How did Melania get an Einstein Visa?

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
What is the Einstein visa? And how did Melania Trump get one?
By Joel Gunter
BBC News

Questions have been raised over Melania Trump's specialist visa, but how hard are they really to obtain?
Melania Trump obtained US citizenship on a visa reserved for immigrants with "extraordinary ability" and "sustained national and international acclaim", according to a report in the Washington Post.

Nicknamed the "Einstein Visa", the EB-1 is in theory reserved for people who are highly acclaimed in their field - the government cites Pulitzer, Oscar, and Olympic winners as examples - as well as respected academic researchers and multinational executives.

Mrs Trump began applying for the visa in 2000, when she was Melania Knauss, a Slovenian model working in New York and dating Donald Trump. She was approved in 2001, one of just five people from Slovenia to win the coveted visa that year, according to the Post.

It gave her the right to sponsor her parents, Viktor and Amalija Knavs, who are now in the US and in the process of applying for citizenship.

The reports of how Mrs Trump obtained her citizenship will rankle with some, at a time when her husband is railing against immigrants and attempting to scrap the right of new citizens to sponsor family members. And questions have been raised about her suitability for the extraordinary ability category.

But just how hard is it to get an EB-1, and should she have made the cut?

Mrs Trump came to the US in 1996, first on a tourist visa and then a string of working visas for skilled immigrants, according to her lawyer. She was working as a model in New York when she met Mr Trump at a party in 1998, a relationship that considerably raised her celebrity profile.

Before applying for a green card - which grants permanent residency - she had worked as a runway model in Europe and featured to a limited extent in UK and US magazines.

She appeared on the cover of British GQ on a fur rug in Mr Trump's private jet, and in the swimsuit edition of Sports Illustrated in the US. She was not a top international model.

To obtain an EB-1 for extraordinary ability, an immigrant has to provide evidence of a major award or meet three of 10 criteria proving excellence in their field. The criteria include coverage of the applicant in major publications, original and significant contributions to a field, and work displayed at artistic exhibitions.

The government guidance for applicants cites Nobel prizes and international acclaim, but the reality is often more prosaic, said Susan McFadden, a specialist US visa lawyer at the Gudeon and McFadden law firm in London.

"You do not have to be a Nobel prize winner to get the extraordinary ability visa. I've gotten EB-1 visas for people you've never heard of and never will," she said.

"An experienced lawyer knows what the US citizenship and immigration services is looking for, and how to bring out of the client's background things that will be attractive to the agency."

Securing an EB-1 is often about defining a field, Ms McFadden said, in the hope of proving the client is outstanding in that field. Trying to prove your client is an outstanding businessman puts them up against Richard Branson. Proving they are outstanding within alternative asset commercial finance management? Less difficult.

Ms McFadden said she had secured EB-1s for a range of diverse specialties, from coaching a specific football position to scientific ballooning. The trick was to define a field narrow enough to excel in, she said, but not too narrow that immigration authorities won't take it seriously.

But where does that leave Mrs Trump? She does not appear at the time to have excelled in a niche area of modelling, nor won awards or had her work written about in significant publications.

Her lawyer has declined to publish details of her application, so we can't know what she submitted as evidence. But she may have been boosted by high-profile testimonial letters, said Nita Upadhye, a US immigration specialist at NNU Immigration Law.

Testimonials form part of the application, and the more high-profile the reference the more weight it carries. If Mrs Trump, already dating Mr Trump at the time she applied, secured letters from luminaries in fashion, that would be significant, Ms Upadhye said.

"If you're in the acting world, and Quentin Tarantino or Steven Spielberg writers a letter saying you're the next best thing, that can be very persuasive," she said.

"It's about getting testimonials from someone who is extraordinary in their own right and has some name recognition, but who can also attest to specific achievements of the applicant. And I'm sure she probably had some pretty significant letters, maybe from Donald Trump."

Ultimately though, lawyerly creativity aside, it comes down to the applicant, she said.

"You could get a letter from President Obama, and that certainly would look impressive with his letterhead. But if he can't say something significant about your achievements, it won't cut it."
 
Maybe she has an extraordinary ability at fellatio? Or an extraordinary ability to write her name in the snow?
 
This entire article can be summarized: She applied for an EB-1 visa in 2000 (That was 16 years before her husband was elected President).

Despite the wording of "an extraordinary ability visa" you don't have to be world famous to be granted one. Ordinary people are granted them every month.

If instead she had adjusted status after marrying in 2005, her current situation would be exactly where it is now.

This is merely a political football.
 
This entire article can be summarized: She applied for an EB-1 visa in 2000 (That was 16 years before her husband was elected President).

Despite the wording of "an extraordinary ability visa" you don't have to be world famous to be granted one. Ordinary people are granted them every month.

This is merely a political football.


Or political golden showering.
 
Yawn!
 
This entire article can be summarized: She applied for an EB-1 visa in 2000 (That was 16 years before her husband was elected President).

Despite the wording of "an extraordinary ability visa" you don't have to be world famous to be granted one. Ordinary people are granted them every month.

If instead she had adjusted status after marrying in 2005, her current situation would be exactly where it is now.

This is merely a political football.

Employment-Based Immigration: First Preference EB-1
You may be eligible for an employment-based, first-preference visa if you have an extraordinary ability, are an outstanding professor or researcher, or are a multinational executive or manager. Each occupational category has certain requirements that must be met:

Eligibility Criteria
Categories

Description

Evidence

Extraordinary Ability

You must be able to demonstrate extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics through sustained national or international acclaim. Your achievements must be recognized in your field through extensive documentation. No offer of employment is required.

You must meet 3 of 10 criteria* below, or provide evidence of a one-time achievement (i.e., Pulitzer, Oscar, Olympic Medal)



Outstanding professors and researchers

You must demonstrate international recognition for your outstanding achievements in a particular academic field. You must have at least 3 years experience in teaching or research in that academic area. You must be entering the United States in order to pursue tenure or tenure track teaching or comparable research position at a university or other institution of higher education.

You must include documentation of at least two listed below** and an offer of employment from the prospective U.S. employer.

Multinational manager or executive

You must have been employed outside the United States in the 3 years preceding the petition for at least 1 year by a firm or corporation and you must be seeking to enter the United States to continue service to that firm or organization. Your employment must have been outside the United States in a managerial or executive capacity and with the same employer, an affiliate, or a subsidiary of the employer.

Your petitioning employer must be a U.S. employer. Your employer must have been doing business for at least 1 year, as an affiliate, a subsidiary, or as the same corporation or other legal entity that employed you abroad.
 
Clearly the visa was obtained fraudulently, and Melania should intern at Insidious Von's place.
 
This is a "YAWN" thread to the Trumptard Cult Followers, but they so passionately debated how Obama was not born in the USA, thanks to their cult leader's and Fox / Breitbart news conspiracy theories. Hilarious!!!
 
Employment-Based Immigration: First Preference EB-1
Really Danmand, you don't think I know this?

However, I'll let the article you started this off with do the talking

The government guidance for applicants cites Nobel prizes and international acclaim, but the reality is more prosaic, said Susan McFadden, a specialist US visa lawyer at the Gudeon and McFadden law firm in London.

"You do not have to be a Nobel prize winner to get the extraordinary ability visa. I've gotten EB-1 visas for people you've never heard of and never will," she said.

"An experienced lawyer knows what the US citizenship and immigration services is looking for, and how to bring out of the client's background things that will be attractive to the agency."

Securing an EB-1 is often about defining a field, Ms McFadden said, in the hope of proving the client is outstanding in that field. Trying to prove your client is an outstanding businessman puts them up against Richard Branson. Proving they are outstanding within alternative asset commercial finance management? Less difficult.

Ms McFadden said she had secured EB-1s for a range of diverse specialties, from coaching a specific football position to scientific ballooning. The trick was to define a field narrow enough to excel in, she said, but not too narrow that immigration authorities won't take it seriously.
 
Really Danmand, you don't think I know this?

However, I'll let the article you started this off with do the talking

It must be obvious to even you that Melania did not qualify for a EB-1 visa, unless USA immigration accepted as afield of excellence "to lie naked on a fur rug".
 
It must be obvious to even you that Melania did not qualify for a EB-1 visa, unless USA immigration accepted as afield of excellence "to lie naked on a fur rug".

It's also obvious from your original post that many many others did not qualify, yet got one. Are you calling for all of these other lawyer aided applicants to be called out as well? As usual if you can afford the right lawyer you can get around the system and this is certainly not an isolated incident.

The liberal hate mongering towards all things Trump is getting a little frenzied to the point of nonsense. Just in time for the midterms, this should be fun! And we thought that the 2016 election was the epitome of libs shooting themselves in the foot .... lol, this could be epic!
 
This entire article can be summarized: She applied for an EB-1 visa in 2000 (That was 16 years before her husband was elected President).

Despite the wording of "an extraordinary ability visa" you don't have to be world famous to be granted one. Ordinary people are granted them every month.

If instead she had adjusted status after marrying in 2005, her current situation would be exactly where it is now.

This is merely a political football.

Taken at its strongest, Melania was a working fashion model in NYC. Some of her shoots may have been a little better than average. If being a working fashion model in NYC gets you an "Einstein visa", then she deserved it. But I am guessing only a small % of working fashion models in NYC get EB-1's - especially so because their work is transitory and interpretive and they can obtain temporary work visas to do this or that runway show and then be sent home. And I am guessing that the small % of fashion models who get EB-1's are legit "supermodels" who do ultra high end shoots continually and make millions of $$$ for themselves and their agencies every year.

If I am wrong and many, many more ordinary fashion models in NYC get EB-1's, then you have proven your case.
 
It must be obvious to even you that Melania did not qualify for a EB-1 visa, unless USA immigration accepted as afield of excellence "to lie naked on a fur rug".

I tried that approach to getting a US visa. They sent it back with a note that I was lying naked on the wrong kind of fur rug.
 
It must be obvious to even you that Melania did not qualify for a EB-1 visa, unless USA immigration accepted as afield of excellence "to lie naked on a fur rug".

Actually since she was given the visa, USA Immigration says she did qualify. Of course they did not consult you, thus you did not have the chance to offer your input. Which I'm sure would have changed immigration's verdict.
 
This is a "YAWN" thread to the Trumptard Cult Followers, but they so passionately debated how Obama was not born in the USA, thanks to their cult leader's and Fox / Breitbart news conspiracy theories. Hilarious!!!

dud i am not interested in your Trump derangement syndrome and the Birther movement was started by the Clinton Campaign take it up with her and her comrades
 
dud i am not interested in your Trump derangement syndrome and the Birther movement was started by the Clinton Campaign take it up with her and her comrades

Dude, your "yawn" nonsense knows no bounds. Your cult leader Trump was the one that to this day believes that Obama was not born in the USA. So you go and take it up with him and the rest of his cult followers!! Okay??
 
Oagre this section of the U.S. Immigration and Nationality Act is among the more interesting, read literally hardly anyone meets its qualifications yet about 40,000 people a year are admitted under the EB Visa program EB1, EB2 and EB3.

Cynics may say that this is all the result of creative lawyering, but Congress quite obviously doesn't object since they have done nothing to amend this section of the Immigration and Nationality Act.

Part of the 'problem' is that the more straight forward O and P class Visas are non-Immigrant (Temporary) visas.
 
Oagre this section of the U.S. Immigration and Nationality Act is among the more interesting read literally hardly anyone meets its qualifications yet about 40,000 people a year are admitted under the EB Visa program EB1, EB2 and EB3. Cynics may say that this is all the result of creative lawyering, but Congress quite obviously doesn't object since they have done nothing to amend this section of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Part of the 'problem' is that the more straight forward O and P class Visas are non-Immigrant (Temporary) visas.

Trump has railed against the EB Visa system. Of course for everyone else.

And I wonder how Melania's parents came. Chain migration perhaps.

The Trumpanistas are too dumb to see that most of the programs that the PGOTUS rails against he has profited or benefitted from.
 
^ So?

Do you honestly believe that no previous U.S. Government has ever done anything that could be construed as hypocritical?

Or are you honestly discussing immigration reform on the merits and arguing the the Immigration and Nationality Act is perfect as it presently stands and not one jot or tittle of it should be changed.