Jewish Achievements

Perry Mason said:
I have often wondered why I have experienced everything from slight dislike to intense hatred from some Christians simply because I am a Jew... so I am very interested in knowing why those who hate me hate me... and damn the political correctness as long as you are honest, respectful and open minded.



Any takers?


No problem


I have a lot of respect for their contributions to literature and the sciences
and their fight against prosecution


What I dislike is the same thing I dislike about all cultures based on religion

they think they are the chosen

I feel the same way about mine -Christianity - which is based on Jewish religion (as is Islam)

Buddism is an exception to this because it is a science not a religion


The other thing about Jews is their business practices

I have been ripped off by Jews to the point I will not deal with them anymore

too many Jews think ethical business practice is a game to be won

this is a generalization but has been my experience
 
There is an ancient thread to anti-Semitism that is passed on through families. Almost all serious religious people feel that if we are right then THEY are wrong. Europe was a 95% Christian continent when these views were really formed in the late middle ageas so a great playwrite like Shakespear could shamelessly create a character like Shylock in MOV and nobody really cared until modern times. Jews were a convenient scapegoat for every disaster, you see it couldn't be Christians and there were only a few Muslims in Spain and later the Balkans.

A lot of modern anti Jewish feeling I feel is jealousy because the community is quite successful, not all but many. Jews are not blameless. They exhibit a kind of paranoia about it but post Holocaust it is honestly come by. Diaspora Jews need to pull back on the Isreali government, it is the worst international advertisment they could possibly have. They don't agree of course and feel victimized but international opinion sees them as a pugnatious bully.

Hope that is something to chew on.
 
I have as much a problem with positive racism as I do with negative racism, for several reasons.

I remember a long time ago I read an article about the German post-war generation. One was quoted as saying he didn't feel the need to be at all penitent about the war, holocaust etc. An old jewish rabbi, commenting on that, said, well, that was all fine and good, but in that case you can't boast about the good in your history either. He had a point.

If you sing the praises of one group, you are in a sense lowering the value of the others. You are essentially following the logic of the 'master race' idea - not to kill anyone of course, but still, to elevate members of a group. You can't boast about the best members of your group and ignore the villains. Fair is fair.

Anyhow, groups groups groups, who gives a rats ass about groups, we are all individuals, not groups. This whole 'I'm proud of my heritage' thing is IMO pure bullshit. I didn't cross the ocean, clear the land, lay the railway tracks, fight in WWI and WWII, so why the heck should I get a warm glow about what my forefathers did?
 
spankingman said:
Most of Hollywood!

The motion picture industry got its start in NYC. During its infancy, the Gentiles felt this industry was "unworthy" of their involvement so the Jews stepped in to fill the void and later moved the industry to California.
 
Somehow I knew when I saw this thread that it was only a matter of time before it turned ugly.

Personally while I'm proud to be Jewish I'm not too keen on Jews being singled out for either positive or negative traits, whether they are generalizations or comments about specific people. We should all be proud to be who we are, and we should just recognize that good people and bad people come from all backgrounds.

Oh, and jerkchicken, your teacher was wrong, you can definitely convert to Judaism if you want, but it's not easy and the first few times you ask a Rabbi about it you'll be discouraged... you have to really want it and be persistent, but it's definitely possible. But it won't make you a great lover! For that you gotta be born into it!
 
poonhunter said:
If you have negative attitude towards it tell me why but i seriously will think poorly of you if you do. Let's hear why you don't like the image, non-Jews can partake.

This better not be one of those stupid, "But it's really a backwards Hindu symbol" comments...
 
Perry Mason said:
Oy vey!

You have no clue what you are talking about... and it shows!!!

Perry

Sorry Perry, you're wrong. You're Jewish yet you don't even know your own history.
 
vsailor said:
I could be wrong..but, I thought "Jewish" was a religion not a race.

Traditionally, being Jewish does in fact have a biological basis, and it is as much an ethno-cultural/racial group as any other, like the Germans or French.
 
Yoga Face said:
I worked at MIT, as a tradesman, and learned some fascinating information


By far and away the greatest number of students at MIT, in relation to population percentage, are Jewish


No other ethnicity comes close

Only one explanation - they have historically practiced gene pool manipulation to create a Superior race. This has been done culturally.
Greater emphasis to become a Rabbi, scientist etc. so those who become intellectuals have more children

Nobody knows for certain what the reason(s) are, but I specifically stated that the Jews diaspora has high IQ, because Israel has a rather low average IQ - it's essentially no different than any other Middle Eastern nation. Jews living abroad test higher, for whatever reasons. A "superior" intellect can be used for good and bad. Einstein gave us the atom bomb.



Yoga Face said:
As far as our culture goes ...

We care more about sports.


Quick quiz:

What professor from UT won the Nobel prize?
What pitcher from the Blue Jays won the Cy Young?
How many athletes can you name that are Jewish ?


This is just my humble theory. Anyone care too comment?

A historical cornerstone of Jewish culture has been to practice cultural/racial separatism, not unlike racial segregation. Their focus on education has come about largely as part of a group evolutionary strategy to maintain Jewish exclusivity, security, power, and to further other group interests. Every group does this to some degree, some far more successfully than others.
 
Perry Mason said:

I have often wondered why I have experienced everything from slight dislike to intense hatred from some Chistians simply because I am a Jew... so I am very interested in knowing why those who hate me hate me... and damn the political correctness as long as you are honest, respectful and open minded.

Open minded? Yes! Is that too much to ask?

Any takers? ;)

Perry


For many of the same reasons that many Christians and Gentiles experience everything from a slight dislike to an intense hatred from Jews. Ingroup/Outgroup resource competition.
 
You can now add DRABINSKY and GOTTLEIB to the list of Jewish "bad boys"

Their GREED got them this "change in lifestyle"
 
Yoga Face said:
No problem

they think they are the chosen
OK... this is an old and very deliberate misinterpretation of what “chosen people” means.

We, Jews, don’t consider this to be a boon or benefit, but the exact opposite, a burden... like “you are the people chosen to clear out the sewer trap!” So, why would we brag about it?

The task is to carry and be a constant reminder to the world of the message contained in the 10 commandments and the ethical obligations that come with it. It is the “price” we paid for freedom for slavery.

How Christians came to see it as arrogance, etc. is beyond us... you want to do it? Go ahead, take over from us!


Yoga Face said:
too many Jews think ethical business practice is a game to be won
You can say this of any given group... we don’t claim to be better or worse than any one else, in that sense. Don’t tell me you believe no one else in the world plays the game that way and compromises their ethics for the sake of money!


Mrbig1949 said:
Diaspora Jews need to pull back on the Isreali government, it is the worst international advertisment they could possibly have. They don't agree of course and feel victimized but international opinion sees them as a pugnatious bully.
You’d be surprised about the vigorous debate in the Jewish community over the what the Israeli government does or does not do and how many feel the same way as you do. But diaspora Jews are not Israeli citizens and cannot vote in Israeli elections; if nothing else, Israel is a vibrant democracy. Ten Jews, 11 opinions!

poonhunter said:
So the "facts" i posted are not true?
I have seen no facts posted by you.


poonhunter said:
btw getting angry online isn't the smartest thing one can do LMAO
poonhunter said:
Perry doesn't like Jewish jokes probably because he is a Jew but i'm sure he's given quite a few non-Jewish (other races) ones to his buddies *wink*

You know if you can't take it stop giving it.
poonhunter said:
What would a Jew say if he saw this symbol?

swastika.gif
poonhunter said:
It was suppose to be but i posted the wrong Swastika LOL
I guess this is what you call intelligent, honest, respectful dialogue?

Thanks, but no, thanks. You have the honour of being placed on my “ignore” list.


burt-oh-my! said:
If you sing the praises of one group, you are in a sense lowering the value of the others. You are essentially following the logic of the 'master race' idea - not to kill anyone of course, but still, to elevate members of a group. You can't boast about the best members of your group and ignore the villains. Fair is fair.
I don’t agree that singing the praises of one group means to lower the esteem of other.

Is that what you think you are doing when you sing our national anthem? Because I don’t!

burt-oh-my! said:
You can't boast about the best members of your group and ignore the villains. Fair is fair.
Agreed.


GotGusto said:
Sorry Perry, you're wrong. You're Jewish yet you don't even know your own history.
Yours is one of the oldest tricks in the debating book: “prove that I am wrong” – “prove or disprove a negative”!

If you have an opinion, state your reasons and argument, then I can respond. Otherwise, it’s like me saying to you “The Moon is made of cheese; prove that I am wrong.”

Nevertheless you might be interested in the history of the Khazars: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khazars

And, if you are open minded, you might be interested in recent genetic research which proves, unequivocally, that as many as 85% of Palestinians share the same, unique genetic markers with Ashkenazi Jews. http://www.the-engagement.org/default.asp

GotGusto said:
For many of the same reasons that many Christians and Gentiles experience everything from a slight dislike to an intense hatred from Jews
I have seen this on a one-to-one basis in the Jewish community but not dislike or hatred as a group... exept for one thing that we do "hold" against you collectively: your continued and false accusations that we are "Christ killers" and that we use the blood of Christian children to bake our Passover matzoh -- which have continued even after The Pope said it was a mistake and apologized for it!

Perry
 
Perry Mason said:
A PROPOSAL​

This could be a very interesting discussion if we could all put away our knives and agree to have an honest, respectful and tolerant exchange of ideas and opinions, no matter how deeply we may disagree... in other words, if we could listen to each other with the intention of learning rather than winning.

I have often wondered why I have experienced everything from slight dislike to intense hatred from some Chistians simply because I am a Jew... so I am very interested in knowing why those who hate me hate me... and damn the political correctness as long as you are honest, respectful and open minded.

Open minded? Yes! Is that too much to ask?

Any takers? ;)

Perry


This would be very interesting but chances of doing it in this forum are pretty much nill. If you can find the appropriate forum, I love to read some of the comments.
 
Judaism is a religion but it is also a culture. They teach their kids the keys to success - hard work, discipline and frugality (some may call it cheap). They also help each other as a community (the kibbutz). As such they have risen to prominent positions in most fields of study that has risen to instense forms of scrutiny (in some cases jealousy) from their peers. This breeds the anti-Semitism that is so apparent today.
 
jiiimmm said:
This would be very interesting but chances of doing it in this forum are pretty much nill. If you can find the appropriate forum, I love to read some of the comments.
Remains to be seen... I suspect that you are right and would like to be shown that I am wrong! :(

Perry
 
Yoga Face said:
I worked at MIT, as a tradesman, and learned some fascinating information


As far as our culture goes ...

We care more about sports.


Quick quiz:

What professor from UT won the Nobel prize?
What pitcher from the Blue Jays won the Cy Young?
How many athletes can you name that are Jewish ?


This is just my humble theory. Anyone care too comment?
I agree in the field of athletics Jewish people haven't excelled like they have in other disciplines. However, there are, and have been, a number of prominent major league baseball players who are Jewish

Ryan Braun (one of the best players in baseball)
Shawn Green (yes the former Blue Jay)
Ian Kinsler
Kevin Youkilis
Sandy Koufax (one of the best pitchers of all time)
 
Perry Mason said:
Yours is one of the oldest tricks in the debating book: “prove that I am wrong” – “prove or disprove a negative”!

If you have an opinion, state your reasons and argument, then I can respond. Otherwise, it’s like me saying to you “The Moon is made of cheese; prove that I am wrong.”

Nevertheless you might be interested in the history of the Khazars: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khazars

And, if you are open minded, you might be interested in recent genetic research which proves, unequivocally, that as many as 85% of Palestinians share the same, unique genetic markers with Ashkenazi Jews. http://www.the-engagement.org/default.asp


I have seen this on a one-to-one basis in the Jewish community but not dislike or hatred as a group... exept for one thing that we do "hold" against you collectively: your continued and false accusations that we are "Christ killers" and that we use the blood of Christian children to bake our Passover matzoh -- which have continued even after The Pope said it was a mistake and apologized for it!

Perry


Perry, just as an aside, all those "studies" have been conducted by... Jews. Look at the names, so take those findings with a grain of salt (Jewish manipulation in the social sciences, for example, is well documented). The fact that there has been interbreeding with others in the region over centuries is not surprsing. This doesn't change how, where, and when the Ashkenazi "Jews" became Jews. I can't go surfing around right now until my highspeed internet connection is restored.

I'm not a Christian. The Jewish and Christian versions of religion hold no sway with me.

Racialism and ethnocentrism go both ways. It's common knowledge that there are many anti-semites walking around. It is also common knowledge that many Jews believe they're superior to the 'dumb goyim' (ie. all non-Jews in the world). You can feign ignorance about this all that you want, but it does have at least some explanatory power for anti-semitism.
 
Rockslinger said:
(Disclosure: I am not Jewish.) Read an interesting article in the weekend papers about Jewish achievements.

Since 1950, roughly 30% of all Nobel Prizes awarded in literature, chemistry, physics and medicine have gone to Jewish recipients. Further, Jews have won 51% of the Wolf Prizes, 28% of the Max Planck Medals, 38% of the Dirac Medals, 37% of the Heineman Prizes and 53% of the Enrico Fermi Awards.

This is an amazing contribution to the world in the fields of literature, science and medicine from an ethnic group that is no more than 13 million people.


How many HEISMANS NHL-NFL-MLB-NBA Awards?