Honoring Pierre Trudeau

Can anyone think of a good reason why a couple of toronto city councillors want to piss away money to honor arguably the worst PM Canada has had in the last 40 years? It's taken 3 succseesive PM's and almost 30 years to undo what he did. The Trudeau years were an unmitigated disaster for Canada, our debt tripled, he single handed ruined our relations with the US by warming up to every 3rd world tin pot despot who'd grant him an audience. He divided our nation through a series of ill devised policies including the constitution that left Quebec out in the cold. He would ascertain what a region of Canda was looking for and then offer the exact opposite. Up until that point separtists were simply a fringe element in Quebec, Trudeau gave them life and a sense of purpose. He was a total fraud and a failure, he opted not to serve in WW 2 he went off to the USSR to promote Stalin's propaganda. He really has a stellar record to merit honoring, only toronto city council could dream up something so stupid. How about renaming Ashbridges Bay sewage treatment plant in his honor as he was full if shit and everything he touched turned to shit as well.
In almost every poll, Trudeau would rank in the top 5 Canadian PM's of all time.
 
You're right about Mulroney fleecing country, but Trudeau managed to rob Canadians of their civil rights over a kidnapping in Quebec.

Once again, it wasn't just a kidnapping. You forgot about the kidnapping and murder of Pierre Laporte and the 50 bombings of public buildings areas and property that took place of the previous 12 months, but you are forgiven, sort of, because you weren't a member of TERB the last time this was discussed,
 
You're right about Mulroney fleecing country, but Trudeau managed to rob Canadians of their civil rights over a kidnapping in Quebec.

He stayed true to his word, restored order, lifted the measures, and ultimately brought in the Charter. He did ok on the human rights score. Whatever you may want to criticize him for, his handling of that situation was masterful and it was that sort of great thing about him that won him so many votes for so many elections.

That speech linked above is something everyone should watch. Pure Trudeau at his best.
 
Whatever sins you think PET did, at least he didn't take envelopes of cash in hotels and then sue canada and make the country pay him $1 million for insulting his character.

Mulroney should be a front runner for worst pm for a long time.

Are you certain that Trudeau didn't take cash? How was it that he had Kieth Davey raise almost 1million dollars to build him an indoor pool and underground tunnel at 24 sussex? Why was a slush fund created with the identity of the donors kept secret then destroyed? Why did Davey mislead the treasury board to procure the balance of the funds? Trudeau would have done well in a one party state, which he often made reference too saying in some cases it worked best. He was a total sham of a PM and his record speaks for itself. What did he do to benefit Canada? If he was as great as some would argue, what part of his his legacy remains other than the Charter? FIRA, NEP, wage & price control , run away inflation, high interest rates, ballooning debt, regional divisions, the decimation of the armed forces, alienation of the US..... those are what he is known for. He was and will remain the worst PM we've had
 
Are you certain that Trudeau didn't take cash? How was it that he had Kieth Davey raise almost 1million dollars to build him an indoor pool and underground tunnel at 24 sussex? Why was a slush fund created with the identity of the donors kept secret then destroyed? Why did Davey mislead the treasury board to procure the balance of the funds? Trudeau would have done well in a one party state, which he often made reference too saying in some cases it worked best. He was a total sham of a PM and his record speaks for itself. What did he do to benefit Canada? If he was as great as some would argue, what part of his his legacy remains other than the Charter? FIRA, NEP, wage & price control , run away inflation, high interest rates, ballooning debt, regional divisions, the decimation of the armed forces, alienation of the US..... those are what he is known for. He was and will remain the worst PM we've had

Those 'some' are a group of the top historians in the country. Of course you think you know better than them. Much like Churchill is ranked in many polls from various sources in the upper 6 Prime Ministers in Britain, yet they turfed him out right after the end of WWII, his biggest victory, go figure. They may have seen the err of their ways and voted him back in for one more try. Much the same for Trudeau, he was the best of the lot of take on the Separatists. Much of his success was in areas that don't make the headlines. He believed in centralized power more than his predecessors and worked at strengthening the offices of the Privy Council and the Treasury Board. Let's not forget this success on the Canadian Constitution and Charter of Rights and Freedom. He also got Canada into the then brand new G7 when they were initially passed over, the first time around.

Someone mentioned his visiting many government belonging to 'them', the bad guys, but forget it purpose, to ease Cold War tension, successful the point of his being awarded the Einstein Peace Prize for his efforts..
 
See, I think Trudeau was one of the greatest Prime Ministers this country has ever seen.

He made Canada what it is today. He reformed the Divorce Act, reformed the legal system, made us more of a middle of the road country, and yes, gave us our own constitution - which is a great document and no-one before him was able to do it.

As to Quebec, I'd argue that if not for Trudeau, Quebec would have left confederation. Trudeau gave made Canada bilingual and he disarmed the separatists at every step.

Pierre, he haunts us still.

One of the greatest Canadians.
 
You're right about Mulroney fleecing country, but Trudeau managed to rob Canadians of their civil rights over a kidnapping in Quebec.

My parents and their relations, who grew up under Mussolini, immigrated to Canada for its social freedoms and liberal democracy. After the War Measures Act they became Liberal supporters en masse.

 
The charter is lacking any sort of oversight by an elected body of who serves as a judge. Who's to say that the top court doesn't get stacked by a PM with an agenda? Again judges are appointed by the PM without having to answer to anyone including an elected parliament. Again Trudeau showing disdain for being responsible to those who elected him. In any event, his economic and social legacy speaks for itself, and it's nothing to be proud of. Every subsequent PM has piece by piece done away with anything he enacted.
 
Here's just one good reason for Honoring Pierre Trudeau

quote-there-s-no-place-for-the-state-in-the-bedrooms-of-the-nation-pierre-trudeau-311285.jpg



Those unforgettable words made famous by a young, charismatic Trudeau in 1967 caused a tidal wave of controversy that rippled across the entire nation. His Omnibus Bill brought issues like abortion, homosexuality and divorce law to the forefront for the first time, changing the political and social landscape in Canada forever.

Trudeau was Justice Minister back when he introduced that controversial bill in the House of Commons, triggering massive changes to the Criminal Code of Canada.

In uttering that famous statement, Trudeau was arguing for the decriminalization of 'homosexual acts' performed in private.

"What's done in private between adults doesn't concern the Criminal Code," he said. And he made that principle about consensual sex a reality which has spinoff benefits for all us heterosexual pooners today.

The other controversial parts of Trudeau's comprehensive Omnibus bill concerned revisions to abortion laws, making it legal for women to get one if a committee of three doctors feels the pregnancy endangers the mental, emotional or physical well-being of the mother.

The bill also called for the legalization of lotteries, new gun ownership restrictions and paved the way for police to perform breathalyser tests on suspected drunk drivers if they have reasonable and probable cause.
 
Whatever sins you think PET did, at least he didn't take envelopes of cash in hotels and then sue canada and make the country pay him $1 million for insulting his character.

Mulroney should be a front runner for worst pm for a long time.

PET is responsible for starting us all down this deficit finance road... oh and that peice of shit Charter thing that has lawyers frothing at the mouth and laughing all the way to the bank... amongst other things.

Mulroney added to that, (bigtime), and then introduced the GST... fucking the entire country even further...

The Lib lovers will be quick to take credit for electing Chretien/ Martin to "balance" the books, but that never would have been possible without the cash cow known as the GST... and don't get me started on the how Shawinigate and Sponsorship scandals etc.

Proof that all politicians in the last 40 yrs have but one agenda.
 
The charter is lacking any sort of oversight by an elected body of who serves as a judge. Who's to say that the top court doesn't get stacked by a PM with an agenda? Again judges are appointed by the PM without having to answer to anyone including an elected parliament. Again Trudeau showing disdain for being responsible to those who elected him. In any event, his economic and social legacy speaks for itself, and it's nothing to be proud of. Every subsequent PM has piece by piece done away with anything he enacted.

I think you'll be hard pressed to find any parliamentary system that has elected oversight. If they were elected that doesn't doesn't mean it's better. We don't elect any judges. They actually do have oversight, look it up. a judge can't just make judgement depending how they feel on the day. You'll find that most of our SCOC judges do much better, when there isn't a politician looking over their shoulder much like what has happened with the Federal ministries when they were politicized under Mulroney. So little is done without someone thinking how will this affect the the Minister.

The judges don't simply get there off the bus, fresh out of school. It takes years to be even considered. The list of qualified candidates is not as long as you think. The isolation of the judges gives them comfort in that they don't have to worry or interference, should they make a legal judgement based on the law of the land, heaven forbid, and not worry about the government of the day screwing it up. Just look at what's been done in various supposed arm length department when they don't rule in the way the Conservatives want. The list is growing every year.
 
The October Crisis was a pivotal event in the history of Quebec and Canada. The vast majority of FLQ supporters and sympathizers renounced violence and vowed to strive for an independent Quebec through peaceful and democratic means. It is my understanding that many former FLQ supporters became PQ members which won power through a democratic election in 1976.
 
That is what judges do in any democracy with the rule of law. Name a country in which judges don't have the power to overturn unconstitutional laws.

You just don't like that the charter enshrined a very good set of values that protect overtime that you would presumably line to persecute.

You approve of a politically leader appointing hand-picked judges?

Reagan and Bush picked their favourites that probably influenced the outcome of events to their liking.

I used to be a Trudeau fan until I got educated and opened my eyes. He had some good points of course. I felt the WMA was an appropriate response against those terrorists at the time.

This is a good critique of Trudeau =>

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/2011/03/23/david-frum-the-disastrous-legacy-of-pierre-trudeau/
 
PET is responsible for starting us all down this deficit finance road... oh and that peice of shit Charter thing that has lawyers frothing at the mouth and laughing all the way to the bank... amongst other things.

Mulroney added to that, (bigtime), and then introduced the GST... fucking the entire country even further...

The Lib lovers will be quick to take credit for electing Chretien/ Martin to "balance" the books, but that never would have been possible without the cash cow known as the GST... and don't get me started on the how Shawinigate and Sponsorship scandals etc.

Proof that all politicians in the last 40 yrs have but one agenda.


Like it or not, the GST was a brilliant form of taxation introduced by his eminence, Brian P. Mulroney. It removed the outdated Federal manufacturers' sales tax buried in the price of our goods for export, so it made us more competitive. There are other good points on this value-added, consumption tax but I won't get into them right now.
 
I'll drink to that (I've even used that quote when questioned by a cop once).




Here's just one good reason for Honoring Pierre Trudeau

quote-there-s-no-place-for-the-state-in-the-bedrooms-of-the-nation-pierre-trudeau-311285.jpg



Those unforgettable words made famous by a young, charismatic Trudeau in 1967 caused a tidal wave of controversy that rippled across the entire nation. His Omnibus Bill brought issues like abortion, homosexuality and divorce law to the forefront for the first time, changing the political and social landscape in Canada forever.

Trudeau was Justice Minister back when he introduced that controversial bill in the House of Commons, triggering massive changes to the Criminal Code of Canada.

In uttering that famous statement, Trudeau was arguing for the decriminalization of 'homosexual acts' performed in private.

"What's done in private between adults doesn't concern the Criminal Code," he said. And he made that principle about consensual sex a reality which has spinoff benefits for all us heterosexual pooners today.

The other controversial parts of Trudeau's comprehensive Omnibus bill concerned revisions to abortion laws, making it legal for women to get one if a committee of three doctors feels the pregnancy endangers the mental, emotional or physical well-being of the mother.

The bill also called for the legalization of lotteries, new gun ownership restrictions and paved the way for police to perform breathalyser tests on suspected drunk drivers if they have reasonable and probable cause.
 
My parents and their relations, who grew up under Mussolini, immigrated to Canada for its social freedoms and liberal democracy. After the War Measures Act they became Liberal supporters en masse.



Canada's lucky that it wasn't Mussolini dealing with the FLQ (perhaps more so the FLQ).

Immigrants supported the Liberals before Trudeaumania when under Diefenbaker, they faced the harshest form of discrimination against them. (My dad was called a 'DP').
 
"The state has no right in the bedroom....' I suppose he had this in mind when he yanked citizens out of their homes and bedroom to be locked up without charge or representation do days and weeks. I'll bet those who suffered jail time for no offence cringe going to PET international. The US did not invoke martial law after 911.