Hitler ordered Luftwaffe to spare Blackpool

The Houdini said:
I don't believe that's true. With the Germans Folke Wolf 190's in particular, and the Messerschmitts 109's they were top dogs over the Spit Fire's and even the P-47 Thunderbolts. Only with the introduction of th e P-51 Mustang could the Allies finally begin to really hurt the Luftwaffe. Especially in support of B-17 Bombers formations over German territory.

Depends on what model of what fighter was flown under what circumstances. The P-47 could nail any FW-190A over 20,000 feet. Under 10,000, the results would be diametrically different. The P-47 was simply designed as a high altitude fighter with massive bulk and little streamlining, but a humongous power plant. In the thin air in the upper atmosphere, sheer power was far more important than sleek design. At low altitude, things were the reverse.

The 109E was about equal to its 1940 equivalent, the Spit II. The Spit turned superlatively well. The 109 had great acceleration and a fantastic clime and dive rate. So Jerry dove out of the sun, hit hard and didn't stop to close-in dogfight.

In late 41-42, Willi Messerschmidt totally revamped the 109 and produced the radically improved F version. This was noticeably faster than the Spit V, its contemporary. Kurt Tank then introduced the first FW-190 models which were FAR faster than the spit, far more heavily armed and which maneuvred fairly well. This created a crisis in Fighter Command.

The crisis was solved with the rapid up-powering of the Spit V to become the Spit IX. The Spit IX was generally better than the 109 f and G models until late 44, when the 109 was fitted with methane boost engines. The Spit IX was about equal to the FW-190.

In late 44, all 3 planes were improved again with brand new power plants. The SPit XIV was fitted with the Griffon engine, instead of the Merlin with a 50 MPH top speed improvement.

The P-51 was known for its high top speed and extreme long range. However, it was not a revolutionary new weapon.
 
jwmorrice said:
A few observations:

The Royal Navy didn't have a single modern capital ship at the time unless one counts the strangely designed Nelson and Rodney. During WWII, only the KGV class battleships were built and commissioned. Obviously it was important to preserve as many of the aged battleshps and battlecruisers as possible to guard against surface raiders. I doubt that any one of those ships would have stood much of a chance against Germany's Bismarck or Tirpitz.

Neither the Bismarck nor the Tirpitz were commissioned at the time of Dunkirk. As for the Scharnhorst and the Gneisenau, neither were true capital ships as they were fitted with 11" guns as a main armament.

What large ships did the Germans commission in WW2? I know off hand the following:

Graf Spee (pocket battleship) - scuttled off Montevideo in 40(?), after being penned in by a RN task force.
Bismarck (battleship) - sunk in the Atlantic by torpedo planes in 41(?)
Scharnhorst (big battle cruiser)-penned in harbour, except for 1 or 2 brief forays.
Gneisenau - ditto
Bismarck (battleship) - ditto
Tirpitz (battleship?) - ditto.

I know at least 1 of those vessels was sunk at its moorings by 617 Squadron (the Dambusters) flying a special mission over Norway with massive deep penetration bombs.
 
I think most historians agree on the fact that the German armour was held up because they had exceeded their supply lines. At the time of Dunkirk the French still were a threat, at least from the German point of view. I wouldn't be surprised if the Germans were still concerned about the French coming back after successive defeats like they did in WWI.

It is true that the in street fighting tanks tend to take higher casulties against infantry formations but the Germans were greatly surprised at how out-classed their tanks were compared to the British heavy armour. At the Battle of Arras, British heavy tanks tore through the German armour as the German guns could do little or no damage to the British tanks. Only when Rommel commanded the German 88 anti-aircraft guns to fire with open-site on the British tanks were the Germans able to stablize things and eventually push the British back as the British armour did not have enough infantry support.

One thing that a lot of people forget is that the Battle for France was not as one sided as everyone thinks. The Germans were taking pretty heavy casulties in their push and most of their sucesses were due to good judgement calls by their field officers, like Rommel, and excellet co-ordination with their air, armour and infantry forces.
 
oagre said:
What large ships did the Germans commission in WW2? I know off hand the following:

Graf Spee (pocket battleship) - scuttled off Montevideo in 40(?), after being penned in by a RN task force.
Bismarck (battleship) - sunk in the Atlantic by torpedo planes in 41(?)
Scharnhorst (big battle cruiser)-penned in harbour, except for 1 or 2 brief forays.
Gneisenau - ditto
Bismarck (battleship) - ditto
Tirpitz (battleship?) - ditto.

I know at least 1 of those vessels was sunk at its moorings by 617 Squadron (the Dambusters) flying a special mission over Norway with massive deep penetration bombs.

Sister-ships Bismarck and Tirpitz were both commissioned after WWII began. The Graf Spee was scuttled off Montevideo in 1939. The Bismarck was not sunk by airplanes. Its rudder was jammed by an airplane-launched torpedo.

jwm
 
Dark Chimera said:
Allies also did some interesting none bombing

Ford manufacturing plants were located in Germany.

Allied bombers went to pains to avoid bombing them.

IBM sold precursor to computer to Germany so they could keep track of Jews they were exterminating
Half-truths are particularly nasty things.

Both General Motors and Ford had German subsidiaries, which in 1939 supplied about 70 percent of the German automobile market and rapidly retooled to become suppliers of war materiel to the German army. Further both appeared to have used forced labour during the Second World War. However, that does not mean that either Ford or GM where aware of what was going on, nor that they could have done anything to prevent it.

As to bombing decisions the target committees certainly didn't make decisions based on who in the end owned the factory, but rather what the factory produced. Hence the horrific casualty rates sustained in the raids on the ball bearing plants in Schweinfurt. The three highest priority targets for the Eighth Air Force were: aircraft factories, petroleum refineries and ball bearing plants.

Finally since Ford received 32 million dollars from the U.S. Government in compensation for the loss of it's German factories from USAAF bombing during the Second World War it's hard to argue that they weren't bombed.

Your last sentence is half correct IBM's German subsidiary Deutsche Hollerith Maschinen Gesellschaft did provide the German Government with punch cards, card punching machines and tabulating machines (technically although automated they were not computers in the sense we generally think of them). There remains question as to what extent IBM was aware of the purposes for which the technology was being put to use. Although in hindsight, and probably even at the time the business raised moral and ethical issues, it was completely legal until Germany declared war on the U.S. in December 1941.
 
oagre said:
What large ships did the Germans commission in WW2? I know off hand the following:

Graf Spee (pocket battleship) - scuttled off Montevideo in 40(?), after being penned in by a RN task force.
Bismarck (battleship) - sunk in the Atlantic by torpedo planes in 41(?)
Scharnhorst (big battle cruiser)-penned in harbour, except for 1 or 2 brief forays.
Gneisenau - ditto
Bismarck (battleship) - ditto
Tirpitz (battleship?) - ditto.
Oagre, I believe the only ones you missed were were Deutschland which in late 1939 was renamed Lützow, and Admiral Scheer. The German Kriegsmarine originally called them Panzerschiffs (armoured ships) but in early 1940 they reclassified Lützow, and Admiral Scheer as heavy cruisers. The term “pocket battleship” comes from the Royal Navy.

Scharnhorst and Gneisenau were classified by the Kriegmarine as Battleships (Schlachtschiffe) but they only had 11 inch (28 cm) main guns. So I wouldn't give you much argument about them being Battle Cruisers.
 
oagre said:
The P-51 was known for its high top speed and extreme long range. However, it was not a revolutionary new weapon.
Oagre, I don't believe you really give the P-51 its due.

By the way not generaly known is that it started life as an RAF project one of the many aircraft projects that were sheparded into production by Air Chief Marshal Sir Wilfrid Freeman who as the subtitle of his biography states was indeed the genius behind Allied survival and air supremacy.
 
my dad flew spitfire's in the battle of britain(and lived to tell about it) he says 4:1 is about right. the british were allways waiting for the germans and above them. also most pilots shot down bailed out and were flying the next day the germans who got shot down spent the rest of the war locked up
 
doggee_01 said:
my dad flew spitfire's in the battle of britain(and lived to tell about it) he says 4:1 is about right.

Did German bombers have fighter escorts (you know what I mean) during the Battle of Britain? Or, was Britain out of range for German fighter planes?

Also, late in the war the German launched the ME-262 (check name) jet fighter plane. Did the Americans or Brits or Russians have an equilvalent?
 
Rockslinger said:
Did German bombers have fighter escorts (you know what I mean) during the Battle of Britain? Or, was Britain out of range for German fighter planes?

Also, late in the war the German launched the ME-262 (check name) jet fighter plane. Did the Americans or Brits or Russians have an equilvalent?
To the best of my knowledge both ME-110's and ME-109's could reach southeast England during the Battle of Britain. Doubtless Doggee_01 knows more about how much further they could go than I.

As to jet powered aircraft the RAF had the Gloster Meteor which was introduced in June 1944 but the F-1 version was only flown over the U.K. principally against the V-2 buzz bombs. In January 1945 a squadron equipped with the improved F-3 version flew in Belgium flying ground attack and armed reconnaissance missions.

The US Army Air Force had experiential jet powered aircraft, but nothing operational during the Second World War, the first US jet powered aircraft was the Bell P-59A which was also the first jet to have its inlet nacelles and engines integrated into the fuselage as do all modern fighter aircraft.

The USAAF was unimpressed by its performance and cancelled the contract
The first operational U.S. jet aircraft was the Lockheed P-80 Shooting Star which still "soldiers on" as the T-33 Shooting Star trainer.

The Soviets did not develop a jet powered aircraft until after the war.
 
doggee_01 said:
my dad flew spitfire's in the battle of britain(and lived to tell about it) he says 4:1 is about right. the british were allways waiting for the germans and above them. also most pilots shot down bailed out and were flying the next day the germans who got shot down spent the rest of the war locked up



Thank him for us.
 
Aardvark154 said:
Oagre, I don't believe you really give the P-51 its due.

I think I secretly hate it for 2 reasons. 1. The "made in the USA" "Dogfights" series on TV always makes the P-51 the star at the expense of all the other planes. And 2. I always spin and stall it when I fly it in the Il-2 computer game. ;)

But seriously, it couldn't turn and weave with a Spit or even a 109. I would pick a Spit for maneuvering and a FW-190 for punch and a P-47 for toughness before the P-51.
 
At the end of the day, the Germans could not beat the British and their allies (Canada, Poland, Free French, Australians, et al.)

The RAF simply didn't crack despite the numerical superiority of the German LW.

Even if the Germans had managed to defeat the RAF, the Germans would have needed to cross the English Channel in boats (just like the Allies did on June 6, 1944) and you CAN BET THE FARM the U-boats or no U-boats, German Dive Bombers or no German Dive Bombers, the RN would have been in there en masse to blast the Germans right out of the water.

It simply wasn't going to happen for the Germans.
 
oagre said:
I would pick a Spit for maneuvering and a FW-190 for punch and a P-47 for toughness before the P-51.

Wasn't the P-51 designed for long range bomber escort and it fulfilled that role magnificently? Prior to the arrival of the P-51, wasn't the death rate of unescorted bombers unacceptably high?
 
Little known about is the massive fuel lines run into the channel along the south and east coast. The plan was that when the hun was coming ashore in landing craft the pipes would be flooded, fuel rises and is set alight. that would have toasted more than a few of those fuckers.


.
 
Rockslinger said:
Wasn't the P-51 designed for long range bomber escort and it fulfilled that role magnificently? Prior to the arrival of the P-51, wasn't the death rate of unescorted bombers unacceptably high?



Spits used drop tanks to extend their range but when you are escorting 600 to 1000 heavies losses will be high regardless of the fighter cover.




.
 
james t kirk said:
Even if the Germans had managed to defeat the RAF, the Germans would have needed to cross the English Channel in boats

The last time an invading army successfully crossed the channel was William the Conquorer in 1066 and he was descented from those great sea warriors the Vikings.
 
Rockslinger said:
Did German bombers have fighter escorts (you know what I mean) during the Battle of Britain? Or, was Britain out of range for German fighter planes?

Also, late in the war the German launched the ME-262 (check name) jet fighter plane. Did the Americans or Brits or Russians have an equivalent?

The 110 had very good range but was far too clumsy to take on Spits and Hurris. So it was pretty useless as much of anything.

The 109 could reach southern England and fight for about 15 minutes before heading home. The Germans feared having to ditch in the Channel or North Sea more than being shot down, as ditching made it probable the pilot would die slowly of exposure before being picked up.

Interestingly, the drop tank was introduced in the Luftwaffe a few months after the BoB. One of the great "what if's" of WW2 history, huh?

The British and the Americans had jets. I don't know much about them. I know that the US P-80 was operational over Italy in '45 in very small numbers. I don't know how its performance compared with the German jets.

The Russians didn't have jets until a couple of years after WW2. There's a great story about how Uncle Joe asked Prime Minister Clement Atlee (the Labour government leader post war) for the newest Rolls Royce jet engine as a gesture of "socialist solidarity".

The engine duly arrives much to the incredulous snickers and chuckles of the Kremlin. It was quickly fitted into the latest MiG jet fighter and used against the Brits and US in Korea 2 or 3 years later.

The Soviets were behind the West in technology. For instance, they copied the US B-29 bomber rivet by rivet to come up with a decent modern bomber of their own in 46. The Soviet bomber was identical to the B-29!
 
Rockslinger said:
Wasn't the P-51 designed for long range bomber escort and it fulfilled that role magnificently? Prior to the arrival of the P-51, wasn't the death rate of unescorted bombers unacceptably high?

That's pretty accurate.
 
oagre said:
The Soviets were behind the West in technology.

Maybe the Soviets were behind the West but weren't their tanks, guns and aircrafts (except for the very few ME-262) superior to the Nazis in the latter stages of WW II?