Man, this is bloody complicated. Let's turn the clock back a little further. Was the Middle East a land of milk, honey, sweetness, prosperity and peace before the arrival of the white man?So there. Middle East history the way I see it, in a nutshell.
Man, this is bloody complicated. Let's turn the clock back a little further. Was the Middle East a land of milk, honey, sweetness, prosperity and peace before the arrival of the white man?
+1.So there. Middle East history the way I see it, in a nutshell.
It's impossible to know because US foreign policy is run by a bunch of overzealous clowns.
The creation of ISIS and their invasion of Western Iraq represents a major intelligence failure and a major policy blunder.
Despite spending Billions of dollars every year to operate their intelligence and surveillance operations, they failed to anticipate the rise of ISIS, its invasion of Iraq, and the creation of a major antagonist in the region.
It was not so long ago that the US was fighting insurgents in Anbar Province at great cost. Now, that is all for nothing as ISIS rules the area with an iron fist.
Man, this is bloody complicated. Let's turn the clock back a little further. Was the Middle East a land of milk, honey, sweetness, prosperity and peace before the arrival of the white man?
I think I will let wilbur come up with the full answer! :biggrin1:Man, this is bloody complicated. Let's turn the clock back a little further. Was the Middle East a land of milk, honey, sweetness, prosperity and peace before the arrival of the white man?
Man, this is bloody complicated. Let's turn the clock back a little further. Was the Middle East a land of milk, honey, sweetness, prosperity and peace before the arrival of the white man?
I think I will let wilbur come up with the full answer! :biggrin1:
The short answer is that quite often it was. Beginning about 900 A.D. the Muslims and Jews together built a golden age along the eastern and southern shore of the Mediterranean while Europe slumbered in the Dark Ages. It flourished in Spain until the Moors were kicked out in the late 15th century and, then, the Jews.
Indeed, for all their faults the Ottomans were able administrators of their empire and kept it reasonable peaceful. Certainly, Jews and Muslims lived in relative harmony and achieved great advances in commerce, medicine, architecture, etc.
Perry
OMG Wilbur!The target audience is indeed the West and the so-called moderate Muslims. They are daring them to come and take them out. Air power alone will never do it. Only a ground campaign will do so and only Iraq and the West's enemies Syria and Hezbollah (supported by Iran) are engaged on the ground against ISIS.
ISIS is reading the situation very well. As long as the US and it's client states obsess about getting rid of Assad first (because Syria is allied with Iran), they know they can get away with what they're doing and reinforce their claim to a separate and independent state.
Meanwhile, despite 3000 western funded and trained 'moderate' Syrian rebels having defected last year with their weapons to Al-Qaida and ISIS, stupid US politicians are going to train another 5000, and they think they can make a difference against 30,000 (and growing) ISIS jihadists.
The US and its Arab allies have to make up their minds who they want to fight: the Shiites allied to Iran (Syria, Hezbollah), or the Sunnis (ISIS) attempting to slaughter the Shiites, including the Shiites who control the Iraqi government. They can't do both at the same time. Given that ISIS is now threatening Sunni regimes (including their original benefactors Saudi-Arabia, Qatar and UAE), the logical choice is quite clear. But logic is not something US politicians and their allies are known for.
C;mon Wilbur, I think you know perfectly well theres someone else playing on the ground of this sandbox......only Iraq and the West's enemies Syria and Hezbollah (supported by Iran) are engaged on the ground against ISIS.
OMG Wilbur!
Everything else you've written in this thread thus far is damn near perfect, and then you go make a mistake like this:
C;mon Wilbur, I think you know perfectly well theres someone else playing on the ground of this sandbox......
It's impossible to know because US foreign policy is run by a bunch of clowns.
The creation of ISIS and their invasion of Western Iraq represents a major intelligence failure and a major policy blunder.
Despite spending Billions of dollars every year to operate their intelligence and surveillance operations, they failed to anticipate the rise of ISIS, its invasion of Iraq, and the creation of a major antagonist in the region.
It was not so long ago that the US was fighting insurgents in Anbar Province at great cost. Now, that is all for nothing as ISIS rules the area with an iron fist.
Its hard to say who really runs US foreign policy. Be it the State Dept, CIA, NSA, Homeland Security, Department of Commerce or IRS. The you have the DOD. It is fragmented and incoherent and all these massive departments are at odds with each other. I wonder if Hillary could see the shit about to hit the fan so she punched out before her presidential run got splattered.
Clinton left a legacy behind her. She appointed Victoria Newland, Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs. She happens to be a confirmed Neocon. She's married to neocon Paul Kagan, who co-authored the "Project for a New American Century" with Paul Wolfowitz, then Under Secretary of State for Policy under Bush 1, and Assistant Secretary of Defense under Bush 2. Wolfowitz, Cheney, Rumsfeldt, Pearle, and the rest of the 24 or so ideologues in successive Republican administrations were called the 'crazies' before they were called 'neocons'.
So you have to ask yourself whether Clinton is a neo-liberal, or a closet neo-con.
So who runs US foreign policy? It's not the NSA, or the State Department, not the CIA nor the DOD. It's the think tank neocons who happened to be hired by the heads of cabinet, like Clinton as Secretary of State. Under George Dubya Bush, it was the neocons under Rumsfeldt in the DOD, under the watchful eye of Dick Cheney, the head neocon; the State Dept was shut out.
The inner cabinet will very often ignore the advice and expertise of professional analysts in the State Department and the military planners and senior generals in the Pentagon in order to push for an ideological agenda. Sometime, the pros win, but very often, they lose. Obama almost bombed Syria last year, but was convinced otherwise by a delegation of 4 star generals. When the US invaded Iraq, the advice of the State Department and even the CIA was ignored in favour of the ideologues in the inner circle who wanted control of the Middle East and its riches.
That has been happening for so long now that we hardly recognize the existence of democratic values any more!Party ideology is overtaking democratic values in western society.