That's really for the playoffs to decide.
Good or bad anything is all about the playoffs.
Leafs changed their style of play for the playoffs.
It's dump and chase vs puck possession.
Regular season is just to tune the team to play this style.
Also to tune their special teams. They didn't go with a 5 forward PP right from the get go.
Berube's PP has been on fire. No more of this Rielly passing to left boards right boards and that's it.
Berube has reduced Keefe's odd man rushes against.
Everyone seems to be flowing except Laughton looks out of place.
These last 11 games are for him to tune himself.
Keefe's Devils has dropped so far back that Ottawa is now only 2 pts behind having played 2 less games to boot.
Leafs are 1st place in the Atlantic Division at this very moment.
Keefe's Leafs were never this close to leading the Atlantic Division in late March.
So I don't see how by regular season standards one can say Keefe was better.
Berube has yet to coach a Leaf playoff game so there's no way to give that comparison right now.