Man Killed Avoiding RIDE Spotcheck

We don't know yet if the driver was driving drunk, he was just fleeing a police checkpoint.
If you guys have been giving Rob Ford the benefit of doubt for all these months, you should do so here as well.

I was thinking the exact same thing. Being a 16 year old, maybe he only had his G, or G1 or whatever the hell there called now which didn't allow him to be driving at that time and he was terrified.
 
If your read the Levitt study, you will see that he took a different approach to the problem than just counting up cases. He worked out the likelihood of causing a crash instead with the only assumption being a binomial distribution.

As you point out, most crashes are not caused by drunk drivers, that's because the overwhelming majority of drivers on the road are sober. Even people who drive drunk are typically sober most of the time. So drunk drivers are very rare, but they cause an outsized share of the fatal accidents.

In calculating their harm to society, he excluded fatalities when the drunk driver killed themselves or a passenger in their own car, noting that these people have presumably accepted the risk of death. He counted up the remaining fatalities, only cases where the drunk killed someone in the other vehicle.

From this, and standard insurance rates for human life, he worked out that it costs society about ten grand every time, and that's in the neighborhood of the average car.

Yes but he even admitted the data was suspect. If you look at how the data is gathered it is VERY suspect. Just because the guy at the wheel was drunk, does not mean the drunkeness caused the accident or had anything to do with it. In Toronto there was a recent case where a drunk pedestrian fell in front of a car driven by a drunk driver and got killed. By all accounts there was no chance to avoid the pedestrian. Yet she went down for drunk driving causing death. If you read previous posts cellphones are more dangerous then drinking. Are we going to suspend drivers and press criminal charges if they touch their cellphone?
 
Yes but he even admitted the data was suspect. If you look at how the data is gathered it is VERY suspect. Just because the guy at the wheel was drunk, does not mean the drunkeness caused the accident or had anything to do with it.

The drunken drivers didn't always cause the accidents. Sometimes the sober drivers did. However, the legally drunk ones were THIRTEEN TIMES more likely to be at fault than a sober driver. The guys with a couple beers but still under the limit were SEVEN times more likely.

The data and the study are very clear.

You are being a little slimy since he pointed out that the defects in the data made his number a LOWER bound, a counting some drunks a sober reduced the difference making the drunk drivers seem less harmful.
 
Last edited:
What???
Who estimated that 2.25% of accidents involved intoxicated drivers???
Hate to break it to you but the insurance bureau of BC (who has actual stats and not made up ones) claimed over 67% of their fatal accidents had alcohol or drugs as a factor

http://www.sense.bc.ca/img/isku_40pct.gif

"It is estimated that 2.25% of all vehicular crashes involve intoxicated drivers."

The 2.25% refers to all accidents, not just fatal ones.
 
The 2.25% refers to all accidents, not just fatal ones.

I think any reasonable person realizes that far less than 2.25 percent of drivers are drunk at any given time.

Non fatal accidents involving drunks are hard to track due to their efforts to flee or otherwise conceal their drunk driving, especially for minor incidents.
 
One drink a few hours ago and your BAC will be near zero. But one drink twenty minutes before you drive will make you a LOT more dangerous. Seven times more likely to cause a fatal crash than normal.


Perhaps. I had a drink 45 minutes before a surprise ride stop. I sort of 'invited' the lady cop to test me by being too honest (I told her I was at a concert, and had wine with dinner hours ago). She made me blow and it was 0.00. Frankly, I couldn't believe that (that drink was a Manhattan). I went to church that weekend and thanked God. Never again. I was lucky.
 
Perhaps. I had a drink 45 minutes before a surprise ride stop. I sort of 'invited' the lady cop to test me by being too honest (I told her I was at a concert, and had wine with dinner hours ago). She made me blow and it was 0.00. Frankly, I couldn't believe that (that drink was a Manhattan). I went to church that weekend and thanked God. Never again. I was lucky.

I had one beer after work one day then drove home. I got stopped by RIDE about 30 minutes after my last sip. Officer asked if I had had anything to drink, I told him I had one beer after work. He looked at me and said "the next time you get stopped at a RIDE and you've only had a beer or two, just say you've had nothing to drink." True story!
 
Since this is TERB I am waiting to see all those closed-minded guys trying to blame this on the police. We already know that they already hate the idea of the RIDE program because it takes away their right to drink and drive.

LOL.. me too.
 
The 2.25% refers to all accidents, not just fatal ones.

You realize if you include ALL accidents you include every single minor bumper
The 401 alone has multiple accidents every single day

This does not mean a drunk is less dangerous, this simply means it gets buried in an avalanche or minor accidents

As posted above drunks are involved in more than 66% of fatalities and also in more than 50% of serious accidents
 
You realize if you include ALL accidents you include every single minor bumper
The 401 alone has multiple accidents every single day

This does not mean a drunk is less dangerous, this simply means it gets buried in an avalanche or minor accidents

As posted above drunks are involved in more than 66% of fatalities and also in more than 50% of serious accidents

I never said a drunk is less dangerous.

According to MADD 2010 Canadian statistics, impaired drivers are involved in closer to 45% of fatal crashes. The CDC reports in 2010, 10,228 people were killed in alcohol-impaired driving crashes, accounting for nearly one-third (31%) of all traffic-related deaths in the United States. Still, way too many as far as I'm concerned. It drives me nuts that they don't lock up people who've been convicted of impaired over and over again.
 
I am rather appalled at the lack of empathy for a 16 year old kid who loss his life!! I cant understand the commemts he got what he deserved n the police r merely doing there jobs obviously that wasnt the case read port credit opp officer subject in investigation !!!He made a impulsive bad decision n Went for a joy ride n.he paid the highest price for it his life!! I feel strongly about this statement no parent should ever bury their child
 
Looks to me the investigation is more a matter of formality than an
indication of the officer being responsible for the death of the teen.
 
how can the public find out if the cops REALLY did call off the pursuit? like i find it so convenient the only time they call off a pursuit the car smashes and a kid dies. can the media request the radio recordings?
 
how can the public find out if the cops REALLY did call off the pursuit? like i find it so convenient the only time they call off a pursuit the car smashes and a kid dies. can the media request the radio recordings?

There probably hundreds of people who monitor police radios on their scanners. I'm sure of you put put a call to them and ask them might just have the answer, although I believe that ability will be much harder sometime in the future.
 
I am rather appalled at the lack of empathy for a 16 year old kid who loss his life!! I cant understand the commemts he got what he deserved n the police r merely doing there jobs obviously that wasnt the case read port credit opp officer subject in investigation !!!He made a impulsive bad decision n Went for a joy ride n.he paid the highest price for it his life!! I feel strongly about this statement no parent should ever bury their child

He made a impulsively bad decision which directly endangered the lives of all of us. Anyone here who had ever been on a highway, which is all of us.
 
Unless you live downtown it's hard to even grab a coffee in the burbs without driving. We crucify folks for drink driving yet I don't know of a bar or restaurant in the burbs that doesn't have huge Parking lots and you certainly need to drive there. Kinda funny having extreme drink driving laws in a country that's been built around the car.
 
Unless you live downtown it's hard to even grab a coffee in the burbs without driving. We crucify folks for drink driving yet I don't know of a bar or restaurant in the burbs that doesn't have huge Parking lots and you certainly need to drive there. Kinda funny having extreme drink driving laws in a country that's been built around the car.

Wow, so it's the city planners made some guy drink to much and drive defence?:confused:
 
Wow, so it's the city planners made some guy drink to much and drive defence?:confused:
Nope. Just saying I watch 90% of the population do it. I'm the only person I know who takes a taxi when I meet up for a couple of pints at my local. As I write this I'm having lunch in a pub and I've watched every single person drive in and order alcohol.

My point is it's extremely difficult to enjoy a pint and not drive.

The kid was stupid and wrong but it's not rape. Poor kid died for something everyone does. (Except me FYI)
 
Unless you live downtown it's hard to even grab a coffee in the burbs without driving. We crucify folks for drink driving yet I don't know of a bar or restaurant in the burbs that doesn't have huge Parking lots and you certainly need to drive there. Kinda funny having extreme drink driving laws in a country that's been built around the car.

Use a designated driver or take a cab. Your poor lifestyle choices aren't an excuse to kill people.

I agree though, if you park at a bar you should have to hand over your keys and pass a breathalyzer test to get them back.

Note that having a single beer with dinner isn't going to put most people over the limit. But having two or three and then immediately driving, is criminal. You need about an hour a drink to be legal. Though I believe that still isn't safe.