Indexed GIC investment

Radio_Shack

Retired Perv
Apr 3, 2007
1,525
1
38
With GIC rates so low as 3% for 2 years, 2% for 1 Yr does it make sense to buy an Indexed GIC?

Your principle is protected 100% and you gain 65% of what the market goes up. If market goes down you get your full deposit back.

Is this a good alternative?

My understanding is if you invested $100K for 1 year. At the end of that period lets say the market was up 10%, you get 6.5% (65% of profit) of that so your investment returns back $106500. And on the down turn you would just get back $100K if the market was even or down.
 
What is the length of this GIC (3 years, 5 years)? Who is the issuer (will they be solvent at maturity or CDIC guaranteed)?
 
Rockslinger said:
What is the length of this GIC (3 years, 5 years)? Who is the issuer (will they be solvent at maturity or CDIC guaranteed)?

CIBC is one that offers, others do as well like TD. 3 and 5 years seems to be only options, your right.
 
In my opinion structured notes are not good value for retail investors

The issuing will take your $ and combine it with a thousand other buyers & buy a government bond with the same maturity.
They will take the interest payments from the bond (or the discount if they buy a zero coupon bond) and buy an equities futures contract with a put option.
If the market goes up they payoff 65% of the gain plus your principle from the maturing bond
If the market goes down, the put on the futures contract negates the futures loss & you get your $ back.

Either way they make a spread (a big one too) between the GIC rate & the yield on the bond + 35% of the upside.

A retail investor is probably best allocating cash between equities & fixed income. If you feel the market is not going to go up much (or its going down) then increase the GIC %
 
JL said:
In my opinion structured notes are not good value for retail investors

The issuing will take your $ and combine it with a thousand other buyers & buy a government bond with the same maturity.
They will take the interest payments from the bond (or the discount if they buy a zero coupon bond) and buy an equities futures contract with a put option.
If the market goes up they payoff 65% of the gain plus your principle from the maturing bond
If the market goes down, the put on the futures contract negates the futures loss & you get your $ back.

Either way they make a spread (a big one too) between the GIC rate & the yield on the bond + 35% of the upside.

A retail investor is probably best allocating cash between equities & fixed income. If you feel the market is not going to go up much (or its going down) then increase the GIC %

Excellent post JL:) . IMHO, if the bank representatives who sell these indexed gics explained things as well as you just did on terb to their individual retail customers then none of their customers would be buying these indexed gic products at all---lol

Thanks to you, I finally understand what buying an indexed gic entails and more importantly why personally I would never buy one!
 
JohnLarue said:
In my opinion structured notes are not good value for retail investors

The issuing will take your $ and combine it with a thousand other buyers & buy a government bond with the same maturity.
They will take the interest payments from the bond (or the discount if they buy a zero coupon bond) and buy an equities futures contract with a put option.
If the market goes up they payoff 65% of the gain plus your principle from the maturing bond
If the market goes down, the put on the futures contract negates the futures loss & you get your $ back.

Either way they make a spread (a big one too) between the GIC rate & the yield on the bond + 35% of the upside.

A retail investor is probably best allocating cash between equities & fixed income. If you feel the market is not going to go up much (or its going down) then increase the GIC %

I kind of understand what your saying but all I am interested in is I have my initial investment secured and have a chance to have more then the posted fixed 2 or 3% of a normal GIC. I don't care what the bank does with my investment I just care about what I have at the end of the period.

Given this what would be a better 100% secure investment that pays more then GICs? If I go with my own stocks I have a lot of risk. Seems to me the banks will reinvest any money you give them either by loaning it to Joe the Pizza guy or buying some other higher yielding investment. Is that really relevant to the investor? If I really felt the market would do very well I would likely take the plunge and buy some dividend yielding stocks and be done with it but I have a feeling the market is still got down side for the next year or 2. Maybe these Indexed GICs are not a good bet given what I think right now.
 
Radio_Shack said:
I kind of understand what your saying but all I am interested in is I have my initial investment secured and have a chance to have more then the posted fixed 2 or 3% of a normal GIC. I don't care what the bank does with my investment I just care about what I have at the end of the period.

Given this what would be a better 100% secure investment that pays more then GICs? If I go with my own stocks I have a lot of risk. Seems to me the banks will reinvest any money you give them either by loaning it to Joe the Pizza guy or buying some other higher yielding investment. Is that really relevant to the investor?

Thats a fair arguement & I understand your logic & if you are comfortable with the product then buy it

However, it comes down to your fear of losing your capital and your view the stock markets are risky
The banks play on that fear.
Over a lifetime they wil get thier share of your money, its a fact of Canadian life, however buying thier overpriced structured notes & mutual funds just makes it that much more of a bite.

Anyone who bought one of these products in th last three years has preserved their capital (thats good), but recieved either very little or a zero return on their investment, while the issuer of the note recieved free capital

Im my opinion, it is best to keep things simple
If you feel the equity markets are risky, do not put your money into stocks at all.

You can getter a higher rate in a straight GIC vs. the structured GICs.

Also any of the Canadian Bank bonds are currently paying a pretty good yield which should (I have not checked)be higher than the GICs. Stable companies like TransCanada, Canadian Tire etc will also give you a yield lift
Pretty slim chance the banks will default.
 
You guys are hilarious. The guy is practically begging to find a product that is buy it and leave it...with the principal protected, which indexed GICs are...and you are still pushing your "trade in the market yourself" garbage. And yet you have not addressed his primary concern...protecting his principal. You're so stuck on the "banks are making money off of you" that you don't realize that an index GIC is probably not a bad idea for him in that he gets to participate in the equity markets to a certain degree and has the security of knowing his primary sum is guaranteed. He obviously doesn't want to day trade for himself. He doesn't want to formulate a portfolio for himself...he just wants to save his money in a vehicle that will provide a guarantee. You guys shouldn't be giving advice to anyone.
 
Radio_Shack said:
I kind of understand what your saying but all I am interested in is I have my initial investment secured and have a chance to have more then the posted fixed 2 or 3% of a normal GIC. I don't care what the bank does with my investment I just care about what I have at the end of the period.

Given this what would be a better 100% secure investment that pays more then GICs? If I go with my own stocks I have a lot of risk. Seems to me the banks will reinvest any money you give them either by loaning it to Joe the Pizza guy or buying some other higher yielding investment. Is that really relevant to the investor? If I really felt the market would do very well I would likely take the plunge and buy some dividend yielding stocks and be done with it but I have a feeling the market is still got down side for the next year or 2. Maybe these Indexed GICs are not a good bet given what I think right now.

Go with your gut feeling and do what you think is right. No one really knows
where the markets will be in the near term, or 5 years from now. Sometimes keeping what you have is more important than making money. Traders call sitting on cash as loading up on the dry gun powder.
 
Barca said:
You guys are hilarious. The guy is practically begging to find a product that is buy it and leave it...with the principal protected, which indexed GICs are...and you are still pushing your "trade in the market yourself" garbage. And yet you have not addressed his primary concern...protecting his principal. You're so stuck on the "banks are making money off of you" that you don't realize that an index GIC is probably not a bad idea for him in that he gets to participate in the equity markets to a certain degree and has the security of knowing his primary sum is guaranteed. He obviously doesn't want to day trade for himself. He doesn't want to formulate a portfolio for himself...he just wants to save his money in a vehicle that will provide a guarantee. You guys shouldn't be giving advice to anyone.

I said "if your comfortable with the product buy it."
I just wanted to point out how these are structured & if he thought the markets are risky a regular GIC pays more.

How does it hurt anyone to understand what they are buying & what other options are available to them.
In the end its his choice.

But you are probably right, its best he get the advice from a branch product manager with
1. an incentive plan to sell these products
2. who may or may not understand what he / she is really selling
3. May or may not explain all the choices to him
 
I am not familiar with index-linked GIC but I do remember a few details about how an investment
in PPN (principal-protected notes) works from an
article by Gordon Pape in the Globe and Mail. I presume
indexed GIC falls into the same category of investment
instrument as PPN.

From what I remember Pape (whose investment
approach is typicaly conservative) was somewhat
negative about PPN. But I think the main issue he had is the hefty fee charged. I won't worry about
putting money in index-linked GIC except that I would
see to it that no hidden fee is going to be incurred.

Radio_Shack said:
With GIC rates so low as 3% for 2 years, 2% for 1 Yr does it make sense to buy an Indexed GIC?

Your principle is protected 100% and you gain 65% of what the market goes up. If market goes down you get your full deposit back.

Is this a good alternative?

My understanding is if you invested $100K for 1 year. At the end of that period lets say the market was up 10%, you get 6.5% (65% of profit) of that so your investment returns back $106500. And on the down turn you would just get back $100K if the market was even or down.
 
Rockslinger said:
How and where can a retail investor buy an "equities contract with a put option"?

I was not suggesting a retail investor do this, rather I was explaining how the issuing companies set up the structured product & how lucrative it is for them

Buying / selling Futures contracts is not something the average retail investor should do.
Contract sizes are huge & lots of leverage is available
If you do not really understand these products you will lose big $ and quickly

CMC Markets has a platform for trading CFDs which could be used. It does not look like they sell put options

http://www.cmcmarkets.ca/en/content/cfd_trading/index.jsp

The companies that do issue principal protected notes use scale to their advantage.
It would be pretty tough for a retail investor to replicate this
Again it was not a recommendation, rather an explanation of the product
 
JohnLarue said:
The companies that do issue principal protected notes use scale to their advantage.
It would be pretty tough for a retail investor to replicate this

Thanks JohnLarue. This business model is very similar to wholesale and retail. As shoppers we would all love to pay wholesale prices instead of retail prices but harder said than done. As investors we would love to cut out the "middleman banks" but again maybe easier said than done.
 
JL said:
How does it hurt anyone to understand what they are buying & what other options are available to them.
In the end its his choice.

But you are probably right, its best he get the advice from a branch product manager with
1. an incentive plan to sell these products
2. who may or may not understand what he / she is really selling
3. May or may not explain all the choices to him

I couldn't have said it better myself:) . I am not a financial advisor. However, I do have an excellent knowledge as to how advisors and bank representatives get paid. I personally know a few people in the financial industry.

JL, your comments are very similar to what my contacts in the industry have shared with me. JL, you are probably in the financial industry yourself but that is none of my business---lol. I say this also because IMHO your financial knowledge is at a very advanced level. I have read all your financial insights very carefully in other terb financial threads as well. The advice that you give is always quite logical and sound and has the consumers best interests at heart.

I think that IMHO Barca is irritated about this thread because he has been a financial advisor for 14 years. He despises the fact that some retail investors aren't stupid. Some of us know how these advisors really get paid.

I have in my possession a grid system from one of the major bank brokerages for goodness sake. This grid system spells out how much these asset under management advisors really get paid. It is all based on the clients asset levels etc etc.

IMHO, PPNS and index-linked gics should not be bought by investors under any circumstances. IMHO, they're much better and cheaper alternatives out there. Again, just my opinion.
 
Barca said:
You guys are hilarious. The guy is practically begging to find a product that is buy it and leave it...with the principal protected, which indexed GICs are...and you are still pushing your "trade in the market yourself" garbage. And yet you have not addressed his primary concern...protecting his principal. You're so stuck on the "banks are making money off of you" that you don't realize that an index GIC is probably not a bad idea for him in that he gets to participate in the equity markets to a certain degree and has the security of knowing his primary sum is guaranteed. He obviously doesn't want to day trade for himself. He doesn't want to formulate a portfolio for himself...he just wants to save his money in a vehicle that will provide a guarantee. You guys shouldn't be giving advice to anyone

However, the problem is that you have to have your money tied up for either three or five years when you buy these index-linked gics:eek: Not a good deal for the retail investor.

Lets say you put in $100000 for five years. After five years if you only get your principal of $100000 back that IMHO is a disasterous investment. IMHO, the investor would be much better off buying a 5 yr corporate or govt bond. Or even buying the XBB. Then using the rest of the money to buy an equity etf etc.

After a 5 year period chances are the market will be trading higher by then. How much you put into bonds at the beginning will depend totally on your risk tolerance.
 
squash500 said:
IMHO, PPNS and index-linked gics should not be bought by investors under any circumstances. IMHO, they're much better and cheaper alternatives out there.

Could you elaborate on these alternatives. I think all of want unlimited upside and absolutely no downside in a perfect world. I was thinking maybe a strategy of buying stocks and then hedging by buying put options. However, there is a cost to buying put options. Is this strategy even practical in real life?

Also, bear in my that most of us have a life and maybe even a career so we can't spend all day monitoring and implementing such a strategy.
 
Thanks
Thats was nice complement.
I do not have an issue with Bacra, I suspect he is very knowledgeable & makes decisions with the best interest of his clients in mind (within the bounds of working for a large institution)

What I did not care for was his statement. "You guys should not be giving advice to anyone"

1. Just because an opinion differs from mine, I still try & show some respect for an individual who has some knowledge on a subject
2. I was not giving specific advice, rather pointing out some facts, options & issues which may be relevant to the original posters question

This is a discussion board & the original poster asked for opinions.
I gave an opinion & a couple of options for that individual to investigate further.
The assumption is he is an intelligent individual who can decide what is in his best interest once he is aware of the facts and the options available to him.
 
Rockslinger said:
Could you elaborate on these alternatives. I think all of want unlimited upside and absolutely no downside in a perfect world. I was thinking maybe a strategy of buying stocks and then hedging by buying put options. However, there is a cost to buying put options. Is this strategy even practical in real life?

Also, bear in my that most of us have a life and maybe even a career so we can't spend all day monitoring and implementing such a strategy.


Again, bare in mind that I am not a financial advisor:) .

Lets say you have a $100000 and are very risk averse. I would buy $80000 worth of the XBB. The XBB is a bond etf made up of a combination of govt, corporate and provincial bonds. Then I would buy $20000 worth of the XDV. The xdv is an equity etf made of of the 30 highest yielding stocks on the TSX.

I would do this through a discount brokerage account. I would then set up what is called a synthetic Drip. This means that every three months you would get more shares of these etfs instead of cash. This is a form of dollar cost averaging.

Chances are that after 3 or 5 years you will earn a higher return on your money using this strategy then if you bought a 3 or 5 year index-linked gic from a bank.

IMHO, the great thing about this strategy is that you have to do absolutely nothing after you buy these 2 etfs. For more information on these etfs you can go to www.ishares.ca. Then look under XBB and XDV to see the securities that are actually apart of these 2 etfs.

Disclosure----Again, this is just my opinion and I am not a financial advisor.
 
squash500 said:
Lets say you have a $100000 and are very risk averse. I would buy $80000 worth of the XBB. Then I would buy $20000 worth of the XDV.

Ok, let's push this example forward 5 years.

The $80,000 of XBB is now worth $100,000 (original capital).

The $20,000 of XDV is now worth $40,000 (100% return over 5 years).

Total investment is worth $140,000 (40% return but we were naked on the downside because both the XBB and XDV could have imploded and we could have lost our shirt).