Light rapid transit vs subway

LRT vs subway

  • more LRT

    Votes: 6 7.0%
  • more Subway

    Votes: 60 69.8%
  • combination

    Votes: 20 23.3%
  • other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    86
I would be pretty sure the folks standing at bus stops in the suburbs would be happy if the number of buses was increased. more frequent pickup would satisfy most needs. rather than wait for subways which will most likely NEVER come. make a couple of east-west routed bus express, add an express route instead of that bypass subway line and by the summer, the transit woes are solved. or try to find popular support for spending billions we don't have.
Just a reminder that the Mayor's Plan—before the TTC Commissioners tossed it and did their own—was to cut the number of buses servicing Finch and other high volume routes, to pay for the extra cost of burying the Eglinton trollies (and huge extra cost for stations) so he wouldn't have to look at them while reading and driving. Like him, there is a sizable population who cannot grasp that every transit vehicle takes many cars off the road. All they see is a bus blocking their righteous way.

It's them you have to convince to come up with extra tax-money for extra busses. Good luck.
 
Raising property taxes somewhat?

I read somewhere Toronto's taxes are some of the lowest in Ontario. I dunno though, just an idea

the government prints the monies in the form of credits



since the monies go to adding to the GNP (the subay itself increases the GNP) inflation is not great then when the increased productivity of subways increases taxes take the monies back out of society
 
The LRT is not enough for the growing city,it will be too small in less than 15 years to move enough people. You charge people for the distance that they travel on the transit line. You set up road tolls on the DVP and Gardiner and you raise money with a dedicated transit lottery. It would help they may even be able to tunnel and build a station a year. That is progress and it is able to move the volumes of people that are growing in the city. There are so many condos going up every year and the sheppard line will be moving the masses in the years to come. That is why they put the new trains on the yonge/university line as sheppard and the new extension will both benefit from the new trains.
 
Do you have data to support the claim that the population would grow enough in 15 years to make a subway cost effective?

I read that the population of Scarborough would have to double before the line would run at a cost effective capacity.
 
I read one critique that pointed out that the population of Scarborough would have to *double* to make a subway there economic. .

So how come they could afford subways 50 years ago when the whole city was probably not much bigger than Scarborough is now?
 
So how come they could afford subways 50 years ago when the whole city was probably not much bigger than Scarborough is now?

Because they go where everybody wants to go, downtown. Nobody really wants to go to Scarborough nor to Yonge/Sheppard.

It is just a feeder to the route to downtown, so the question becomes is there enough population for a feeder subway?

The yonge subway is fed by every east/west subway and streetcar, what feeds Sheppard?
 
The City should be building subways downtown.

Priority 1 = Another North / South Line (Bathurst, or Broadview)

Priority 2 = Queen Street (from Sherway Gardens to Victoria Park)

Priority 3 = Extend Bloor to Sherway Gardens.


BTW, there are many abandonned railway corridors in Toronto that would be perfect to be converted to subway. Example - the old CPR line (Belleville Subdivision) that runs from Union Station to Leaside Yard. Then, there is the CPR's North Toronto Subdivsion (which runs from Leaside Yard to Toronto West Junction basically paralleling Dupont, alongside the LCBO at Summerhill,etc. There is room for 5 tracks and CPR uses 2 tracks.
 
Monorails do not REPLACE subways.

they feed people to the subways.

replacing fossil fuel burning buses with triple the size greener vehicles.

obviously!!
 
How about this Idea ?


No way, man!!! These fucktard bus and streetcar drivers can't even drive now without hitting something. You want them to drive OVER cars? Pass.
 
Monorails do not REPLACE subways.

they feed people to the subways.

replacing fossil fuel burning buses with triple the size greener vehicles.

obviously!!
Nope, because a monorail has to run on electricity, which has to come from somewhere (which in our case is nuclear power). This is not green energy, sorry
 
PhIl..if you wanna eliminate electricity as well....Might as well start this thread over.


lets go back to the Big Bang.......

or at least rickshaws to start the conversation :)

But seriously, having looked at Seattles monorail on YouTube, that seems old and cumbersome. And yes, if a breakdown, hard to repair.


my idea of a monorail, replacing buses, is more like we have at our Airport. Throw some sonotubes in the ground, cement a 'T' on top, and slap down some lightweight metal tracks. Easy maintenance, lightweight, green, running off a cable. Easy and certainly cheap to build! And that thing is real smooth, and keeps a schedule to the second!
 
No, I dont wanna eliminate electricity.

I'm just saying its not green energy. Although its as close to green as you can come
 
As I've viewed this thread, I have seen various suggestions on ways to address the need for public transit from monorails to expanding the subway routes in various directions to the merits of LRT. However, these are all suggestions about what to build.

Here's a question to all of you. What do all of you think will likely happen with respect to Toronto city council addressing public transit? As I've posted earlier, my answer to this question is nothing. Perhaps because I believe that the current City Council simply do not have the capability to think rationally about transit, nor do they have the foresight to consult researchers and experts (civil engineers, urban planners, etc.) who actually know something about this.

Am I wrong to be so pessimistic about this? If so, how?
 
As I've viewed this thread, I have seen various suggestions on ways to address the need for public transit from monorails to expanding the subway routes in various directions to the merits of LRT. However, these are all suggestions about what to build.

Here's a question to all of you. What do all of you think will likely happen with respect to Toronto city council addressing public transit? As I've posted earlier, my answer to this question is nothing. Perhaps because I believe that the current City Council simply do not have the capability to think rationally about transit, nor do they have the foresight to consult researchers and experts (civil engineers, urban planners, etc.) who actually know something about this.

Am I wrong to be so pessimistic about this? If so, how?

Am I wrong in assuming a thorough and professional study was done and they decided more LRT ? and it is Ford who wants more subways because "that is what the people want"
 
Ford says, "Subways are what the people want".

People say (through their Council) "LRT is what we'll pay for".

Actually they said a whole lot more in a thing called Transit City, and it even included some subway, but cancelling it was Ford's first significant act as Mayor.

The people may want subways but they voted for a Mayor with no plan to build any and no idea how to find people to make the plans for him.
 
Ford says, "Subways are what the people want".

People say (through their Council) "LRT is what we'll pay for".

Actually they said a whole lot more in a thing called Transit City, and it even included some subway, but cancelling it was Ford's first significant act as Mayor.

The people may want subways but they voted for a Mayor with no plan to build any and no idea how to find people to make the plans for him.

"transit city" spent years studying this very complex issue this issue then Ford thought about it for a few days and said "no"


me thinks his ego is rather huge
 
Am I wrong in assuming a thorough and professional study was done and they decided more LRT ? and it is Ford who wants more subways because "that is what the people want"

You might be right about the LRT, but if there was a thorough, professional, and independent study outlining the methodology, costs weighed, and other factors in a report that is accessible to the public, I'm not aware of it.

You are right about Ford who wants subways (but of course has made no feasible plan to fund the expansion of it). It is his intransigence (and lack of faith on my part in the rest of City Council in mustering a united front to force through the issue) which leads me to be pessimistic about whether anything will ever be actually built.

Again, am I wrong to be so pessimistic?
 
perhaps someone has checked to see if politics played a part in the original Transit city plan. i didn't and won't be. any person standing at a bus stop in the cold/rain doesn't care if a bus/lrt/subway is coming along, all they want is to get picked up and begin the journey. so, what can we afford? subways? hardly. lrt? lots of disruption. buses? sure. move them around as required. they're not stuck to only go where the tracks are. they have merge right-of-way, set up a few more bus lanes for rush hour and things will really move. i know Ford positions himself as against buses but his bluster should just be ignored by council.