Hitler ordered Luftwaffe to spare Blackpool

Several issues...

Rockslinger said:
Not familiar with the Blackpool situation, but the biggest mystery (at least to me anyway) is why Hitler didn't order the destruction of the Allied troops at Dunkirk.

Its far from clear that he could have.
The Brits, many French and some Belgians were fighting in the pocket.

The rest of the French army was still hard at it, and Hitler had no way of knowing about the collapse that was coming within a few weeks. (Which was more political than military, the French middle and junior ranks were far more effective than generally acknowledged). It made sense to push elsewhere and ignore Dunkirk.

At the time Hitler had a soft spot for the UK, aside from Mosley's blackshirts, Edward VIII was a fan. He never had designs on the UK. He stated more than once that he was fine if the British Empire carried on, and left him the continent.

It also was to some extent a "leave it to the Luftwaffe" situation. And it did wreak havoc on the beaches, the Navy and volunteer evacuation boats and ships. If the weather had not been so perfect "destruction" might have bneen the word.
 
The Houdini said:
The Russians had dick on a stick. They rationed bullets to soldiers. In fact half the soldiers didn't even have guns, they had to wait for some comrade to die on the battlefield to grab his weapon.

Now this is true ignorance. And too much Call of Duty.

Newsflash to you... every army rationed bullets to soldiers.

Yes, there were times when the Soviets didn't have enough of everything. But if you think that's an accurate picture of the Soviets in WWII, then you're so out to lunch there's not much more to say to you.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Yes, there were times when the Soviets didn't have enough of everything.

I think the Great Patriotic War went through at least 3 phases for the Russians. In the beginning, it probably was true that the Russians were severely underequipped. Didn't the Nazis captured 3 million Russian prisoners in the first weeks of the war?
 
Keebler Elf said:
Correction to your correction.

Inferior to the German heavy tanks for one simple reason: it took too damn long to load the two-piece ammunition. They'd be blown apart long before they could reload for a second shot.

On the whole, German tanks were superior. As I have already indicated.

The masses of Soviet tanks were not IS-2's. Just like the masses of German tanks were not King Tigers.

Well, no. Tank fighting isn't high noon at the OK Corral where you fire off your bullets as quickly as possible. All those guys - at least the ones who survived the battle - were firing from concealed positions, hull down if possible and with a wall or ridge in front. They were picking their shots and taking their time.

How much does a 88mm King tiger round weigh? Quite an armful I'd say. Almost as cumbersome as a 2-part 122mm.

The British Chieftain used two-part ammo right up to the 70's. So it couldn't have been that much of a disadvantage.

The mass of German tanks were Mark IV's and III's up until summer 1944. The Eastern Front was more poorly equipped than Normandy because the Germans flooded Normandy with their elite SS Divisions. Army Group Centre mainly had Mark III assault guns when it was destroyed in July 1944 and very few real tanks of any sort. The entire Army Group had 1 tiger battalion which was used as an emergency stopper for serious crises.

The Russians hit with several hundred T-34's and IS-2's and kept rolling to Warsaw 6 weeks later.
 
The Houdini said:
The Russians had dick on a stick. They rationed bullets to soldiers. In fact half the soldiers didn't even have guns, they had to wait for some comrade to die on the battlefield to grab his weapon.

They survived by sheer numbers and the knowledge that if they deserted the'd be executed. Their tanks sucked, their planes sucked. At the end the Germans literally ran out of supplies and spare parts to fix their equipment. And slowly lost tens of thousands of men to the brutal cold.

I guess that's all ignorant.

Maybe you should visit the library at some point. Or at least check out Wikipedia.
 
Rockslinger said:
I think the Great Patriotic War went through at least 3 phases for the Russians. In the beginning, it probably was true that the Russians were severely underequipped. Didn't the Nazis captured 3 million Russian prisoners in the first weeks of the war?

Correct...

That's why I was saying that the Russians had no chance in beating the Germans on their own. Sure, later in the war (1943)their overall quality of equipment did improve as did quantities.
 
oagre said:
Maybe you should visit the library at some point. Or at least check out Wikipedia.


Early on the Russians were a mess, to put it mildly.
 
LancsLad said:
from the few anecdotes Dad related of that early morning beach trip in June, Normandy was no "picnic" by any stretch. The Day itself was brutal , but was only a precursor to the carnage to come as once inland the standard mortality tables ( Hobbes i think they were) that the Army used for combat modelling needed a never before used Double Intense rating. The life expectancy of an ordinary rifleman dropped to one week.


Also don't forget that for a relatively small pop base Britain was more than a smidge occupied with fighting the japs on the sub-continent. Of the main combattants at play of the european Jap and yanks, Great Britain had the smallest population.


Lets also not forget the countless thousands of naval crew from the RN and RCN that lost their lives on the horrible convoy runs taking supplies to the Russians.
Even for the U.S.A. with its vastly larger population, D-Day particularly Omaha Beach was hellish as indeed was the entire Normandy Campaign until the break-out and race across France.
 
The Houdini said:
Russia was and still is the largest country in the world. They lost more soldiers than any other country in WW2. They lost half a million soldiers and civilians (mostly soldiers) in Stalingrad alone. There were over a million Russian soldiers fighting the German 6th army by the time the Germans capitulated in 1943.
Also remember that the Red Army was quite segregated. Great Russians and with come caveats other Slavs were "trustworthy and were in Combat Arms and vital support services Intelligence etc. . ., while Central Asian and ethnic minority troops were principally in support branches Quartermaster, Engineers, medical orderlies etc. . .
 
Aardvark154 said:
. ., while Central Asian and ethnic minority troops were principally in support branches Quartermaster, Engineers, medical

Wasn't it one million Central Asian reinforcements dressed in all white that turned the tide at Stalingrad? Up to that point, I think the Nazis were making slow but steady progress. Thank goodness, Hitler was a military idiot. His field commanders wanted to make a controlled withdrawl from Stalingrad. He wanted them to stand their ground and die on the spot. He went ballistic when he heard that 225,000 Nazi soldiers were captured alive.
 
Rockslinger said:
Hitler was a military idiot. His field commanders wanted to make a controlled withdrawl from Stalingrad. He wanted them to stand their ground and die on the spot. He went ballistic when he heard that 225,000 Nazi soldiers were captured alive.

Hitler wanted his general at Stalingrad (von Paulus) to commit suicide and avoid captivity. Instead, v Paulus surrendered and became a Russian stooge, making speeches against Hitler and testifying for the Russians at the Nuremberg War Trials.
;)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Paulus
 
oagre said:
Hitler wanted his general at Stalingrad (von Paulus) to commit suicide and avoid captivity.


Hitler promoted von Paulus to Field Marshal (or something like that) because no German Field Marshal had ever been captured alive (hint, hint). Is it true that only 3,000 of the original 225,000 German soldiers walked out of Russia after the war?
 
Rockslinger said:
Wasn't it one million Central Asian reinforcements dressed in all white that turned the tide at Stalingrad? Up to that point, I think the Nazis were making slow but steady progress. Thank goodness, Hitler was a military idiot. His field commanders wanted to make a controlled withdrawl from Stalingrad. He wanted them to stand their ground and die on the spot. He went ballistic when he heard that 225,000 Nazi soldiers were captured alive.
Honestly, I don't know on that point Rockslinger, I'm going but what I've read here, and what I was told there - not being something I've devoted hour upon hour to as I say I honestly don't know - It very well could be particulalry if they were regarded as expendable.
 
Aardvark154 said:
Half-truths are particularly nasty things.

Both General Motors and Ford had German subsidiaries, which in 1939 supplied about 70 percent of the German automobile market and rapidly retooled to become suppliers of war materiel to the German army. Further both appeared to have used forced labour during the Second World War. However, that does not mean that either Ford or GM where aware of what was going on, nor that they could have done anything to prevent it.

As to bombing decisions the target committees certainly didn't make decisions based on who in the end owned the factory, but rather what the factory produced. Hence the horrific casualty rates sustained in the raids on the ball bearing plants in Schweinfurt. The three highest priority targets for the Eighth Air Force were: aircraft factories, petroleum refineries and ball bearing plants.

Finally since Ford received 32 million dollars from the U.S. Government in compensation for the loss of it's German factories from USAAF bombing during the Second World War it's hard to argue that they weren't bombed.

Your last sentence is half correct IBM's German subsidiary Deutsche Hollerith Maschinen Gesellschaft did provide the German Government with punch cards, card punching machines and tabulating machines (technically although automated they were not computers in the sense we generally think of them). There remains question as to what extent IBM was aware of the purposes for which the technology was being put to use. Although in hindsight, and probably even at the time the business raised moral and ethical issues, it was completely legal until Germany declared war on the U.S. in December 1941.

Now this is why I am impressed by the preverts of TERB

Educated, bright and enjoy their God given sexuality

what more is there?

Greatly appreciate the response

Curious though as to why Ford recieved compensation

the big 3 did its part in mobilizing the war effort - built a lot of tanks - but as to why Ford received any compensation for destruction of its German subsidary that was suppling the Nazi war machine leaves me wondering WTF?
 
Aardvark154 said:
Honestly, I don't know on that point Rockslinger, I'm going but what I've read here, and what I was told there - not being something I've devoted hour upon hour to as I say I honestly don't know - It very well could be particulalry if they were regarded as expendable.




There was a very controversial book published some years back called "Other Losses", i think the author was a french guy.

It discussed how the germans captured by the various Allied Armies fared and what their post war treatment was like.

Seems that for the hun, being captured by the commies was less than ideal.


.
 
oagre said:
The Von Paulus article says 6,000 returned home and 91,000 surrendered.

Maybe 225,000 was the original German attack force and 134,000 were killed, escaped or MIA. 91,000 captured alive.
 
LancsLad said:
Seems that for the hun, being captured by the commies was less than ideal.

Life for Russians captured by the Nazis was very unpleasant. It is a little known fact that after the war, soldiers of the British 8th army were ordered to repatriate all German captured Russians back to Russia. Once they arrived back in Russia they were all summarily murdered by Stalin.
 
Make no mistake, the Germans and Soviets were fighting a "total war." It was not at all uncommon for neither side to take prisoners. This was particularly true for the Waffen SS (both for and against).

A common Soviet punishment was dousing a German in petrol and lighting him on fire.

A common German punishment was putting a Russian in a warm bath and then tossing him outside in the -40 weather.

There are numerous tales of soldiers being found dead by a self-inflicted gunshot, surrounded by the bodies of enemies they had killed while saving the last bullet for themselves.

This is what's different about the Eastern Front. It was FAR more savage than the other European theatres.
 
Rockslinger said:
Life for Russians captured by the Nazis was very unpleasant. It is a little known fact that after the war, soldiers of the British 8th army were ordered to repatriate all German captured Russians back to Russia. Once they arrived back in Russia they were all summarily murdered by Stalin.

Source for that?

I think you're may be referring to Cossack units who had switched sides to fight with the Nazis and were then captured by the British. It would be pretty standard for all nations to shoot such traitors in the 40's.

Ordinary Soviets who had been captured were treated unkindly when freed by their comrades later. But they were not shot. The death rate for Soviet PoW's in German hands was astronomical anyway. Few ever survived to be rescued.