Luke Schenn

One plus that Schenn has...

Insidious Von said:
The Leafs have never been any good at developing young talent. Sure Schenn will learn much from Ron Wilson, let's hope he doesn't follow in Gary Nylund and Al Iafrate's footsteps. And as for the culture of losing, does it really make a difference? Schenn could become the Carl Crawford of hockey. Crawford toiled in futile obscurity with the Tampa Bay Rays for seven years...and look where he is now!



...at least the coach is a bonafide, upper tier NHL coach. I was looking at who the coaches were during Nylund's tenure with the Leafs..Mike Nykoluk, Dan Maloney and John Brophy...not exactly the bright lights of the coaching fraternity..Iafrate had Brophy and Doug Carpenter. My guess is that Schenn has benefited more from Wilson's teaching in the preseason and 5 games than Nylund and Iafrate benefited from any of the has beens thy had for coaches


N2G
 
ahhhh 21pro, i would not say ron wilson knows how to get the best out of his star players.

in san jose, joe thornton racked up alot of points, which is nice, but he stopped being a goal scorer, going to the net, and became strictly a periphal player. we won't mention his playoff stats and lack of success. with his size and shot, he should be a power forward scoring many goals, driving the net and causing havoc.

patrick marleau has never realized his vast potential under ron wilson as well. he regressed badly last year.

jonathan cheechoo has seen his productivity suffer three years straight.

RW had some promising players in michalek, bernier, pavelski, clowe, erhoff and carle, but they have all not achieved much, so far in their careers. only michalek has had a little success at this point.

shall we touch the very dissappointing playoff runs the sharks have had the last 4 years running? in san jose, he had a team capable of winning it all, but never did it.

ron wilson is a good coach, but not great.


as for schenn, he has been mightily impressive. i don't think sending him back to junior hockey does him any good anymore. he is on a steep learning curve, and is already close to being the leafs best defensive blueliner. caution though, it is early, and the grind of the season will affect him. in junior, he was a man amongst the boys, but now in the NHL, a young man against grown men, night in, night out.

Plyrs99
 
some great criticism plyrs... but this is my considerations:

Ron Wilson got Joe Thornton, Jonathan Cheechoo, Joe Juneau and others (Kyle McLaren, M-A Vlasic, Evgeni Nabakov) into their best playing days of their careers.

playoffs are another specimen. San Jose never had thorough leadership in the post season like Detroit 08, Anaheim 07, Carolina 06, or Tampa Bay ... so what can be said of RW in the post season under your logic should be applied to most other coaches, which some of them are termed the greatest to have ever coached the game. I don't think I've ever saw an NHL coach have as consistent of a record of creating massive improvements in player development as with RW... another being Lindy Ruff. but, really- there aren't many else out there.

and another thing that I feel as important consideration is that: It's not the coach that sacrifices his body in the post season. that's where boys are expected to play like men at war. sorry, but I'll never blame the coach for that. Joe Thornton had trouble in post season even as a jr. and in Boston. the coach can only do so much as for post-season motivation. OTHERWISE, the consistent league's best coach would win the Stanley Cup every year. Never happens.

but, back to Luke Schenn. my sole argument is that Schenn is much better playing under Ron Wilson for this season than he would be with his alternatives. 1. under Paul Maurice, had Leafs management not made a change or 2. under Ryan Huska (coach of his jr. team)
 
21pro, when it comes to "jumbo" joe, the boston brass knew that joe was not a guy who could lead the team all the way, that is why they got rid of him. they obviously did not get fair value for him, but that is another topic.

as for your comment about thorough leadership, of the last four stanley cup winners, coaching was a small part of it. teams like detroit, anaheim and carolina all had strong leadership from within the team. detroit had the veteran chris chelios and all-star niklas lidstrom from the back end, with guys like draper and maltby up front providing strong leadership. carolina had veterans like wesley and brind'amour, while anaheim had scotty neidermayer and chris pronger. i would say that tampa bay did not have great leadership, but rode incredible performances from khabibulin and richards all the way. all i am saying, is that coaching is not always the main reason teams win. the great teams all have veteran savvy and leadership, with the manager/coach just basically keeping the team focused.

i will give you that ron wilson does have a very credible record of developing talent. having said that, there are coaches who are great with teams under no pressure to win, with a young nucleus in a rebuilding phase. these guys only take a team so far. jacques martin is a prime example, and i would put ron wilson in there as well. then you have coaches who have the right temperament to deal with a veteran team built to win. mike babcock is one such guy.

you are right too, that a coach is not on the ice, so the players have to carry the load in the playoffs. but it is a coach's priority to know each player on his team, and what makes them tick, how to poke and prod them to their highest levels. the coaching part, all the x's and o's, the systems and gimmicks, get hammered home during the season. in the playoffs, the coach has to take all that knowledge from the season, and put it to his best use. he has seen all his players in all situations, and has to know where and when to place and play each player to maximize their best results.

schenn played another good game tonite against the ducks.

Plyrs99
 
21pro said:
19 minutes to 25 minutes per game is BIG TIME minutes for a rookie Defenceman- the hardest position to learn in the NHL.



...so help me out slowandeasy- I have a 16 year old on my jr A squad that will probably be a 1st round NHL pick in 2 years. he is one of my most talented players and one of the tops in Canada for his age. my team is rebuilding from last year where a lot of vet's have graduated onto college, etc... so, effectively I'm in the same situation as Ron Wilson (albeit quite a few leagues south of him)... anyways, let's say I send him back to minor midget... do you really think he'll come back a better player next season than what he can by staying with my team, learning the jr A systems and building leadership and rapport with his teammates that he is soon going to lead?

I have not got a clue of what you are trying to say regarding Luke Schenn. On one hand you seem to be saying that he should stay in the NHL, and on the other you SEEM to make a case for the fact that D-men take longer to develop, and should spend more time in the minors/junior...


As far as your 16 year old is concerned, there are similarities but there are big differences as well... The first is the physical development of the 16 year old, the second is his mental/psychological development.

Lastly, if a kid has the talent to play at a certain level, and the desire to play at that level then it is usually best for him to play at that level.

RE: Schenn... He has the talent and the should be playing with the Leafs...
However, it is most important that they manage expectations for this young
That would be the same thing for your 16 year old.. most often, coaches
rely too much on their "stud" players. The result is either a guy who
develops an overly exaggerated opinion of his value, or loses his confidence
when the shit hits the fan...
 
I fully agree with every comment you've made.

with regards to the confusion... partly that is due to the fact that I flip sides and post the 'devil's advocate' response to certain arguments. frankly- my opinion is that I don't care where Schenn plays this year. If I was GM I'd send him back to save an extra year on his entry level contract... but, this being Toronto- cash flow is not a problem, salary cap is... so whatever happens, happens. If I was Coach, I'd keep him up and mold him into the player I want him to become.
 
In true democracy manner, have we asked Schenn whether he wants to stay or go back to Kelona? Has anybody cared about how he feels and what he thinks is best for himself? Man, I'm disappointed in how insensitive we've all become!!!

Kidding aside, he has been Leafs' steadiest defensive defenseman so far and seemed capable of playing against the league's top lines. I think he should stay.
 
He clearly said he wants to stay In Toronto many times.

now, go back to being sensitive with sensitive issues like tree hugging iam...
 
21pro said:
He clearly said he wants to stay In Toronto many times.

now, go back to being sensitive with sensitive issues like tree hugging iam...

Woop, he did? So he should stay as he wishes, and I'll go back to tree hugging .... :p
 
There is no doubt in my mind that Schenn will be a solid NHLer. The only problem that I see him having is his lack of speed but he is only 18 and should improve. I don't believe we will see much of an offensive upside but I think he will be very good under Wilson's guidance.
 
iam0234 said:
Woop, he did? So he should stay as he wishes, and I'll go back to tree hugging .... :p
glad you can take my jokes. with all of the global financial crisis news, it seems somehow the environment has been shoved under a rug.

I'd join you in the tree hugging as I am a fan of composite sticks, however, I'm going to heat my house with wood fire this year.
 
Schenn set the tone for the game last night. He wasted no time slugging it out with Neil. I did not give a damn what happened after that. Schenn has a nose for doing the right things to motivate his team. I am ready to pin the "C" on this kid...

Seriously, he has shown the kind of heart to be a leader. But I am afraid that he is getting too much of a load so early in the year, and they are expecting too much of him. If he is going to stay up, they need to carefully manage his minutes.
 
Paul Hunter column in Star Saturday re how many recent defencemen drafted into the NHL in one of top ten draft slots from 1987 to 2006.

Of 57 under considration 30 of them had played at least 30 NHL games by the end of second year after their draft year.

http://www.thestar.com/Sports/Hockey/article/524471
 
slowandeasy said:
Schenn set the tone for the game last night. He wasted no time slugging it out with Neil.
really? wow. didn't catch much hockey tonight. had a game instead. i'll have to look for the video footage for that one. No D-man on the leafs woulda went with Neil over the past 5 years except 1/2 timer D/Forward Wade Belak.

... so less than 50% of D-men drafted in the top ten picks... wow. that's hardly any over such a long period.

what that stat says is that even if you are a top 10 draft pick and a defensemen, the odds are still against you making the NHL even 2 years after your draft year.
 
I think Mr. Schenn was very lucky to come out alive, in that fight tonight.
He was starting to get worked by Neil, so he turtled and let the refs break it up.

It was your typical new NHL mentality, why the fight started in the first place.
Someone gets hit, so a teamate dances with the guy throwing the hit.

These guys are such pussies, learn to take a fucking hit, it's part of the game.



BTW this is my favorite hit of all time.
 
rayfinkel said:
I think Mr. Schenn was very lucky to come out alive, in that fight tonight.
He was starting to get worked by Neil, so he turtled and let the refs break it up.

It was your typical new NHL mentality, why the fight started in the first place.
Someone gets hit, so a teamate dances with the guy throwing the hit.

These guys are such pussies, learn to take a fucking hit, it's part of the game.



BTW this is my favorite hit of all time.

I agree that Schenn was lucky to come out alive in that fight but he must be given credit for sticking up for a teammate.

If you watched the play, Neil was trying to take Stajan's knee out. That's a dirty play, don't you think? The Leafs do not have a true enforcer so Schenn gave it a try and will probably think twice about doing something like that again. He should have waited for Hollweg or Mayers to dance with Neil but he was caught up in the moment which is understandable.

this is one of my favourite hits if not my favourite
 
rayfinkel said:
I think Mr. Schenn was very lucky to come out alive, in that fight tonight. He was starting to get worked by Neil, so he turtled and let the refs break it up.

I thought Shenn handled himself well considering it was Neil he tangled with. If I'm not mistaken, he had Neil down (almost on his knees) first for a split second or so but softened up mercifully that let Neil bounced back.

In any event, it is the thought and bravery to stick up with your team-mates that count. Hope the rest of Leafs could learn from this 18 year old rookie - particular the bigger guys, like Pony, Kabina, etc ....

I like the direction the Leafs are going.
 
rayfinkel said:
I think Mr. Schenn was very lucky to come out alive, in that fight tonight.
He was starting to get worked by Neil, so he turtled and let the refs break it up.

It was your typical new NHL mentality, why the fight started in the first place.
Someone gets hit, so a teamate dances with the guy throwing the hit.

These guys are such pussies, learn to take a fucking hit, it's part of the game.

Make up your mind... you say that players should be able to take a hit, and not be such pussies... then you say that Schenn was lucky to come out alive... what he can't take a hit, he has never been in a fight??

Neil won the fight, but Schenn held his own. He is showing the grit that is needed on this team. In less than 10 games, he has shown me
more than Darcy "heart and soul" Tucker, and more leadership than Mats.

Jason Blake finally crashed the net. Kubina played alright, Grabovski got the monkey off his back and Vesa did well. The powerplay even got a goal.

If the Leafs continue to play with this kind of toughness, they will be alright.
 
Last edited:
lawyerman said:
I agree that Schenn was lucky to come out alive in that fight but he must be given credit for sticking up for a teammate.

If you watched the play, Neil was trying to take Stajan's knee out. That's a dirty play, don't you think? The Leafs do not have a true enforcer so Schenn gave it a try and will probably think twice about doing something like that again. He should have waited for Hollweg or Mayers to dance with Neil but he was caught up in the moment which is understandable.

Definitely a serious cheap shot.
And right in front of the ref, and he didn't call it. Didn't see the whole game but they let some blatant open ice trips and and a headshot go without a call.
Brutal reffing last night.
On the bright side, Schenn is way beyond 18 yrs old.
And he is way beyond sending back to the minors. That's a dead issue.