Leaders' Debate

It's easy for Harper to agree to releasing the report, since.. it's not under his control. Or any of the other leaders (but they already knew that and were being disingenuous).

This is the thing that really stuck in my throat after all was said and done. Here we had Iggenstein demanding that the Prime Minister release the report, as if he has any authority to do this.

Harper should have pointed out to the visiting professor that if he had studied up on his Canadian politics, he would have known that the AG reports to Parliament, and that she is not permitted to release any report unless Parliament is sitting.

This kind of cheap grandstanding is what makes people cynical about politicians. And here I thought that Iggy was supposed to be a serious candidate. He is relying on the old tried & true Liberal strategy of bullshitting the puiblic and hoping that we're too stupid to see the truth.

OK, I'm done now...
 
There was a difference in how the 'Coalition' proposals went down.

Back in 2004, with Liberals at 135 seats, they were facing a bad vote and Harper reminded the GG that, as per Constituion, the GG could go to the next leading party (Conservatives) and ask them to form a government, as opposed to an election!! Of course, the support of the other parties would have been needed and crucial but that merger never happened.

THIS is very much in contrast to the Liberal Ploy, who did not go to GG, but in fact surreptisciously went into back rooms with the other two parties (NDP and BLOC) and put to paper a plan, an agreement to take over.

There are some remarkable differences in how you interpret the 'COALTION' in each case!!

Uh dude, the two situations were pretty much identical. In both cases all the opposition parties got together "surreptisciously" [sic] and worked out a back room deal, then afterwards released a joint public statement. Identical.

Whatever differences there are are minute and irrelevant. Harper's just a lying hypocrit--but we already knew that.
 
Michael, his eyebrow color didn't match the color of his hair

It is irrelevant to his performance but I found it looked strange as this is the first time I really looked at him. I mean if it was grey eyebrows with black hair, you would write it off as a hair dye job but those big black bushy eyebrows reminded me of Groucho Marx. Certainly not a chick magnet !
 
There was a difference in how the 'Coalition' proposals went down.

Back in 2004, with Liberals at 135 seats, they were facing a bad vote and Harper reminded the GG that, as per Constituion, the GG could go to the next leading party (Conservatives) and ask them to form a government, as opposed to an election!! Of course, the support of the other parties would have been needed and crucial but that merger never happened.

THIS is very much in contrast to the Liberal Ploy, who did not go to GG, but in fact surreptisciously went into back rooms with the other two parties (NDP and BLOC) and put to paper a plan, an agreement to take over.

There are some remarkable differences in how you interpret the 'COALTION' in each case!!

Absolutely correct, Frank, but it appears that so few people appreciate the difference. When David Peterson created a working agreement with the NDP, it was much more legitimate in my eyes. Bob Rae and his cronies were needed to support the Liberals, which is legitimate, but they were given no seats in the Cabinet.

The coalition of losers was a true coalition, but unlike Peterson's deal with the NDP, neither of those parties had the largest number of seats in the House. Hence, the "coalition of losers" tag. They did not go to the GG and ask permission to form a government, which is what is actually required, but attempted this sneaky back room approach, with Layton telling Harper not to fight it, but just walk away and accept the inevitable. It was already a done deal.

What kind of leader would accept this? It honestly reminded me of a rapist telling his victom to relax and accept the inevitable. And then we would have had the reality of Layton & Co. having senior Cabinet posts. Jack Layton - Minister of Finance! This is not what Canadians voted for a mere 6 weeks before...
 
Absolutely correct, Frank, but it appears that so few people appreciate the difference.

The difference depends if you consult the rules of parliament and not Conservative brochures. First there must be a vote of confidence - if the majority of house of commons members (by your definition - the Winners) believe the they have no confidence in existing government, the Governor General has no choice but to select a government that represents the majority of the commons members (aka: democracy). Harper convinced the GG to suspend parliament (aka democracy) so that the vote could not be taken.

As much as I hated the thought of a Dion lead government - one cannot fight democracy just because it isn't to your party's advantage. (Unless you are a Harper supporter) hence my thought of a bad decision at the right time. Harper has proven to me that once you ignore the democratic will of parliament once, there is nothing to let stop you repeating it.
 
I listened to it on the radio...long drive home.

No knock-out punch was delivered. It sounded somewhat boring and almost routine.

* Harper: Predictable and even tempered. Stuck with his "focus on the economy" game plan, which is his strength given the global economic conditions
* Iggy: Families, families, families! Nice to see the federal counterparts are keen on promoting the nanny state. Spent more time attacking the conservatives than promoting his own party
* Jack: Always good for a laugh or two, however if the NDP ever got in power...God help us all! We would be financially bankrupt inside of a year. Jack seems to think that every senior should be wealthy, every family will have a doctor and home care 24/7...and the greedy corporations will pay for it all. Sorry Jack, they don't pay uh, jack! Pie in the sky dreams will come out of our pocket.
* Duceppe: Why bother showing up. Seriously. He brings nothing to the show. Dig up the corpse of Levesque, at least he had some personality!

Did the debate change my vote? No.

Too bad there is not a competent, young, aggressive alternative candidate/party out there...It's high time to rid ourselves of these tired old white guys.

Excellent summary! Pretty much says it all there.
 
The format of the debate was good and better then the round table of 2 years ago. I was glad the May was not in this debate as it was difficult enough to deal with four leader let alone 5. She would not have added anything new other then being yet another person in the room to attack the PM.

Harper did what he had to do and remained cool and looked into the camera to speaking directly to the people and deflected alot to of the attacks. Ignatieff actually surprised me. I thought he gave a good performance but spent too much time attacking rather then what his plan would do. Jack is Jack and had a good knock against Iggy for missing a large number of votes in the Commons.

Duceppe - hard to understand at times. I laughed when he congratulated Harper on answering a question from a Canadian for the first time during the election. He did not add much to the debate other then attacking Harper along with Iggy and Jack. But on the point of Health Care Duceppe was bang on regarding that it was a Provincial jurisdication. Contray to what Jack and Iggy were saying was that they would do this and that to preserve the system but realistically the Federal government can't to very much (other then provide funding with some strings attached) given that the day to day administration of Health Care is done by the provinces.

All in all though I don't think the performances swayed many to change their minds on who they were going to vote for. The undecided voters had a glimse of the leaders however not sure if the debate help them in their decision on who they would cast a vote for.
 
Uh Dude Uh Fuji...you need to go back and look at the record Dude!

Saying they were 'pretty' much identical makes my point Dude. THEY were not the same DUDE.

Harper remained the GG of the option to call on him...she questioned his ability to form a coalition Dude - as per CONSTITUTION...and agreements needed to be reached.

IN THIS CASE....JACK AND IGGY went to the back rooms...ignored prrotocol..ignored the GG..ignored the constitution....and tried to figure out a way to get power..minus the GG.

Some difference Dude!~
 
...the Governor General has no choice but to select a government that represents the majority of the commons members (aka: democracy).


I am just expressing my opinions here, and don't want to get involved in a flame war, but if we are talking about procedure, I don't believe that the GG ever "selects" a government. In the case of minorities or coalitions, the GG invites the parties that are involved to present the foundations under which they would form a government, all subject of course, to the Constitution. In the event that the GG does not feel that any party has made their case, it would typically result in a general election...

...Harper convinced the GG to suspend parliament (aka democracy) so that the vote could not be taken.

Yes, it was only with the constitutional support of the GG that the ruling was made. the PM does not have this kind of power. And for the record, while I was against the coalition, I felt that I would support the GG in whatever decision was about to make, in the belief that whatever decision she took would have been made for what she believed to be the best interests of the country. I guess that is what makes it useful at times when someone who is not a politician can rule without bias. This decision was made by the Head of State and it was required to be done within the framework of our parliamentary democracy.

For the record, I said at the time that I would have accepted her judgement if it had been to support the coalition, such is my belief that there are times when the Constitution gives adequate guidance to the Head of State without the partisan hacks getting in the way...
 
The coalition of losers was a true coalition, but unlike Peterson's deal with the NDP, neither of those parties had the largest number of seats in the House. Hence, the "coalition of losers" tag. They did not go to the GG and ask permission to form a government, which is what is actually required, but attempted this sneaky back room approach, with Layton telling Harper not to fight it, but just walk away and accept the inevitable. It was already a done deal.

Complete rubbish. Their plan was to approach the GG and ask to form the government. That was Harper's plan too, when his party did not have the largest number of seats, and he wanted the GG to make him Prime Minister anyway. Did you misrepresent this on purpose, or was it an honest failure of understanding on your part?
 
I did not represent anything...HARPER went to GG...I SAID THAT.

Fuji...Lets just agree to disagree.

You being wrong..

the right being right!!!

:)
 
For the record, I said at the time that I would have accepted her judgement if it had been to support the coalition, such is my belief that there are times when the Constitution gives adequate guidance to the Head of State without the partisan hacks getting in the way...

Sadly, I didn't want the GG to take the correct path. I didn't like Dion as PM. The GG choses the PM to form a government - I read that it is possible for the GG to select someone who isn't even a member but it wouldn't be done.
 
Saying they were 'pretty' much identical makes my point Dude. THEY were not the same DUDE.

The only material difference is that back then the Liberals were in power, and the coalition was Conservative-Bloc-NDP, and the second time the Conservatives were in power and the coalition was Liberal-Bloc-NDP.

There's no other difference.

Harper remained the GG of the option to call on him...she questioned his ability to form a coalition Dude - as per CONSTITUTION...and agreements needed to be reached.

This is false. Completely and utterly false. No formal or informal coalition needs to be formed. The GG simply approaches the leader of the 2nd largest party and asks if they think they can form a government. And that's it.

IN THIS CASE....JACK AND IGGY went to the back rooms...ignored prrotocol..ignored the GG..ignored the constitution....and tried to figure out a way to get power..minus the GG.

Completely false. Their intention was to vote down the government and then approach the GG and ask for form a new government as an alternative to an election. You don't have the least foggiest smallest tiniest itsy bitsy clue what you are talking about.
 
Did you misrepresent this on purpose, or was it an honest failure of understanding on your part?

If this was their plan, why did they not then go to the GG? These guys held a press conference! And please, tell me what it is that I have misrepresented? I'll trust you to point out my "failure". No wait a minute - that what my wife is for...
 
Yeah, I didn't know that about Iggy and it really sours me on him.

I don't like Harper. I would never vote for the NDP or Layton, so I was figuring to hold my nose and vote for Iggy. This revalation by Layton was an eye opener for me and it would take full breathing gear to vote for Iggy now.

I can only hope that Harper gets a minority, Iggy resigns and slithers back to Harvard, and Frank Mckenna runs for and wins the liberal leadership.

Why would that sour you. The leader of the opposition has a lot of other responsibilities as does the PM. So full time attendance is not necessary when you have a substantial number of seats.
 
Jack won the debate, but it won't change my vote. The Liberals, even with Ignatieff, are much better than Harper. Jack seems okay (debatable) but he has no chance of winning, so voting for him is a wasted vote.

No vote is a "wasted" vote. It's true that Layton would need more than a miracle to win this election, but if you truly think he is the best candidate and agree more with the NDP party than other parties, your vote (and other's who think voting for them would be a waste) can help boost their base which increases their influence in parliament and could shape future elections for them.
 
The smart money says..speak to the audience. Harper was quite smart in not engaging the other guys in the spat, but looking into the camera is a smart move. VERY SMART!!

I'm surprised smart guys like the others, would not have at least gotten advice to do the same. Not too savvy!!
 
The smart money says..speak to the audience. Harper was quite smart in not engaging the other guys in the spat, but looking into the camera is a smart move. VERY SMART!!

I'm surprised smart guys like the others, would not have at least gotten advice to do the same. Not too savvy!!

The smart money is you make eye contact with everyone, especially the one who asked the question. Harper's avoidance was noted by many so far today especially a couple of communication experts.