They are totally different.I find it interesting that MLB will allow this, but they won't allow the shift anymore. Both are forms of defensive strategy to deal with a particular offensive player's strength.
In one, the team is setting up prior to a ball being put in play. It's a pre-programmed strategy by the manager. In the other, there is no pre-planned strategy. The ball is put in play and then the players have to figure out the strategy, not the manager. Nobody knows where the ball is going to go or how fast or how high in advance. They have to think on their feet. That is the essence of defense.
If you think about it, there are probably thousands of different defensive strategies that varies from batter to batter if not pitch to pitch. I don't think that you can have one blanket rule that covers all of those strategies.



