Leaders' Debate

CBC reported that Layton was the most appealing in the debate according to a group compromised of mainly young voters. They said he was the only one that made any sense. I guess they didn't live through the last NDP Ontario government under Bob Rae, lol.

Layton is the most at ease, but that is easy to do when you do not have any real pressure on you. Iggy did have a few brain cramps, but I think he did ok.
 
CBC reported that Layton was the most appealing in the debate according to a group compromised of mainly young voters. They said he was the only one that made any sense. I guess they didn't live through the last NDP Ontario government under Bob Rae, lol.

Of course, Bob Rae's a Liberal now.
 
Who do you think did the best tonight? Is there a defining moment that changes your vote?

It's not who did the best.it's who was the loser. the loser should be eliminated from the next debate(like the playoffs) after 3 weeks we have a winner.
"defining moment" The only way these boring bullshit debates could change my vote would be if the leader I was voting for dropped dead on stage! then I would have to reconsider.
 
Start raising corporate taxes now and foreign subsidiaries will be rolling out of town quickly. The current greenback devaluation isnt going away any time soon, Canadian exporters need the low tax advantage now more than ever. While the "tax the wealthy coprorations" makes a nice socialist sound bite, it would be the nail in the Canadian economy's coffin in this economic period.

Shall we list the companies that have already 'rolled out of town' already with the rates where they are? Their rate is competitive and still will be if they went up two points. Most high profile economist said as much. The starting tax rate is only the starting point as the over complex tax system hides many of the real rates. Those on this BB that deal with this part of the businness world can expand on this. I pay someone very well so I don't have to.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_rates_around_the_world.

I know what tax rate I pay in the end and it's no where near as high as 16/18%. So it's ashell game for sure to claim the rates can't be higher.

From; http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...veals-as-election-pledges-fly/article1972599/

But the reality is there are no easy answers when it comes to measuring the impact tax rates have on job creation. Economic growth in Canada can be attributed to a lot more than just corporate tax rates. Such things as commodity prices and the value of the Canadian dollar also play a role.

The issue boils down to this: At a time when Ottawa and many provinces are awash in deficit, should governments invest scarce resources in making life more affordable for families by enhancing social programs or in giving corporations additional tax cuts?

Successive federal governments have chosen the latter path in recent years in a bid to make Canada more competitive and attractive to international investors. In 2000, the combined federal-provincial tax rate was just over 42 per cent, ranking Canada near the top among industrialized nations. The combined rate has since fallen to 28 per cent, placing the country in the middle of the pack, and Conservative Leader Stephen Harper’s goal is to reduce it to 25 per cent by fiscal 2013.

Businesses were widely expected to use the extra money from successive rounds of tax cuts to build factories and offices and buy new machinery and equipment. At one time, they did just that. From 1960 until the early 1990s, corporations invested almost every penny of their after-tax cash flow back into the business.

But the tax cuts appear to have reversed decades of tradition. Investment in equipment and machinery has fallen to 5.5 per cent in 2010 as a share of Canada’s total economic output from 6.8 per cent in 2005 and 7.7 per cent in 2000,


IT"S A BIG LIE!!

Harper's repeated claimed support from the Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters lobby group and Jayson Myers goes completely against the facts stated earlier, but what else is new.

From; http://www.thestar.com/business/article/958881--budget-targets-productivity-and-investment

The head of the Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters lobby group praised the budget, the sixth Finance Minister Jim Flaherty has delivered.

“When you talk about things which drive productivity, it’s investment in new products, it’s investing in people, and it’s companies investing in new technology. I see a lot of evidence in this budget that they’ve addressed all of those things,” said Jayson Myers.

The trouble is that the fact show the investment is decreasing. I wonder which board of directors Harper will be sitting on in his next civilian life. Is Meyers lying or just ignorant?
 
Who won?

No clue, as it looked like a school yard bitch fight to me.

Who lost?

qsk1G.jpg


Every single one of us, since these are the people that run our country!
 
what i find sad is how reaction to the debate is so partisan. few people can watch without letting their inherent biases take over.
 
I tried not to be partisan.

I looked at it...what each leader needed to do....

and made a well balanced analysis.

Nothing partisan at all!!

For instance...any conservative, NDP or Bloc..could easily tell before hand that Iggy had to do very well...throw some knock out blows...win some scrums..if he was going to gain anything in the polls. Iggy failed miserably in that respect. All the pundits say so. Any observer with half a brain saw that!!..Is it partisan (Because I might be Con, NDP or Bloc)...or is it the truth?
 
Harper's repeated claimed support from the Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters lobby group and Jayson Myers goes completely against the facts.

I think this is why Harper won the debate. His style reminded me of Brian Mulroney who lied about many issues but once he had the majority - simply rode his agenda through the majority government for 5 years without any accountability. Most Canadian voters are morons who are not going to bother fact checking what politicians said during a debate. Harper even denied Ducette's claim that he signed an already published agreement with the PQ in 2004 that allowed Harper to take over as Prime Minister even though his party did not have as many seats as the Liberals.

Harper looked in into the camera smiling and simply denied everything (factual or not), lied and refused to discuss any details other than saying basically - 'don't worry - it will work itself out'

My first time looking at Michael Enigma speak. I found him obviously smart but lacking in debating skills. He offered up complicated explanations and failed to press points that had Harper exposed. As an economist, I liked that he described how he planned to pay for his programs and steer money from the corporations gutting the income of normal people (Oil, Banks) to small business owners. Harper simply deflected the argument without having to address how he was going to pay for his programs. Enigma simply backed off.

Layton was simply Layton. It is easy to promise the world when you know you will never have to deliver. I did find his delivery better than Enigma who seemed to hesitate at times when he was frustrated.

Doucette was good. You must remember that he is only their to get as much power and money as he can for Quebec. He only needs to show Quebecers he is looking after their interests and I think it he did that. On generic interests that are common to all Canadians, I thought he brought up some valid points.

Just my read.
 
I think this is why Harper won the debate. His style reminded me of Brian Mulroney who lied about many issues but once he had the majority - simply rode his agenda through the majority government for 5 years without any accountability. Most Canadian voters are morons who are not going to bother fact checking what politicians said during a debate. Harper even denied Ducette's claim that he signed an agreement with the PQ in 2004 which has been published that allowed Harper to take over as Prime Minister even though his party did not have as many seats as the Liberals.

Harper looked in into the camera smiling and simply denied everything (factual or not), lied and refused to discuss any details other than saying basically - 'don't worry - it will work itself out'

My first time looking at Michael Enigma speak. I found him obviously smart but lacking in debating skills. He offered up complicated explanations and failed to press points that had Harper exposed. As an economist, I liked that he described how he planned to pay for his programs and steer money from the corporations gutting the income of normal people (Oil, Banks) to small business owners. Harper simply deflected the argument without having to address how he was going to pay for his programs. Enigma simply backed off.

Layton was simply Layton. It is easy to promise the world when you know you will never have to deliver. I did find his delivery better than Enigma who seemed to hesitate at times when he was frustrated.

Doucette was good. You must remember that he is only their to get as much power and money as he can for Quebec. He only needs to show Quebecers he is looking after their interests and I think it he did that. On generic interests that are common to all Canadians, I thought he brought up some valid points.

Just my read.

Pretty much bang on.
 
Layton said Ignatieff has "the worst attendance record in the House of Commons of any member of Parliament."
"You know, most Canadians, if they don't show up for work, they don't get a promotion," Layton said. "You missed 70% of the votes."


Not much Iggy can say to that.
 
Layton said Ignatieff has "the worst attendance record in the House of Commons of any member of Parliament."
"You know, most Canadians, if they don't show up for work, they don't get a promotion," Layton said. "You missed 70% of the votes."


Not much Iggy can say to that.

I've always said that attendance should be made public, but they explain away as being else where doing work, soooo ......
 
There was a difference in how the 'Coalition' proposals went down.

Back in 2004, with Liberals at 135 seats, they were facing a bad vote and Harper reminded the GG that, as per Constituion, the GG could go to the next leading party (Conservatives) and ask them to form a government, as opposed to an election!! Of course, the support of the other parties would have been needed and crucial but that merger never happened.

THIS is very much in contrast to the Liberal Ploy, who did not go to GG, but in fact surreptisciously went into back rooms with the other two parties (NDP and BLOC) and put to paper a plan, an agreement to take over.

There are some remarkable differences in how you interpret the 'COALTION' in each case!!
 
Nobody could make Harper flinch, but being the best stonewaller doesn't make a good Prime Minister.
It's sad that we choose our leaders by how they act and look and sound.
 
There was a difference in how the 'Coalition' proposals went down.

Back in 2004, with Liberals at 135 seats, they were facing a bad vote and Harper reminded the GG that, as per Constitution, the GG could go to the next leading party (Conservatives) and ask them to form a government, as opposed to an election!! Of course, the support of the other parties would have been needed and crucial but that merger never happened.

There are some remarkable differences in how you interpret the 'COALTION' in each case!!

Harper did sign a document of understanding with Doucette - it was published and no one disputed it. That is why Doucette attacked Harper as hypocrite during the debate.

Regarding the Constitution, each elected member can vote as he feels best represents his constituents. Constitutionally the selection of Prime Minister is:' stipulate that the monarch's representative, the governor general, must select as prime minister the person most likely to command the confidence of the elected House of Commons; this individual is typically the leader of the political party that holds the largest number of seats in that chamber.'

This idea that coalition parties cannot form a government is a blatant lie as Harper knows from his own attempt to seize the 'crown'. I always held that Stephen Harper's unfortunately habitual prorogue (aka: suspension of democracy) of parliament to hold power from an alliance headed by Stéphane Dion was the wrong decision at the right time. As much as I didn't want Stéphane Dion Prime Minister - my gut told me that it was wrong. Now Harper has prorogued parliament more than once to avoid democratic votes that represents the majority of the populations representatives. It is scary and a bad practice.

I think they should clearly set out rules to prorogue parliament e.g. in times of war. Coalition governments representing the majority of the peoples vote are a reality in many countries and totally legal here.
 
Doucette was good. You must remember that he is only their to get as much power and money as he can for Quebec. He only needs to show Quebecers he is looking after their interests and I think it he did that. On generic interests that are common to all Canadians, I thought he brought up some valid points.

Just my read.

Who is Doucette?
 
I found it a very refreshing debate in comparison to the US presidential debates. The four party leaders did not talk "down" to the viewers. The differences in their policies were welll noted and considering the time restraints were fairly well explained. I really enjoyed it. Cheers GB
 
Of course, Bob Rae's a Liberal now.

Yeah, he left (in his own words) because the NDP had been taken over by those who believe(d) that Free Enterprise is evil and should be brought down.

Rae wrote in his book that after 20 years, he concluded the NDP was "wedded to a culture of opposition and protest."

The federal NDP's recent opposition to any tax changes for large and even small business is a sure sign that 'private sector is bad, public sector is good' is a flawed mantra it simply can't avoid," he said.


http://bigcitylib.blogspot.com/2006/10/thats-gotta-hurt-bob-rae-disses-ndp-in.html
 
Layton said Ignatieff has "the worst attendance record in the House of Commons of any member of Parliament."
"You know, most Canadians, if they don't show up for work, they don't get a promotion," Layton said. "You missed 70% of the votes."


Not much Iggy can say to that.

Yeah, I didn't know that about Iggy and it really sours me on him.

I don't like Harper. I would never vote for the NDP or Layton, so I was figuring to hold my nose and vote for Iggy. This revalation by Layton was an eye opener for me and it would take full breathing gear to vote for Iggy now.

I can only hope that Harper gets a minority, Iggy resigns and slithers back to Harvard, and Frank Mckenna runs for and wins the liberal leadership.