Leaders' Debate

Jack won the debate, but it won't change my vote. The Liberals, even with Ignatieff, are much better than Harper. Jack seems okay (debatable) but he has no chance of winning, so voting for him is a wasted vote.
 
The debate was a big waste of my time. Didn't change my opinion on who I will vote for at all.
 
Just because it didn't change your mind does not mean it was a waste of time. Harper was in good form, he is a pro. But I think the others were very effective in cornering him on some key points. He persisted with his deny, deny, deny strategy. What does "other options" mean? Also I think Iggy made a good point about Harper dismissing "bickering" in parliament. Unfortunately bickering is a big part of true democracy. Debate, advocacy and opposition are essential to the system of democracy. Harper showed his preference to rule by edict. I thought the tough on crime legislation and the politics of fear points were also very important to make. I thought Duceppe made some excellent points, but he was difficult to understand. Layton brought up proportional representation, which I think would be a better system for our country.
 
I think Iggy blew it. He seemed angry but much too aloof.

I thought Layton seemed the most likeable, while Harper seemed the most professional and, surprisingly, more genuine than expected.

By the way, my comments are only based on how they presented themselves. There wasn't anything new in terms of content, so I only looked at how the leaders came across on TV.
 
I believe Layton came off as doing very well.

Hard for Harper as he was attacked from every angle. But I think he weathered the attacks and came out as the adult among children.

Duceppe is such an empty suit. Why the hell was he even there? Go win your useless 20 seats from rural Quebec that mean nothing Gilles and shut up. You'll still get your money from Ottawa. The guy is a 1st class weasel.

Ignatieff was unbelieveably scripted since he could never seem to get his point across clearly. Made him seem very unintelligent. He seemed to repeat himself 20+ times. If I hear his voice say "jets and jails" one more time I think I may collapse into a fit of uncontrollable nausea.
 
Just because it didn't change your mind does not mean it was a waste of time. Harper was in good form, he is a pro. But I think the others were very effective in cornering him on some key points. He persisted with his deny, deny, deny strategy. What does "other options" mean? Also I think Iggy made a good point about Harper dismissing "bickering" in parliament. Unfortunately bickering is a big part of true democracy. Debate, advocacy and opposition are essential to the system of democracy. Harper showed his preference to rule by edict. I thought the tough on crime legislation and the politics of fear points were also very important to make. I thought Duceppe made some excellent points, but he was difficult to understand. Layton brought up proportional representation, which I think would be a better system for our country.

Your spot on! What struck me is how well Harper lied, he has truely evolved. Before this debate I thought highly of Layton, but tonight he seemed to me to be more of a city counsellor type than a Prime Minister. Iggy was better than I expected, which isn't really saying much but he is the only one that can give Harper a challenge outside of Quebec.

Duceppe did a good job and will dominate in Quebec.
 
I believe Layton came off as doing very well.

Hard for Harper as he was attacked from every angle. But I think he weathered the attacks and came out as the adult among children.

Duceppe is such an empty suit. Why the hell was he even there? Go win your useless 20 seats from rural Quebec that mean nothing Gilles and shut up. You'll still get your money from Ottawa. The guy is a 1st class weasel.

Ignatieff was unbelieveably scripted since he could never seem to get his point across clearly. Made him seem very unintelligent. He seemed to repeat himself 20+ times. If I hear his voice say "jets and jails" one more time I think I may collapse into a fit of uncontrollable nausea.

Had trouble concentrating on your post, my eyes kept going to your sig. pic
 
Duceppe is such an empty suit. Why the hell was he even there? Go win your useless 20 seats from rural Quebec that mean nothing Gilles and shut up. You'll still get your money from Ottawa. The guy is a 1st class weasel.

Having him in there was pointless. He really doesn't belong on a national stage because he only cares about Quebec. He should just participate in the French language debate only.
 
I listened to it on the radio...long drive home.

No knock-out punch was delivered. It sounded somewhat boring and almost routine.

* Harper: Predictable and even tempered. Stuck with his "focus on the economy" game plan, which is his strength given the global economic conditions
* Iggy: Families, families, families! Nice to see the federal counterparts are keen on promoting the nanny state. Spent more time attacking the conservatives than promoting his own party
* Jack: Always good for a laugh or two, however if the NDP ever got in power...God help us all! We would be financially bankrupt inside of a year. Jack seems to think that every senior should be wealthy, every family will have a doctor and home care 24/7...and the greedy corporations will pay for it all. Sorry Jack, they don't pay uh, jack! Pie in the sky dreams will come out of our pocket.
* Duceppe: Why bother showing up. Seriously. He brings nothing to the show. Dig up the corpse of Levesque, at least he had some personality!

Did the debate change my vote? No.

Too bad there is not a competent, young, aggressive alternative candidate/party out there...It's high time to rid ourselves of these tired old white guys.
 
I'll just vote based on the colour of each party's logo.

Will that be green? lol

Debate was predictible, just like all the others. Didn't miss much if you didn't see it.
 
Very accurate summary.

Layton and Duceppe??? Cmon guys, does anybody take either of these two clowns seriously?
 
Having him in there was pointless. He really doesn't belong on a national stage because he only cares about Quebec. He should just participate in the French language debate only.

What about english speaking Quebekers? Yes Duceppe represents only a province, but I see regionalism as a growing trend. The Cons are largely a western party and the libs are stronger in the east. I welcome Duceppe into the debate. I think he made some excellent points, especially on how Harper refused to cooperate and pass tough on crime legislation for political reasons. As a result a bike gang leader is now walking the streets in Quebec after serving only 1/6th of his sentence. I think one big breakthrough is that Harper seemed to agree to the release of the AG's report. I wonder if he will now try to weasel out of that one?
 
I think one big breakthrough is that Harper seemed to agree to the release of the AG's report. I wonder if he will now try to weasel out of that one?

That was going to happen anyway, whether at the debate or shortly thereafter, no breakthrough IMO. The press and other party leaders wouldn't let him get away with that one and would have increased the rhetoric significantly just before the election if he didn't release it.
 
It's easy for Harper to agree to releasing the report, since.. it's not under his control. Or any of the other leaders (but they already knew that and were being disingenuous).
 
*Harper did the best, as he played the good son. Stayed calm and collective, and remained as an adult in front of two children.
*Jack Laydon came across as a bullshiter, and his talks didn't have any sound game plan. He spend too much time ripping up Iggy, him not being in cabinet 70% of the time and then Harper for lying. But if they did get elected into office, it would spell trouble there game plan is for the seniors, when the majority of us are young, hardworking canadians.
*Michael, his eyebrow color didn't match the color of his hair and looked off. He spend too much time attacking the conversatives and not enough time promoting his new plan. Raising corporate taxes isn't a good idea if you asked me during this economic recession.
*Bloc they will get the majority in Quebec.

One thing Layton mentioned is that we should have a mixed representational proportional system, which would be a better model for our country. I agree.
 
CBC reported that Layton was the most appealing in the debate according to a group compromised of mainly young voters. They said he was the only one that made any sense. I guess they didn't live through the last NDP Ontario government under Bob Rae, lol.
 
I saw no clear winner, but Harper has the easiest job of just stand and take it and that's what he did. I couldn't get use to him talking to Iggie, but looking at the camera, as he obviously was advise to do by his handlers. Iggie at least looked at the guy talking to him.

No knock out punch.

I won't watch the French debate tomorrow. I hate simultaneous translation. I'll wait for the book to come out.
 
It's easy for Harper to agree to releasing the report, since.. it's not under his control. Or any of the other leaders (but they already knew that and were being disingenuous).

I don't think so. Some elements of the report have been leaked. They could be construed as damaging. When this happens a full release is typically the solution. If all the part leaders agree to it, I can't see why the AG would not release it as long as she still gets her day in Parliament to report on the contents as well offer recommendations.