Legal question

There is no evidence that Crown has no interest in prosecuting it. Only evidence that we don't know if it ever was prosecuted.

I keep, occupy, and resort to my home for the purpose of sheltering myself from the elements. The fact that prostitution may occur here from time to time is incidental--it's where I happen to be, the place is not kept for that purpose it is kept for a very different purpose.
 
I keep, occupy, and resort to my home for the purpose of sheltering myself from the elements. The fact that prostitution may occur here from time to time is incidental--it's where I happen to be, the place is not kept for that purpose it is kept for a very different purpose.
it's kept for a different purpose but it's resorted to for purpose of prostitution
reread the definition, there is OR in it
 
it's kept for a different purpose but it's resorted to for purpose of prostitution
reread the definition, there is OR in it

I don't resort to my home for the purpose of prostitution. I resort to it for shelter. Any prostitution that happens in my home is unrelated to the reason why I resort to my home. I believe the reason why the Crown is uninterested in prosecuting these cases is that the Crown generally believes the court will adopt this sort of narrow interpretation.
 
I don't resort to my home for the purpose of prostitution. I resort to it for shelter. Any prostitution that happens in my home is unrelated to the reason why I resort to my home.

do you think that a prostitute who visits you somehow can escape a definition of "one or more persons" who resorts to your home? please

read this case if you are interested in this subject: http://scc.lexum.umontreal.ca/en/1967/1968scr0-157/1968scr0-157.html , it's a classic one.
 
I don't resort to my home for the purpose of prostitution. I resort to it for shelter. Any prostitution that happens in my home is unrelated to the reason why I resort to my home. I believe the reason why the Crown is uninterested in prosecuting these cases is that the Crown generally believes the court will adopt this sort of narrow interpretation.

or maybe the reason is that people who can habitually attract prostitutes are smart enough to not piss off their neighbours, or the cops have no resources for surveillance that would be required to prosecute such a case
 
do you think that a prostitute who visits you somehow can escape a definition of "one or more persons" who resorts to your home? please

read this case if you are interested in this subject: http://scc.lexum.umontreal.ca/en/1967/1968scr0-157/1968scr0-157.html , it's a classic one.
We really need more case law and an annotated CCC to form any sort of educated opinion as to the legal interpretation of this section of the statute.

There are certainly opinions, which I believe are well supported in law, that a location would be provided by, or under the control of the SP to qualify as a bawdy house. But there would seem to be broader opinions that suggest that the reputation of the premises, even if it's the john's own home, that meets the definition.

I'm not aware of any case law testing the latter definition - that a john's hotel room or residence would meet the bawdy house definitions, but others can do a legal search more readily than can I. I might suggest, though, that suggesting a john's home is a "place of ill repute" would be a label many guys might even aspire to, even if it's not a good thing.
 
do you think that a prostitute who visits you somehow can escape a definition of "one or more persons" who resorts to your home? please

read this case if you are interested in this subject: http://scc.lexum.umontreal.ca/en/1967/1968scr0-157/1968scr0-157.html , it's a classic one.

Note in that case the house was resorted to for the purpose of prostitution: The customers and the girls all went there for no other reason. None of them could claim to have resorted to it as their primary residence, nor even a temporary residence, nor even just for shelter. No-one could claim that the prostitution occurred there simply as an incidental aspect of their other uses of the residence. The home was clearly arranged and provisioned for no other purpose than prostitution.

My claim (untested by any case law) is that if you occupy, resort to, and keep a place as your primary residence then it's ludicrous to assert that you keep, occupy, or resort to it for prostitution--any prostitution occurring happens there incidentally, for no other reason than it's where you already were.
 
We really need more case law and an annotated CCC to form any sort of educated opinion as to the legal interpretation of this section of the statute.

I don't believe you'll find much that's directly relevant because the police at the direction of the crown simply don't go after these cases. My opinion is that this is because the crown believes they could not win.
 
My claim (untested by any case law) is that if you occupy, resort to, and keep a place as your primary residence then it's ludicrous to assert that you keep, occupy, or resort to it for prostitution--any prostitution occurring happens there incidentally, for no other reason than it's where you already were.

Let's not make it more complicated than it is. The Supreme Court says: Schroeder J.A. was of the opinion that the words “kept or occupied” and the words “resorted to” as used in s. 168(1) (b) (i) and (ii) connote a frequent or habitual use of the premises for the purposes of prostitution. I am in accord with that view.
What else do you need to know to realize that your defence of incidental use is going to be rejected and that frequent or habitual use of prostitutes in one's own home may well lead to a bawdy-house finding?
 
You have a rather novel interpretation of how the courts work. It seems you think the existence of one defense invalidates other defenses. I agree with you that to be a bawdy house the resorting or keeping or occupying has to be frequent and habitual. What I am saying is that when the place is your primary residence, a place you always keep and occupy and resort to in any case regardless of whether or not you engage in prostitution, then it is not resorting or keeping or occupying for the purpose of prostitution at all--never mind habitual or frequent. It was resorted to, kept, and occupied for the purpose of shelter--the prostitution came later and was incidental to and not the purpose of the resorting/keeping/occupying.
 
You have a rather novel interpretation of how the courts work. It seems you think the existence of one defense invalidates other defenses. I agree with you that to be a bawdy house the resorting or keeping or occupying has to be frequent and habitual. What I am saying is that when the place is your primary residence, a place you always keep and occupy and resort to in any case regardless of whether or not you engage in prostitution, then it is not resorting or keeping or occupying for the purpose of prostitution at all--never mind habitual or frequent. It was resorted to, kept, and occupied for the purpose of shelter--the prostitution came later and was incidental to and not the purpose of the resorting/keeping/occupying.
it's not you it's the fucking PROSTITUTE that resorts to your house for prostutution, and it's not even incidental because it's her main purpose (although it does not matter).
 
In practical terms, if the police charge you it is just as bad whether you get convicted or not. It is going to cost you $10k and the arrest record will be on that police departments (and CPIC's) computers forever.

In practical terms I also doubt VERY much that the police or Crown are going to go to the expense of investigating and charging you with any Bawdy House charges in your own residence whether it is a hotel or your apartment or detached house whatever for hosting a prostitute at your residence.

Then again
this discussion may appear to be somewhat of an academic nature

But I recall a situation where police went to investigate a guy who was partying in a hotel with SPs. (The guy paid for his room and has been partying there and booking outcalls - so it was very close to our scenario). The cops went in to investigate what they described as prostitution-related situation (an SP complained that she did not get paid) and found drugs.
One of the Charter issues was: why the fuck the cops went to investigate something that was an outcall and should not have been investigated in the first place? Exclusion of drugs hinged on that to a significant degree.

So you never really know when an academic argument may become quite a practical one.
 
Agreed. How did the case play out? What was the case if you recall?

The Crown agreed to a plea to simple possession and to a conditional discharge on the strength of the above argument. Case not reported. Drugs found (a bag of cocaine and MDMA) ordinarily would upon conviction lead to house arrest or real jail sentence, which indeed was the initial Crown's position.
 
I googled the definition for my own read. Read this page. http://www.duhaime.org/LegalDictionary/B/BawdyHouse.aspx

It says that a bawdy house can even include a parking lot (the primary or original purpose of the venue is irrelevant it seems to the definition - what matters is the frequency of use). However, the Supreme Court in 2005 ruled against a sex club being a bawdy house because it consisted of a private sex club which the court ruled was not harmful to individuals or society. Therefore, this might also suggest that what two consenting adults do in the privacy of one's home avoids any legal repercussions if it doesn't 'harm society'.

Therefore, I would conclude just on this read that your home or outcall location wouldn't be a common bawdy house if you were not always using it as such and if it was not harmful or a nuisance to society.
 
You have a rather novel interpretation of how the courts work. It seems you think the existence of one defense invalidates other defenses. I agree with you that to be a bawdy house the resorting or keeping or occupying has to be frequent and habitual. What I am saying is that when the place is your primary residence, a place you always keep and occupy and resort to in any case regardless of whether or not you engage in prostitution, then it is not resorting or keeping or occupying for the purpose of prostitution at all--never mind habitual or frequent. It was resorted to, kept, and occupied for the purpose of shelter--the prostitution came later and was incidental to and not the purpose of the resorting/keeping/occupying.

Again: the courts have described the definition in terms of the reputation of a place, not in terms of other uses. If a place has a reputation as a place of ill repute, if it has a reputation as a bawdy house, I would expect lawyers (including judges) could well find it is a bawdy house.

But the key, as you previously agreed, is that prosecutions under the bawdy house statute are unknown for locations under the control of the john but are (as far as we can tell) applied for locations provided by, or under the control of the SP: that there is a nexus between the one receiving the proceeds of prostitution, and the one providing the accomodation for it.
 
if it has a reputation as a bawdy house, I would expect lawyers (including judges) could well find it is a bawdy house.

By that definition a private home that is never open to the public could not have a reputation as a bawdy house.
 
Okay, so since outcalls are discreet situations and probably not frequent or habitual occurrences, there are probably no cases ruling them as illegal, but that doesn't mean they are legal.
Woo! What a dismal and dangerous view of our world that is where something can be illegal, even if there's no law saying it is illegal. Fortunately I believe our courts prefer that all is legal unless specifically prohibited.

In any case, an outcall is an event, an act of prostitution arranged for a place designated by the purchaser. Th Criminal Code has nothing to say about an individual act of prostitution (or even a string of them) being a crime. What is criminal is being connected with the place such acts commononly are done, profiting from the acts or advertising/arranging them in public.
 
I'm not sure that's true. I think the question is whether it is "a place that is kept or occupied, or resorted to by one or more persons, for the purpose of prostitution or the practice of acts of indecency".

If it is your own home you keep it, occupy it, and resort to it for the purpose of sheltering yourself from the elements, it's primarily your residence. Any prostitution that occurs there is incidental to your keeping of your home, and not your primary purpose. At least, not unless you have prostitutes there several times a day, all day long--odds are that prostitution activities are a relatively rare activity in your home compared to eating, sleeping, watching TV, inviting friends over, and all the other things people do in their own residence.

I don't know that's been tested in court but it's certainly what the defense would likely argue and it seems the police and crown are also of the opinion that they would not be able to get a conviction so there's likely some merit to the argument.

In the case of an independent escort that argument could still be made although it's less clear--perhaps part of the home would be deemed to be kept for the purpose of running the home prostitution business. Still, this may be one reason why you don't hear a lot about independents being arrested in their home.

When you get to an apartment rented by an agency into which a couple of girls are parachuted, then even if they live there the argument becomes stronger that the place is kept and resorted to primarily for the purpose of prostitution, and then finally obviously the agency incall site that nobody resides at but is used strictly for prostitution is clear cut.

In short while I don't know where the line between a bawdy house and a residence is, I am pretty sure that your home doesn't count. As you move further along that continuum you will eventually get to a point where the crown and the police will contemplate pressing charges but it's not as simple as "frequency".
I think your view has merit, but as in any legal matter, the courts write the definitions over the years, and that's why we hire lawyers. If you, the homeowner were to be charged, it would certainly be an argument to make, but I see no reason the CRown couldn't argue that no words require the primary purpose of the place be prostitution or indecency, that a single purposefully arranged act is technically sufficient for that test, and that in any case they have evidence of more than one. Relying on the test of purpose alone would make it possible to convict anyone who rented a garçonnerie before even having a single encounter, just for being a tad loos-tongued with the landlord. On the other hand, it would be quite a useful legal possibility if a notorious pimp leased a rooming house and wanted to know about short-term parking deals in the lot next door.

Point is that law's not there to harass individuals quietly enjoying themselves in their own homes, even if it can and has often been used that way; be cool and don't make waves.
 
By that definition a private home that is never open to the public could not have a reputation as a bawdy house.

Wha? Not at all. Any place could have a reputation as a place of prostitution, including a parking lot, as has been pointed out above.
 
Wha? Not at all. Any place could have a reputation as a place of prostitution, including a parking lot, as has been pointed out above.

Sure, but in those examples the parking lot or other place of prostitution is open to the public (or at least any member of the public willing to pay). A private home is not similarly open to the public.