bbking said:
You know I really don't know about that - certainly what Young was part of was terrific but I have to ask myself had he decided to move on rather than ride the bench during the Montana days would he have been able to pull a so/so team up and make them at least mediocre.
Someone mention Quarterback ratings -
That would be me (because I'm the only one who has). Remember, the one you have on "ignore" and can't read what they're writing... (lol... you are such liar).
bbking said:
a useful tool but not all that reliable because offences differ so greatly and certainly the offence these two ran differed greatly.
Weak argument. QB ratings most closely follow completion percentages (which Young is also the all-time career leader in). Some have said that it gives bias to west coast offences, but look at Manning's numbers this past year (and he runs just about as much as Marino did). It isn't perfect, but it is the best measure of a quarterback that we have (especially over the longer term).
bbking said:
Hell I remember Greg Landry from a pathetic Detroit Lions team being ranked as having the #1 quarterback rating one year largely because Landry was so skillfull at running for his life.
That's funny, because QB ratings have nothing to do with rushing... only their passing statistics.
Landry's best number was 92.5... he had acceptable numbers, but it was based on only 136 attempts. The more attempts you have, the more statistically relevant it becomes, and that is why career statistics require in excess of a couple thousand of attempts....
bbking said:
As for Marino standing in a pocket and not moving compared to Steve Young being more mobile and thus more athletic, I think one only need to look at the fact that Marino was only sacked 253 times compared to Youngs 330 can hardly be a comparison of athletic ability since it would appear that Marino got the job done in this area more effectively.
Different rules back then. With the introduction of the "intentional grounding" rules (i.e. having to get out of the pocket to throw it away), Marino's numbers would be a LOT worse.
As for athleticism, look at the career rushing yards: Young: 4,239; Marino: 307.
Comparing the athleticism of Young to Marino is like comparing Vick to Manning. Not even close.
And, by the way... Marino never "got it done". That was the original point of the question... would you pick someone like Marino, who had some passing records but never did win in the end - or would you pick someone like Young, who actually won a Superbowl.
That said, Marino WAS pretty good at getting rid of the ball. But that also comes into play in his completion and ratings numbers.
bbking said:
Also I would think athletic ability can be measured in longevity - Marino played in 223 pro games and started in 221 while Young played in 159 games and started in 133.
Marino had more longevity as a starter... Young, however, patiently waited several years on the bench behind #16. His 15 years, vs. 17 for Marino, is not material in terms of "longevity".
Marino may have had better durability (arguable), and a better (more competitive) attitude... but in no way was he as athletic as Young. Not even close.
bbking said:
While I might be tempted to say with all of Steve's success that he left early to rest on his laurals you need to remember that Young finished his last two years in, I think, in Tampa.
Wrong (like pretty much all of your "facts"). What the hell are you talking about? He retired a 49er, and not "resting on his laurels". Three games into 1999, he had his bell rung for the last time, and he never played again.
His first couple of seasons were as a Buc, before he was acquired by SF....
Just curious... why do you continue to "contribute" such meaningful things when you obviously haven't even the slightest clue?
bbking said:
It really is hard for anyone to say who is more athletic when you are comparing athletes at this level but on longevity alone I would have to say Marino was the better athlete.
What? He played two more years. That's 13%.
And, despite that... you think longevity determines athleticism? Running backs average 4 years in terms of their careers... they are less athletic than Peyton Manning? Bo Jackson was less of an athlete than Dan Marino? Kickers like Morton and Gary Anderson are the best athletes the league has ever seen?
Please.
Young can be criticised on many fronts (his ability to play "big games" - despite his one big win, he had a devil of a time getting past the NFC playoffs... his dedication... his durability and/or inclination to play hurt...), but as far as "talents" and athleticism go, it can't really be questioned. Though not the best quarterback ever (due to mental factors, IMO), he arguably had the most talent of anyone to play the position.