19 minutes to 25 minutes per game is BIG TIME minutes for a rookie Defenceman- the hardest position to learn in the NHL.
slowandeasy said:
I disagree... the key is not to force too much on him. It's silly to expect or even tell him that he is one of the best defencemen on the team.
Practice and being around NHL players is the best thing for him... Telling people that he is one of your top 4 defenceman is the WRONG thing to do.
Perhaps this is the reason other people believe that it is best to send him back to the WHL. That would keep the expectations from running too high.
...so help me out slowandeasy- I have a 16 year old on my jr A squad that will probably be a 1st round NHL pick in 2 years. he is one of my most talented players and one of the tops in Canada for his age. my team is rebuilding from last year where a lot of vet's have graduated onto college, etc... so, effectively I'm in the same situation as Ron Wilson (albeit quite a few leagues south of him)... anyways, let's say I send him back to minor midget... do you really think he'll come back a better player next season than what he can by staying with my team, learning the jr A systems and building leadership and rapport with his teammates that he is soon going to lead?
if anything Stamkos should be sent back to Sarnia, not Schenn.
examples of recent 1st round pick NHL players sent back to juniors:
Angelo Esposito - in minors still today and a 2007 pick
Bobby Ryan - in minors still and a 2005 pick
Benoit Pouliot - minnesota NHL now, but a 2005 pick
Gilbert Brule - in minors still today and also a 2005 pick
Derek Brassard - Columbus NHL now, but a 2006 pick
Schenn's draft position comparables:
Karl Alzner - drafted 5th overall 2007... went back to jr. now in the AHL
Tomas Hickey - drafted 4th overall in 2007... went back to jr. and is now in the AHL
imo- Schenn is already better than both of these players^^^
D men that made the jump in their draft year.... is very, very rare.
(remember all of Drew Doughty, Alex Pietrangelo, Zach Bogosian, and Luke Schenn are
all still in the NHL) it would be an abnormality if any of these make the NHL clean w/o AHL experience. even Scott Niedermayer went back to junior.
Chris Pronger is the only one defenceman I can think of without pulling up any stats that has made a clean jump to NHL and never got sent back to jr or to the minors.
goes against my own thoughts