Luke Schenn

That's cool MojoRisin.

I really like this kid and he should be a force in the NHL for years to come.
I'm just saying that he needs more seasoning. He needs to improve his skating.
 
21pro said:
no problem. happens all the time. i eat my words alot, too. so is life.

guess it was a good call this time. Still I dont agree with you or the leafs that this is a good idea. Time will tell. Maybe Ill eat my words this time ;)
 
We will see what happens. They can play him for the first 9 games of the season and then send him down but I'm not sure what good that is going to do.

Like I said before, I believe that this kid is a gem and his confidence can be ruined quickly playing for a team like the Leafs. He does seem like he has a great head on his shoulders and should succeed. I hope for the best for him.
 
lawyerman said:
They can play him for the first 9 games of the season and then send him down but I'm not sure what good that is going to do.

not much good ever comes from sending a kid back to junior... to the AHL, yes- a player can perfect his game there, but these so-called toronto hockey experts (the 'respected' media guys included) you hear call in on the radio and by the water cooler that think he's somehow going to get better from playin another year of junior don't know what they are talking about.

he's ready for the next step. maybe not to dominate at that next step, but atleast ready to learn that next step. that won't come from anymore junior experience. he's already done it all in the juniors.
 
guyroch said:
I would room him up with Carlo Colaiacovo ...

no no no no no Carlo would be bound to trip over him in the hotel room ripping both their knees apart in the process. Keep that boy away from the walking emergency room. ;)
 
I think that it's great that he made the team and I do have pretty high expectations from him (in the future).

I just pray that they don't send him down after 9 games into the season and they play head games with him.
 
guyroch- you are 100% spot on in that he needs a co-player mentor.

i think Kaberle could do that for him. but, i'd much prefer it was someone like Adam Foote or Niklas Lidstrom, LOL. even a Darian Hatcher or Darryl Sydor ... they don't have to be all-stars, just experienced players that are genuinely good leaders.

however, I still think the chance is still present that he goes back to junior after his 9 games... because of other reasons than his development. i think it's stupid to sign him to an entry level and then send him back- but it does happen.

about his skill... yes, you are starting to see his slip-ups on inexperienced mistakes... but isn't Ron Wilson the best coach he can have right now? also, as are the present of the small slip-ups you are also starting to see how reliable he is and how cool under pressure he is. he handles the league's top talent very, very well.

his blood seems to run ice cold under pressure. i'll take that in a defenceman any day. that is the rarest of defensive talent there is. skills can be built, but nerves have more to do with something you can't change in somebody. strong, calm nerves is what allows a player to work through his own booing crowd. Sundin did this very well, as for McCabe and others??

I'm seeing more in Schenn now than ever. I expect him to be every bit a better defenceman than both Jack and Eric Johnson, Shea Weber and maybe Duncan Keith. Those are all expected future all-stars. Schenn is perhaps the greatest young defenceman prospect in the entire eastern conference right now.
 
guyroch said:
I have kind of changed my stance with this Kid and agree with 21pro .. If he is a student of the game he can learn a lot from Toronto's coaching staff and from the vetern defenseman we have on this Roster ... Although 21pro you would have to agree that everyone should be eveluated differently and not be painted with the same brush ... Not all players will be ruined by staying and learning on the Job but some can be ruined ... Toronto's managment team
has to determine which catergory this player falls into ..

I would room him up with Carlo Colaiacovo ... He was a 1st rounder with high expectations and can maybe share his experiences ..

What I can never understand is how people can expect him to develop in the WHL better than he could develop in Toronto. If anything the Leafs have the budget and resources here to help him develop. He can practice everyday against NHL caliber players and receive NHL coaching, training and assistance.
 
slowandeasy said:
What I can never understand is how people can expect him to develop in the WHL better than he could develop in Toronto. If anything the Leafs have the budget and resources here to help him develop. He can practice everyday against NHL caliber players and receive NHL coaching, training and assistance.

I believe that Leaf fans really want a good kid like Schenn not to fail because they have drafted miserably in the past and have ruined careers by throwing these kids to the wolves. I don't believe there is any doubt in the hockey world that he can play in the NHL. Personally, I want him to exceed my expectations.
 
21pro said:
better be careful... did you know that most players that go back to the juniors digress? truth is, very few improve with another season of junior (goalies excluded).
At 18?! Most players "digress"? (I think you mean REgress, but whatever.)
Bullshit.
Everyone should KNOW this is bullshit, because the vast majority of NHL players are in Junior at 18.
 
King Elessar said:
Everyone should KNOW this is bullshit, because the vast majority of NHL players are in Junior at 18.

I believe that he is referring specifically to high draft choices who have a shot at making an NHL roster but are returned to their junior teams.

Most players who reach a certain level have high expectations for themselves. Once they reach a certain level and feel that they are capable of playing at a higher level, they HATE going back to the lower level.

It seems to me that Schenn has proven that he is capable of playing in the NHL. I don't have the background to say that most players who return to their Junior teams regress. But I do believe that it would be a mistake to return Schenn to the WHL. However, he definitely should be allowed to pay in the World Junior Championships.
 
Actually, I think Schenn is best served by being on the big club - as are most players of his calibre - as long as he gets regular ice-time.
 
in that case, yes. you are correct King. since he is too young to go to the AHL, if he doesn't get played, then yes, put him back in the jr's...

but I still hold the impression that he's one of the Leafs best defencemen RIGHT NOW!
 
terbul said:
It boils down to which side of the trade-off do you think is more important. NHL level coaching and practice with limited game ice time, or AHL (or other) coaching and practice with lots of game ice time.

What's better to develop a young player?

Great boiling down of the facts...

Once you put it that way, the choice should be obvious right?

NO? Ok.. its only obvious to me then :)

Having a young guy at the NHL level is best. He gets to practice and train with the pros. Hopefully, the coaches, GM, trainers, and players will help him get used to the pressure and expectations. Limited ice time is actually a bonus because you don't want to throw him in the fire to burn.
Practice is where you learn, and improve..
 
21pro said:
in that case, yes. you are correct King. since he is too young to go to the AHL, if he doesn't get played, then yes, put him back in the jr's...

but I still hold the impression that he's one of the Leafs best defencemen RIGHT NOW!

I disagree... the key is not to force too much on him. It's silly to expect or even tell him that he is one of the best defencemen on the team.

Practice and being around NHL players is the best thing for him... Telling people that he is one of your top 4 defenceman is the WRONG thing to do.

Perhaps this is the reason other people believe that it is best to send him back to the WHL. That would keep the expectations from running too high.
 
I don't see Schenn..

...getting limited ice time if he stays with the Leafs...he was just short of 20 mins in game #1. Other than being outmuscled and outpositioned by Holmstrom on the Wings 2nd goal (and that is not a crime...many defensemen have failed to handle this guy...in fact most can't), he played very well, smart passes, no panic in his game...I'm really coming around on this guy...don't let age be the determining factor..if he's ready for the big time...let him play...


N2G
 
19 minutes to 25 minutes per game is BIG TIME minutes for a rookie Defenceman- the hardest position to learn in the NHL.

slowandeasy said:
I disagree... the key is not to force too much on him. It's silly to expect or even tell him that he is one of the best defencemen on the team.

Practice and being around NHL players is the best thing for him... Telling people that he is one of your top 4 defenceman is the WRONG thing to do.

Perhaps this is the reason other people believe that it is best to send him back to the WHL. That would keep the expectations from running too high.

...so help me out slowandeasy- I have a 16 year old on my jr A squad that will probably be a 1st round NHL pick in 2 years. he is one of my most talented players and one of the tops in Canada for his age. my team is rebuilding from last year where a lot of vet's have graduated onto college, etc... so, effectively I'm in the same situation as Ron Wilson (albeit quite a few leagues south of him)... anyways, let's say I send him back to minor midget... do you really think he'll come back a better player next season than what he can by staying with my team, learning the jr A systems and building leadership and rapport with his teammates that he is soon going to lead?

if anything Stamkos should be sent back to Sarnia, not Schenn.

examples of recent 1st round pick NHL players sent back to juniors:

Angelo Esposito - in minors still today and a 2007 pick
Bobby Ryan - in minors still and a 2005 pick
Benoit Pouliot - minnesota NHL now, but a 2005 pick
Gilbert Brule - in minors still today and also a 2005 pick
Derek Brassard - Columbus NHL now, but a 2006 pick

Schenn's draft position comparables:
Karl Alzner - drafted 5th overall 2007... went back to jr. now in the AHL
Tomas Hickey - drafted 4th overall in 2007... went back to jr. and is now in the AHL
imo- Schenn is already better than both of these players^^^

D men that made the jump in their draft year.... is very, very rare.
(remember all of Drew Doughty, Alex Pietrangelo, Zach Bogosian, and Luke Schenn are all still in the NHL) it would be an abnormality if any of these make the NHL clean w/o AHL experience. even Scott Niedermayer went back to junior.

Chris Pronger is the only one defenceman I can think of without pulling up any stats that has made a clean jump to NHL and never got sent back to jr or to the minors.

goes against my own thoughts
 
how bad the rest of the team is no doubt.

but, Schenn can't get Ron Wilson type mentorship and coaching in the OHL. Ron will have him an all-star if he's allowed to have him learn 'his way' which, just by RW being Ron Wilson, is a way that will lead to many, many wins. coach Wilson is a great mentor and hockey brain. he knows how to bring out the best in his star players and it seems that Schenn has clearly found a spot under RW's wing.

gotta go. i'll check in after 11pm.
 
The Leafs have never been any good at developing young talent. Sure Schenn will learn much from Ron Wilson, let's hope he doesn't follow in Gary Nylund and Al Iafrate's footsteps. And as for the culture of losing, does it really make a difference? Schenn could become the Carl Crawford of hockey. Crawford toiled in futile obscurity with the Tampa Bay Rays for seven years...and look where he is now!