If NHL Is Serious About Reducing Thuggery...

Hard Idle

Active member
Jan 15, 2005
4,952
21
38
North York
This is related to a post from the Steve Downey thread:

champ said:
Coincidently Bob Cole and Greg Millen were talking about him prior to the punch being sent to the Phantoms to learn how to keep himself from going "over the edge" with his temper and emotions..
Never gonna happen. First of all alot of these guys are too juiced to always have that control during the game. That's one problem.

More importantly, as long as they know this kind of crap is their ticket to a pro hockey contract, players will be hard-wired to do this stuff.

I am a Flyer fan and knew this fellow was trouble when people in the Flyer organization said he was cut in the Bob Clarke mold.

Thats what I mean. Organizations want their scouts to get them players like that. That's why the suspensions and penalties should be designed to hurt the organization as whole, not just the individual player.

The disciplinary measures must be such that, in a few years they will change the entire way rosters are built. Signing and drafting guys who "play with an edge" will become a sure way for a GM to get fired, not promoted.

Instead of telling his scouts to draft him a bunch of guys who have some Bobby Clark or Dale Hunter in them , a President will order his GM & scouts to get him a roster of guys who make Rick Middleton look like a psycho.

To acomplish this, you have to institute a "graduated scale" system that makes these guys a huge liability to their team. For example :

Once a guy gets a suspension of more than 10 games for an "attempt to injure" such as Downey was, he is on probation for his next 200 games. During that time, ANY suspendable infraction will automatically result in a suspension TWICE as long as the previous one, PLUS whatever suspension the incident would normally be assessed...PLUS another 200 games probation is added. After a THIRD suspension while under probation, even a 5 minute major becomes a suspendable offense.... with next one being a lifetime ban...

Since many of these guys can't go more than 20 shifts without doing something stupid, it wouldn't be long before they find themselves in a situation where each year, they are under suspension for many more games than they can dress for, and one step away from banishment - just by "playng their game".

Even at the NHL minimum salary, these guys would be a huge waste of Cap room - and because they're always under suspension, a team would need to dedicate 7 or 8 roster spots to ensure they always have a couple of "Energy Players" in the lineup.

Furthermore, the prorated $$ value of all games under suspension should count 4 times against that teams Salary Cap the next year. So if a couple of goons who's contracts are worth $5 000/game serve a combined total of 40 games in suspensions, that will charge an extra $800 000 to their teams Payroll the following season.

But, if a No.1 defensemen who might make $35G a game gets one 15 game suspension, that alone will cost his team $2.1 Million of cap room next season.

This, along with incremental team fines for accumulation of Major Penalties, Game Misconducts, and Suspendable offenses, is the only way to CHANGE THE CULTURE form the top down, and make so-called "Energy Players" more trouble than they are worth by hitting clubs hard in the pocket book and affecting their ability to maintain a competitive roster.
 
I agree, the culture needs to change from the top down.

The excuse that fighting is a "release valve" and prevents grabbing, high sticking and slashing is nonsense. It's like saying it's good to be a driver who screams in rage because he's releasing anger, not true because he's only reinforcing and strengthening those feelings and showing his children how to handle problems badly.

I don't even watch hockey anymore, there's so much of this that it's boring as hell.
 
Heres a goofy Idea... Suspend the spot on the bench ... get a major suspension and the team can't dress a replacement...
 
Neverenuff$ said:
Heres a goofy Idea... Suspend the spot on the bench ... get a major suspension and the team can't dress a replacement...

crazy...but i like it!
maybe the teams will step in and curb the BS...

shame it'll never happen though...

makes WAY too much sense...
 
What about if a player is suspended for ten games, that refers to ten games against the team involved when the infraction occurred, and that would include playoffs, and subsequent seasons. The suspension against a particular team would also carry over if that player was traded.

I don't have the stats to back this up, but I would think that serious infractions rarely happen in inter conference games. When teams play each other once or twice a year, the opportunity and impetus for retaliatory measures is seldom there.
 
did you guys not watch the buffalo/pittsburg game on new years day on nbc. both intermissions talked about fighting and even showed highlights of that stupid movie that Paul Newman made abotu the three goons in hockey. Clearly NBC has figured out that if it has any shot at rating for hockey it has to include fighting......so guess which direction Bettman is going to take the league....a 1.5 share during prime time for the NHL finals ain't good enough.....fighting will come back to appease the Americans.
 
so what? i don't turn my back when a fight breaks out.

but, i can disagree with cheapshots.