Fischer Investments anyone use them?

Big Rig

Well-known member
May 6, 2009
2,422
514
113
"Fisher is a fiduciary because they are a Registered Investment Adviser, meaning they are legally required to put your interests first. They also invest directly in stocks and bonds rather than layering on additional mutual fund fees, which helps their claim."

However, they take 1% + and you need 500k

That money must be in registered account to make sense otherwise you have to cash it out then pay taxes

The tax monies lost is not the issue as you will pay taxes sometime, but the issue is those monies will no longer compound

so Fischer has to beat the index by 1% + and also make the compounding of your tax loss back

So, they have to beat market by several points which is not gonna happen consistently

But, if you are using registered monies no taxes involved but they still have to beat index by 2% to make move worthwhile as their expenses are 1%+
and that is very difficult to do consistently, if not impossible, as that is the holy grail of investing to beat the indexes in alpha and beta consistently over several market downturns


Anyone use Fisher? They claim to beat is the MSCI World Index

  • The MSCI World is a market-cap-weighted index. This means its performance is heavily influenced by whichever countries or sectors have the largest market value at a given time.
  • How Outperformance Happens: To beat a market-cap-weighted index like the MSCI World, a manager must intentionally "tilt" or "overweight" certain areas. For example, they might put more money into a country or sector they believe will perform well. A common critique of Fisher's historical strategy is that they achieved outperformance by simply holding more US stocks than the MSCI World's US weight. Whether this is skill or just good timing is the central question.



"If Fisher truly had a reliable system to beat the market by several points, wouldn't they advertise that specific number everywhere, rather than vague promises about being a fiduciary that cares about you?"
 
They have weighted into the S&P and that has carried them since 1995 when they created the Fisher Investments Private Client Group (FIPCG) Global Total Return Composite investment pool

They do not have an increased sharp ratio compared to S&P



YearFisher Global Total Return (Net of Fees)S&P 500 Total Return
201931.58%31.49%
202026.10%18.40%
202123.31%28.71%
2022-25.56%-18.11%
202335.29%26.29%
202423.08%25.02%
202521.94%17.88%


in 2022 they held no defensive position as they tanked more than s&p

they are beating the MSCI by weighting into the usa

What exactly is their evidence they can beat the MSCI world index and provide a defence against the USA market?

I see none and yet they have been around since 1995. I call them a mutual fund under another name and they take 1.5% where an ETF is free by comparison

A MF used to give salesmen 1% that no longer is the case so at 1.5% and no 1% to salesman they retain their profit margin and still provide no alpha just like MFs did not
 
  • Like
Reactions: ez$$$
I do not know the specifics of their funds or their track record but I woukd advise to stay away from firms/managers that insist on a minimum investment threshold such as $500K or $1M.

It kind of seems to me that they want do the interior decorating and hang the curtains after you have already built the foundation, layed the concrete and done the brick laying.

If you have already worked with a manager/firm and have been able to successfully grow your portfolio to that threshold, I would explore investment management, taxation and estate issues with that firm first before exploring an outside options.

Best to dance with the one that brought you.
 
Last edited:
Fisher had his day and is now back for a second bite. If you need the name recognition of a market has-been, more fool you.