Legal question

Does anybody know if your hotel room (or your house) could become a "bawdy house" if you see a lot of escorts in a short period of time (e.g. multiple SPs in a day for a hotel room or once a week if it`s at your house)? Have the courts defined what a "bawdy house" is?
The question came up from this thread: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?317237-Incall-vs.-Outcall
theoretically it can but practically the cops would have to collect evidence of that
if escorts are questioned after leaving your room and give statements, that would typically become evidence in such a case
a complaint from neighbours would normally be required for the cops to begin their investigation (constant screaming in a condo with sensitive neighbours maybe can do that, and its a big maybe, however I admit that I have these thoughts when they go "fuck me yes yes omg" etc at my place )

hard to see how else a case can be proven or even start

I would hope that if an escort is questioned after leaving your room then 1. the escort would not admit to p4p and 2. the agency would let you know...although I would not bet a farm on either

I can add that legally it can be tricky to defend a bawdy house allegation because the law allows "reputation in the community" to be considered, i.e. hearsay can go in which is quite uncommon in a criminal case. I am aware of a case where an ex-cop neighbour gave statement to the investigating cop that a MP is known to be a bordello and the judge refused to exclude the statement and relied on it without hearing from the neighbour. That was in Collingwood area a few years ago. We should all hope that Toronto/Newmarket judges would not rely on BS like that.
 
Does anybody know if your hotel room (or your house) could become a "bawdy house" if you see a lot of escorts in a short period of time (e.g. multiple SPs in a day for a hotel room or once a week if it's at your house)?
No.

You are the one responsible for the expense of the location and you are not using it as a place of business, i.e. you do not profit financially from the activities going on at the location you are responsible for.
 
No.

You are the one responsible for the expense of the location and you are not using it as a place of business, i.e. you do not profit financially from the activities going on at the location you are responsible for.

sorry but you are way off, profit and business has nothing to do with it (except that practically if it's not a business you likely don't have $$ to attract enough SPs to get noticed)
 
Whether you are in a hotel or your own home it does not matter.
If you call them to come see you it is considered an outcall and completely legal.
 
Does anybody know if your hotel room (or your house) could become a "bawdy house" if you see a lot of escorts in a short period of time (e.g. multiple SPs in a day for a hotel room or once a week if it`s at your house)? Have the courts defined what a "bawdy house" is?
The question came up from this thread: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?317237-Incall-vs.-Outcall
No, no one knows, not until it`s tested in a court and decided so decisively and clearly that the appeals stop. As others have said, the practical difficulties of collecting evidence make it very unlikely.
 
Without re-checking the criminal code and case literature, I would say no if it's an outcall but discretion is key since if your home has a revolving door with escorts, the perception may be that you're running a bawdy house and not just seeing escorts yourself for your own personal pleasure.
 
Does anybody know if your hotel room (or your house) could become a "bawdy house" if you see a lot of escorts in a short period of time (e.g. multiple SPs in a day for a hotel room or once a week if it`s at your house)? Have the courts defined what a "bawdy house" is?
The question came up from this thread: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?317237-Incall-vs.-Outcall

Yes, it could. The issue is frequent or habitual use.

Incall or outcall is irrelevant. You will not see these words in the Criminal Code.

Whether you are profiting is a separate issue.
 
Without re-checking the criminal code and case literature, I would say no if it's an outcall but discretion is key since if your home has a revolving door with escorts, the perception may be that you're running a bawdy house and not just seeing escorts yourself for your own personal pleasure.
As Lenny says; all you've got going for you at your residence is your good relations with your neighbour and a real problem in evidence-gathering for the cops, but you're into offence-territory after the first couple of paid visits. Doesn't matter to the law if you're the only customer, so don't give the neighbours incentive to do something about you.
 
The OP is not profiting. He is asking if he has a steady string of SP's entering his house for his own use is his residence considered a bawdy house. Since they are coming to him and he is not profiting from them.. well financially anyway, he is not in violation of the bawdy house laws.
 
If they are coming to his place it is an outcall.

It depends on what the primary purpose of the hotel room is. If it was rented by someone from out of town who needs a place to stay then it is primarily a place to stay, just like a home, and not a place primariliy resorted to for prostitution even if it's also used for that. There are any number of reasons why a local person would also need to stay in a hotel room: Fight with the wife, just painted the house, etc.

If it was rented purely for the purposes of prostitution then technically it would be a bawdy house, but as someone posted up thread, that's just theoritical as it would be very difficult for the police to prove it. About the only way you would get charged is if upon arrest you blurted out something dumb like, "Yes officer I only rented this hotel room to call prostitutes and had no intention of using this room as my residence today."

Really aside from far-fetched things like you voluntarily incriminating yourself, it's too difficult for the police to get the evidence they need, for too minor a charge, so they won't bother trying.
 
The OP is not profiting. He is asking if he has a steady string of SP's entering his house for his own use is his residence considered a bawdy house. Since they are coming to him and he is not profiting from them.. well financially anyway, he is not in violation of the bawdy house laws.
Whether someone profits is irrelevant to whether a place is a bawdyhouse; that only requires that sex for money, i.e. acts of prostitution take place there frequently or customarily. It might be that no one could be dinged for operating the joint, but it's still an offence to be an inmate or to be a found-in, and it would be lotsa fun to hear someone argue a place can only be a bawdyhouse if it made a profit—can't think of another business like that. What was GM's COO operating while they were hemmoraging if he wasn't operating a business?

The issue is repetition, and that can happen anywhere, your home is as dangerous as her home, except that it's likely easier for cops to recruit fake-johns than fake call-girls, and if we assume your sexual hunger doesn't drive you to the frequency of a sole-source SP, your neighbours aren't likely to tipoff the cops. But don't get into a tiff over dogs barking os some such.

Although he didn't ask about them, the laws the OP is safe from are the laws against receiving 'the avails' of prostitution, i.e. the profits, you're concerned about, NB. But those offences follow the money, not the address.
 
The issue is repetition, and that can happen anywhere, your home is as dangerous as her home

I'm not sure that's true. I think the question is whether it is "a place that is kept or occupied, or resorted to by one or more persons, for the purpose of prostitution or the practice of acts of indecency".

If it is your own home you keep it, occupy it, and resort to it for the purpose of sheltering yourself from the elements, it's primarily your residence. Any prostitution that occurs there is incidental to your keeping of your home, and not your primary purpose. At least, not unless you have prostitutes there several times a day, all day long--odds are that prostitution activities are a relatively rare activity in your home compared to eating, sleeping, watching TV, inviting friends over, and all the other things people do in their own residence.

I don't know that's been tested in court but it's certainly what the defense would likely argue and it seems the police and crown are also of the opinion that they would not be able to get a conviction so there's likely some merit to the argument.

In the case of an independent escort that argument could still be made although it's less clear--perhaps part of the home would be deemed to be kept for the purpose of running the home prostitution business. Still, this may be one reason why you don't hear a lot about independents being arrested in their home.

When you get to an apartment rented by an agency into which a couple of girls are parachuted, then even if they live there the argument becomes stronger that the place is kept and resorted to primarily for the purpose of prostitution, and then finally obviously the agency incall site that nobody resides at but is used strictly for prostitution is clear cut.

In short while I don't know where the line between a bawdy house and a residence is, I am pretty sure that your home doesn't count. As you move further along that continuum you will eventually get to a point where the crown and the police will contemplate pressing charges but it's not as simple as "frequency".
 
If it was rented purely for the purposes of prostitution then technically it would be a bawdy house, but as someone posted up thread, that's just theoritical as it would be very difficult for the police to prove it. About the only way you would get charged is if upon arrest you blurted out something dumb like, "Yes officer I only rented this hotel room to call prostitutes and had no intention of using this room as my residence today."

It does not have to be used exclusively or even predominantly for prostitution. The issue is whether it is continually and habitually have been used for prostitution. The definition is "place...resorted to by one or more persons for the purpose of prostitution". A hotel or a parking lot may be (and have been) found to be a bawdy house.

If you throw at your place playboy-style parties and book escorts to entertain your friends or business associates, and a police is called for whatever reason and escorts end up giving statements confirming that it happens regularly, I don't see why you cannot end up being convicted.
Even one escort's statement that she habitually visits you at your place for p4p may theoretically lead to your conviction.
 
There is no line between bawdy house and residence. If you use it as a residence, it's a residence. If you use it as a bawdy house, it's a bawdy house. If you use it as both, it's both. And it would be easier for the cops to find you on the property and tie you to the bawdy house's operation.
 
As Lenny says; all you've got going for you at your residence is your good relations with your neighbour and a real problem in evidence-gathering for the cops, but you're into offence-territory after the first couple of paid visits. Doesn't matter to the law if you're the only customer, so don't give the neighbours incentive to do something about you.

Okay, so since outcalls are discreet situations and probably not frequent or habitual occurrences, there are probably no cases ruling them as illegal, but that doesn't mean they are legal.
 
I don't know that's been tested in court but it's certainly what the defense would likely argue and it seems the police and crown are also of the opinion that they would not be able to get a conviction so there's likely some merit to the argument......
...In short while I don't know where the line between a bawdy house and a residence is, I am pretty sure that your home doesn't count. As you move further along that continuum you will eventually get to a point where the crown and the police will contemplate pressing charges but it's not as simple as "frequency".

I can similarly argue that one is entitled to smoke (and possess a smoking joint of) marijuana in his residence as no one was prosecuted for it. Your home is indeed your castle, but only when no one complains about it.
 
I can similarly argue that one is entitled to smoke (and possess a smoking joint of) marijuana in his residence as no one was prosecuted for it. Your home is indeed your castle, but only when no one complains about it.

Reread my post. I did not argue that it was legal just because nobody has ever prosecuted it. I argued that it was legal because your primary residence does not fit the definition of a bawdy house. I mentioned that the Crown seems uninterested in prosecuting it only to demonstrate that the opinion is widely held despite not having been tested in court.
 
Reread my post. I did not argue that it was legal just because nobody has ever prosecuted it. I argued that it was legal because your primary residence does not fit the definition of a bawdy house. I mentioned that the Crown seems uninterested in prosecuting it only to demonstrate that the opinion is widely held.

There is no evidence that Crown has no interest in prosecuting it. Only evidence that we don't know if it ever was prosecuted.

And your residence may well fit the definition of a bawdy house. Mine sure as hell does.