Luke Schenn

Schenn won't be eligible for any kind of Free Agency until he has three years of professional experience. If he plays more this year, that will count against that limit. If he gets sent down and doesn't come back, it won't.

Since he's staying with the Leafs, this will count as his first year of playing in the NHL. After two more years, if they don't sign him long-term, he'll become a "Group 2" player - a "Restricted" Free Agent.

The only real argument I could see against keeping Schenn up would be that the Leafs are "wasting" a year of his guaranteed service when they really have no chance. It is possible, though unlikely, that he'll be gone in 2011-12. If this is the first real year of the Leafs being back to competitiveness, they'll want him on-board.
 
The kid is ready now. I didn't think it was possible but he proved me wrong.

Sending him down could perhaps hinder his development.

There is a good coaching staff in place and this kid should be a defensive gem for years to come.

He is gaining experience and although losing many games could ruin many 18 year olds, Schenn has a great head on his shoulders and he should benefit.

Leafs management were actually leaning towards sending him down at the end of training camp but how can you send him down when he is definitely holding his own?
 
King Elessar said:
Schenn won't be eligible for any kind of Free Agency until he has three years of professional experience. If he plays more this year, that will count against that limit. If he gets sent down and doesn't come back, it won't.

Since he's staying with the Leafs, this will count as his first year of playing in the NHL. After two more years, if they don't sign him long-term, he'll become a "Group 2" player - a "Restricted" Free Agent.

The only real argument I could see against keeping Schenn up would be that the Leafs are "wasting" a year of his guaranteed service when they really have no chance. It is possible, though unlikely, that he'll be gone in 2011-12. If this is the first real year of the Leafs being back to competitiveness, they'll want him on-board.

Thanks... finally someone with a real good reason why Schenn should be sent to the minors... But I still would not send him down. Although this reason is not such a bad one.
 
slowandeasy said:
Thanks... finally someone with a real good reason why Schenn should be sent to the minors... But I still would not send him down. Although this reason is not such a bad one.

Actually a horrible argument or reason.

Otherwise, the Penguins shoulda kept Crosby down in the Q for atleast 2 more seasons! for what... to save a few years on his contract... whatever :rolleyes: It's not saving anything. rather delaying. It's much better to have a staggering of RFA maturity from your core talent than have it occur all at the same time. With Schenn, the leafs will still get another few high picks over the next few seasons and he'll be a captain in 3-4 years.
 
21pro said:
Actually a horrible argument or reason.

Otherwise, the Penguins shoulda kept Crosby down in the Q for atleast 2 more seasons! for what... to save a few years on his contract... whatever :rolleyes: It's not saving anything. rather delaying. It's much better to have a staggering of RFA maturity from your core talent than have it occur all at the same time. With Schenn, the leafs will still get another few high picks over the next few seasons and he'll be a captain in 3-4 years.
I agree.
Besides. I'm not sure that we all agree on what the objective is here. For some, it's to keep this guy guaranteed for an extra year. For others, including myself, it's to develop him as best and as quickly as possible. That's in his best interest which in turn is in our (Leafs) best interest.
Leaving aside the extra year argument, I don't see how his development would be furthered in the juniors. No one here is saying he's the next Orr, or Potvin, or Robinson, but he does have a fundamental soundess to his game, a maturity beyond his years, and a tremendous attitude and poise. If he went back to the juniors, it would be practise for a year. To develop him, you have to push the envelope, challenge his physical abilities and his wits. In my opinion he's shown that he's ready for that challenge and he deserves it. How do you think he would feel if he believed he was more than deserving to stay with the Leafs, but was sent down because they wanted to keep him for that one extra year.
The Leafs keep getting beat up on about what a shit organization they are, that they don't know how to handle or treat their players. Well, here they are, showing an 18 yr. old kid the kind of respect and confidence that he deserves, keeping him under the guidance and tutelage of some of the best coaching in pro hockey, without concern for the "extra year". Why do they want to keep him? Because they want to make the playoffs?
This is about more than Schenn, it's about a long term program of developing a new culture, a competitive spirit, a team that young players as well as free agents want to play for.
Don't worry about the extra year, that shit will take care of itself when the time comes. It means nothing in light of the big picture.
 
slowandeasy said:
Thanks... finally someone with a real good reason why Schenn should be sent to the minors... But I still would not send him down. Although this reason is not such a bad one.
I'm not sure I agree that this is good enough reason to send him down, but it's a valid one.
 
21pro said:
Actually a horrible argument or reason.
Not really.

21pro said:
Otherwise, the Penguins shoulda kept Crosby down in the Q for atleast 2 more seasons! for what... to save a few years on his contract... whatever
Uhhh ... you mean the team that was actually competitive last year, and made the Stanley Cup Finals? lol And the one that needed SOME REASON to keep them in Pittsburgh because they couldn't sell any tickets?
You think the Leafs are in the same boat IN ANY RESPECT? :rolleyes:
More importantly, you think Schenn and Crosby are in the same boat? ... Wow. Enjoy the Leafs koolaid while it lasts, folks. Eight games, and Luke Schenn is a Hart candidate.
Anyway, nobody said anything about TWO more seasons. Clearly, there comes a point where a guy has to play.
Keeping a kid down when he's 18 is hard to argue with ....

21pro said:
It's not saving anything. rather delaying.
No, you're wrong. It's saving a year of his services UNTIL THE LEAFS ARE BETTER, BY DELAYING his promotion to the big club. Delaying his services until the Leafs aren't a probably last-place team. It has SAVED them a year of Schenn contributing his services to a nowhere team.

21pro said:
It's much better to have a staggering of RFA maturity from your core talent than have it occur all at the same time.
Prove this? I see the Blackhawks as a good counter-example.

21pro said:
With Schenn, the leafs will still get another few high picks over the next few seasons and he'll be a captain in 3-4 years.
And by the time those picks come to fruition, Schenn might be gone. That gonna be a good thing?

I don't think it's reason enough to send him down, seeing how he's played this year. ... BUT, I think it would have been easy enough to send him back after training camp and not be having this discussion.

Again, it's a thin line either way. But, there's no doubt the Leafs are spending a year of his time THIS YEAR. You can't get that year back.
 
jazzpig said:
I agree.
Besides. I'm not sure that we all agree on what the objective is here. For some, it's to keep this guy guaranteed for an extra year. For others, including myself, it's to develop him as best and as quickly as possible. That's in his best interest which in turn is in our (Leafs) best interest.
I didn't say I was IN FAVOUR of sending him down because of this - I said it would be a reason someone might put forward, rather than the silly, unresolvable "development here or in Junior" argument ... which I see you've put forth below. ;)

jazzpig said:
Leaving aside the extra year argument, I don't see how his development would be furthered in the juniors. No one here is saying he's the next Orr, or Potvin, or Robinson, but he does have a fundamental soundess to his game, a maturity beyond his years, and a tremendous attitude and poise. If he went back to the juniors, it would be practise for a year.
No, it wouldn't be "practice".
Unless you think the World Juniors Championships are nothing games.

jazzpig said:
To develop him, you have to push the envelope, challenge his physical abilities and his wits.
So you say.
I'm not convinced.
And you're going to find yourself eminently unable to provide evidence to back up your opinion.
The development argument is all opinion.

jazzpig said:
In my opinion he's shown that he's ready for that challenge and he deserves it.
I agree.

jazzpig said:
How do you think he would feel if he believed he was more than deserving to stay with the Leafs, but was sent down because they wanted to keep him for that one extra year.
You'll notice, if you bothered to read my post, that I said "if he was okay with it".
Try re-reading that again, just so you understand.

jazzpig said:
The Leafs keep getting beat up on about what a shit organization they are, that they don't know how to handle or treat their players. Well, here they are, showing an 18 yr. old kid the kind of respect and confidence that he deserves, keeping him under the guidance and tutelage of some of the best coaching in pro hockey, without concern for the "extra year".
That argument cuts both ways, as many Leaf fans will point out.
They've practically ruined many young players - especially defensemen - by rushing them into the grinder and playing for shit teams.
Maybe "the kind of respect and confidence he deserves" would have been to send him back to Junior after training camp, let him get another full year AS A TEAM LEADER under his belt, and play with the best U-20s in the world, both in the WHL and the World Juniors.

jazzpig said:
Why do they want to keep him? Because they want to make the playoffs?
Yeah, I'm sorry to break this to you, but it's not gonna happen this year.
But, it SHOULD be their goal to make the playoffs in two or three years. Not just make the playoffs, but make noise in them. And Schenn should be a big part of that.

jazzpig said:
This is about more than Schenn, it's about a long term program of developing a new culture, a competitive spirit, a team that young players as well as free agents want to play for.
Don't worry about the extra year, that shit will take care of itself when the time comes. It means nothing in light of the big picture.
Uhhh ... making sure that players like Schenn are Leafs when the time comes IS the big picture.
This team won't be made or broken by promoting or demoting Luke Schenn and the rest of the young guns they draft. It WILL be made by making sure that those players are locked up AS LEAFS when they're ready to go. It won't do them any good to do some other team's development for them ...
 
I don't think that sending him down to own him for an extra year is a good idea, in that he would be aware of it, and potentially resent it. If you knew that you were good enough to stay, and that they sent you down so that they could pay you less than market for an extra year, would you really want to resign when you were freed? Conversely, if they treat you with respect, wouldn't that make it more likely that you would be wanting to stay with such an organization? I know I would.
 
King Elessar said:
I didn't say I was IN FAVOUR of sending him down because of this - I said it would be a reason someone might put forward, rather than the silly, unresolvable "development here or in Junior" argument ... which I see you've put forth below. ;)


No, it wouldn't be "practice".
Unless you think the World Juniors Championships are nothing games.


So you say.
I'm not convinced.
And you're going to find yourself eminently unable to provide evidence to back up your opinion.
The development argument is all opinion.


I agree.


You'll notice, if you bothered to read my post, that I said "if he was okay with it".
Try re-reading that again, just so you understand.


That argument cuts both ways, as many Leaf fans will point out.
They've practically ruined many young players - especially defensemen - by rushing them into the grinder and playing for shit teams.
Maybe "the kind of respect and confidence he deserves" would have been to send him back to Junior after training camp, let him get another full year AS A TEAM LEADER under his belt, and play with the best U-20s in the world, both in the WHL and the World Juniors.


Yeah, I'm sorry to break this to you, but it's not gonna happen this year.
But, it SHOULD be their goal to make the playoffs in two or three years. Not just make the playoffs, but make noise in them. And Schenn should be a big part of that.


Uhhh ... making sure that players like Schenn are Leafs when the time comes IS the big picture.
This team won't be made or broken by promoting or demoting Luke Schenn and the rest of the young guns they draft. It WILL be made by making sure that those players are locked up AS LEAFS when they're ready to go. It won't do them any good to do some other team's development for them ...
?????

My post wasn't directed specifically at you or a response to you, so I'm not sure what your getting all defensive about.
And your right, ALL arguments here are just opinions, mine as well as yours.
Sit back and relax, no need to try to push anybody around.
 
Huh?
Well, since I was the ONLY ONE who posted that argument about saving a year of Schenn's services, it seemed pretty clear.
Not defensive at all - just pointing out some flaws in your post.
Not pushing anyone around at all, either.
Sheesh - don't get so defensive.
;)
But, you're right. Arguments are opinions. ... However, it is FACT that they'll be costing themselves a year of Schenn's services this year if they keep him up. Unless they sign him long-term, that's one year less of Luke Schenn in blue and white - and a year that's pretty clearly wasted as far as competitiveness goes ...
 
King Elessar said:
Huh?
Well, since I was the ONLY ONE who posted that argument about saving a year of Schenn's services, it seemed pretty clear.
Not defensive at all - just pointing out some flaws in your post.
Not pushing anyone around at all, either.
Sheesh - don't get so defensive.
;)
But, you're right. Arguments are opinions. ... However, it is FACT that they'll be costing themselves a year of Schenn's services this year if they keep him up. Unless they sign him long-term, that's one year less of Luke Schenn in blue and white - and a year that's pretty clearly wasted as far as competitiveness goes ...
You're right....
 
Last edited:
guyroch said:
Who fucking cares what Howard Berger thinks.
These media jerks don't give a flying fuck about what's right or wrong, or what's really important or not important. He's just looking to stir the pot because he's got to write about something and he's going to look for any angle to make any point at all.
He makes the stupidest, most juvenile comment I can think of, "But, history has long shown that what the Leafs say doesn’t necessarily dovetail with the premium course of action… and this could be another example."
Wow...brilliant. I mean, think how stupid this argument really is.
If the Leafs had of decided to send Schenn back to junior, that comment still applies. So really, no matter what they do they're wrong, and he's right.

"In a carefully crafted effort, the Maple Leafs have hyped and boosted rookie Luke Schenn in virtually every public forum during the first two-plus weeks of the season – building an aura around their top draft pick from last summer..." Yea, that's right, they've had their spin doctors working veeeeery carefully on this. What is so wrong about the way they feel or talk about this guy?
He's played well, he's impressed people, and he's earned a spot on the team. And the only public forums they talk about him is at media scrums and interviews, where repoters bombard them with questions about why and when and how, over and over and over. They force them to respond about him and their decisions, and all of a sudden they're "creating an aura".

"...and making it sound entirely logical to keep the 18-year-old defenseman in the NHL. " It sounds logical because it IS logical.

And by the way, he didn't get "clobbered". It took a lot of guts for a kid that age, who's not a true fighter, to stand up for one of his teammates against one of the best fighters in the league. It took a lot more guts to do that than to sit at a laptop spewing this kind of bullshit. And if Burger can't give him some credit for that, he's a shameless piece of sh*t.
 
jazzpig said:
Who fucking cares what Howard Berger thinks.
These media jerks don't give a flying fuck about what's right or wrong, or what's really important or not important. He's just looking to stir the pot because he's got to write about something and he's going to look for any angle to make any point at all.
He makes the stupidest, most juvenile comment I can think of, "But, history has long shown that what the Leafs say doesn’t necessarily dovetail with the premium course of action… and this could be another example."
Wow...brilliant. I mean, think how stupid this argument really is.
If the Leafs had of decided to send Schenn back to junior, that comment still applies. So really, no matter what they do they're wrong, and he's right.

"In a carefully crafted effort, the Maple Leafs have hyped and boosted rookie Luke Schenn in virtually every public forum during the first two-plus weeks of the season – building an aura around their top draft pick from last summer..." Yea, that's right, they've had their spin doctors working veeeeery carefully on this. What is so wrong about the way they feel or talk about this guy?
He's played well, he's impressed people, and he's earned a spot on the team. And the only public forums they talk about him is at media scrums and interviews, where repoters bombard them with questions about why and when and how, over and over and over. They force them to respond about him and their decisions, and all of a sudden they're "creating an aura".

"...and making it sound entirely logical to keep the 18-year-old defenseman in the NHL. " It sounds logical because it IS logical.

And by the way, he didn't get "clobbered". It took a lot of guts for a kid that age, who's not a true fighter, to stand up for one of his teammates against one of the best fighters in the league. It took a lot more guts to do that than to sit at a laptop spewing this kind of bullshit. And if Burger can't give him some credit for that, he's a shameless piece of sh*t.
What he said
 
21pro said:
Actually a horrible argument or reason.

Otherwise, the Penguins shoulda kept Crosby down in the Q for atleast 2 more seasons! for what... to save a few years on his contract... whatever :rolleyes: It's not saving anything. rather delaying. It's much better to have a staggering of RFA maturity from your core talent than have it occur all at the same time. With Schenn, the leafs will still get another few high picks over the next few seasons and he'll be a captain in 3-4 years.

The Pens were in a completely different situation. They had good young talent other than Crosby.

I was not saying it was a good enough reason... but it is the only decent one of all the arguments.
1. He gets the opportunity to work on his offensive game
2. NO Pressure... at least much less pressure than in Toronto
3. We won't have guys ready to annoint him the next Nik Lidstrom
4. He gets to play in the WJC
5. The Leafs get an extra year to build the team
6. If the Leafs suck, we get a higher pick
7. He does not have to suffer while coach and management figure
out what they want to do.

I am not saying... I'm just saying...
 
slowandeasy said:
The Pens were in a completely different situation. They had good young talent other than Crosby.

I was not saying it was a good enough reason... but it is the only decent one of all the arguments.
1. He gets the opportunity to work on his offensive game
2. NO Pressure... at least much less pressure than in Toronto
3. We won't have guys ready to annoint him the next Nik Lidstrom
4. He gets to play in the WJC
5. The Leafs get an extra year to build the team
6. If the Leafs suck, we get a higher pick
7. He does not have to suffer while coach and management figure
out what they want to do.

I am not saying... I'm just saying...
All very good points. One of the reasons why management wants to keep him here could be that they want to keep fans' interest up on the team, and Schenn is becoming one very popular Leaf player. Who else can be considered a fan favourite ?
 
Schenn has played well enough to stay with the Leafs. What the hell is wrong with some of these people? He's here to stay whether you like it or not.

I believe that if Berger was watching the games instead of trying to create a bit of controversy, then he wouldn't of meant what he said. I understand that he is with the Leafs all the time but is he really watching the games.

Here he is trying to say that because he does not have any points and he's a minus three, he basically sucks and is not ready for the big time. Interesting stat that popped up during the game that Joe Thornton did not receive his first point until about game 27 of his first year and he is a forward. He has turned out to be one of the best players in the NHL. I am not saying the Schenn will turn out the same way. Different positions and styles make this comparison impossible and I was only trying to say that even Joe Thronton struggled to find his first NHL point.

The kid has made some mistakes but they have been few. For a kid of 18 years old, he has shown great poise and should only get better.

Schenn has been the best defensive defenceman on the team this year and we should send him down. Does this make sense to anyone?

Berger has many good things to say but he missed the mark on this one.

The Leafs have a following larger than life and they really don't need Schenn to be a gimmick because he is popular. The fact of the matter is that he is good. Do you think that the fans will not go to the games if Schenn was sent down? There would be a huge debate and perhaps outrage but the Leafs have full capacity at the ACC every night.
 
guyroch said:
Isn't everyone in this forum expresing an opinion ... You just spent time writing a post which was your opinion ... Should we post this statement after
everyone who writes on this fourm ... I bet if Howard Berger agreed with you you would not have wrote that ...

Howard Berger who has the job of following the Leafs and is at every game , every practice , on road trips and sole job is too to eat and sleep Leafs and
I am supposed to ingore an opinion of his and just read posts on TERB and watch a game on the tube to construct my opinion .... The fact is I don't know which is the best coarse of action for this kid and am open to other opionions and only the future will determine which is the best coarse of action to take .... and even that would give us the answer cause we will
never know if sending him down would have made a better hockey player in the future ..
Guyroch, you missed my point completely. It's not whether Schenn should stay or go down. This issue has been beaten to death. It doesn't really matter much in the end does it? I have no problem with you're own reasons for why he should go down. I don't agree with everything you say but I believe you are genuine in you're reasons for thinking so.
This is not the case with Burger.
That article was completely inflammatory and misrepresentative and laced with inuendo based on nothing. You're own opinion is sound enough that this jerk off doesn't need to be introduced as some kind of witness to the truth.
Please reread my post, and you'll see it has nothing to do with arguing Schenn's case to stay.
Burger makes up bullshit and twists stuff around and completely mirepresents facts to get some kind of reaction out of his column. I don't understand how you can't see it, it's so bloody obvious.
The fact that his job is to eat and sleep Leafs means absolutely zero. Case in point, how much insightfull stuff can you write when that's all you do. Think about it, there is only so much to write about before you have to start creating drama to justify column space. He's the one that keeps fanning the fire, not the Leafs. His arguments are completely assinine. I'm not going to go through this article paragragh by paragragh to make my point because I could write pages. I wouldn't wipe my ass with his column. Just read what I wrote without the Schenn "stay or go" issue clouding things.
I'ld give anything to make these guys accountable for every stupid article, or wrong prediction, or inaccurate reporting...then we'ld see how easily they would shoot off their mouths without any consideration to the consequences.
Who gives a fuck that Schenn has zero points and is -3 after 7 games. He's 18 yrs. old, in his first year pro, on a rebuilding team, who's playing well and getting better all the time. Now he's got to worry about shift by shift critique by media wolves? Give me break.
You want intelligent, insightfull hockey analysis? Listen to Pierre Maguire or Bob Mackenzie. Everybody else is a distant second. Burger is at the bottom of the heap.