Is God right wing?

screwge said:
Let me restate the question I am interested in. Why are the so-called Christian Right in Canada and the US so disconnected from Christian values?

I don't know that they are, I think the cliché view of the Christian Right is disconnected but not the real Christian Right.

Most "Right Christians" that I know are very generous souls, give tons of money but have fairly conservative social views (abortion, gay marriage).

OTB
 
Christian Right & Pharisees are the Same

screwge said:
Let me restate the question I am interested in. Why are the so-called Christian Right in Canada and the US so disconnected from Christian values?

That's easy because the Christian Right are more like those Pharisees from biblical times. Those 'money changers' from the Bible that Christ, (WHO BTW WAS THE FIRST ORIGINAL HIPPY) threw out of the Temple!
 
screwge said:
Is God right wing?
Is the “religious right� an oxymoron?

One thing I have never been able to fathom, is how Christians in the US or anywhere claim that right wing issues are God’s issues.

Principles I learned as a Christian seem to support the other conclusion, such as:

1. do unto others as you would have them do unto you
2. I am my brother’s keeper
3. the meek shall inherit the earth
4. suffer the little children to come to me
5. Jesus threw the money changers out of the temple
6. Jesus healed the sick, inspired the disadvantaged
7. turn the other cheek
8. Jesus forgave those that betrayed him

The list goes on. Jesus taught tolerance, acceptance, respect for others, caring for others. Jesus recognized a separation between church and state: render under Ceasar what is Ceasar’s and render unto God what is God’s.

The US seems to be fearful that Muslim fundamentalists are taking over states in the Middle East, a fear I share, but they seem not to recognize that the US government is being heavily influenced by Christian fundamentalists, who, in my view, are not espousing true Christianity. Why is there such a disconnect?

I thought he had two wings....
 
Back to the original question of this thread: "is god right-wing?"

Of course it depends to which god one is referring. While most of the rest of this thread deals with the gods described in a certain book of legends referred to as the "bible", I will attempt to answer the question from the point of view of the True God.

1. The Great Pumpkin is the True God.

2. The Great Pumpkin (aka God) is neither right wing nor left wing. He is rather spherical in nature and has no "wings". God doesn't care for elephants who trample through His Pumkin Patch, but He figures that most donkeys are just asses.

3. God's favourite colour is orange, not red or blue.

4. God is pleased if you wait up for Him in the Pumpkin Patch next October 31, but you won't be punished too severely if you don't.

5. Those who mock the Great Pumpkin are doomed never to kick a football again.

6. Don't go around blaming God for hunger, famine, hurricanes, death, disease, Bob Goodenow, earthquakes or war. He's just a pumpkin for God's sakes !!!!

7. God won't get you out of shit that you caused yourself just because you get on your knees and beg Him to - stand up, be a man, and fix your own shit.

8. The stem on top of the pumpkin is not a dildo - but He doesn't mind if you use it as one.

9. God doesn't really mind if you worship Yahweh, Jesus or Allah instead of Him. But he'd like you to eat Pumpkin Pie on Sunday and give a little something to the little rugrats who will come around begging for candy Sunday night.

10. God isn't fussy about the form of worship. Whether you read the bible, light a candle in a cathedral, pray in a mosque, perform transcendental meditation, or have a beer while watching the ball game, it all counts as worship to him. We've been lobbying Him to include CBJ as a form of worship (or even BBBJ for the sectarians), and are expecting approval of this by year's end.
 
Is God right wing?

No.

He's just God. He doesn't take sides, He just sits in the bleachers and watches the show.

Not sure if He's George Burns, Morgan Freeman or "The Hot Guy" on Joan of Arcadia, but the one thing I do believe is that He gave us all free will - like it or lump it.

May we all go with God.
 
assoholic said:
..some of the biggest assholes I have ever met were born again Christians, they talk about compassion, charity exct, but thats all they do talk about it. Its like their religion gives them an excuse to be a jerk,maybe becuase when they go to Church they think they have their sins forgiven , at least for another week.
IM Born-Again,and all my sins have been forgiven,past.present and future.
 
screwge said:
Let me restate the question I am interested in. Why are the so-called Christian Right in Canada and the US so disconnected from Christian values?
This is easy,Right-wing Christians vote on these two issues,Pro-life,anti-gay marriage.George Bush is a Christian and supports both..Thats it.
 
Thanks DonQ for the reference to the Duke U article about the beliefs of the Christian right. I read it carefully. This has made me more concerned than ever that the so-called Christian right has moved so far away from the tenets of Christianity that its name is a misnomer.

The article says the 4 pillars of the Christian right are:

1. they believe in moral absolutes (examples: fixity of sexual identities; capitalism, hard work, sanctity of unborn life)

[I haven’t read anything about these things in the New Testament; what I have read is that Christ threw the capitalists out of the temple; he preached tolerance and acceptance]

2. morals, politics, and customs are embedded in a continuum such that distinctions cannot be drawn between public and private spheres of life.

[this continuum is a social construct and has nothing to do with Christianity; Christ said render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s and render unto God what is God’s. This says one can make distinctions)

3. the government’s role is to cultivate virtue, preserve the authority of the Bible, not interfere with the operation of the marketplace or workplace – honesty, truthfulness and patriotism should be guided and laziness and unpatriotic actions should not be rewarded.

[This is weird: they want to protect the authority of the Bible but ignore the tenets of Christianity as set out in the New Testament; how did patriotism get in here? There were no nation states until the last 200-300 years, so it can’t be national patriotism unless this is a late add-on – certainly it was not advocated by Christ, in fact it seems alien to his teachings; and where does it say that governments shouldn't be involved in the workplace - there weren't workplaces (as we know them) in Christ's day - there was the feudal system; so is the Right saying that we should still have slavery?]

4. all successful societies need to work within a common set of assumptions

[nothing necessarily wrong here until it is taken to the next step to say these common assumptions can’t change – history is replete with Christianity having to adjust to more knowledge. If the Right had its way, we would still believe that the sun and planets revolve around the earth and that God created the world out of nothing - hey did I just hear the word creationism?]

The article concludes that Republicans are agents of morality while Democrats are agents of justice. The Right feels under siege because the pursuit of justice has had the effect of undermining long held moral beliefs (e.g. Engel v Vitale re reading the Bible in school; Roe v Wade re abortion; Lemar v Kertzman re government interventions in Christian academies etc.)

[ My purpose in putting this here is not to say that the Christian Right is right or wrong. Rather, it is to say that they are not Christian. If you read the New Testament, you cannot but agree with this. So I say to those of the "Christian Right", if politics is your main focus, call yourselves members of the Right; if religion is your main focus, call yourself a Christian (if in fact you reflect Christian values espoused by Christ). But never should anyone refer to the Christian Right. To do so would, even under your own values referred to above, violate the truth.

The concept “Christian Right� was developed to dupe Christians into thinking it is possible to be a good Christian and to be on the extreme right politically. This is evil because it has been done intentionally.
 
The counterpoint to the Christian right has to be the socialists masked as liberals.
Their consistent push over the last 30 or 40 years trying to turn the uSA in to an european clone, is as frightening to me.
The christian right and the liberal left are both fringe groups. Most people are in the middlle.
I don't want any of those gaining the upper hand. My hope is, that at the end of the day we have enough brains to meet in the middle.
These two fractions got polarized over the last few years. Unless thay come to their senses, they both will be doomed.
 
screwge said:
Is God right wing?
Is the “religious right� an oxymoron?

One thing I have never been able to fathom, is how Christians in the US or anywhere claim that right wing issues are God’s issues.

Principles I learned as a Christian seem to support the other conclusion, such as:

1. do unto others as you would have them do unto you
2. I am my brother’s keeper
3. the meek shall inherit the earth
4. suffer the little children to come to me
5. Jesus threw the money changers out of the temple
6. Jesus healed the sick, inspired the disadvantaged
7. turn the other cheek
8. Jesus forgave those that betrayed him

The list goes on. Jesus taught tolerance, acceptance, respect for others, caring for others. Jesus recognized a separation between church and state: render under Ceasar what is Ceasar’s and render unto God what is God’s.

The US seems to be fearful that Muslim fundamentalists are taking over states in the Middle East, a fear I share, but they seem not to recognize that the US government is being heavily influenced by Christian fundamentalists, who, in my view, are not espousing true Christianity. Why is there such a disconnect?

I guess the problem here is you are trying to apply political terms to Christs teachings. Christ taught us to be there for eachother and always be willing to give.

But before you draw the conclustion that giving means starving your children to pay your taxes, then I think you will find this to ne a left wing idea. Now if you think healing the sick means reseaching the sex habits of the rare african invisible grasshopper. You neglect that Christ healed for free.

Is GOD RIGHT WING??

if that means protecting the un-born

allowing people rights


keeping goventment out of your home

and allow religious freedom

Then Yes God is.
 
Langeweile: I agree that extremists at either end of the spectrum are dangerous. It is clear to virtually everyone that neocons (the extreme right) control Bush and that his actions in the last 4 years reflect this.

As for Kerry, I don’t see him being controlled by the extreme left. What I have seen is the extreme right labelling anything to the left of them (including the center) as being liberal which equals socialist which equals communist. It is true that Kerry is to the left of Bush. But if he were in Canada, Kerry’s policies would fit with the right wing of the Liberal party, a party of the center.

The neocons are trying to scare you. Resist man, resist.
 
God is definitely a left winger and neutral politically, remember JC was the original Hippy.

That being said religion in gereral is an OK concept. The problem arises when too many people just take it too damn seriously!

Our founding fathers realized this. It was a main reason for leaving Europe, to get away from those religious zealots and this was central in their keeping Church and State separate.....as it should be.

We don't need Dubya playing the role of Oliver Cromwell along with his Roundheads (Rove included).
 
screwge said:
Is God right wing?
Is the “religious right� an oxymoron?


God is not right wing – or left wing – human who preach their version of God may be.

“Religious right� is not an oxymoron – human who misuse it may be.

God, whoever He (or She) may be, is the Love and Perfection that all human should praise and practice, regardless of one’s religious belief or the lack thereof.

If there is God high above, He (or She) must be fairly concerned of the hostilities and wrongdoings of mankind, whom according to all religions are the creation of God. If God is almighty, perfect and loving for all mankind, why did He (or She) create such an imperfect world, where the poor of some parts of the world live worse than the pets of the rich? Why did God create so much inequalities, so many sins in human possessions, so many diseases to make His or Her beloved children miserable, and so many humanistic wars and killings in the name of religion?

I have no answers cause God is almighty beyond humanistic comprehension. All I know is, as parents, we will do whatever we could to make our children’s lives better. We’ll do whatever we can, including sacrificing our lives to protect them. Our children all make mistakes but parents will forget and forgive. Adam and Eve antagonized God in eating the forbidden apple, and God made us pay - though with His almighty power could have been a lot more forgiving.

I respect religion. It is the humanistic means of making the world a better place for all. I respect those who have strong religious belief. I despise those who abuse their religious belief for personal cause. I have no respect for those who persist that their God is the right God – that mine is not.

I particularly disagree that only those who follow the gospel of God can go to Heaven, and those who don’t but practice human kindness can.
 
I'd rather know than believe

You touch on the 'Problem of Evil' and the present struggle between science and religion and Bush's somewhat puritanical outlook on things.

"The first and simplest emotion of the human mind is curiosity," Edmond Burke

Uncurious George

Despite what is unfolding before us, the majority of this country's honest, freedom-loving people seem ever less interested in knowing, and ever more inclined toward believing that what we're being shown and what we're being told and what is being carried out in our name, is truth.

By Dom Stasi ResponDS1@aol.com

August, 14, 2003: I'd rather know than believe. Five words, penned by a paragon of thought, they have stayed in my memory and my own humble thoughts since I first encountered them several years ago. For me, the words leapt from the pages of Carl Sagan's masterpiece of reason entitled, The Demon Haunted World.

Humanity lost Dr. Sagan to a prolonged illness in 1996. But in his short 62 years, the renowned scientist and philosopher left all of us far more than most. Among his gifts are those five haunting words: I'd rather know than believe. Ironically, what I've chosen to believe Carl Sagan was relating, but I'll never know for certain is this: Seek truth though knowledge, not through faith.

His words haunt me still. They haunt me first because they provide me an insight to faith, and the wanting to believe that is somewhere inside us all. I want to believe that my interpretation is exactly what their author meant. I want to believe that my children will live long and happy lives. There are certain things I want very much to believe. The simple phrase thus tempers my cold, engineer's logic with humanity. I'm aware now that there is something in all of us that sometimes would rather just believe than know.....

Link to the rest of this article on how Bush would rather have you follow him by 'faith' rather than 'knowledge':

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4454.htm
 
The answer is that Kali, Shiva and Balrama are. The rest are a bit left of center.
 
n Your article has alot of good and substantial points.I will say i am voting for Mr. Kerry.But faith does play a big part in Christianity.God inone instance cant be seen.But the scriptures state the heavens declare the Glory of God.One and only.Through scriptures you can see Jesus being God died on the cross for our sins and was resurrected on the third day seen by countless hundreds and all that wrote the Bible.Of course being President and a leader you must have wise counsel and investigate things thourougly,especially when you commit young men and woman to war.Al Franken calls him intelectualy lazy,which can best describe it.