn't seem to make sense. If we look through the history of the 20th century. By analyising the Arctic ice patterns one thing is clear, the icecap now covers only 25% (during the summer months) of what it did 100 years ago. It is projected that 25 years from now there will be no ice remaining at the Artic during the summer months.

So how can we say there is global cooling in effect? The data shows otherwise.
 
When we look back a few hundred years people seemed so dumb like..tough but not too smart..like why didn't cars, electricity come around in Europe in the 1600's, 1700's they could have but didn't. "doctors" drilled holes in heads to help headaches, lol

Jump to year 2350 are we going to be look at as being so dumb as well?
 
When we look back a few hundred years people seemed so dumb like..tough but not too smart..like why didn't cars, electricity come around in Europe in the 1600's, 1700's they could have but didn't. "doctors" drilled holes in heads to help headaches, lol

Jump to year 2350 are we going to be look at as being so dumb as well?

We've been drilling holes in the head since roman times for cranial relief and still do today.
 
Oh, so those who once believed the world was flat were not so dumb, lol

Its like nothing much happen until the late 1800's, life was about the same old with different customs century after century. Its only now where even the last 25 years have seen much change...in the 1980's who have have though cell phones could be so small and do so much..the pager was high tech.
 
SC J;

I'm not sure what your point is.

It's often stated in many ways that we have learned more in the last 100 years than in the previous 5000 years. Exactly why is open to a very long discussion, but in many ways because of open/expanding education opportunities and going back further to the invention of the printing press, the taking away of the control of information from the church, the only large faction of society that could read or write and therefore control knowledge and learning.

Suspicions, theories and expectations are one thing but proof can take time.

There are members of the flat earth society today but they won't tell you how many, even though we've suspected it since classic Greek times and proved it mathematically by the 9th century, Th Arab mathematicians proved and estimated it to within 2800 feet/1 degree.

T

There are still members of the flat earth society and they won't tell you how many.
 
The theory of global cooling doesn't seem to make sense. If we look through the history of the 20th century. By analyising the Arctic ice patterns one thing is clear, the icecap now covers only 25% (during the summer months) of what it did 100 years ago. It is projected that 25 years from now there will be no ice remaining at the Artic during the summer months.

So how can we say there is global cooling in effect? The data shows otherwise.

he Ice caps have indeed shrunk over the last 50 years , the problem is what is the correct amount of ice at the polar caps? That is a question that nobody can answer because there really is no answer to the question. The cuurent ice melt mania is interesting because the people claimingthe ice is melting of the caps much to fast are basing their measurements on a late 1960's sset of measurments when the ice cap was at an historical high, yes it has reduced since then but what is the " correct " amount . If you are a global warming advocate the correct amount would be somewhere south of Montreal , if you are actually interrested i the science the amount would be different.

If you remember your history, Greenland used to be farmed during the viking times, that was an era known as the medevial warm period, grape vines grew in England and things were much warmer . During the American revolution there are reports of canon being pulled across rivers that don't freeze up now, as well as winter fairs on the Thames river.

All of this is just to show that the climate changes on a regular basis what is normal changes based on a set of influences that we

A) can not even accuratly identify at this time
B) relate to each other in ways we can not even imagine.

The bottom line is has mankind changed the climate? Yes we have urban heating is one example

Are CO2 feddback loops forcing the global climate to change? We don't know. The real trick is to find out what is happening not what people with vested interest on both sides of the argument want to be happening.
 
My point is we look back and shake our heads what people knew and believed a few hundred years ago, how do we know people a few hundred years later on might not think the same of us now. There is still much more to learn, what if controlling the weather might be possible?

It solve many problems, no major snowstorms-no long dry spells, no hurricanes...so much more land could be used, so much money saved and don't think cause we have no idea how to do it today it might not be easily done say 500 years from now.

Then for sure we will be laugh about by school children for worrying about climate change.
 
My point is we look back and shake our heads what people knew and believed a few hundred years ago, how do we know people a few hundred years later on might not think the same of us now. There is still much more to learn, what if controlling the weather might be possible?

It solve many problems, no major snowstorms-no long dry spells, no hurricanes...so much more land could be used, so much money saved and don't think cause we have no idea how to do it today it might not be easily done say 500 years from now.

Then for sure we will be laugh about by school children for worrying about climate change.

As I have said on at least two occasions, the ecology, climatology and geological inter-relationships are so complex that it's hard to say ,with any certainty ,what will happen and what can be done to ' control' the weather. Influence it maybe, but to control doubtful because we are just a cog in the machine.

Your understanding of how snowstorms, hurricanes and dry spells effect all of the above appears to lack something. Each one is necessary in certain parts of the world to have the ecosystems work at their peak. Even the definition of snow storm varies from place to place. One places storm is another places flurries. Define dry spell. If we get no rain for a month we call it a dry spell, yet our whole annual precipitation would be a serious dry patch in some areas and still other get less rain in a year than we get in a summer. Each situation gives rise to different flora and fauna, in some cases unique that area. So what do you use to define proper rainfall.

Krill, the most abundant creature in the world by weight, is the corner stone of all living sea creature and is the most seriously affected by the slightest of water temperatures. If they lose the rest of the oceans fish and mammalian life loses big time.

The melting ice caps 5000 mile away affect the ocean currant temp by not cooling them enough and give rise to these massive storms along the ocean belt line, not allowing the equatorial water to heat up and begin migrating to the poles. Not to mention the non migrating water going under the ice caps and causing the ice to move and melt faster than expected. Cool waters at the equator, slow food growth for the sea creatures whoa can't eat enough to survive the bad months and that just one of about approx 10 different chains of events that occur over and over around the world. think of this current as an figure eight put on it's side and give it the name of the Great conveyor. Heavy snow in the mountain need to come regularity to give rise to spring runoff for plants to grow below the the line feed the smaller creatures who live and breed the medium size and so on . The river need to be big enough to allow fish to swim to spawning grounds to bred. It goes on and on. There are so many places where even the smallest f**k up will cause major damage and we won't be able to easily control it.

Where we show ignorance is seen in the still prevalent philosophy of bigger is best and mono-crop cultures are more economical (not best) and we just keep catching more and more amore of the breeding stocks of cod, salmon and haddocks and clear cut the oceans floor not wanting to say stop as it will be politically unpopular.

I've run off at the mouth a bit, but it shows how complex it is and no one knows everything, requiring everyone to work as a team and that's really a tough thing to do right now.
 
The theory of global cooling doesn't seem to make sense. If we look through the history of the 20th century. By analyising the Arctic ice patterns one thing is clear, the icecap now covers only 25% (during the summer months) of what it did 100 years ago. It is projected that 25 years from now there will be no ice remaining at the Artic during the summer months.

So how can we say there is global cooling in effect? The data shows otherwise.

100 years ago? How accurate was measuring the ice cap 100 years ago? It's too close in time to use ice core drilling, flight was in its infancy and crossing the atlantic took up to 1.5 weeks. Now I'm not saying that pollution doesn't exist. It does and it's not healthy but I'm not convinced of global warming trends as a result of human activity.

I remember reading in the 70's that pollution was causing global cooling because of all the pollution we were throwing into the air, which reflected solar radiation in the upper atmosphere, preventing the sun from warming the Earth. Now, I'm obviously not a scientist or an expert at these things, but I have a health scepticism for any theory that has billions of $$$ tied to it.
 
Black rock makes a point i have been trying to make for a while we just don't know.

http://www.smalldeadanimals.com/archives/012962.html

This is an example .

http://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/01/03/swiss-eth-glaciers-melted-in-the-1940s-faster-than-today/

glaciers melting???

http://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/01/...ic-carbon-dioxide-fraction-in-past-160-years/
http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/12/...arming-since-1995-a-quick-mathematical-proof/


http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/12/...entific-results-useful-to-a-political-agenda/

http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/12/21/gaming-the-peer-review-system-ipcc-scientists-behaving-badly/

http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/12/...an-2008-cooling-attributed-to-natural-causes/ this is the ocean temp study


All these liks are through wuwtr and small dead animals , they basically collect the opinions and papers and archive them. Some of them are opinion pieces and others are peer reviewed papers that were published .

Please note that these two sites tend to be on the lets see whats going on type , they do tend to do their best to question the prominant theories, so if you wish to call them oil supported climate change deniers if you wish, but the ideas and concepts that they bring up are interesting if you have an open mind
 
The wait and see position has one major flaw, we're cutting so close now that if we missed the tipping point it's over and that pisses me off as we have the chance now to start something to turn this ocean liner around.
 
What I do not understand is that the CO2 we put ionto the stratosphere is a tiny fraction compared to a good volcanic eruption

Yet hard to argue with scientists