Is "oriental" truly offensive?

Babypowder

Active member
Oct 28, 2007
1,869
0
36
I believe ford had to apologize because he said the orientals work likke dogs. And I seem to recall it was the worst apology ever. He brought out a flier and noodle wrapper that used term oriental in his apology.

Oriental is not the most acceptable term but it is not truly offensive. It will date you.

WG
to me he should be apologizing for stereotyping Asians instead of using the term Oriental. but thats just MHO
 

Clear History

New member
Mar 15, 2004
443
0
0
Thanks WG.

I think the "taking over" was the part considered most offensive even more so than the "work like dogs".

From wikipedia: Again sparking controversy during a March 2008 debate at City Hall, Ford said, "Those Oriental people work like dogs. They work their hearts out ... that's why they're successful in life. ... I'm telling you, Oriental people, they're slowly taking over, because there's no excuses for them. They're hard, hard workers."
 

paulman77

Banned
Nov 13, 2011
182
0
0
WTF! people take things too seriously... how else are we supposed to distinguish Orientals from South Asians then? Don't want us to use the words chink, gooks, japs etc, now orientals too?
At this rate the word Asian will become offensive soon too.
 

larry

Active member
Oct 19, 2002
2,070
4
38
that "oriental work hard' statement may have been the only truism in his so-far-reign. if canadians would work that hard, we'd be doing a lot better.
 

frankcastle

Well-known member
Feb 4, 2003
17,872
242
63
I think people got bent out of shape by Rob Ford because he made a generalization about people based on race. He was trying to complement asians from a percieved good work ethic. Not that bad of a thing to say.

But I think the expectation is that a voted representative is supposed to be held to higher standards of conduct.
 

frankcastle

Well-known member
Feb 4, 2003
17,872
242
63
I find it fucked up when people constantly use Asian when they mean oriental. Oh dude I really dig oriental chicks. Really, everything from Turkish and Israeli to Japanese and all chicks in between. Fuck dude, you might as well say you are a hetrosexual.

When you use the term Asian when you really and obviously mean oriental, it shows a gross geographic ignorance.


To me it is about as offensive as the use of Little People [I mean really should I pet them on the head and pinch the cheeks of midgets now?]
Or BCE instead of BC. Before Christ is offensive you must use Before Common Era. But wait, what year is used as the divider. Why the traditional year of the birth of our lord and savior. And the difference is what now?


Hot Asian chick

To some people the word asian means east asian to others it means the whole continent..... so I guess using a direction e.g. East, south, southeast helps to clarify what one is talking about.

On the other hand to me Chinese, Japanese and Korean are very unique (politically, linguistically, and in terms of food just to mention a few) so if possible I prefer to distiguish them.

Much like I'm sure Irish, Scottish, Welsh, English people might apprecciate being acknowledged. Same goes for all the branches of Christianity.

Of course if you didn't know which country someone was from I don't think anyone would care if someone said asian.

Oriental isn't fighting words though just funny sounding like coloured folk or negro.
 

ig-88

New member
Oct 28, 2006
4,729
4
0
it's not so much that it is offensive; it signifies ignorance

the equivalent word for Caucasians is "occidental" ... how often is THAT term used?

if "occidental" were used as often as "oriental," no problem
 

saliksalik

Active member
Sep 16, 2004
2,505
13
38
Toronto

WoodPeckr

Protuberant Member
May 29, 2002
46,949
5,755
113
North America
thewoodpecker.net
"Oriental" refers to THINGS from the Orient - such as food, rugs, souvenirs, etc...material THINGS. Therefore, when you call a human being "oriental" you are referring to them as an object with no soul or substance. This is why "Oriental" is offensive and LEGALLY a racist term (at least in the U.S.A. In Canada it's still a dubious term.)

I know an hot lady from Laos who says she is an Asian and was brought up and trained that Orientals live in China and Japan. I told her I thought Asian and Oriental were synonymous terms. She said NO! She said Oriental is a proper term to be used for those from China and Japan but since she is from Laos, she is Asian.
 

FatOne

Banned
Nov 20, 2006
3,474
1
0
To some people the word asian means east asian to others it means the whole continent....
But words have meaning. If someone started using the term human when they mean some subsector of humanity, they would be considered nuts. I refuse to engage in verbal contortion just because don't dingbats get their panties in a knot and the slightest thing, especially for no reason at all.

If I were to say I really dig mammals as pets and started to list of breeds of cats and only cats, any sane person [of which the anal politically correct crowd in this case are not included] would wonder why the fuck I didn't just say I dig cats. They would be right to do so.

From now on I will be politically correct. I won't use the term oriental, I will just use the term chainsaw to mean east asian.

Actually from now on, I term fat as offensive if used by anyone who isn't fat. I know demand that everyone the world use the term gravitationally challenged. There is a lot of bad history with the word fat and every time a non gravitationally challenged person uses it, they hurt my poor little feeweens. So it is no longer trans fats, that us just too hurtful, you must use trans gravitationally challenged food item. Or monounsaturated gravitationally challenged food item.
I demand and order you to do this because as you said in another thread, you are not in a position to say what is offensive and what isn't for fat people. If you don't you will be guilty of a hate crime.

In real life, if I were serious, you would tell me to go fuck myself, or you would if you were worthy of any respect and had the balls to stand up for yourself.

Hot asian, but not a hot chainsaw.
Kareena Kapoor
 

Viggo Rasmussen

New member
Feb 5, 2010
2,651
0
0
Lots of good responses.

So far, nobody has mentioned if they think agencies that use the term "Oriental" in their name are ignorant or mildly offensive or out of date. I'm guessing it's okay just as long as Rob Ford isn't operating it.
 

rld

New member
Oct 12, 2010
10,664
2
0
it's not so much that it is offensive; it signifies ignorance

the equivalent word for Caucasians is "occidental" ... how often is THAT term used?

if "occidental" were used as often as "oriental," no problem
except that language, and common parlance does not work like a computer program. I still have not seen anyone post what they want used as the replacement word. Asian is clearly far too broad.
 

ig-88

New member
Oct 28, 2006
4,729
4
0
"white" and "Caucasian" is too broad ... that could mean Brits, Irish, Greeks, Italians, Russians, Eastern Europeans, etc.

the term "oriental" has been used out of ignorance and alienation ... it implies that the person is foreign, not one of us

"Asian" at least implies that the person is a fellow countrymen ... just with an ancestry from a different continent
 

Viggo Rasmussen

New member
Feb 5, 2010
2,651
0
0
the term "oriental" has been used out of ignorance and alienation ... it implies that the person is foreign, not one of us
Are you saying that agencies who use the term "oriental" aren't run by Asians? Are the owners ignorant for using the word?
 

Carling

Banned
Apr 14, 2011
3,562
1
0
WTF! people take things too seriously... how else are we supposed to distinguish Orientals from South Asians then? Don't want us to use the words chink, gooks, japs etc, now orientals too?[/QUOTE]
what's with white people and their need to call us whatever they want???...so you want to use chink to describe us?...WTF?...i bet you want to use the N-word as well...know tonnes of white guys who are always like" well if they call each other that. why can't i?"...fuckin idiots
 

ig-88

New member
Oct 28, 2006
4,729
4
0
Are you saying that agencies who use the term "oriental" aren't run by Asians? Are the owners ignorant for using the word?
I don't know why some agency uses that term; maybe they did it out of ignorance themselves (because they didn't know any better and that's the only term they know), maybe they use the term because that is what is easier for their customers to identify with.

But this pales in comparison to the far more widespread use of the term by the majority society.
 

Viggo Rasmussen

New member
Feb 5, 2010
2,651
0
0
Thanks ig-88.
I was wondering why people didn't comment on agencies on here using the term, glad to read your perspective.
 

asterwald

Active member
Dec 11, 2010
2,579
0
36
Asian includes central Asia, like Iran, Azerbaijan, etc. South Asia, siberia.

Most "Asians" Like the Japanese, Korean live on islands. The only Asian ethnic groups that do live on the continent are the chinese and Mongolians.

South East Asians are different all together. I think using "Asian" is VERY confusing and demeaning towards other ethnicities as it almost always implies being North East Asian.
 
Toronto Escorts