Luke Schenn

guyroch said:
Why is this a dead issue ??? I know cause the Leafs will keep him but lets not
go nuts ... He has 0 goals 0 assists and -3 but wow the way this city is talking about this kid already ... Thats why I always wonder why we always trade our 1st round pics ... This city goes nuts with excitement when ever we do pick our pic ...

Well hopefully he gets to at least experience World Jr Championships ..

Hold on a second here. The Leafs are not an offensive juggernaut by any stretch of the imagination and Schenn has definitely been one of their top defencemen. He is a defensive defenceman. To put a plus/minus figure on this type of player is crazy. Even the very best of defensive defencemen do not have the greatest plus-minus state because they are playing against the best players every night. I had my doubts about Schenn because defencemen usually take longer to mature and we know how the Leafs have ruined prior draft picks by not developing them properly. This kid is a keeper and I think that everyone is surprised by his maturity and development. I never had a doubt that he would be successful in the NHL. I was surprised at how quickly he has turned out to be quite solid.

If he is playing well with the bug club , why should he play for the World Juniors? If he wants the experience then so be it but once you are a regular in the NHL, playing in a junior tournament is most likely on the back burner.

I think that the World Junior tournament is great but he looks good as an NHL player at the moment and if I was Cliff, I wouldn't let him go and risk injury elsewhere.
 
guyroch said:
Okay I would like him to play for the Jrs and you wouldn't ... Personal reference thats it ... Risk injury ??? Management has already said playoffs isn't teams objective this year and so if he gets hurt what will that mean ???
Finishing 15th instead of 12th ..

Why should he play ??? It is in Canada ( Ottawa ) so Jet lag won't be a issue but like I said I would like him to play cause I think the experience will out weight a 3 week Leaf scehdule of games ...

Again I say .. To be one of the top Leaf defenseman isn't a major medal of honour ... The Leafs are playing great team defense and that reflects on the shots on goal in the first 10 games of the season ...

Let me get this straight ... I am not bashing Schenn and won't get into a debate that he has looked good but lets
put things into perpective ... I am just stating facts ... 0 goals and 0 assists and -3 ( On a team team that is playing
good defense ) and so it shouldn't be a black and white issue that he should stay ...

I would like to play in the Junior tournament as well but you are missing the point. I try and see the big picture and if he does get injured in the tournament then what? The Leafs defence is quite good and like I said before it is the offence that is the major problem.

I really don't think people watch the games anymore. I do and I have my own take on it. I have been around all of the major sports my entire life and I am telling you that Schenn is that good. He will not be sent back down.
Here you are going on about the stats again. He is a defensive defenceman and so he is a minus 3. Big deal. Stamkos doesn't have any points and he is supposed to be all firepower so what's your point?

Again you clearly don't understand that the defence is the strong point of this club and even though you think it's not worthy of anything, there are players capable of playing in this league and are not seeing regular time on the Leafs blue line. Do you care to explain? I will explain my side. The Leafs are quite deep in the defensive side of things and to be one of the better defencemen on the team is not easy. Especially for someone that's 18 years old.

BTW, did you watch the game on Saturday? The Leafs were leading 3-2 with one minute left to play in the third period and Schenn was out there. Wilson trusts the kid. Apparently he is not good enough for you. You make me laugh. You are contradicting yourself in terms of stats and if he should stay. Please make sense of this.
 
guyroch said:
Again I say ... I am not going into a debate that will result in me stating negatives of Schenn ... Thats not why I posted my thread .... Holly shit .. I have to read stuff like ( I guess he is not good enough for you ) ... I give up ... All I said their are pros and cons in him staying and him going and was not doing it shit on the Kid .... There are 3 young defenseman who are healthy scratches last game and so how is that development going ??? Forget it ...

Don't debate what you don't know. Of course there are pros and cons with everything and what I am saying is that kid deserves to stay with the big club and maybe instead of sending him to the World Juniors, give another kid a chance to experience it.

Obviously, the other three healthy scratches were Ian White (yet to play this year and not the first time he has been scrached), Coliacovo who I happen to like but there is no room for him at the moment and Frogren who has played relatively well and is quite physical. Jeff Finger came back into the lineup so at the moment the defence corps is healthy and there is no room for the three mentioned. They were not going to sit Finger out any longer since he is getting paid huge dollars.

Forgotten.
 
guyroch said:
That nice .... I won't stoop to that level ... I hope I don't do that in any my posts ... Go Schenn Go !!! I won't insult you and I am a Leaf fan but if the Leafs think something is a good idea then I have come to the conclusion that
more times then not it isn't ...

I didn't mean anything by it because you usually have very informative posts and I enjoy reading them.

My apologies.

You are questioning if he should be here based on stats? Give me a break.
Watch the kid play. He is pretty damn good man, especially for an 18 year old. Very composed.
 
I agree with you guyroch. Schenn is playing very well. For an 18 year old kid to be playing against the Sens down 1 goal with one minute left in the third period means Wilson trusts the kid. He's not going anywhere. I would be shocked if he was moved and I think that many people would be asking for Wilson's head.
 
lawyerman said:
To put a plus/minus figure on this type of player is crazy. Even the very best of defensive defencemen do not have the greatest plus-minus state because they are playing against the best players every night. I had my doubts about Schenn because defencemen usually take longer to mature and we know how the Leafs have ruined prior draft picks by not developing them properly. This kid is a keeper and I think that everyone is surprised by his maturity and development. I never had a doubt that he would be successful in the NHL. I was surprised at how quickly he has turned out to be quite solid.

If he is playing well with the big club , why should he play for the World Juniors? If he wants the experience then so be it but once you are a regular in the NHL, playing in a junior tournament is most likely on the back burner.

I think that the World Junior tournament is great but he looks good as an NHL player at the moment and if I was Cliff, I wouldn't let him go and risk injury elsewhere.

Nik Lidstrom has a +385 career... That is a freak!!!!!.. I agree with you that its' difficult to have really great +/- numbers if you are playing against the other team's top line, AND you are not on the Powerplay, AND if you are killing penalties...


The only thing that I think needs to be done is that coaches and management and PR for the Leafs keep the expectations in check. Unfortunately, Wilson (the last guy I expected it from) already publicly announced that he has been the team's best defenceman (I think he added something like "in our own zone" ).

As I said, let's keep it in check... Schenn has played 9? games.
 
I was talking to you, obviously. :rolleyes:

"I agree with you that its' difficult to have really great +/- numbers if you are playing against the other team's top line, AND you are not on the Powerplay, AND if you are killing penalties... "
If this isn't your quote, feel free to not be offended by my post.
 
King Elessar said:
I was talking to you, obviously. :rolleyes:

"I agree with you that its' difficult to have really great +/- numbers if you are playing against the other team's top line, AND you are not on the Powerplay, AND if you are killing penalties... "
If this isn't your quote, feel free to not be offended by my post.

This is not the first time I have an encountered a smartass. This isn't my post. I don't want to insult you but who the hell are you anyway?
 
guyroch said:
Oh yea it helps your +/- if your goalie isn't crap also ... slowandeasy is the one who made the point about powerplays ... King Elessar corrected the post and so why is name calling going on ???
No idea, dude. I got called a smartass and asked to give my credentials. lol

Yes, lots of things affect plus-minus - most importantly, your linemates. Since your goaltender is ALWAYS playing at the same time as you are, and since his play is more important than any other single player on the ice with you, it definitely helps to have a good goaltender.
 
My apologies about jumping on your back KE.

Your post was right after mine so I thought you were questioning something I said. I didn't mean any harm.
 
I just believe that Schenn is worthy of staying with the big club that's all.

Like I said before, Luke will need to work on his speed and he has taken a couple of penalties because of it.

His positioning is very good.

He almost reminds me of a Rod Langway. Rod had a great plus minus when he was with the Habs but when he went to the Caps, it fell quite drastically.

He was good with Montreal and even better with Washington. Back in the day, opposing forwards needed to go through Langway and Scott Stevens.
That's a tough defensive pair.
 
I think he's worthy of staying with the big club, too. I don't think there's too much doubt about it.

I'm not sure that arguments revolving around his development whether we keep him or send him down are worth much. The main point to me would be - do we really want to waste one of his guaranteed-Leafs years THIS year?
I'm not sure. I'm pretty sure, on the other hand, that the Leafs aren't going anywhere this year.

I'd probably send him down, just to let him play in the World Juniors again, and tell him he's coming back up immediately after that. As long as he was good with that, he'd be gone, for now. The Leafs, fwiw, have a glut of semi-useful defensemen, now that Finger's back.
 
Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Ron Wilson confirmed Monday that rookie defenceman Luke Schenn will remain with club for the remainder of the 2008-09 season.

“I sat down with him a little while ago and told him he is staying,” Wilson told the Globe and Mail following the team’s practice. “We are in the process of notifying his junior team.”

The statement from Wilson comes just one game before the club needed to decide whether to keep the 18-year-old talented blueliner with the team or send him back to his junior team – the Kelowna Rockets of the Western Hockey League.

According to Wilson, Schenn’s play over the course of Toronto’s first eight regular season contests has proven he can play at the NHL level.

“He is certainly in our top four [defencemen],” Wilson told the Globe and Mail. “He's been our best defenceman defensively in almost every game. He makes the best outlet pass on our team; he will take a hit to make a play.”

Schenn will play in his ninth professional game when the Leafs host the Tampa Bay Lightning at Air Canada Centre on Tuesday (7:30 p.m.)
 
Yeah, the man whose opinion counts most (Fletcher) already made it clear that he wasn't going anywhere.
That fight with the fuckstick Neil certainly didn't hurt his case. ;)
 
King Elessar said:
1. Who the fuck said it was your post? Why did you feel like you had to respond?

2. Who the fuck are you?

Yes.. who does he think he is the king???

I had always that it was a stupid statistic if you were rewarded for being on the PP, and penalized for being on the PK.

That's why you are THE KING...
 
King Elessar said:
The main point to me would be - do we really want to waste one of his guaranteed-Leafs years THIS year?

This might be a stupid question, but can you clarify what the implications of this comment are?