Toronto Girlfriends

Hitler speech

asterwald

Active member
Dec 11, 2010
2,579
0
36
Isn't it common knowledge that Stalin killed more? What was his motive? Did he regard the Ukrainians as inferior or what? Was it pure racism?
It was his quest for absolute control. He ruled with an Iron fist. Any resistance had to be eliminated.
 

eric42

Member
Jul 5, 2003
264
0
16
If that's the single sum total of your contribution to this thread so far 5 pages in, thanks for coming out.
What is your contribution. Once sentence are the only words of wisdom you could squeeze out?
I appreciate you feedback!
 

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,799
476
83
The Keebler Factory
... keep in mind that many in the SS hierarchy had a great deal of admiration for muslims and that IIRC there was a muslim SS regiment.
Himmler had some pretty wacky views on a variety of subjects, muslims as SS being one of them. The broader German tolerance of muslims had more to do with the historical anti-British sentiment within the Arab world and the leverage that gave the Germans to undermine British rule in the Middle East.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13th_Waffen_Mountain_Division_of_the_SS_Handschar_(1st_Croatian)

As for the "non-Aryan" SS formations that were raised in the latter stages of the war, that was based on a "scraping the bottom of the manpower barrel" objective rather than a true desire to form SS units out of ethnic groups that would otherwise have been dismissed by the Nazis as "sub-human" or "non-Aryan" peoples.

As the war progressed and German manpower resources became stretched to the breaking point, the standards of SS recruitment were dramatically lowered to the point that they formed entire units of ethnic groups that would likely never have been allowed to associate with the SS/Nazis had there not been such a crisis in manpower.

The Wehrmacht did not undertake the recruitment of foreigners as eagerly as the SS did but that likely has more to do with the SS being more of a political entity than the Wehrmacht (i.e., in terms of political indoctrination and the ultimate goal of defeating communism - an ideal that was shared by many non-German peoples and went back further than the Nazis themselves. Anti-communism was the lynch pin that galvanized the non-German SS units, versus the greater emphasis on Aryanism that the German SS units held near and dear to their hearts).

So to point to that as some kind of "tolerance" for other ethnic groups is misrepresentative of the facts.

Ironically enough, some of the final defenders of Berlin were soldiers of these SS ethnic groups (see links below) who by that point had absolutely nothing to go home to (other than prosecution and/or execution) and fought it out to the bitter end. It's a skeleton in the closet for the Dutch that more of their men volunteered to fight for the Third Reich than to volunteer to fight against it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/11th_SS_Volunteer_Panzergrenadier_Division_Nordland

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/33rd_Waffen_Grenadier_Division_of_the_SS_Charlemagne_(1st_French)
 

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,049
1
0
What is your contribution. Once sentence are the only words of wisdom you could squeeze out?
I appreciate you feedback!
Most members have already said what I would say and there's little use repeating their comments. Yours was just useless vitriol.
 

diehard

_\|/_
Aug 6, 2006
2,985
0
0
Isn't it common knowledge that Stalin killed more? What was his motive? Did he regard the Ukrainians as inferior or what? Was it pure racism?
Pure incompetence, neglect and the criminal and brutal forced collectivization of farms.

All earned currency from grain exports was used to fund the industrialization of the country. Many consider Stalin to have modernized Russia... But that's another topic altogether.
 

rld

New member
Oct 12, 2010
10,662
2
0
Judging yourself guilt worthy on the basis of Austrian ancestry, isn't much different from judging someone on the colour of their skin rather then the content of their character. So I am using the standard definition of racism, simply applying it in an unusual but legitimate way.

Unless you personally had something to do with Hitlers rise to power.


Also
"I am Austrian by descent, so we kind of share some of the same guilt. "
You have an odd concept of celebrating culture and heritage.

Also nothing I said implied abandoning ancestry or heritage, simply that guilt or pride should be on the basis of things you have actually done, and the type of person you are, and not who your parents and ancestors are.

Although now that we are on the topic, I say yes, we would be much better if we adopt what is best from what the world offers. If wearing a dress, listing to tortured cats and eating Haggis turns you one, why not go for it, even if you are not Scottish. I'd say it is more sensible for someone to spend their time listening to Newfie music, eating Indian food, doing Chinese martial arts, living in a Swedish style home, absorb themself into the history of Latin America and read Shakespeare in the Original Klingon rather then get hung up on what your parentals and grandparentals were into... if the above floats your boat that is.

Granted what floats your boat will be at least someone influenced by ancestry, I'll admit to a bit of pull myself. But when it comes to guilt and pride, that is something we can use less of.
I find it funny when people who blather on about cultural pride the most often [even if not always] are those who have done the least with their lives.
In the earlier quote I said "we", not I.

I believe that cultural pride, and/or guilt/shame serves a useful purpose when directed properly. If your culture, has a tendency towards...say xenophobia being able to look at historical precedents as a cautionary tale may put a drag on this negative tendency.

Cultural and national pride can inspire greater efforts and give a healthy sense of identity to individuals and a group.

My anecdotal experience with people who celebrate cultural pride is the reverse of yours. In the case of the Austrian-Canadian community most of the people I have been with at cultural events and organizations are very successful. Frank Stronach is very proud of his heritage and active in our community and I would dare say he has accomplished more than a little.

I also happen to enjoy African culture and music and food, when I get the chance, but it does not quite resonate the same way as a good schnitzel.
 

artj

Member
Jun 29, 2008
183
6
18
After reading the last four pages most of you forgot that the main reason the nazi party got into power. There was high inflation and high unemployment. Anywhere in any industrialized nation,one who promises work and a good living, would get into power. INMHO it's not far off south of the boarder!
 

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,970
5,601
113

papasmerf

New member
Oct 22, 2002
26,520
0
0
42.55.65N 78.43.73W
I will not post my thoughts on this thread for fear of being banned
 

great bear

The PUNisher
Apr 11, 2004
16,163
54
48
Nice Dens
Fowl Ball! Duck!! This town ain't big enough for two of us , eider your leave or DM does.
I think we should start a movement named "Down with Eider". DM is constantly hatching new plots against us. His favourite TV show was the Partrige Family.
 

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,970
5,601
113

red

you must be fk'n kid'g me
Nov 13, 2001
17,551
10
38
I think we should start a movement named "Down with Eider". DM is constantly hatching new plots against us. His favourite TV show was the Partrige Family.
way to throw a wet blanket on the thread
 

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,970
5,601
113
Toronto Escorts