I love my iPod for checking email and apps like facebook - instant on and just sit wherever at home to access or for showing recipes etc, checking weather.
It is the Apps that make the product.
I like the look of the iPad, however, I think it is too large (perhaps 5x8 would have been better then it is more like a stenographers notepad) - maybe the drive to a more full size keyboard and movies/newspapers was more the dirver, than an effective mobile device?
I would also have included a camera (not on ipod- grrr) and also some tablet writing process to then comete/replace tablet PC operations and truly be the 'pad' part of iPad.
With or without an OS, the available apps (with appropriate syncing) already make up for that!
The extra features - camera and hand-writing process would have bridged the gap between a netbook and an ipod better IMO