MGM Grand Toronto???

See, I disagree with the premise that Tall Buildings = Exciting Buildings

Now contrast Dubai to London, or Paris, or Rome, or Florence.

Tall buildings = dead zones.

Sky-lines composed of huge tall sky scrappers only look good on post cards and from far away. The reality is completely different.


I don't disagree that dead-zones can form around tall buildings but that's the short-sightnedness of the urban planners. The problem is cities are growing upwards and not outwards that pace will grow not slow. The municipality borders aren't expanding, costs of operating the city are rising, and without increasing taxes the way to increase revenues is to tap more people in the same amount of space (grow up) and/or get more external (tourist) revenues.

Those European cities that you mentioned had most of their infrastructure built hundreds of years ago. Before the elevator and before public transit. Height was limited to about 6 storeys as that's all people could walk up while carrying stuff and the cities were compact. European cities are walking cities to be explored on foot. The attraction for the North American tourist is to go there and see the old and seek out the charm. Whereas, Europeans want to come to North America and see the new and exciting as at a cost of $200+/day for hotel and meals (plus the cost of the flight) the Annex, the ROM, the CN Tower and High Park alone won't be it.

More tall buildings will be built in the downtown core there's no stopping it. We just have a choice on it being cookie cutter or something fresh and attractive. Who's going to built it though leaves the choices to Building offices (not going to happen soon in this economy), condos (likely not going to happen either do to price that would have to be passed on to the purchaser) or Hotels and entertainment complexes.

Whether that venue has a casino in it or not, I really don't care, but I do recognize it's impact it could have on tourism if it's high-end. I just think we need a catalyst to change the design mindshift in Toronto or run the risk of increasing those dead-zones. A hotel and entertainment zone may be something to build around as, an NFL team and stadium wouldn't be put downtown, and it could be 20 years, if ever, that we see the Olympics in this city.
 
Toronto actually has an official policy of "densification" - i.e. trying to increase density. And I agree that suburban sprawl must be stopped. (Suburbs = death in my humble opinion. They chew up massive amounts of land, usually prime farm land and they are hugely expensive to service - everything costs more than in the inner city.) And I also agree that the infrastructure in North America is not the same as in the classic European cities. Here in NA, the cities have been built around the use of the automobile and that fact has dictated road widths (12 foot wide lanes) and everything has been built around "the car" and it will not change.

But if I look at the tall buildings that Toronto has built, they are mundane, boring, and they create dead zones.

The question would be how to solve that problem. The first is obviously the architecture itself. Everything is about cheap. As Frank Lloyd Wright once said, "God is in the details" and he's absolutely correct, however, the details cost money. Developers just want to build a concrete and glass box because nothing is cheaper, then sell it and get the hell out with a big bag of money. There is little to no architectural style to any tall building that I see being constructed.

The next issue that I see with the condo culture in Toronto is that the buildings are being built as if they were in Mississauga. Case in point would be the wasteland that has been built down by skydome. For some reason, the buildings are set way back from the streets and they have these large areas of paving stone nothingness where they slap in a few benches, a few trees and some sort of lighting. The result is a dead zone. Not a park, not a square, but just paving stones. Gotta have paving stones. Sort of a faux cobble stone thing happening. The buildings are spaced out, irregularly located as if they were in the suburbs as opposed to the grid pattern, then this area of nothingness.

The next issue with the Toronto condo culture is that these buildings (if they face the street) are just more of the same as was built straight up - just spandrel glasss and concrete. Retail storefronts become just as boring as the boxes above.

It all combines to produce cold, impersonal, boring crap where no-one wants to be, other than to sleep.

I think the solution might be to build the streets to emulate what works currently in Toronto, then build the big towers behind the main streets. As far as some sort of interesting architecture - well, if the city could force the developers to do so, that would be great, however, I doubt that it would be possible. As a result, all we are going to continue to see is more of the same concrete and glass banality which has become the hallmark of the current condo craze in Toronto.