Is this a good idea ?

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
Instead of mass voting a sample group of voters should make the decision after they have been educated via seminars on all major issues :confused:
 
People vote their conscience.
 
Instead of mass voting a sample group of voters should make the decision after they have been educated via seminars on all major issues :confused:
Certainly not in a democratic system of government. Instead of your proposal one could of course adopt Nevil Shute Norway's proposal of the multiple vote.

What you propose is really a form of Oligarchy.
 
What you propose is really a form of Oligarchy.

I disagree as everyone has the same chance of being in the sample group (if they so choose) and the group would be randomly chosen from the conforms of demographic makeup

What you have as a result is the vote the general public would have made if they were all educated

As well, even if you are not in the sample group you can still influence those who are through public argument
 
It's only a good idea for the people who get to vote.

Besides, who decides the content of the seminars? You might be imagining a situation where all sides of every issue are presented fairly and without bias, but in practice this would be very unlikely. Which means the people who do the educating may end up being the real oligarchs.

Better off sticking with democracy (or a democratic republic). As Churchill said: "Democracy is the worst form of government except for all those others that have been tried."
 
It's only a good idea for the people who get to vote.."

No as even those who cannot vote can still influence those who can which more meaningful than one pointless vote in millions

Besides, who decides the content of the seminars? You might be imagining a situation where all sides of every issue are presented fairly and without bias, but in practice this would be very unlikely. Which means the people who do the educating may end up being the real oligarchs.

Good point but everyone can speak within time limits I would suggest which is better than what we have now

Who speaks now ?? Only those allowed to by corpoate controlled media !
The question is is my idea an improvement not is it perfect
 
the whole point of a democracy is one person one vote, the choice of who votes is up tp the person .
 
Instead of mass voting a sample group of voters should make the decision after they have been educated via seminars on all major issues

Is this not our current system :confused: ...........a "sample group" is put in this position by a few people who BOTHER to vote and then lose their voice for another four or five years (min four) when they get voice again but seldom use it ...not reallya one person one vote ...boils down to representation of the polling turn out MAYBE if that turn out still agrees to what the member is voting

a member can be elected by 51% or less of a 10% electoral turn out so that is what 6% of the population in the area he /she represents so has to answer to very few





.
 
Instead of mass voting a sample group of voters should make the decision after they have been educated via seminars on all major issues :confused:

They already do - it's called Parliament. We don't all individually vote on every issue, we elect representatives who are expected to be knowledgeable about the bills they vote on.
 
No as even those who cannot vote can still influence those who can which more meaningful than one pointless vote in millions



Good point but everyone can speak within time limits I would suggest which is better than what we have now

Who speaks now ?? Only those allowed to by corpoate controlled media !
The question is is my idea an improvement not is it perfect

Corporate controlled media is the best kind there is! I mean, come on, all those earnest little independent newspapers and stuff must really suck, or else they'd be popular.
 
Corporate controlled media is the best kind there is! I mean, come on, all those earnest little independent newspapers and stuff must really suck, or else they'd be popular.

Good point ! Why does not the public choose independent newspapers ?


Reason

1 They do not advertise in order to keep their independence so they charge and the TV news is free

2 People fall for the conventional news line as it falls in line with their indoctrination and they do not want to rethink issues they want to watch the Leafs


3 The media moguls, and the corporate sponsers, have control over the airwaves so alternative thought is not broadcast to ther masses and can only be found by the few who search it out and most will not
 
They already do - it's called Parliament. We don't all individually vote on every issue, we elect representatives who are expected to be knowledgeable about the bills they vote on.

I am talking about electing the representatives
 
I can deal with what we have now, just tinker with it a bit.

We could incorporate everyone's first, second and third choice on one ballot, with computers we could weight them accordingly and determine who among them is acceptable to most people, not necessarily the favourite among them.
 
And who gets to be in your special little pool of voters?

I prefer democracy, not oligarchy.



EVERYONE IS ELIGIBLE and the sample pool includes all groups so it remains a democracy but now it is a democracy of the educated
 
EVERYONE IS ELIGIBLE and the sample pool includes all groups so it remains a democracy but now it is a democracy of the educated

So you're really talking about placing conditions on people's right to vote.

I think it is a bad idea.
 
I'd like to see the candidates backed by the wealthy given fewer advantages, let's keep cracking down on election expenses and donor limits.
 
EVERYONE IS ELIGIBLE and the sample pool includes all groups so it remains a democracy but now it is a democracy of the educated
Who decides who gets to be in the sample pool? I know you're thinking it would be random, but how do we ensure that it truly is random? Lot's of opportunity for corruption when some government agency is tasked with selecting the people who vote.

Your motivation is good - the general ignorance of voters is a flaw in democracy. But there are too many practical problems with the proposal to make it workable, even if you accept the basic principle.
 
Who decides who gets to be in the sample pool? I know you're thinking it would be random, but how do we ensure that it truly is random? Lot's of opportunity for corruption when some government agency is tasked with selecting the people who vote.

Your motivation is good - the general ignorance of voters is a flaw in democracy. But there are too many practical problems with the proposal to make it workable, even if you accept the basic principle.

Statistics prove a good sample group is accurate 99% of the time 99% of the time ... very close to hundred percent

I do not see many problems

It would be quicker and less expensive than traditional votes as campaigning is now restricted to the sample group

The one you pose is valid but not insurmountable ... you surrender too fast
 
No as even those who cannot vote can still influence those who can which more meaningful than one pointless vote in millions
How on earth to you figure that?! I should give up my vote to because I can "influence" an elector who may not pay any attention at all to what I say.

It sounds to me like you should instead be advocating the multiple vote.