Jewish Achievements

Rockslinger said:
(Disclosure: I am not Jewish.)
This is an amazing contribution to the world in the fields of literature, science and medicine from an ethnic group that is no more than 13 million people.

I worked at MIT, as a tradesman, and learned some fascinating information


By far and away the greatest number of students at MIT, in relation to population percentage, are Jewish


No other ethnicity comes close

Only one explanation - they have historically practiced gene pool manipulation to create a Superior race. This has been done culturally.
Greater emphasis to become a Rabbi, scientist etc. so those who become intellectuals have more children



Elsewhere the poor have more children as they were a form of old age security


As far as our culture goes ...

We care more about sports.


Quick quiz:

What professor from UT won the Nobel prize?
What pitcher from the Blue Jays won the Cy Young?
How many athletes can you name that are Jewish ?


This is just my humble theory. Anyone care too comment?
 
Perry Mason said:
OK... I agree to disagree.


Not so. Not that simple. You are ignoring a great deal of scholarship and research that has gone into this question over the years, as if it did not exist... especially the genetic research.

I am a Jew because my mother was Jewish... even if I practice any other religion!

But if you choose to ignore scholarship, etc. you can say anything you want... though your saying so does not make it so.

Perry

Last time I checked, there were 5 races:

Mongoloid
Caucasoid
Negroid
Australoid
Capoid

None of these have anything to do with religion.

I don't care what any religious scholar has to say frnakly since religion is simply a concept that mankind has come up with over the years to try and attribute our existance to one higher power or another. Religions come and go.
 
Yoga Face said:
Quick quiz:

What professor from UT won the Nobel prize?
What pitcher from the Blue Jays won the Cy Young?




Frederick Banting and ??? Don't know, Clemens, Doc, Stieb or Morris?????

How did I do Yoga Face?

Winstar, you say you're not a racist, but judging from your posts I would suggest you have a bit of that in you. Generalized statements about a race, religious group, colour or any other sector in society is typically an indication of a racist. There are good and bad apples in all groups, but to pick on one group and characterize all of them as arrogant and racist is an indication of a racist.
 
Mia.Colpa said:
Frederick Banting and ??? Don't know, Clemens, Doc, or Morris????

How did I do Yoga Face?


Not very good but you got Banting which is commendable for a Canadian :rolleyes:

Banting won in 1923 for Medicine

Polanyi, from the UT, won in 1986 for chemistry


"Doc" Haliday pitches for the Jays and is considered the best in baseball
 
asn said:
Do you seriously believe only Jews do this?
Historically they have had this culture since Moses.


asn said:
A prof of mine in HS was best friends with a dean in MIT. He said if I wanted to go it was no problem he would have a word with his friend. The Ivy league schools are about connections. That there are a lot of Jews in there is no surprise. .

How do you think Bush and Cheney went to Ivy college? Connections!

Once there everyone passes because they paid for it. Just take the easy stuff. Bush admitted he is an alcoholic. Where do you think he learned to drink?

But MIT ???? There are no Mickey Mouse courses their, are there?

How can you get an engineerring degree from MIT without working hard and being a genius?
asn said:
As far as Nobel Prizes give it a hundred or two hundred years more. The Chinese and Indians will be winning a lot more.

They have, throughout history, been superior to the Europeans in lots of intellectual fields. With their population explosion and emphasis on brains -we emphasis sports and entertainment - they will surpass us with ease
 
poonhunter said:
I'm a Jew because some people call me "frugal" otherwise known as cheap and i have NO religion
I am not surprised to see some of you closet bigots coming out of the closet when you can do so anonymously. :p

Perry
 
Mia.Colpa said:
Winstar, you say you're not a racist, but judging from your posts I would suggest you have a bit of that in you. Generalized statements about a race, religious group, colour or any other sector in society is typically an indication of a racist. There are good and bad apples in all groups, but to pick on one group and characterize all of them as arrogant and racist is an indication of a racist.

We all generalize. It's a basic cognitive schema human beings incorporate to organize information about the world. For example, when it's cloudy, we generalize that it's going to rain. It doesn't always (as in it could also mean a snowfall in winter), but these generalizations serve us in these circumstances. To say someone generalizes and it's wrong to generalize, as if you yourself do not, is actually quite ridiculous. I am sure you also make generalizations about people, about race, about their capabilities, based on their age, or gender, or whatever criteria you choose.

The key is that generalizations, if they occur, should be positive ones. I am not saying that there are not individuals who do not fit this mold, but based on my observations this doesn't seem to be the case. In the end, my perceptions about people are the most relevant to me and how it affects my life (as yours are to you also), but that doesn't mean I have to agree with everything here, or can't share my perspective being that I don't necessarily agree with something because it came from Jewish person or that I cannot disagree without being called a racist or anti-semite. This is wrong also.

Positive generalizations are based on one's perceptions. and if those perceptions are not backed by more positive experiences than negative ones, then that person will not have a positive view of said community. I think discussing issues of race and how we all get along, or if we have problems from a group (or groups) is important in a multicultural city like Toronto. We have to be able to say what we don't like about a particular group, if we want to see changes occur. Without discussion, progress may never occur. It also tends to reinforce one's belief that they are better than everyone else, and no one else's feelings matter. But if someone says "Hey I have a problem with your group and here is why", and it is well thought out, then I don't see that as a disadvantage. The problem is, we are socialized to be quiet about our true feelings towards one another, and feel socially stigmatized when we speak up and express why we feel the way we do. I think to progress we need to move beyond this. It is not useful anymore to keep quiet about one another as if each group only participates in this society in only a positive way, when in fact this may not be the case. In this case, I have a problem with the Jewish community, in that I do tend to find them racist and arrogant, and yet expects everyone else to treat them in a non-racist fashion.

Umm nope.

You want people from other groups to respect you, you've got to do the same, And that doesn't include isolating yourself from everyone, and treating them like they are beneath you because you aren't the same race as them. This isn't racist of me to say this, if I am pointing out another group's racist behavior and I have a problem with it.
 
Winstar...

Your logic is transparent... what a piece of work you are!

Perry
 
Bush was Ivey League.

Cheney got kicked out of Yale and ended up at the University of Wyoming. He came from a very modest up bringing and it is doubtful he had any serious connections.

Bush however is a different story.
 
Some of the anti-Semetic bigotry is astonishing. Seems most of it is based on ignorance. I'm no big fan of Isreali government policy. I think they often do things which makes things worse for both Isreali Jews and Jews in the diaspora but you guys are raising all of the old canards that have been dealt with for centuries. I'm surprised we haven't heard about the forgeries of the Protocals of the Elders of Zion. We have heard everything else. It is 2009 people, wake up. It is exactly this shit that comes out from under a rock with every recession.
 
james t kirk said:
Bush was Ivey League.

Cheney got kicked out of Yale and ended up at the University of Wyoming. He came from a very modest up bringing and it is doubtful he had any serious connections.

Bush however is a different story.


You are correct

I saw a documentary on Cheney

It was not very complimentary about his intellectual prowness

Forgot why he got kicked out

I think he was a party boy and drinker like Bush

Bush also got initiated into the secretive "Skull and Bones Society" while at Yale

It is said to be a conspiratorial group that has secretly controlled the world for centuries - What is that called? There is a word for a secretive backroom controlling group

I say it is a bunch of elitists forming their own boys club to feel superior
 
Mrbig1949 said:
Some of the anti-Semetic bigotry is astonishing. Seems most of it is based on ignorance. I'm no big fan of Isreali government policy. I think they often do things which makes things worse for both Isreali Jews and Jews in the diaspora but you guys are raising all of the old canards that have been dealt with for centuries. I'm surprised we haven't heard about the forgeries of the Protocals of the Elders of Zion. We have heard everything else. It is 2009 people, wake up. It is exactly this shit that comes out from under a rock with every recession.

I agree with this complexly.

One thing I've noticed with the Jewish families I know is the focus on children - the culture as I've witnessed it is so child centric that it's not surprising that these kids grow up to be successful adults.

If you want to find the strongest critics of Israeli policy you'll find them in the Jewish community. I was at a dinner party last week where one Jewish woman said "the Israelis are treating the Palestinians like the Nazis treated the Jews, why are we supporting that"..... pretty heated exchange I can tell you.

OTB
 
I admired Jewish people so much, especially for their scientific achievements, I was a big fan of Einstein. Always thought they are the smartest poeple. I had high IQ and smartass myself in school, so I had a lot of Jewish friends. Also I liked their culture and food. So I wanted to become a Jewish myself...

me: Teacher teacher! How can I become a Jew?
teacher: no hun, you can't. You have to be born Jewish.
me: but I thought Jewish is a religion, just like Christianity or Budism, why can't I be converted?
teacher: no Judaism is a very special religion, only special "chosen people" born with their genes can join their exclusive society.
me: [sad....]


So there, I still think most of Jewish people are nice and like their culture, but from that day on, I felt left out and rejected by the very people I loved so much. Why can't Jewish society be more open and accept people of all background to participate in their religion?
 
jerk chicken said:
How can I become a Jew?

Claim to be a member of the lost seventh tribe
 
Yoga Face said:
Claim to be a member of the lost seventh tribe

no but seriously, I tried to study at a jewish community center. because I was awaiting for a Jewish friend of mine. I got denied entrance by the security because I was not a Jew. Not until my friend showed up, they let me in. I felt like an outcast, or even worse victim of racism!
 
A PROPOSAL​

This could be a very interesting discussion if we could all put away our knives and agree to have an honest, respectful and tolerant exchange of ideas and opinions, no matter how deeply we may disagree... in other words, if we could listen to each other with the intention of learning rather than winning.

I have often wondered why I have experienced everything from slight dislike to intense hatred from some Chistians simply because I am a Jew... so I am very interested in knowing why those who hate me hate me... and damn the political correctness as long as you are honest, respectful and open minded.

Open minded? Yes! Is that too much to ask?

Any takers? ;)

Perry
 
Perry, I like your attitude man. a lot of my jewish friends feel the same. It is true there are still some anti-semites now, but a lot of times, people automatically assume the worst - especially someone talks about something controversial, because they are just ignorant or misinformced. For all we know is he was probably ignorant and insensative to a particular group. So instead of counter attacking him as a racist, and make him feel guilty, which will only make him even more defensive and in process we may create a real hater, we can try to educate him with real facts and un-brainwash him from the racist propaganda.