Light rapid transit vs subway

LRT vs subway

  • more LRT

    Votes: 6 7.0%
  • more Subway

    Votes: 60 69.8%
  • combination

    Votes: 20 23.3%
  • other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    86
You might be right about the LRT, but if there was a thorough, professional, and independent study outlining the methodology, costs weighed, and other factors in a report that is accessible to the public, I'm not aware of it.

You are right about Ford who wants subways (but of course has made no feasible plan to fund the expansion of it). It is his intransigence (and lack of faith on my part in the rest of City Council in mustering a united front to force through the issue) which leads me to be pessimistic about whether anything will ever be actually built.

Again, am I wrong to be so pessimistic?

yes you are


LRT is runnung downtown and on St Clair WEST and the LRT TUNNEL is being built on eglinton

the York subway is being built and downtown train station is being refurbished to accomodate added transit

what is beng debated is future LRT vs subway
 
The operative question is not, "What do you want?, because that produces useless answers. "What will you pay for?" is the only useful question. Surely, of all people, the pooners on TERB should be familiar with that reality.

Why are we now on the third page of 'discussing' the equivalent of getting free sex?
 
The operative question is not, "What do you want?, because that produces useless answers. "What will you pay for?" is the only useful question. Surely, of all people, the pooners on TERB should be familiar with that reality.

Why are we now on the third page of 'discussing' the equivalent of getting free sex?
that's a great way to put it. using the same analogy, why are we asking my neighbour to pay for my wife's sex toys (i.e.: car drivers pay for ttc)?
 
The operative question is not, "What do you want?, because that produces useless answers. "What will you pay for?" is the only useful question. Surely, of all people, the pooners on TERB should be familiar with that reality.

Why are we now on the third page of 'discussing' the equivalent of getting free sex?

so what this wrong wth this idea ?


the government prints the monies in the form of credits

because the subways add to the GNP inflaton is minimal

IE greatest inflation happens when the government prints monies then hands it out with no equivalent product being made


after the subways are built the governmet collects more taxes IE land values rise and the economy is greater becase things like people and goods are transported faster

as well, condos are built on the line (frst thing that happens) increasing the tax base and getting people out of cars


now the government can eliminate the added monies through increased taxes but without increasing taxes


any economists out there?
 
so what this wrong wth this idea ?


the government prints the monies in the form of credits

because the subways add to the GNP inflaton is minimal

IE greatest inflation happens when the government prints monies then hands it out with no equivalent product being made


after the subways are built the governmet collects more taxes IE land values rise and the economy is greater becase things like people and goods are transported faster

as well, condos are built on the line (frst thing that happens) increasing the tax base and getting people out of cars


now the government can eliminate the added monies through increased taxes but without increasing taxes


any economists out there?

In theory the government can print money in the form of credits. However, you are not taking into consideration a number of factors. For example, by printing money in effect they are devaluing the currency so inflation may not actually be as minimal as you suggest (primarily because subways may not add to the GNP immediately). Furthermore, printing money in the manner you suggest also sends a signal to the bond markets regarding the value of the Canadian dollar, which may have potential unintended circumstances.

Now I personally feel that the federal government, along with various provincial and municipal governments, should be making substantial investments in public transit in various forms across the country to reduce dependence on the car and address the increasing traffic gridlock and stresses on the roads (not to mention also the environmental benefits). And if that funding is forthcoming through increased taxes, cautious borrowing or through printing money, I believe it is a worthwhile investment.
 
because the subways add to the GNP inflaton is minimal

This is false. You will have more dollars in more pockets (subway construction worker pockets) chasing the same number of goods, creating monetary inflation.

You will also have driven up labor costs for private business by competing with them for the limited supply of workers, creating wage inflation.

It is much better to clearly tie funding to real economic activity by funding it from present or future taxation.
 
This is false. You will have more dollars in more pockets (subway construction worker pockets) chasing the same number of goods, creating monetary inflation.

You will also have driven up labor costs for private business by competing with them for the limited supply of workers, creating wage inflation.

It is much better to clearly tie funding to real economic activity by funding it from present or future taxation.

i realize my idea is flawed or this is how they would do it

but building the subway will and does create goods or GNP or is it GDP?

your argument that it drives up construction salaries sounds valid unless it is a recession when they would not be working otherwise but in any case this inflationary pressure will be relieved from a wider future tax base when the monies could be taken back through taxes then not spent by the government

an analogy is a company building another factory for future profit but in that case they borrow the monies forcing interest payments

if the goveremnet prints the monies there is no interest which is a huge savings as the only real cost of borrowing is the interest so why not print the monies if by doing so you create a wider tax base and as a side benefit get cars off the road, reduce congestion and reduce greenhouse gases (as there is a real economic cost for pollution) ?
 
i realize my idea is flawed or this is how they would do it

but building the subway will and does create goods or GNP or is it GDP?

This can be a good argument for building the subway but it has nothing to do with the inflationary effect of doing it with printed money.

The correct argument is that the future economic payoff will generate more taxes in the future, enabling the government to repay debt it took on to build the subway. Whether that is true depends on a realistic estimate of the expected future taxes versus the expected debt payments.

if the goveremnet prints the monies there is no interest which is a huge savings as the only real cost of borrowing is the interest

You cannot really get something for nothing. The costs just redistribute from taxpayers to the economy in a more general way, through the negative effects of inflation and the diversion of private sector workers away from other activities.

If you do it to try and kick start an economy with a lot of unemployed workers it gets more interesting, but even there the claim is just that the inflationary harm is worth it to get the economy going. Lots of economists debate the merit of that back and forth.