Man Killed Avoiding RIDE Spotcheck

They really should post an unmarked car at the previous intersection before a ride check, to pull over people doing that shit.
 
Plainly we should adopt a zero tolerance policy, making it illegal to drive with a non zero BAC, and imposing a non criminal but very steep fine on offenders between zero and the current legal limit.

Given that the measured cost is steep, in the ballpark of the cost of a car, seizure and forfeiture of the vehicle being driven seems like an appropriate fine for driving with a non zero BAC. Police could then auction it and refund to the perpetrator any proceeds above ten grand on the sale.

That level of penalty is fully supported by the data, and as you say, we prefer deterrents to compensating society.

So if you blow .01 they take away your car? You live in a strange fantasy land don't you fuji. The problem is there's no way for anyone to know or accurately measure exactly how much alcohol is in their bloodstream. An approximation maybe but what you're proposing is so completely unrealistic. The problem is alcohol is metabolized at the rate of .015 of blood alcohol concentration (BAC) every hour. Without knowing exactly what your BAC was when you stop drinking you don't know exactly how long you have to wait before your BAC get to exactly .00 which is why you are allowed to have a small amount in your system.

In a perfect world, drivers would have a zero BAC when behind the wheel but we don't live in a perfect world which is why there are limits. There has to be a bit of a margin for error.

I'm not condoning drinking and driving, just saying zero BAC is completely unrealistic.

As a side note, I wonder how many people drive when taking legally prescribed meds which can also impair your ability to operate a vehicle? Probably a bigger problem than one would think.
 
They really should post an unmarked car at the previous intersection before a ride check, to pull over people doing that shit.

The police generally do that. When you come around a corner or over a hill to the point where you can see RIDE stop, the side street at that point is the one the cops site at and they do stop everyone that turns onto the side street.

Can’t see the RIDE were the cops tried to stop this young guy until you come around the corner on the QEW off ramp to Hurontario. He had no where to go but forward. Expect he was running traffic lights as there are about 5 traffic lights between the QEW and were he crashed at Dundas.
 
So if you blow .01 they take away your car?

That is what the data supports doing, based on the average harm done by people who drive after having a single drink. The harm done is in the ballpark of a typical car's value.

The problem is there's no way for anyone to know or accurately measure exactly how much alcohol is in their bloodstream.

It's reasonable to give people the benefit of the doubt if the measurement cannot be made accurately. Public policy should be zero. How close to zero we can get then becomes a question of what sort of accuracy the police can prove in court.

Technology will improve. The law should specify zero with it being a valid defense that a reading is within the margin of error of zero.
 
1) The guy may have had a warrant out for him. 2) You don't have to answer questions at a RIDE stop (best to do if you're sober). "Where you coming from/heading to" - "Have you had anything to drink tonight?" 3) You don't have to partake in field sobriety tests (stupid coordination tests that sober people can fail). Videos online are available of DUI refusals at 'checkpoints' people video record in the USA. In Canada we're too polite to not comply with police.
 
Are u crazy?
Besides the obvious at least we clean up the gene pool since this 16 yr old can never reproduce now why in the world would you estimate 86% of people would engage a high speed pursuit?
I'd be willing to bet everything I own there are more people on this forum who have had licenses suspended than fled (actually I bet more have been in prison even than fled)

I meant driving while over the limit.....
 
Having a couple of drinks did no kill him, being a complete fucking idiot and running a police check stop at what was obviously a high rate of speed is what got him killed. I have a hard time believing 86% of posters here would run a police check stop.

The circumstances create the reaction. You are dealing with people with impaired judgement, in case you didn't notice, people behave differently when drunk.
 
That is what the data supports doing, based on the average harm done by people who drive after having a single drink. The harm done is in the ballpark of a typical car's value.

How was this data collected? Are you telling me they know each person's BAC when they had an accident after having one drink? They would've had to have tested these people after consuming a drink, got in their car, had the accident, wait for Police to arrive, take them to a the station and test them all within an hour to determine their BAC? I find that very hard to believe.

Technology will improve. The law should specify zero with it being a valid defense that a reading is within the margin of error of zero.

That's not going to happen. There's too many people in Government who like to have a drink with dinner and drive home for them to ever change the law to zero tolerance. You think the courts are backed up now, just imagine what they'd be like with zero tolerance. Totally absurd proposition.
 
How was this data collected? Are you telling me they know a person's BAC when they had an accident after having one drink? They would've had to have tested these people after consuming a drink, got in their car, had the accident, wait for Police to arrive, take them to a the station and test them all within an hour to determine their BAC? I find that very hard to believe.



That's not going to happen. There's too many people in Government who like to have a drink with dinner and drive home for them to ever change the law to zero tolerance. You think the courts are backed up now, just imagine what they'd be like with zero tolerance. Totally absurd proposition.

I hope all of FUJI's mouthwashes don't have any alcohol in them or those of his favourite ladies for that matter. Wouldn't want anyone to blow over .01 and get suspended.
 
We don't know yet if the driver was driving drunk, he was just fleeing a police checkpoint.
If you guys have been giving Rob Ford the benefit of doubt for all these months, you should do so here as well.
 
We don't know yet if the driver was driving drunk, he was just fleeing a police checkpoint.
If you guys have been giving Rob Ford the benefit of doubt for all these months, you should do so here as well.


Most people don't flee a RIDE stop because they are late for an appointment. He may not have been drunk but it's pretty clear he thought he would blow over. Then again it could have been that last bong hit that was on his mind.
 
3) You don't have to partake in field sobriety tests (stupid coordination tests that sober people can fail). Videos online are available of DUI refusals at 'checkpoints' people video record in the USA. In Canada we're too polite to not comply with police.
Before someone takes your advice literally. Refusal to take a BAC test in most jurisdictions, including Ontario, results in an automatic license suspension. In many jurisdictions the consequences of refusing to test are deliberately the same as though your BAC showed you where close to death from alcohol poisoning.
 
We don't know yet if the driver was driving drunk, he was just fleeing a police checkpoint.
If you guys have been giving Rob Ford the benefit of doubt for all these months, you should do so here as well.

It's got nothing to do with Rob Ford nor is there an analogy of any sort.

This guy was pissed and/or simply unlawful. He got what he deserved, and thankfully, he didn't hurt anybody. What he did was criminal ("just fleeing a police checkpoint" - are you fucking nuts?). We don't need him on the road if he disobeys even a police check point.
 
In any case it is clear driving after even a single drink is risky. Should get a 5000 fine, from that article, for having non zero BAC but lower than criminal levels, per that article.


I think that's crazy. One drink of wine with a meal or two won't impair you, especially if the time involved is over several hours and you also drink water, etc. etc.

I've admitted to wine with a meal at check points but was allowed to carry on (once was asked to blow and registered 0.00) because I didn't reek of alcohol or drive impaired.

However, if they can get breathalyzers into all cars such that you can hold off from driving or take a cab, I would welcome that, only that these devices might be subject to re-calibration over time, and this might require new regulations.