Over the entire season I agree with you.
But check out his stats 15 days and 7 days before he was released.
Those were good numbers. Better than Cimber's numbers, thats for sure
It is not a choice of long term / short term. On June 8 (give or take a day or two) the Jays were required under MLB ROSTER RULES to demote somebody from the main roster. Bass at the time was the clear logical choice at the time as outlined below because he was a poor fit for what they needed, and other options to demote would not have cleared waivers.
Those numbers were not better than Cimber's numbers at the date of the designation. Cimber had an ERA of 3.94 - he was skeptical, but had not imploded either.
Players actually understand how roster rules, options, the 30 day rehab rule (forced call up) actually work. They realize that ANTHONY BASS WOULD HAVE BEEN DESIGNATED FOR ASSIGNMENT WHETHER HE WAS A TRUDEAU LOVER OR A TRUMP LOVER. It was a baseball move. Whether he would have been released after the 10 day DFA period is more open for debate. On June 8 he did not fit on the MLB roster and was an easy player to pass through waivers.
Remember that Bass was not released or DFA'd when he made the insensitive remarks initially because he still earned that roster spot. It was several weeks later that he was ultimately DFA'd - when the Jays were forced to demote somebody to call up Mitch White.
When Mitch White's 30 day rehab assignment ended, and HE HAD TO BE CALLED UP BY MLB RULES and Alex Manoah went down meaning they needed length out of the pen (which Bass could not provide). So let's look at the options at the time;
- Mitch White would have 100% been claimed on waivers (given his miniscule contract) if they did not recall him. And he fit the role.
- Bowden Francis would have almost certainly been claimed + he fit a role.
- Trever Richards and Anthony Bass were the worst relievers on the team at the time, and Richards can go 2-3 innings unlike Bass.
- Adam Cimber had an ERA of 3.94 at the time. He would have very likely been claimed on waivers (at that time) He was pitching better than Bass at the time (still stinky though), as a low leverage reliever. It made no sense to DFA him, at that time, instead of Bass. Unfortunately after the last 3 weeks, Cimber would also clear waivers.
- Anthony Bass was struggling and had a contract of $3m this year and next. HE WOULD NOT BE CLAIMED ON WAIVERS on performance alone due to his contract size that extended into 2024. He was easily the most logical DFA for baseball reasons.
DFA is not the same as release though - it just forces you to put a player through waivers, and then you have 10 days to call the player back up, At least at the end of the 10 day period (around June 18) there may have been a debate as to whether he fit on the roster (politics aside)... on June 8 the decision to DFA him was easy.
The real issue is here is that the Jays have some poor bullpen options and a lack of guys coming up to push for those spots.