Schenn won't be eligible for any kind of Free Agency until he has three years of professional experience. If he plays more this year, that will count against that limit. If he gets sent down and doesn't come back, it won't.
Since he's staying with the Leafs, this will count as his first year of playing in the NHL. After two more years, if they don't sign him long-term, he'll become a "Group 2" player - a "Restricted" Free Agent.
The only real argument I could see against keeping Schenn up would be that the Leafs are "wasting" a year of his guaranteed service when they really have no chance. It is possible, though unlikely, that he'll be gone in 2011-12. If this is the first real year of the Leafs being back to competitiveness, they'll want him on-board.
Since he's staying with the Leafs, this will count as his first year of playing in the NHL. After two more years, if they don't sign him long-term, he'll become a "Group 2" player - a "Restricted" Free Agent.
The only real argument I could see against keeping Schenn up would be that the Leafs are "wasting" a year of his guaranteed service when they really have no chance. It is possible, though unlikely, that he'll be gone in 2011-12. If this is the first real year of the Leafs being back to competitiveness, they'll want him on-board.

