Man Killed Avoiding RIDE Spotcheck

1) The guy may have had a warrant out for him. 2) You don't have to answer questions at a RIDE stop (best to do if you're sober). "Where you coming from/heading to" - "Have you had anything to drink tonight?" 3) You don't have to partake in field sobriety tests (stupid coordination tests that sober people can fail). Videos online are available of DUI refusals at 'checkpoints' people video record in the USA. In Canada we're too polite to not comply with police.

However, if they ask you to take a breathalyzer and you refused, you will be convicted on that basis.
 
How was this data collected?

Fatal crash coroner's reports. Autopsy results, and blood samples taken from accused drivers and used in criminal prosecutions. Incredibly accurate data. The US actually had compiled the data from ALL crashes, so it wasn't a sample but a total population measurement.

It turns out that the accurate, comprehensive data from fatal crashes is good enough to draw conclusions about the cost of drunk driving in general, since we know the total number of drivers in the US.

The estimated cost is a LOWER bound, because it excludes harm done in cases that did not result in a fatality. So, cases where someone was merely paralyzed were excluded.

Also, undetected drunk surviving drivers were implicitly included in the sober category, which minimizes the difference between drunk and sober making the estimator a lower bound for a second reason.

Thus the estimated cost of driving drunk is very clearly a lower bound, the true cost, and true risk, is certainly higher than estimated.

Are you telling me they know each person's BAC when they had an accident after having one drink?

Yes, in the data they have the exact BAC's.

The study broke drivers down into three categories: drunk over the legal limit, under the legal limit, and sober.

Drunk over the limit drivers were 13 times more likely to cause fatal crashes than sober drivers. Drunk under the limit drivers were 7 times more likely. This is enough information to attribute the total number of fatalities to each category, and with some binomial assumptions, the fraction of drivers on the road who are in each category.

By computing the share of fatalities caused by each type of driver and combining that with standard values on human life used in insurance calculations, they determined that a driver found drunk by police at a roadside stop has done a average 10k damage to society (8k, adjusted for inflation).

That is in the ballpark of the value of the average car, and since it is clearly a lower bound, time to start seizing cars.
 
I think that's crazy. One drink of wine with a meal or two won't impair you, especially if the time involved is over several hours and you also drink water, etc. etc.

One drink a few hours ago and your BAC will be near zero. But one drink twenty minutes before you drive will make you a LOT more dangerous. Seven times more likely to cause a fatal crash than normal.
 
1) Videos online are available of DUI refusals at 'checkpoints' people video record in the USA. In Canada we're too polite to not comply with police.

He still would have been in massive trouble in US since a 16 year old is not allowed to drink in any state
Maybe thats the answer in Canada, raise our minimum legal age to match the US
 
I think that's crazy. One drink of wine with a meal or two won't impair you, especially if the time involved is over several hours and you also drink water, etc. etc.

Actually your idea is crazy
Different people are effected by alcohol in different ways

I know a girl who could and did feel the effects of a single drink
And to trot out the race card many asians are impaired at a significantly lower blood alcohol level than non asians
 
One drink a few hours ago and your BAC will be near zero. But one drink twenty minutes before you drive will make you a LOT more dangerous. Seven times more likely to cause a fatal crash than normal.

I think there should be strict laws on drinking and driving and anyone who drives impaired deserves the punishment but there are of course some flaws in the reporting as this person points out.

http://www2.potsdam.edu/hansondj/DrivingIssues/1101913925.html#.UpUGsNJOOSo

Alcohol Consumption and Traffic Crashes
by David J. Hanson, Ph.D.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety in an unbiased evaluator of all the causes of traffic crashes, injuries and deaths. The insurance companies that sponsor its work are interested in reducing traffic accidents. Neither the insurance industry nor the Institute has an ideological agenda to promote.

The following information is from the Institute’s web site Question and Answer page about alcohol:

What proportion of all motor vehicle crashes is caused by alcohol? It is impossible to say with certainty. Although alcohol is known to increase crash likelihood, its presence is neither necessary nor sufficient to cause a crash. Every crash in which a driver has a high BAC is not caused by alcohol. To learn the number of crashes caused by driving at various BACs, it would be necessary to find out how many trips that do not involve crashes are driven by people with positive BACs -- something that is only measured periodically in roadside surveys or special studies of motorists not involved in crashes.

What proportion of motor vehicle crashes involves alcohol? The most reliable information about alcohol involvement comes from fatal crashes. In 2002, 32 percent of fatally injured drivers had BACs of at least 0.08 percent. Although alcohol may not have been a causal factor in all of the crashes, this statistic is frequently used to measure the change over time in alcohol involvement in fatal crashes.

In 2002, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) estimated that 35 percent of all traffic deaths occurred in crashes in which at least one driver or nonoccupant had a BAC of 0.08 percent or more and that any alcohol was present in 41 percent of all fatal crashes in 2002. Such statistics are sometimes cited as proof that a third to half of all fatal crashes are caused by "drunk driving" and that none of the crashes that involve alcohol would occur if the alcohol were not present. But this is incorrect and misleading because alcohol is only one of several factors that contribute to crashes involving drinking drivers. Furthermore, some fatally injured people in alcohol-related crashes are pedestrians with positive BACs, and these fatalities still would occur even if every driver were sober.

Alcohol involvement is much lower in crashes involving nonfatal injuries, and it is lower still in crashes that do not involve injuries at all.

Ten percent (10%) of all people who receive injuries in traffic accidents do so in alcohol-related crashes, according to NHTSA estimates. It is estimated that 3.22% of these injury-producing crashes involve intoxicated drivers.

Seven percent (7%) of all traffic accidents involve alcohol use, according to NHTSA estimates. It is estimated that 2.25% of all vehicular crashes involve intoxicated drivers.

These statistics are all estimates based on incomplete information. Often they are estimates based on other estimates. However, 12.8% of all drivers involved in fatal accidents in the U.S. during 2001 are known to have been intoxicated according to the BAC laws (.10 or .08) of their state. This number is based on a systematic examination of the official records of each and every accident involving a fatality during that year in the US. It is based on factual evidence rather than on estimates or guesses.

The higher numbers commonly reported in the press refers to accidents in which NHTSA believes that some alcohol has been consumed by someone associated with the accident. For example, if a person who was believed to have consumed any alcohol is stopped at a red light and is rear-ended by an inattentive completely sober driver, that accident is considered to be alcohol-related.

Alcohol consumption, cell phone use, drowsy driving, aggressive driving, and drugged driving are all important but preventable causes of traffic accidents, injuries and deaths. There has been a dramatic and continuing drop in alcohol-related traffic crashes, but much more needs to be done to prevent drunk driving.

However, virtually ignored have been the other major causes of vehicular crashes. For example, using a cell phone is even more dangerous than driving while intoxicated. We can and must do even more to reduce traffic crashes from all causes.

A person who dies in a traffic crash is just as dead whether the accident was caused by a drunk driver, a cell phone user, an aggressive driver, or a drugged driver. They must all be stopped.

"It is estimated that 2.25% of all vehicular crashes involve intoxicated drivers." If that's true, it means the other 97.75% of vehicular crashes are caused by other factors. Based on that, I don't think we need to live in fuji world where someone who blows a .01 has their car taken away and sold. I think the word draconian is appropriate for those measures.
 
...When you make the penalties so high, criminalize people and advertise to people that DUI means your life is over, some people are gonna believe it and take huge risks when confronted.....

I love the view that the idiot driving drunk isn't to blame. Have you ever heard of personal responsibility?
 
Sure that would be ideal, but often people don't plan to drink...

Drink all you want, just don't drive afterward. Easy Peasy.
 
1) The guy may have had a warrant out for him. 2) You don't have to answer questions at a RIDE stop (best to do if you're sober). "Where you coming from/heading to" - "Have you had anything to drink tonight?" 3) You don't have to partake in field sobriety tests (stupid coordination tests that sober people can fail). Videos online are available of DUI refusals at 'checkpoints' people video record in the USA. In Canada we're too polite to not comply with police.

And what would the benefit of refusing the test be for someone not engaged in criminal activity?
 
...

What's interesting here is that a single drink is half as bad a being legally drunk,....

Interesting data since for most adult men, 1 drink will be metabolized after 1-1.5 hours. That means having a glass of wine at dinner then socializing for an hour after means 0.0 BAC.
 
I think there should be strict laws on drinking and driving and anyone who drives impaired deserves the punishment but there are of course some flaws in the reporting as this person points out.

If your read the Levitt study, you will see that he took a different approach to the problem than just counting up cases. He worked out the likelihood of causing a crash instead with the only assumption being a binomial distribution.

As you point out, most crashes are not caused by drunk drivers, that's because the overwhelming majority of drivers on the road are sober. Even people who drive drunk are typically sober most of the time. So drunk drivers are very rare, but they cause an outsized share of the fatal accidents.

In calculating their harm to society, he excluded fatalities when the drunk driver killed themselves or a passenger in their own car, noting that these people have presumably accepted the risk of death. He counted up the remaining fatalities, only cases where the drunk killed someone in the other vehicle.

From this, and standard insurance rates for human life, he worked out that it costs society about ten grand every time, and that's in the neighborhood of the average car.
 
Sure that would be ideal, but often people don't plan to drink...

If you can't drink because you goofed up and drove to the bar, don't drink. Have a soda.

It's really not that hard.

I can drink like a fish and have been staggering drunk on a few occasions, but I have never driven drunk. I have no problem skipping the beer if it's not possible.

And really if you are honest most of the time when you say you didn't "plan" to drink, you knew it was in the cards. I have certain friends that if we get together, odds are, we're drinking. If I am meeting up with those guys, either plan to order soda, or leave the car at home.

And don't give me after work bs. Leave the car in the office parking lot overnight. Take the transit in the morning.
 
Interesting data since for most adult men, 1 drink will be metabolized after 1-1.5 hours. That means having a glass of wine at dinner then socializing for an hour after means 0.0 BAC.

Sure and those who metabolized their alcohol and were back to zero were counted as sober. The study was based on actual bloodwork.

People who had alcohol measured in their system, but still below the legal limit, we're seven times more likely to cause a fatal accident. Those who had readings above the limit were thirteen times more likely.
 
Sure and those who metabolized their alcohol and were back to zero were counted as sober. The study was based on actual bloodwork.

People who had alcohol measured in their system, but still below the legal limit, we're seven times more likely to cause a fatal accident. Those who had readings above the limit were thirteen times more likely.

So when you wrote
...

What's interesting here is that a single drink is half as bad a being legally drunk,....
you were playing fast and loose with definitions. Did you mean to say that having a BAC above 0.25 makes you more likely or did you want people to really believe your argument that having one drink makes you just as likely to crash?

The problem of arguing for the sake of arguing and rabidly sticking to your initial claim is problematic when you have to actually be consistent.


p.s. Can you actually back up your claims of how the study's methodology works or is that too just for the sake of the debate?
 
I think its bullshit to do a blanket test on alcohol consumption and then you get charged. I know people that will beat 10/10 seniors in a driving test drunk. How about throwing seniors in jail and taking their license away for a year if they fail a roadside test just cause they're fucking old and shouldnt be driving. Isnt the point to get people that can cause an accident off the road? this blanket law is BS.

PS Ive never drank alcohol in my life and am a huge civil liberty advocat.
 
I think there should be strict laws on drinking and driving and anyone who drives impaired deserves the punishment but there are of course some flaws in the reporting as this person points out.

"It is estimated that 2.25% of all vehicular crashes involve intoxicated drivers." If that's true, it means the other 97.75% of vehicular crashes are caused by other factors. Based on that, I don't think we need to live in fuji world where someone who blows a .01 has their car taken away and sold. I think the word draconian is appropriate for those measures.

What???
Who estimated that 2.25% of accidents involved intoxicated drivers???
Hate to break it to you but the insurance bureau of BC (who has actual stats and not made up ones) claimed over 67% of their fatal accidents had alcohol or drugs as a factor

http://www.sense.bc.ca/img/isku_40pct.gif
 
In reference to the comments of alcohol being a factor thet havent ruled that out but they havent confirmed it either j
get ur facts straight!!! second he was not a man he was child age 16!! Most young boys have a fascination with cars!! Unfortunately he made a bad impulsive decision based on being young n.impulsive!! Adults in their mid to late 60's get dui all the time! Ironic!!
My condolences to the family !! I do feeling strongly that no parent should bury their child!!