Luke Schenn

21pro

Crotch Sniffer
Oct 22, 2003
7,829
1
0
Caledon East
...already the Leafs best defenseman. better than Strahlman, better than Colaiacovo, Van Ryn, etc... we'll see how he looks with Kaberle in the season.

that was fine work he did covering Malkin and Staal lastnight!
 
21pro said:
...already the Leafs best defenseman. better than Strahlman, better than Colaiacovo, Van Ryn, etc... we'll see how he looks with Kaberle in the season.

that was fine work he did covering Malkin and Staal lastnight!

The kid does look really good but he most likely will not make the team this year.

He certainly has a great future ahead of him.

I think that management is doing the right thing with him. The Leafs aren't very good and that can destroy the kid's confidence.
 
21pro said:
...already the Leafs best defenseman. better than Strahlman, better than Colaiacovo, Van Ryn, etc... we'll see how he looks with Kaberle in the season.

that was fine work he did covering Malkin and Staal lastnight!

Really? You are going to put all that pressure on this kid? Leaf fans are incredible. I wonder how long it will be before you start treating him like McCabe.
 
guyroch said:
I hear the word " preasure " a lot .... This Kid has played in playoff games before and has worn the " Canadian Jersey " in one of the most watched hockey events of the year ( World Jr Championship ) ... I think he has seen
presure before and wants to suceed as much as we want him too ....

You say treate him like McCabe .... I think Leaf fans also worship our Home team Stars ... He can own this town like Wendal , Dougie , and so don't forget this city hasn't won a Cup in 40 + years but still have hockey heros and
so expectations aren't as bad as if you were a rookie in " Montreal "

Schenn has seen his fair share of "pressure" and I'm not doubting that for a minute (I like the kid) but it fails to compare the rigours of NHL life where the toughest critics in the hockey world are, Toronto.

We do worship our stars to a point but Mats was never "worshipped" even though he has been the only offensive threat in the lineup for years.
He was expected to do everything himself because he was the best player on the team and the captain as well. One player cannot win the Cup by themselves. That has never happened before nor will it ever.
 
The pressure is certainly much higer on Schenn in Toronto then say if he was playing in Montreal.

Now I'm not arguing that Montreal is any less of a critical or pressurized market then Toronto ... it could be more.

That being said Montreal has any entire crop of young players plus a very good team to deflect the attention from a top pick. And the Price situation was different last year... the pressur arose because he was the starter on a #1 seed.

But the most important think is that fans love to circle jerk about their young orospects, and much more so. when things are not so good at the NHL Level. Add the fact that Maple Leafs prospects as a whole are pretty darn unappealing, and that's a lot of people that are targeting and putting pressure on Schenn.

But you are right kids today have been exposed to more pressure then ever before. Now the pressure may expose them earlier in their career... before the NHL.
 
so what are you saying Maurice? the pressure is certainly much higher in Toronto, but Montreal could be a more pressurized market than Toronto? I'm perplexed... you are putting those difficult algorithms into your statements again. lol...

ok, enough with the Montreal hi-jacking... back to Luke Schenn.

did you guys notice that Malkin was able to easily blow by any other leafs player, including Kaberle, except for Schenn? covering Malkin is no easy task. but, my role as a jr A head coach perhaps leads me to have an understanding of hockey that is a little better than average.

I'm telling you- he's ready.

also, the leafs do have a FAST MOVING, albeit small team. they look like a bunch of water-bugs.
 
Schenn knows how to play his position well. He is a good skater and he should develop into a better one in due time.

I would like to see Schenn in the NHL this year but he is a special player and I think they should work him in slowly.

I believe he will be a dominant force on the defensive side and if his offensive side turns up for the better (it's not bad), the Leafs have found a gem.
 
agreed, lawyerman, and well said.

Nhl ready doesn't necessarily mean leafs ready... or ACC ready. they've ruined enough good D-men over the years.

lol... time for a new thread...
 
Prior to the draft Luke Schenn was considered one of the most NHL ready draft eligable prospects. He's close, but I wouldn't put him on a weak NHL team at this point...just like it's Sundin's fault that we have no cups, this upcoming season would be Luke's fault...since he's our highest draft choice since 89. I think there is some untapped offensive potential in him, and he can probably find that dimension this year in the WHL. Not that confidence is an issue, but if he goes to the WHL he can find his offensive game and possiblely be named best defenceman in Canadian junior hockey...he can captain the WJC team to a gold medal. He can really develop alot and build up his confidence versus playing all season for the struggling Leafs where all he can hope for is a roster spot...with Fletch in charge I'm positive he gets a look but will go back to junior.
 
Did any of you watch the Pittsburgh game??

Schenn was a puck cough up machine....he is physically not ready to handle the strength of good NHL grinders in the corners, and to be a 6th D on a weaker team(although I have a feeling this team will overachieve this year) is not a good training ground for a young D man..

I hope that one of the other 5 guys can take that # 6 spot..


N2G
 
re: the Pittsburgh game. his positional play was bang on, and he finished the game with ZERO giveaways.

so I don't know what you mean by puck cough up machine.

seriously, i like this guy. he's impressed me much more than Stamkos and may have a chance at Calder if he stays up. imagine, a defensive defenceman...
 
21pro said:
agreed, lawyerman, and well said.

Nhl ready doesn't necessarily mean leafs ready... or ACC ready. they've ruined enough good D-men over the years.

lol... time for a new thread...

I don't understand the thought process of putting a guy in the minor leagues if they are ready to play in the Big Leagues. I get the idea that he would get more game time in the minors. However, if he is ready to take the #5 spot, then why not keep him up in the NHL to get experience? Also, why not have him practicing against NHL players than AHL players...

Finally, if the guys' psyche is so weak, that he loses it over one bad year or getting kicked around the NHL, how is he going to take not making a team for the first time in his life????
 
A quote from an article by Howard Berger...

21pro said:
re: the Pittsburgh game. his positional play was bang on, and he finished the game with ZERO giveaways.

so I don't know what you mean by puck cough up machine.

seriously, i like this guy. he's impressed me much more than Stamkos and may have a chance at Calder if he stays up. imagine, a defensive defenceman...


http://www.canada.com/windsorstar/news/story.html?id=72b0f2cd-04b1-485c-b35a-3c24ab68489a

"First-round draft pick Luke Schenn faced a number of players that competed in the Stanley Cup final last spring, and he looked shakier than he did against Buffalo's patchwork lineup. The Pittsburgh forwards - notably, Talbot - pressured him in the corners and Schenn coughed up the puck several times. Schenn, of course, is still just 18".




....seems to back up my view of his play...

Yea 21pro....I know you used to "play the game"...and seem to be connected with some NHL guys....but us so called "dumb fans" sometimes watch too much sports..and actually catch on to the nuances of the game...lol


N2G
 
slowandeasy said:
I don't understand the thought process of putting a guy in the minor leagues if they are ready to play in the Big Leagues. I get the idea that he would get more game time in the minors. However, if he is ready to take the #5 spot, then why not keep him up in the NHL to get experience? Also, why not have him practicing against NHL players than AHL players...

Finally, if the guys' psyche is so weak, that he loses it over one bad year or getting kicked around the NHL, how is he going to take not making a team for the first time in his life????

It's either junior or the NHL. He cannot play in the AHL per agreement between Junior/NHL... unless something has recently changed?
 
If a player is 19 or younger, they go back to junior if they don't stick with the NHL team.
 
Cliff Fletcher said it would be a miracle if Schenn makes the team.

Let the kid try and dominate the other kids in junior (he was very good but not dominant). This would (hopefully) help his offensive game to be a better all-around defenceman.

I don't understand what the rush is to bring him up ot the big club.

When the year is over in junior hockey, he will be able to play with the Marlies and upgrade his game even further.

Leafs management is doing the right thing with this kid.
 
lawyerman said:
Cliff Fletcher said it would be a miracle if Schenn makes the team.

Let the kid try and dominate the other kids in junior (he was very good but not dominant). This would (hopefully) help his offensive game to be a better all-around defenceman.

I don't understand what the rush is to bring him up ot the big club.

When the year is over in junior hockey, he will be able to play with the Marlies and upgrade his game even further.

Leafs management is doing the right thing with this kid.

Agreed.

Next to goaltending, defence is the second toughest position to jump right in and play. It’s not just about handling the puck. It’s reads, it’s being physical, it’s knowing when to jump into the rush, it’s chemistry with your partner. Not to mention things happen so much quicker than in junior or in minor pro.

Let the kid develop, it's not like the Leafs are counting on the kid to lead them to the promised land in 2008-09.

Don't forget, media and Leaf followers practically had Carlo Colaiacovo going to the Hall of Fame before he played one game in the NHL. He ended up back in junior for the entire season after he was drafted. Even through all his comebacks from injury, he still spent considerable time in the AHL.

Unless Schenn is the second coming of Bobby Orr, I say to the Leafs leave him be, take your time with him, he will get there when he is good and ready.
 
21pro said:
role as a jr A head coach perhaps leads me to have an understanding of hockey that is a little better than average.

Sorry, off topic but ..........Schenn would look good in your lineup, maybe you can work something out with Cliff......lol

You will be close to my neck of the woods this weekend, maybe a pack of terbites should show up and heckle you from behind the bench. :p

BTW, I still do not understand this idea of the newly formed Division. They put all the tops teams (supposedly) into one Division? Isn't that sort of like the old NHL expansion in 1967 with the East and West. The East would beat up on the West in the Stanley Cup every year in the early going. Unless teams in the other Divisions will be very competitive come playoff time and when they end up crossing over towards the end? How did they end up deciding which teams to lump all together?
 
the drama surrounding the re-aligning of the Divisions to create the super-division is something I try to avoid getting into. It was meant to provide better exposure to NCAA scouts, etc... Yes, it is a slippery slope as once you create a 'more' competitive division within a league you start to draw the best talent and then you begin to differentiate yourself from the rest of the league.

I try to just think of it as a place for the top non-OHL juniors to play... can't get to politically involved with it... I leave that for others to debate.

I do have to try and keep my integrity intact. Word gets out that my identity is spilled on an escort review board, I can only imagine what all of those Catholic hockey moms will do to me ;) I'm trying to cut back on my terb involvement, but... you know- I got quite a post history record here.... as said in post-revolution France, you live by the guillotine, ...

regarding Schenn... he's a future Team Canada candidate no doubt. he'll go back to jr., but I was impressed with his outing.
 
^^ yes that's pretty much what I got from the re-alignment. Anyways, I was jk about sending a terb heckling crew out. I don't get to as many junior games as I used to and it is mainly the 'O' when I do go out. I catch the occasional junior Red Wing game near by.