Lincoln

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
With the release of the movie "Lincoln", would anyone be interested in having a calm, rational, polite, unemotional and unbiased discussion of the man, his times and his legacy?
 
In 1860, the population of the North was 23 million, the South 5 million plus 3.5 million slaves.

Can't blame some of you guys for dodging such a sensitive subject.
 
With the release of the movie "Lincoln", would anyone be interested in having a calm, rational, polite, unemotional and unbiased discussion of the man, his times and his legacy?

Sorry I never met him :)
 
Haven't seen the movie yet. How many vampires does he kill in this one?
 
Actually the newly released movie starring Daniel Day Lewis is getting pretty decent reviews and I probably will lay out the cash for the theatre.

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/lincoln_2011/

The only thing I worry about is Spielberg pulling a Spielberg and making the characters out to be much more than they ever were.

For example, the "Mrs Bixby Letter" scene from "Saving Private Ryan"

No way it ever happened, no way any General in the US army thought of Mrs. Bixby, no way he just happened to have the book there, no way he knew the words by heart, etc. Typical Spielberg getting all misty-eyed romantic on the audience.
 
With the release of the movie "Lincoln", would anyone be interested in having a calm, rational, polite, unemotional and unbiased discussion of the man, his times and his legacy?

Well there has been over 1500 books wrote about the man . Quite a lot of reading there .

Obama used Lincolns' bible to be sworn in as President back in 2008 .
 
Mr. Lincoln (a Republican) won the 1860 presidential election with 1,865,593 votes. His Democrat challenger, Stephen A. Douglas, won 1,382,713 votes and his other Democrat challenger, John C. Breckinridge, won 848,356 votes.

Quote from President Lincoln: "My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and it is not to either save or to destroy slavery."
 
Well there has been over 1500 books wrote about the man .
That is a lot of reading. Do they address the following two key questions:
1) Was the Civil War and almost 700,000 deaths avoidable?
2) Did the President have a plan to integrate the freed slaves into American society? What I have read is that the freed slaves were without homes and without visible means of support because all the plantations had been destroyed.
 
Normal people aren't generally interested in history. They would much rather watch a movie about vampires, zombies and/or werewolves.

... or British M5 agents with a license to kill. What should I see tonight Rock? 007 or Lincoln? I like both genres and leading actors, although DDL is an exceptional actor.
 
The only thing I worry about is Spielberg pulling a Spielberg and making the characters out to be much more than they ever were.

For example, the "Mrs Bixby Letter" scene from "Saving Private Ryan"

No way it ever happened, no way any General in the US army thought of Mrs. Bixby, no way he just happened to have the book there, no way he knew the words by heart, etc. Typical Spielberg getting all misty-eyed romantic on the audience.
Secretary of State and General of the Army George Catlett Marshall, Jr. (U.S. Army Chief of Staff during World War II) was a very well read man.


The Bixby Letter together with the Gettysburg Address and the Farewell Address are regarded as the finest of Lincoln's short works.
 
I just saw the movie, not sure what I was expecting but I didn't really enjoy it that much.

Spoiler Alert !!

Lincoln is assassinated at the end of the movie.
 
I just saw the movie, not sure what I was expecting but I didn't really enjoy it that much.
The author Eric Foner said the movie is "inadequate" in its portrayal of Lincoln but he also said you can't do Lincoln justice in just 2 hours. Maybe that Ken Burns guy can do an 8 hour documentary on Lincoln like he did with the Civil War and Baseball.